Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout02-22-2017 Council Packet AGENDA LITTLE CANADA CITY COUNCIL WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 22, 2017 CALL TO ORDER – Workshop Meeting – 6:00 p.m. Roll Call 1. Discussion about Possible Code Amendment to Allow Chickens (Livestock) Adjourn CALL TO ORDER – Regular Meeting – 7:30 p.m. Roll Call Approval of Minutes February 8, 2017 Workshop Minutes February 8, 2017 Regular Council Minutes Announcements PUBLIC HEARING 1. Continued - Preliminary & Final Plat for a 14-Unit Townhome Development at 2736 & 2744 Rice Street – TABLED UNTIL MARCH 6, 2017 Applicant: Cash for Houses, LLC 2. Concept Review of 11-unit Single Family Residential Development at 3000 Labore Road Applicant: The Lincoln Group, Inc. CONSENT AGENDA 3. Approval of the Vouchers 4. Reschedule March 8 Workshop and City Council Meeting to Monday, March 6, 2017 5. Approval of Plans and Authorizing Advertising for Bids for 2017 Improvement Project 6. Accept Feasibility Report & Call for an Improvement Hearing on March 22, 2017 at 6:30pm for Keller Parkway Street Project STAFF & CONSULTANT REPORTS City Administrator 7. Organized Collection Contract 8. Purchase of a Used Sewer Camera Trailer 9. Purchase of John Deere Tractor and Flail Mower 10. Purchase of a New Pumper Truck for the Little Canada Fire Department 11. Adoption of 2017 Goals DEPARTMENT REPORTS Economic Development/City Council Public Safety/Gaming Public Works Building/Zoning/Code Enforcement Parks & Recreation ADJOURN STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of City Council FROM: Heidi Heller, City Clerk DATE: February 17, 2017 RE: Workshop – Discussion about Code Amendments to Allow Poultry (Livestock) At the January 25, 2017 City Council meeting, a group of residents approached the City Council and asked that the discussion to allow chickens be revisited by the City. This group had been working with Councilmember Torkelson, and have done quite a bit of community outreach on this topic. The Council chose to hold a workshop and invite the community members to present their information and request to the Council and have another discussion on this topic. Attached is information and emails that were sent from the Council and resident Amanda Guitierrez, along with information from Mark Nagel on what Elko/New Market has adopted. Backyard Chicken Information Packet for Residents of Little Canada, MN Updated 1/2017 Keeping chickens can be an extremely rewarding past-time, but it is also a lot of work. Whether you are planning to keep chickens for your own egg consumption , insect control, garden cultivation, or for enjoyment, this document will help you plan for success. This document is broken up into three major parts:  The Process: this section is a checklist of the permit process in Little Canada, MN  The Must-dos: talks about the ordinance and regulations surrounding keeping of chickens in Little Canada, MN  The Should-dos: are recommendations and best practices for some of the most commonly encountered situations surrounding keeping chickens Supplemental information at the end of this packet includes the natural history of chickens, pictures of various types of shelters and pens, and references. The Process A one-time permit specific to the owner and property is required to keep chickens in Little Canada, MN. The permit process is outlined below:  Read this document and sign the last page stating you read the entire document and return the last page to the City  Fill out the Chicken Permit Application  Pay the one-time permit fee: o If you take a chicken keeping course* and provide proof of attendance, the permit fee is $50 o If you do not take a chicken keeping course, the permit fee is $100 *Suggested chicken keeping courses:  Eggplant Supply in St. Paul holds a few classes every year on city chicken keeping. http://www.eggplantsupply.com/classes.html  Chicken Run Rescue (CRR) is a chicken sanctuary in Elko, MN that allows you to volunteer while they teach you how to appropriately care for chickens as pets http://www.chickenrunrescue.org/Chicken-Care-Certification  Online course: Chicken Behaviour and Welfare https://www.coursera.org/course/chickens  Other classes will be approved upon review The Must-Dos Ordinance outlines the specific rules regarding keeping chickens in Little Canada, MN. They are summarized in the points below.  Chickens are only allowed in R-1 lots.  A permit is required to keep chickens.  Number/type of chickens is dependent on lot size for practical and nuisance reason Lot Size (acres) Maximum # of chickens allowed Type of chickens allowed 0-0.49 4 Hens 0.5-.99 6 Hens 1-1.99 8 Hens 2-2.99 10 Hens 3-3.99 12 Hens 4+ 14 Hens/Roosters   Noise must be kept to a minimum as per Noise Ordinance. See FAQs for pointers for keeping noise down.  Manure must be kept cleaned up in a sanitary manner as per Nuisance Ordinance and Pet Ordinance. See FAQs for acceptable disposable methods and how much work you can expect.  Back stock food must be kept in rodent-proof containers  All building codes and permits must be abided by when building a shelter; shelters need to be in the rear of the yard with 15ft setbacks from property lines. More suggested.  If repurposing an existing shelter, the shelter must already be in conforming use. Non- conforming use structures cannot be repurposed.  Chickens must be contained to your yard.  Butchering or killing of chickens is not allowed  Health: chickens need to be kept in good hea lth. If they become sick veterinary care must be sought for treatment or euthanasia. Animals can be impounded for lack of proper care. The Should-Dos: Recommendations for Keeping Backyard Chickens How to be a good chicken neighbor  Talk to your neighbors: Please consider talking to your neighbors before you get chickens. Most people will react positively if the conversation is started before any changes are made.  How to keep noise down: o Keep chickens in the coop until most people have woken up for the morning (make sure the temperature of the coop isn’t too cold or warm!). o Keep coop and fence/runs away from property and follow all codes/ordinances  Keep your chickens clean: o You can dispose of the feces in your garbage bin just as you do cat/dog feces/litter, compost (see link below for composting) or if your pen is large enough (~80 square feet per bird) you may not even see the feces. Remember—healthy compost does not smell. See https://www.cals.uidaho.edu/edcomm/pdf/CIS/CIS1194.pdf o It is important to keep the area that chickens are in dry and clean. Moist areas will harbor mold and can be detrimental to chicken health. The Chicken Shelter aka Coop  Location: Shelter and pen should be in an area that provides shade, sunlight, drainage, and wind protection and located in the rear yard.  Nest boxes: Minimum 1 per 3 hens  Roosts: Chickens will be stressed if they can’t roost up high at night. 3-4” flat lumber or 2” round branches, securely fixed 2-3’ off the ground & 18” from the wall. If higher, provide stairs or ladder.  Predator proof: Large rodents, weasels, fox, raccoons and opossums are abundant in the city and the shelter needs to be predator proof from dusk till dawn. Frequently inspect it for any gaps larger than 3/4” and fix.  Moisture: It is important to keep the humidity in the coop relatively low to prevent growth of mold and keep ammonia levels from manure to a minimum. Ensure there is adequate airflow in the shelter; roof/eve vents that can be opened or closed work well.  Access: You will want at least 1 human-sized door for your access.  Planning for dusk: You will need to lock the birds up before dusk so consider automatic chicken coop door or networking with neighbors.  Floor and substrate: Ideal floor is concrete (easily cleaned, dries out, etc) with substrate on top (aspen shavings, sand, etc.) but no matter what your floor and substrate are, it is important to keep both clean and dry.  Winter shelter functions: The winter and summer shelter can be the same structure but they have different function depending on the season o Electricity: is needed for supplemental heat and light (see below) o Temperature: Winter shelters should be heated to >45 degrees F in the winter to prevent frostbite, immune system suppression and comfort. Due to heating the coop, you will likely want to lock up the coop and manually let the birds out on days warmer than 45 degrees F.  NEVER use heat lamps or heaters with hot wire filament, exposed filament heaters, exposed element space heaters, etc. as these can start fires!  OK heaters to use: oil radiant heaters (see picture to the right), Sweeter Heaters (http://sweeterheater.com/) o Light: Having adequate light to see and a normal day-night light cycle is important for health. Supplemental light is usually needed inside the coop and having it on a timer is a handy way to ensure adequate light cycles. o Size: 12 square feet of floor space per bird, ideally with added levels and roosts for them to explore. The coop will be both their shelter AND their exercise area so they need more room. o Enrichment: chickens are curious and easily bored in a coop. Google ‘chicken enrichment’ and give them new enrichment daily.  Summer shelter functions: The winter and summer shelter can be the same structure but they have different functions depending on the season o Temperatures: Chickens overheat when the temperature is >80 degrees F. Ensure they have access to plenty of shade, fresh drinking water and ambient breezes. o Size: Because they will only be locked up dusk-dawn, 4 square feet of floor space per bird is adequate. Roosts should accommodate all birds. o Birds should be locked up dusk-dawn and let out into their pen for the entire day, but have free choice back into the coop. If you keep them locked up until humans are woken up (which is often many hours past sunrise), monitor temperature in the shelter to ensure it does not get too hot on summer mornings. Fenced Outdoor Yard aka Run Chickens need to have access to outdoor space whenever weather allows (when it is >45 degrees F) for enrichment, foraging, and their health. It is also great for us as they eat many insects and aerate the soil.  Size: Generally, 43 square feet per bird of outdoor yard/run space means you may need to rotate the run every 4 weeks unless you plan to landscape for chickens inside the run (ie pea gravel, wood chips, chicken resistant plants,[see book Free-Range Chicken Gardens] etc) By increasing the square feet per bird, you may be able to skip rotation depending on the soil, plant types and landscaping.  Temperature: Chickens should be let outside when >45 degrees F and should always have access to shaded drinking water, shade, shelter, and ambient breezes for when it is hot outside.  Run construction: Chickens, like many small animals can be victims to urban predators, such as raccoons, opossums, fox, coyote, raptors, mink, weasel and stray dogs. Most predators will be excluded from the run with 2x4” welded wire, however they can climb and dig under these fences. Predators such as hawks can come in from above. Smaller predators such as mink and weasel can fit through 2x4” welded wire. To completely predator proof an outdoor run, hardware cloth (1/2” holes) can be used for fencing (or attached tightly to another type of fencing from the inside) and sunk into the ground at least 6”. Netting, such as knotted gamebird netting (cutlersupply.com) works well for the top of the pen but winter precipitation will cause it to sag, bringing your fence down with it, so remove every fall. Feed  Chicken specific: Always choose a feed that is specific for chickens (not ducks, not gamebirds, not ‘all birds’) unless caloric, mineral and vitamin content has been evaluated to be appropriate. Recommendations on appropriate feed content can be found in Backyard Poultry Medicine and Surgery (see reference list).  Life stage specific: Always choose a feed that is specific to the life stage. If you have laying hens, get a layer feed. If you have chicks, get a chick starter feed. The high amount of calcium in layer feed is not healthy for birds who aren’t laying. The high amount of protein in chick starter isn’t healthy for adults. For all adult birds (laying or not) , Roudybush Maintenance low- fat crumbles is a great feed for all adults (make sure there is plenty of oyster shell available).  Extra calcium: no matter what feed you choose, extra calcium should be available free choice. Oyster shell crumbles are readily available at most feed stores  Grit: chickens need small bits of mineral in their stomachs in order to grind and digest their feed. You can get commercial grit at stores, otherwise oyster shell is also considered a ‘grit’  Where: the above feeds are readily available at most feed stores including Fleet Farm and Houle’s Farm Garden and Pet  Treats: Such as fresh fruits and vegetables, are great to supplement. Like all treats, feed in moderation (any food in excess can be toxic) and avoid toxic foods  Foods toxic to/unhealthy for chickens: Avocados, white potatoes (sweet potatoes are ok), leaves of tomatoes/eggplants, fruit seeds/pits, raw/dried beans, rhubarb, onions, chocolate, coffee/tea/caffeine, nothing too sweet/salty/fried, rice/pasta/bread, dairy  If you have feeders outside, do not leave them outside overnight. Move them into a rodent proof area  A second feeder should be provided if there are especially submissive or aggressive birds, as feeder guarding can occur Water  Fresh, clean water should be provided and changed daily  A second water bowl or source should be provided if there are especially submissive or aggressive birds, as water guarding can occur.  Each bird can drink up to a liter of water per day so ensure your water containers contain at least that volume Eggs  Egg laying starts at 5-6 months of age, peaks around 18 months and declines thereafter and will stop with reproductive disease  Different breeds lay at different rates; in general, humans have bred hybrid egg-laying breeds to lay the most, but at the cost of a shortened lifespan (see breeds below)  Eggs can be laid anytime; pick eggs in the AM and PM to decrease chance of predators finding them, decrease chance of hens learning to eat them, and will keep them out of the hot sun or from freezing in winter  To encourage egg-laying in the nester, line it with soft material such as aspen savings or hay and change often; keep the nester clean and dry.  Chickens don’t lay their entire life. Chicken Health  Veterinarians: A veterinarian is strongly recommended for your chickens. Ideally, each chicken would have an appointment with a chicken veterinarian when you first get it (“healthy pet exam”) to establish a relationship with a veterinarian. That way when it gets sick, you already have a veterinarian of record. Veterinarians below regularly see backyard chickens (there are many others in the Twin Cities area): o Cedar Pet Clinic, Lake Elmo Drs. John Baillie, Anna Ulfeng, Noemi Plantz 11051 Stillwater Boulevard Lake Elmo, MN 55042 651-770-3250 cedarpetclinic.com o Valley View Pet Hospital Drs. Larry and Michelle Tholl 13600 Cty. Rd 11 Burnsville, MN 55337 952-432-9661 valleyviewvet.com o Camden Pet Hospital Dr. Cynthia Fetzer 1401 44th Ave. N Minneapolis, MN 55412 612-522-4374 camdenpet.com  Preventative medicine: o It is important to regularly handle your chickens so you can identify when they might be sick. Chickens hide illness so when you notice your chicken is sick, they are often very ill. o Chickens would also benefit from yearly fecal examinations by your veterinarian and subsequent deworming as needed. o Vaccines are generally only given to chicks at the hatchery so are not needed. o If you acquire new chickens at any point, a 2-week quarantine period is recommended. During this time, keep the new chickens (and anything that comes into contact with them) completely separate from your existing flock. This period allows you to monitor for underlying health problems before introduction.  What does a healthy chicken look like? (from Chicken Run Rescue) o Eyes: clear, clean, wide open, alert o Face/comb/wattle: clean, soft, blemish free, healthy deep red indicating good blood supply, (some faces are not red) o Posture: head erect, good balance, stand or perch on both feet on extended legs, good grip on perch, facing activity o Odor: none or slightly fermented hay o Beak/nostrils: clean, uniform, shiny and solid o Legs/feet: clean, shiny, uniform scales and nails, foot bottom soft and blemish free, legs and toes straight and functional Feathers; clean, bright, shiny, smooth or fluffy, free of mites or lice o Wings: held close to body, symmetrical, smooth movement in joints when flexed, flight feathers intact o Skin: clean, soft, pale pink and translucent (some breeds have bare red patches at shoulders and keel), free of mites or lice o Droppings: 70% odorless green/ white, firm, 30% stinky brown pasty (cecal), watery if stressed o Keel/sternum: Straight, good muscle mass on either side, lump free o Crop (on bird’s right side of lower neck): full, contents of consumed food easily palpated o Vent: petite, clean, moist, soft, pliant o Respiration: 12-37 per min., inspiration louder and shorter than expiration, minimal chest movement, closed beak  What does a sick chicken look like? o It is important to know what your chickens NORMALLY look like—this is healthy. If anything changes, likely this is ABNORMAL and likely needs to be looked at by a vet. o This picture is of a VERY sick chicken that needs veterinary care immediately. Note how the chicken is standing low to the ground, appears slightly fluffed, eyes are closed, tail is held down, etc.  What do I do if my chicken is sick? o Bring to your veterinarian, just like any other pet. o It is inhumane to let a sick chicken slowly die without veterinary care. Miscellaneous FAQs: Find a chicken mentor, the best way to learn about keeping chickens is to volunteer with CRR, or spend time with someone who already owns city chickens.  What can I expect to spend? o Start-up costs: for coop, maintenance, tools, cleaning, equipment, heating/cooling appliances, dishes, nets, food storage, scale, fencing, security locks, lighting, motion detectors, monitors, cameras, permit application = $2000-3000 o Annual supplies per bird: for food, bedding, nutritional supplements, hygiene supplies, utilities= $300 o Veterinary care per bird per service: office exam $66, fecal test $28, plus other services as needed for illness or injury $?  How long do chickens live? 2-10+ years o While many birds won’t make it past the age of 2 some can live to be 10+ years. o You must plan to care for your chickens for their entire life as re-homing is difficult and shelters in the Twin Cities do not take chickens  How much time per day can I expect to spend on chicken care? 30-60+ min/day o Monitor and observe them twice per day o Daily maintenance to shelter and fencing o Minimum twice yearly large scale maintenance (deep cleaning coops, hauling bedding, re building fencing, etc) which will take hours/days. o Much more time will be needed if foraging time is supervised, any birds are sick, etc  Where do I get chickens? o Adopt! Chicken Run Rescue, Minneapolis Animal Care and Control, etc o If you purchase chicks from a breeder, this is a high likelihood you will accidentally get roosters. You won’t be able to tell they are roosters for several months, after you’ve become bonded. There are no more rooster homes in the Twin Cities area.  How many chickens should I get? o Chickens are flock animals so a minimum of 2 is recommended o Start with the lowest number possible until you know you can handle more (ie start with 2 for the first year and increase as space, time and resources allows) it is easy to find more chickens to adopt but will be almost impossible to re-home unwanted birds.  What kinds of breeds do I want to get? Recommendations on breeds o Meat chickens, Cornish, Cornish-cross, hybrid meat type birds: These breeds aren’t meant to live past 5 months of age and they have chronic pain issues, joint problems, heart attacks etc. These birds should be euthanized after 5 months of age for humane reasons. o Hybrid egg laying, sex-linked, egg-laying breeds: these breeds are bred to lay an egg a day, and often have health issues associated with their over active ovaries, including laying internally, egg-yolk peritonitis, cancer, lash eggs, nutrient depletion, poor feather quality, and more. If you get this breed, anticipate increased veterinary bills and decreased lifespan. o “Heritage” Breeds: Are breeds usually bred for shows or other physical characteristics rather than their egg laying potential. Often these have less health problems. o Production (aka fake) Heritage breeds: many “heritage breeds” have actually been crossed with egg laying breeds to increase production, and therefore have increased health problems related to their over active ovaries.  What if I can’t keep the chickens I have? o Shelters in the Twin Cities area do not take chickens. You need to have a back-up plan; do you know anyone you can rehome the birds to? What kind of life will the new owner provide the bird? o Consider ways to keep your commitment to your chickens; CRR has some great advice and tips on this and rehoming: http://www.chickenrunrescue.org/Finding-a-New-Home- for-a-Chicken o As a last resort, have them euthanized by an avian veterinarian; this is more humane than releasing or letting them starve/freeze to death. Referenced Materials: Bloom, Jessi & Kate Bladwin. 2012. Free-Range Chicken Gardens: How to Create a Beautiful, Chicken-Friendly Yard. Timber Press, Portland, OR. Chicken Run Rescue, www.chickenrunrescue.org, Elko, MN. Cutler Supply, knotted gamebird netting http://cutlersupply.com/zen_new51/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=9_117 Greenacre, Cheryl & Theresa Morishita, 2015. Backyard Poultry Medicine and Surgery. Wiley Blackwell. How to compost chicken feces: https://www.cals.uidaho.edu/edcomm/pdf/CIS/CIS1194.pdf To see some great chicken shelters, consider taking the Twin Cities Coop Tour (usually occurs one day every fall) you can start reading about some of the past tours here: https://sites.google.com/site/twincitiescooptour/ NATURAL HISTORY OF THE CHICKNE (from CRR) It is important to understand how chickens live in the wild and to provide them with an environment that meets those instinctive physical and psychological needs as closely as possible. Chickens are all descended from Tropical Jungle Fowl are adapted to living in a natural habitat that is spacious, richly vegetated, diverse and warm. This presents a particular challenge in a small urban setting in a cold climate like Minnesota. Flocks have a highly developed social structure and depend on each for companionship and security. Naturalists have observed that they can recognize and remember 180 other individual flock members. They are ground dwelling birds. Most are capable of low flight in short distances, smaller birds can fly higher and farther. In the wild they roost in trees at dusk before they sleep or to escape predators. They hide their nests in cavities in the ground. The majority of their waking hours are spent active, wide ranging, grazing, foraging for food- plants, bugs and occasionally small rodents. In their natural state. They typically travel 1/2 mile from their roost each day. In the wild, they are never over crowded- if the population becomes to dense, members will break off into subgroups and spread out. They move on from one area to another which allows food sources to regenerate and their waste is not concentrated in one place and it can decompose without health risk to the flock. Roosters alert the flock to danger, find food and call the hens to it and stand guard as they eat. They select and build nests and will even participate in caring for the young. They also act as peace keepers to intervene in disputes that can develop between flock members. Roosters will start to crow and display courting behaviors at about 6 months of age. It is essential to gently handle a rooster on a daily basis to establish that you are the flock leader (Alpha) and maintain a well socialized companion. The hens spend their time scratching for food, dust bathing, preening, playing and napping. Hens begin to lay eggs at about 6 months of age. Hen in the wild produce only a few clutches of eggs a year for the sole purpose of reproduction. Domesticated hens have been bred to lay one egg a day but by 18 month of age, egg laying frequency generally diminishes and many adult or senior hens stop laying altogether. Chickens are sociable, cheerful and intelligent creatures who can form lifelong bonds with each other and other species including humans, dogs and cats. Because of their keen intelligence and instinctive physical activity, they need a stimulating environment that mimics as much as possible the rich and diverse world nature designed them to enjoy. Please fill out this page and return to City Hall of Little Canada: Resident information: Name:____________________ Address:____________________ Phone number:________________ I, (print name)_____________________, have read and understood the Backyard Chicken Information Packet obtained from the City of Little Canada. (signed name) _____________________________ (date)_________________ Ordinance Proposal: Tiered allowance based on lot size Lot Size (acres) Maximum # of chickens allowed Type of chickens allowed 0-0.49 4 Hens 0.5-.99 6 Hens 1-1.99 8 Hens 2-2.99 10 Hens 3-3.99 12 Hens 4+ 14 Hens/ Up to 2 Roosters Permit required: Smell, noise, and maintenance concerns are addressed in other ordinances (Noise, Nuisance, Cat & Dogs.) Permits are revocable (after 30 day notice) if city staff feels complaints, ordinance violations are not addressed. Roosters only allowed on exceptionally large lots. 4+ acres. Minimum 15ft Setbacks required. r y r i n n i i A i l w h i k n S u e o O a c e S t a n a r s w i t C t e s t a t o C c e s v R o o s t e r s # A l l o w e d L o t S i z e H e i g h t o f R u n R u n / E x e r c i s e S i z e A r e a A l l o w e d H o u s e o r G a r a g e A n o k a N o 4 S i n g l e F a m i l y n o r e q u i r e m e n t n o r e q u i r e m e n t n o t s p e c i f i e d B l o o m i n g t o n N o 4 S i n g l e F a m i l y X x N o D u l u t h N o S S i n g l e F a m i l y n o t s p e c i f i e d 1 0 s q f t p e r N o E a g a n N o S S i n g l e F a m i l y n o r e q u i r e m e n t n o r e q u i r e m e n t N o F a r m i n g t o n N o 3 S i n g l e F a m i l y 4 ' 2 0 s q f t p e r N o L a k e E l m o N o 4 t o 2 2 * * * * 1 / 2 a c r e m i n i m u m t o a l l o w 6 ' 1 0 s q f t p e r N o M a p l e w o o d N o 1 0 S i n g l e F a m i l y 6 ' 1 0 s q f t * N o S h a k o p e e N o 5 S i n g l e F a m i l y 6 ' 2 0 s q f t p e r N o S h o r e v i e w y e s a n d n o * * 4 R e s i d e n t i a l n o t s p e c i f i e d n o t s p e c i f i e d n o t s p e c i f i e d S t . P a u l N o 1 c h i c k e n p e r c o o p s i z e S i n g l e F a m i l y n o t s p e c i f i e d n o t s p e c i f i e d n o t s p e c i f i e d S t i l l w a t e r N o 5 3 a c r e s o r m o r e n o t s p e c i f i e d n o t s p e c i f i e d n o t s p e c i f i e d S t . P a u l P a r k N o 4 S i n g l e F a m i l y 6 ' 2 0 s q f t p e r N o S . S t . P a u l N o 4 S i n g l e F a m i l y n o r e q u i r e m e n t n o r e q u i r e m e n t N o W h i t e B e a r L a k e N o 4 S i n g l e F a m i l y 4 ' * * * 6 s q f t f e n c e d , 1 0 s q f t n o f e n c e N o V a d n a i s h e i g h t s c h i c k e n s p r o h i b i t e d b u t r e v i e w i n g o r d i n a n c e s r i g h t n o w ( L i k e l y t o p a s s . N e w m a y o r i s i n f a v o r . ) R o s e v i l l e y e s n o l i m i t A n y g e n e r a l f e n c i n g r e s t r i c t i o n s a p p l y n o r e q u i r e m e n t n o t s p e c i f i e d M i n n e a p o l i s y e s C i t y t h a t s h a r e s a b o r d e r w i t h L i t t l e C a n a d a * M a p l e w o o d s t a t e s 1 0 s q f t p e r c h i c k e n f o r a r u n t h a t h a s a c c e s s t o a f e n c e d y a r d . I f n o a c c e s s t o e x e r c i s e a r e a t h e n 1 6 f t p e r b i r d r e q u i r e d . E x e r c i s e y a r d s a r e r e q u i r e d t o b e f e n c e d a n d i f t h e r u n t o e x e r c i s e y a r d i s n o t 1 6 f t p e r b i r d t h e n t h e e x e r c i s e y a r d h a d t o p r o v i d e 1 7 4 s q f t o f a r e a p e r b i r d . * * O n r e s i d e n t i a l p r o p e r t i e s 2 a c r e s o r l e s s . P e r m i t t e d w i t h 2 a c r e s o r m o r e p r o v i d e d t h e c r o w i n g i s n o t a n u i s a n c e . * * * W h i t e B e a r L a k e c i t y s t a f f r e c o m m e n d e d o r d i n a n c e t h a t r e q u i r e s 6 ' h e i g h t o f r u n d u e t o c o m p l a i n t s t h e y ' v e r e c e i v e d f r o m t h e i r r e s i d e n t s o n t r o u b l e s c l e a n i n g . * * * * L a k e E l m o i n c r e a s e s t h e n u m b e r o f c h i c k e n s a l l o w e d b y e v e r y h a l f a c r e . Re: chicken complaints ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ From: Amy Kirkeide <Amy.Kirkeide@cityofroseville.com>  Date: Fri, Sep 16, 2016 at 8:26 AM  Subject: RE: chicken complaints  To: Renee Scho턗 <scho턗ski1@gmail.com>  Cc: Brian Coughlin <Brian.Coughlin@cityofroseville.com>  Good morning, Renee,   I will double check with Brian Coughlin, who was in this posi) on for several years before I started this past May.  As far as I know, we haven’t had any chicken complaints since I started four and a half months ago.  We have had one rooster complaint, since they can be noisy.  Brian will return to the office on Tuesday September 20th, and he can offer more informa) on than I can.    One thing that has surprised me since I started is the number of Roseville residents who have or ask about ge뭭ng chickens.  There have been about a dozen inquiries into the rules for chickens just this summer!   Amy Kirkeide | Code Compliance Of Re: Chicken question ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Chris Swanson <chris.swanson@maplewoodmn.gov>  Date: Fri, Sep 16, 2016 at 8:53 AM  Subject: Chicken ques Kara  Coustry City Clerk 4701 Highway 61 City of White Bear Lake (651) 429‐8508 kcoustry@whitebearlake.org    |  www.whitebearlake.org                 Follow us on Facebook & Twi Re: FW: Notifier 2 ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Emily Becker <EBecker@lakeelmo.org>  Date: Mon, Sep 19, 2016 at 8:06 AM  Subject: RE: FW: No릸fier 2  To: Renee Scho Re: Chicken complaint ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Tony Wippler <twippler@ci.farmington.mn.us>  Date: Mon, Sep 19, 2016 at 8:15 AM  Subject: Chicken complaint  To: "scho Re: chicken complaints ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Bill Reynolds <BReynolds@shakopeemn.gov>  Date: Fri, Sep 16, 2016 at 2:06 PM  Subject: FW: scho Re: FW: chicken complaint question From: Carrie Lane   Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 1:13 PM  To: Kyle Deming <kdeming@DuluthMN.gov>  Subject: RE: chicken complaint ques Re: Eagan Citizen Support Center Service Request Updated :: W016722‐ 091516 ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐  From: Ci Unhappy Resident Greetings Council Members I am writing you today to express my disappointment in how the issue of allowing chickens in Little Canada was handled. I'm not sure which part frustrates me more, the fact that you denied the measure or the fact that you were considering adopting it when it only benefited Renee Schott and potentially four other properties in the city. I wish I could have attended the meeting myself so that I could have tried to bring some reason to the discussion, but unfortunately, I could not. My husband and I moved to Little Canada in 2012 from our home in Maplewood. We have three daughters. I am a nurse and my husband is a shop foreman and Roseville Firefighter of 16 years. Before we purchased the home, I had researched about whether chickens were allowed. I love chickens. I always have and it has been a dream of mine to own them. Every year, I spend lots of time in the poultry building at the MN State Fair. I was unhappy about the fact that chickens weren't allowed in Little Canada and even considered looking for other properties elsewhere. However, we loved the 1913 farmhouse that we found ﴾on a half acre lot﴿ and decided to buy it anyway. At the time, I guessed that it was only a matter of time before the city would change the ordinance, because nearly every other city in the surrounding area had. I thought that if a city council as bad as that of Maplewood could get it together enough to make it work, surely the council members of Little Canada could as well. We're not reinventing the wheel here. Copying the codes from other nearby cities with successful, happy, chicken‐owning residents should not have been difficult. I have a brother who lives in Roseville. He and his roommates have a number of chickens on their small city lot, which measures about 1/3 of an acre. One of his roommate's sons participates in 4H with the chickens. They have never had a single neighbor complain about the chickens. In fact, the chickens have brought them together. Neighbors come to visit the chickens with their children and my brother gives them eggs. I have talked to my neighbors about the topic of chickens and they were overwhelming approving of the idea. This was something that I was looking forward to sharing with my children and all of the other kids in the neighborhood that they play with. My hopes on this matter are that the city council will be willing to have new and better discussions on the issue in the near future so that we can find a common resolution that will work for everyone. There were so many details that were not addressed ﴾or at least not discussed at the meeting﴿, like the potential of using permit fees to cover the cost of potential city inspector visits. I also believe ﴾having had so many conversations with other residents about it﴿ that other people in the city are very much in favor of this. It's unfortunate that the city council members based their decisions, at least in part, on the lack of expressed support from city residents. If I'd had enough warning that this was to be discussed, I certainly would have made arrangement to be able to attended the meeting. I would have asked my neighbors and other resident that I know to write a letter or an email, or perhaps to sign a petition. I believe that the desire is there. Going forward, this is something that I will consider in future council elections. ﴾I've heard other people say the same in past years, having asked some candidates on their views on this.﴿ I sincerely hope that this is not the end of this discussion. Regards, Amanda Gutierrez Amanda Gutierrez <amgutierrez23@gmail.com> Sun 9/18/2016 9:35 PM To:John Keis <john.keis@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Tom Fischer <tom.fischer@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Christian Torkelson <christian.torkelson@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Michael McGraw <michael.mcgraw@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Rick Montour <montourrick@comcast.net>; Cc:mlhagert@lillienews.com <mlhagert@lillienews.com>; Chickens in Little Canada Dear Mayor Keis and Council, I am wri Removing Chicken Ban Dear Council Members and Mayor, I am in favor of removing the ban on chickens in Little Canada. I was excited to buy my first home and move to Little Canada, where I had hoped to have chickens. I was very saddened to learn that they are not allowed here, not to mention every other surrounding city either allows them, or is in the process of allowing them. I know at the last council meeting regarding chickens it was stated that the ban wound't be lifted because not enough people want them; isn't that a good thing if hundreds/thousands of people don't instantly want chickens? Why wouldn't it be good to start small, with the people that really want them and then it can slowly spread. I am open to classes, rooster bans and getting a permit. I just ask that you please reconsider your position. Times have changed, information about urban farming is readily available and it seems as though it's going incredibly well in other communities. Thank you, Andrea Main Little Canada resident Andrea Main <andreajomain@gmail.com> Mon 1/23/2017 9:22 AM To:John Keis <john.keis@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Tom Fischer <tom.fischer@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Christian Torkelson <christian.torkelson@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Michael McGraw <michael.mcgraw@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Rick Montour <montourrick@comcast.net>; A request to the city of Little Canada Dear Councilpersons and Mayor, It has been brought to my attention that there has been increased attention in our city for the allowance of backyard chickens. It pains me to have to write this, because can't believe that a town that has held pride in the fact that we are working class with plenty of pride of ownership in our homes cannot be trusted to hold chickens in their backyards. Many of our surrounding communities are able to enjoy the freedom of having chickens, including larger communities with smaller yard spaces ﴾such as Minneapolis and St. Paul﴿. Communities similar in socioeconomic and culture to ours have also allowed chickens ﴾such as Maplewood, Oakdale and Shoreview﴿. Chickens are an environmentally friendly way to provide food for families. Many of us working class people are on tight budgets. When people are free to raise their own eggs, they are probably also self sufficient enough to garden for themselves and take pride in their homes in yards. Also bear in mind the following facts: Chickens are fun, friendly pets with educational value for children about where food like eggs comes from They can provide food security for poor families They lay healthier eggs compared to store‐bought eggs They give gardeners high‐quality fertilizer They control flies and other pests, not add to them, and dispose of weeds and kitchen scraps that otherwise might end up in the landfill When their pen is kept clean, the smell and waste is no worse than a home with dogs or cats. There is a steady rise of urban "farming" among the younger Gen X and Millennial generations. Homeowners are doing more and more Do It Yourself work and taking on the responsibility of maintaining more than just their house on their property. We want more options to serve ourselves and our families without breaking the laws of the community and neighbors around us. I sincerely hope that the council members who are opposed to offering Little Canadians this small freedom will reconsider their views and listen to what the people of their community desire for their own quality of life. Regards, Andrea Blalock 33 E County Road C Unit 104 Little Canada, MN 55117 andrea.g.blalock@gmail.com A Blalock <andrea.g.blalock@gmail.com> Mon 1/23/2017 9:43 AM I am in Favor of allowing citizens in Little Canada to raise a few chickens. Hi Christian, I am in favor of allowing the citizens in Little Canada to be allowed to raise a few chickens in their back yards in Little Canada. They should also be allowed to sell or give the eggs produced to their neighbors and/or local local flea markets and or local grocery stores. Thank You. Kind Regards, Wendy Fairbanks St. Clair 215 Co. Rd. B2 East Apartment 202 Little Canada, MN. 55117 763.310.4795 ﴾﴾﴾﴾Be the change you wish to see in this world﴿﴿﴿﴿ wendy fairbanks st. clair <wmhick@hotmail.com> Wed 1/25/2017 8:29 AM To:Christian Torkelson <christian.torkelson@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; From:Rick Montour To:Joel Hanson Subject:Fwd: In Favor of raising a few chickens in back yards in Little Canada, MN Date:Wednesday, January 25, 2017 10:55:54 AM Get Outlook for iOS ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: "wendy fairbanks st. clair" <wmhick@hotmail.com> Date: Wed, Jan 25, 2017 at 8:46 AM -0600 Subject: In Favor of raising a few chickens in back yards in Little Canada, MN To: "rick.montour@ci.little-canada.mn.us" <rick.montour@ci.little-canada.mn.us> Hi Rick, I am in Favor of allowing citizens in Little Canada to raise a few chickens in their back yard. They do not need a rooster in order to raise egg laying hens. If we can live through train noise, construction noise, freeway noise, road noise, emergency vehicle noise, the noise of children playing and dogs barking, we can certainly live with the noise of a few chickens clucking. Thank you. Kind Regards,Wendy Fairbanks St. Clair215 Co. Rd. B2 EastApartment 202Little Canada, MN 55117763.310.4795 ((((Be the change you wish to see in this world)))) Please support lifting the ban on chickens: Greeĕngs.  Thank you for taking the ĕme to read this short note.   I grew up in a family that raised chickens in a suburban neighborhood and thought it was a fun learning experience. We never had issues with our neighbors and received nothing but posiĕve feedback. (This might have had something to do with all the eggs we shared.) As a Liĥle Canada resident I’d love to share this interesĕng experience with my own two children.   I feel like there really isn’t a good reason to not allow chickens if our immediate neighbors raise no objecĕon. It seems to be working well in nearby communiĕes that allow it. I don’t think this is a slippery slope where people will soon be clamoring to raise horses and goats. I would be in favor of a ban on roosters and seħ ng a limit on number of hens per area of land.   I thank you for your consideraĕon and I look forward to the li├ing of the ban on chickens here in Liĥle Canada. It could be a fun opĕon for homeowners!   Jason Holschuh  |  Tierney  |  Graphic Designer   1771 Energy Park Drive, St. Paul, MN 55108  jasonholschuh@ĕerneybrothers.com  P: 612‐455‐3632  |  F: 612‐331‐3424   Website I Facebook I Twiĥer I LinkedIn   Jason Holschuh <JasonHolschuh@tierneybrothers.com> Wed 1/25/2017 11:49 AM To:John Keis <john.keis@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Tom Fischer <tom.fischer@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Christian Torkelson <christian.torkelson@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Michael McGraw <michael.mcgraw@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Rick Montour <montourrick@comcast.net>; Chickens! Hello All!   First, thanks for making Li FW: Chickens An e‐mail Council Member McGraw received. FYI     From: "John and Jean Storm" <jj.storm@comcast.net>  Date: September 26, 2016 at 11:33:27 AM CDT  To: <michael.mcgraw@ci.liΑle‐canada.mn.us>  Subject: Chickens Mr. McGraw:  you have my support in opposing  allowing chickens in LiΑle Canada.   How does anyone think a code can be changed and affect only one person.  Allowing chickens on any property affects the neighbors.  I have trusted the Council to make good decisions for the whole of LiΑle Canada residents not just one.   I sincerely appreciate all the work you do for the City of LiΑle Canada.  I hope that you can work with your other members to consider all residents not just one.   You may share this e‐mail with your council.   Jean D. Storm 2485 Canabury Drive  #107 LiΑle Canada, MN  55117   Joel Hanson Mon 9/26/2016 2:41 PM To:Christian Torkelson <christian.torkelson@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; John Keis <john.keis@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Michael McGraw <michael.mcgraw@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Mike McGraw ﴾mcpuck93@aol.com﴿ <mcpuck93@aol.com>; Rick Montour <montourrick@comcast.net>; Tom Fischer <tom.fischer@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Little Canada ‐ Code Amendment for Farm Animals Dear Mayor Keis, Council Members and Mr. Hanson,   I have lived in LiΑle Canada for 22 years and am wri΄ ng to express my opinion that the City not amend the Code to allow farm animals in the City of LiΑle Canada. I have heard that a poten΄ al home buyer who is a veterinarian is reques΄ ng the Code amendment to allow her to raise twelve chickens. Although she may have experience with chickens, I don’t think that her request should be granted.   First, LiΑle Canada is a suburban area, not agricultural, and I believe that having chickens in residen΄ al areas is not appropriate. I would not want to live next to someone raising any chickens, let alone twelve chickens. What would the setback requirements be for chicken coops, would chickens be free range up to neighbors’ property boundaries, and how would neighbors be assured that the yard would be kept clean and sanitary?   Second, as an aΑorney, I don’t think that a Code amendment could be craēed to limit chicken ownership to people who are educated and knowledgeable in raising farm animals. It’s been suggested that there be a permiΕ ng process that requires training for someone who wants to raise chickens. Who would do the training and tes΄ ng – Ramsey County Extension Service? Who would cover the cost of the training and tes΄ ng? And if a property owner proves to be unfit, what would the City do? I don’t want to be the neighbor calling the City about unhealthy condi΄ ons, trespassing by the chickens, etc.   Although amending the City Code to allow ownership of twelve chickens in a rural area may encourage this family to move to LiΑle Canada, it might encourage current residents who have always lived in a suburban area to move away from the nuisance of having farm animals as neighbors.   Thank you for your considera΄ on.   Julie Wrase 636 LaBore Road LiΑle Canada, MN 55117 Julie Wrase <jwrase@comcast.net> Mon 9/12/2016 7:02 PM To:*LC_council <LC_council@metro‐inet.us>; John Keis <john.keis@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Joel Hanson <joel.hanson@ci.little‐ canada.mn.us>; NOOOOO CHICKENS !!!!!!  Chickens smell very bad. Backyards are not for chickens.  This is the cities, not a 1000 acre farm. I grew up near chicken barns only half a mile away from my house and city limits. No way do I want farm animals smelling up my air. Nor do I want to see or hear them. If I wanted to do that I would be living on a farm. It is bad enough when someone elses dog poops in my yard and I step into it and have to smell that. Farmers go back to the country where you belong. The cities is no place for farm animals! PHEUUUUEEEEE! Susan Dollery SUSAN <sjdollery@yahoo.com> Tue 1/10/2017 9:42 PM To:John Keis <john.keis@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Tom Fischer <tom.fischer@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Christian Torkelson <christian.torkelson@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Michael McGraw <michael.mcgraw@ci.little‐canada.mn.us>; Rick Montour <montourrick@comcast.net>; Concern over proposed backyard chickens ordinance in Little Canada Hello, I hold concern over the proposed ordinance that would allow chickens to be raised in Little Canada, which I was informed that it will be addressed at the council meeting on the 25th. I was raised on a farm in Wisconsin and we raised 250 chickens a year. The eggs were sold and we burched the old chickens and then sold the chicken meat to a local market as this was in the 1940's, when there was less regulations that we have now. Have the people who want the chickens indicated their intent and reasoning behind on why they would like backyard chickens (as pets, for locally grown food, etc.)? Most lots in Little Canada are small to the point where their backyards wouldn't be able to large enough more than a couple chickens. It can also be tricky to keep up with maintaining a chicken coop. I believe that these people will not have enough chickens to have enough eggs for the family to eat. What are these people going to do in the winter with the chickens?  Also when the chickens get old, what are they going to do with them (if they don't eat them, how do they plan to dispose of the remains)? I am concerned if people will ensure to maintain the upkeep required for keeping chickens, as Minneapolis has had issues with that (it did state that most owners did seem to maintain them though). I do see that various suburbs also allow backyard chickens; have we contacted the city officials from those municpialities to learn how their ordinances may have either negatively or positively impacted their community? According to a survey, many residents are apparently in favor of this, albeit I still hold multiple concerns (as stated above) about having this becoming an ordinance. Thanks, Betty Davison BETTY <davison.b@comcast.net> Fri 1/13/2017 6:17 PM To:*LC_council <LC_council@metro‐inet.us>; From:Rick Montour To:Joel Hanson Subject:Fwd: Chickens! Date:Wednesday, January 25, 2017 7:13:24 PM Another Thanks Rick Montour 612 247 1239 Begin forwarded message: Resent-From: <LC_council@metro-inet.us> From: John Kobler <jkobler@local471.com> Date: January 25, 2017 at 6:43:55 PM CST To: <council@ci.little-canada.mn.us> Subject: Chickens! Reply-To: <jkobler@local471.com> Hello All! First, thanks for making Little Canada a wonderful place to live! I want to urge further deliberation on allowing residents to own chickens within the city limits. Please take more time to liberate on the ordinance regarding the backyard chickens. Have we asked the right questions? Understand the issues? Thought through options that could be win-win on both sides of the issue? What is in the city's role to alleviate some issues instead of totally rejecting it? Are there compelling reasons to reject it? Especially if surrounding cities are okay with it. I think most concerns could alleviated by requiring anyone desiring to keep chickens to obtain a license from the city with conditions amenable to the non- chicken keepers. The number of chickens limited and the price of the license scaled to the number. Revocation based on complaints regarding noise, appearance of habitat etc. I’m not going to raise chickens here, but if others want to I’m ok with it under the right conditions. For the record, I really like chickens. I think they are delicious. I mean, pets that you can eat. What’s not to like? Well, good luck. I really think this isn’t that big a deal. I don’t see thousands of Little Canadians becoming chicken ranchers. At least none of my neighbors have ever revealed a great desire to do so and I know them pretty well. Again. Thanks for all you do! This is a great place to live! Sincerely John Kobler Parkview Court MEMORANDUM TO: Elko New Market Mayor and City Council FROM: Bob Kirmis, City Planner SUBJECT: Chicken Regulations DATE: April 28, 2016 INTRODUCTION At the April 5, 2016 meeting of the Planning Commission, the Commission held a public hearing to consider a draft Zoning Ordinance amendment which would allow the keeping of backyard chickens in the City as an accessory to single family residential uses (in residential zoning districts). The public hearing represented the culmination of many months of work as discussions related to the keeping of background chickens were initiated in June of 2015. The work effort included, but was not limited to, a review of example ordinance, informal input from local residents and a business owner, an examination of the pros and cons of the use, review of example backyard chicken facilities (photographs and a video) and input from the City’s Chief of Police and Code Enforcement Officer. As the City Council is aware, the Elko New Market Zoning Ordinance presently limits the keeping of “farm animals,” which includes chickens, to farms. In this regard, the keeping of chickens in residential zoning districts would represent a change in City policy. Background information related to the amendment is provided in our office’s memorandum dated March 15, 2016. DISCUSSION Zoning District Allowance. As part of previous, informal review of the draft amendment, the City Council raised question regarding the need to limit the keeping of backyard chickens to R-1 Districts and lots measuring at least 12,000 square feet in size if required setbacks are satisfied. In this regard, the idea of allowing the activity in R-2, Urban (Small Lot) Residential Districts and upon smaller lots was indirectly raised. The R-2, Urban (Small Lot) Residential District is intended to accommodate single family dwelling units at a relatively dense urban scale and is applied to the Elko and New Market “Original Townsite” areas. Within R-2 Districts, a minimum lot size of 10,000 square feet and a minimum lot width of 50 feet is required. 2 This issue was raised at the Planning Commission’s April 5, 2016 meeting. In consideration of zoning district allowance, the Commission agreed that the keeping of backyard chickens should be allowed in both R-1 and R-2 zoning districts if setback requirements can be satisfied. This change, along with the removal of the minimum 12,000 square foot minimum lot size requirement, is reflected in the attached amendment. Amendment Provisions. With the exception of the two above-referenced changes recommended by the Planning Commission, the provisions of the amendment are identical to those previously reviewed informally by City Council. A summary of the various amendment provisions is provided below: Application Requirements: • The backyard chicken requirements would be imposed within the “Animal Control” section of the City Code and would be allowed by annual permit • First time permit applicants would be required to review educational materials related to the keeping of backyard chickens • A written application and permit fee would be required • The application would include the following: o Breed and number of chickens specified o Agreement to comply with City conditions o Property legal description and evidence of ownership o Property owner consent for keeping of chickens o Submission of site plan o Payment of fee • Annual permit renewal would be required Zoning District Allowance: Backyard chickens would be allowed within the City’s R-1, Suburban Single Family Residential and R-2, Urban (Small Lot) Residential zoning districts. General Requirements: • Occupancy - The owner of backyard chickens would need to reside on the premises • Number of Chickens - A maximum of four chickens would be allowed • Roosters - The keeping of roosters would be prohibited • Prohibited Enclosures - The keeping of backyard chickens in a dwelling, garage or accessory structure not meeting the requirements of the amendment would be prohibited Coop Requirements: • Coops would be prohibited in front and side yards • A maximum of one coop would be allowed per lot 3 • A minimum of four square feet per chicken would be required with a maximum coop area of 40 square feet • Minimum setbacks of 25 feet from principal structures and 10 feet from all property lines would be required • Coops would be prohibited within utility easements • The height of coops would not be allowed to exceed 10 feet in height • The color of the coops would be required to be the same or similar to the principal structure • The material requirements of the coop would mimic the City’s accessory building requirements (as provided in the Zoning Ordinance) • Coops would have to be constructed in a manner to protect chickens from extreme heat and cold • Coops would be required to be maintained in good condition • Coops would need to comply with Building Code requirements Run Requirements: • Runs would need to be attached to and provided access to the coop • Minimum setbacks of 25 feet from principal structures and 10 feet from all property lines would be required • Coops would be prohibited within utility easements • A maximum of one run would be allowed per lot • The maximum of the area of the run would not the allowed to exceed 20 square feet per chicken • Runs would be required to be fully enclosed and covered with durable materials. Structural components of the run would be required to be consistent with coop materials • Fencing materials used as run components would be required to be consistent with fence requirements imposed in residential zoning districts • Runs would be required to be maintained in good condition Sanitation Requirements: • The slaughtering of backyard chickens would be prohibited • The sale of chicken or chicken byproducts would not be allowed • The premises would be required to be kept clean from filth, garbage, and any substances which attract rodents • Coops and surroundings area would be required to be cleaned frequently (to control odor) • Manure would not be allowed to accumulate in a way that causes an unsanitary condition or causes odors to be detectible from another property • Grain and food stored (for backyard chickens) would be required to be kept indoors in a rodent-proof container • Persons no longer intending to keep backyard chickens would be required to notify the City in writing and remove the enclosed coop and run 4 • Coops and runs would be required to be removed from properties upon permit expiration and/or permit revocation (at the property owner’s expense) Public Hearing Comments. Comments at the public hearing were limited to two residents (Dawn Weitzel and Shari Luebbert) who expressed their support for the backyard chicken amendment. In this regard, no public testimony in opposition to the amendment was received. To be noted is that a letter of support for the amendment was received from an Elko New Market resident and business owner (Anna Simon). Such resident/business owner was not however, present at the meeting. Letters of support for the amendment, as provided by Ms. Weitzel, Ms. Luebbert and Ms. Simon are attached to this memorandum. Planning Commission Recommendation. Based on the background information, the recommendation of City Staff and the evidence received at the meeting, the Planning Commission unanimously recommended approval of the attached Zoning Ordinance amendment. Again, the amendment includes the following changes as recommended by the Planning Commission: 1. An allowance for backyard chickens in R-2, Urban (Small Lot) Residential Districts. 2. The elimination of the 12,000 square foot minimum lot size requirement. While the vote on the amendment was unanimous, it should be noted that two Planning Commissioners reiterated their belief that a determination of use acceptability is the responsibility of the City Council (and not the Planning Commission). Additional Correspondence. Following the Planning Commission meeting, a letter in opposition to the amendment was received from Tyler and Kris Osiecki. A copy of the received letter is attached to this memorandum as Exhibit D. Effective Date. Rather than becoming effective immediately upon its passage and publication, the attached amendment references an effective date of June 1, 2016. Such date is intended to provide time for Staff to prepare various application-related materials (including the educational pamphlet and application form) prior to the receipt of formal applications from City residents. BUDGET IMPACT Approval of an amendment may or may not impact City Code enforcement expenditures. This is considered a City Council policy consideration. Such expenditures could however, potentially be addressed though permit/license fees. 5 ACTION REQUESTED Approval of the attached amendment, as recommended by the Planning Commission, which would allow the keeping of backyard chickens in the City as an accessory to single family residential uses (in single family residential zoning districts). Attachments: • Exhibit A - Dawn Weitzel Correspondence • Exhibit B - Shari Luebbert Correspondence • Exhibit C - Anna Simon Correspondence • Exibit D - Tyler & Kris Osiecki Correspondence 1 CITY OF ELKO NEW MARKET SCOTT COUNTY, MINNESOTA ORDINANCE NO. 2016 - _____ AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ELKO NEW MARKET CITY CODE TITLE 6, CHAPTER 4 (ANIMAL CONTROL) AND TITLE 11 (ZONING) TO ESTABLISH REGULATIONS RELATED TO THE KEEPING OF BACKYARD CHICKENS THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ELKO NEW MARKET ORDAINS: SECTION 1. Section 6-4-2 of the Elko New Market City Code (Animal Control Definitions) is hereby amended to add the following definitions: BACKYARD CHICKEN: A female chicken or hen which serves as a source of eggs. COOP: A structure used for housing of backyard chickens as permitted by this Section. ROOSTER: A male chicken. RUN: An enclosed outdoor area, as permitted by the Section, within which backyard chickens may roam. SECTION 2. Section 6-4-4 of the Elko New Market City Code (Nondomestic Animals) is hereby amended to read as follows: 6-4-4: NONDOMESTIC ANIMALS: It shall be illegal for any person to own, possess, harbor, or offer for sale any nondomestic animal within the city limits. Any owner of such an animal at the effective date hereof shall have thirty (30) days in which to remove the animal from the City, after which time the City may impound the animal as provided in this Chapter. Exceptions to this prohibition are as follows: A. The keeping of backyard chickens as regulated by Section 6-4-5-1 of the City Code. B. Animals specifically trained for and actually providing assistance to the handicapped or disabled, and for those animals brought into the city as part of an operating zoo, veterinarian clinic or licensed show or exhibition. 2 SECTION 3. Section 6-4-5-1 of the Elko New Market City Code (Keeping of Backyard Chickens) is hereby added to read as follows: 6-4-5-1: KEEPING OF BACKYARD CHICKENS: A. Purpose. It is the purpose and intent of this Section to permit, but strictly limit, the keeping of backyard chickens as an egg source in a clean and sanitary manner which is not a nuisance to or detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare of the City of Elko New Market. B. Keeping of Backyard Chickens Allowed. A person may keep up to four (4) backyard chickens on property zoned R-1, Suburban Single Family Residential as provided for in Section 11-25A-3 of the City Code and R-2, Urban (Small Lot) Single Family Residential as provided for in Section 11-25B-3 of the City Code provided that: 1. The owner of the backyard chickens resides in a detached dwelling located upon the parcel at which the backyard chickens are kept. 2. The owner of the subject parcel obtains a backyard chicken permit from the City, issued in compliance with this Section. C. Permit Required: A permit is required for the keeping of backyard chickens. 1. Those desiring to keep backyard chickens shall file a written application with the City Clerk on a form provided by the City and pay an application fee. 2. Application materials provided to first time applicants (by the City) shall include and educational pamphlet concerning the raising of backyard chickens in residential areas of the City. Such educational pamphlet shall be in a form approved by the City. Prior to permit issuance, applicants shall acknowledge, in writing, that they have read such pamphlet. 3. The application shall include the following: a. The breed and number of chickens to be maintained on the premises. b. A written statement that the applicant shall, at all times, keep the backyard chickens in accordance with all of the conditions prescribed by the City and that failure to obey such conditions shall constitute a violation of the provisions of this Chapter and will be grounds for cancellation of the permit. c. A legal description of the real property upon which it is desired to keep the chickens and evidence of title to the property. 3 d. Consent of the property owner for the keeping of chickens. e. A site plan of the property showing the location and size of the proposed chicken coop and run, setbacks from the chicken coop to property lines and surrounding buildings (including houses and buildings on adjacent lots), and the location, style, and height of fencing proposed to contain the chickens in a run or exercise area. Portable coops and cages are allowed, but portable locations shall be illustrated with the site plan. f. The required permit fee in accordance with the City’s adopted fee schedule. g. Other information as may be required by the City Clerk necessary to process the permit. h. The City Clerk and/or designee shall process the application. 4. All initial permits shall expire on December 31st of the following year after their issuance unless sooner revoked. Renewal permits shall expire on December 31st of the second year following their issuance unless sooner revoked. 5. The City, upon written notice, may revoke a permit for failure to comply with provisions of this Section or any of the permit’s conditions. 6. The City may inspect the premises for which a permit has been granted in order to ensure compliance with this Section. If the City is not able to obtain the occupant’s consent to enter the property, it may seek an administrative search warrant or revoke the permit 7. The City may revoke any permit issued under this Section if the permit holder fails or refuses to comply with the requirements of this Section or any state or local law governing the cruelty to animals or the keeping of animals. Any person whose permit is revoked shall have the right to appeal the revocation according to the process provided under Section 4- 1-11 of the City Code. 8. Any person whose permit for the keeping of backyard chickens is revoked or who fails to renew a permit shall, within ten (10) days thereafter, humanely dispose of all chickens owned, kept or harbored by such person on the subject property. D. General Standards for the Keeping of Backyard Chickens. 4 1. The keeping of roosters is prohibited under this Section. 2. Backyard chickens shall not be raised or kept for the purpose of fighting. 3. Backyard chickens shall not be kept in a dwelling, garage or accessory structure other than those meeting the requirements of an enclosed coop. 4. All backyard chickens shall have access to an enclosed coop meeting the following minimum standards: a. The enclosed coop may not occupy a front or side yard. b. A maximum of one (1) coop per lot shall be permitted. c. The enclosed coop shall have a minimum size of four (4) square feet per chicken and shall not exceed a maximum of forty (40) square feet in total area. d. The enclosed coop shall be setback a minimum of twenty-five (25) feet from the principal structure, at least ten (10) feet from all property lines and shall not encroach upon utility easements. e. The enclosed coop shall not exceed ten (10) feet in height. f. The enclosed coop shall be the same or similar in color to the principal structure on the lot. g. Enclosed coops shall be compatible with the principal building on the lot. Under no circumstances shall sheet metal, corrugated metal, asbestos, iron, plain concrete block (whether painted or color integrated or not) be deemed acceptable as major exterior wall materials. "Compatible" means that the exterior appearance of the coop (accessory building) is not at variance with the principal building from an aesthetic and architectural standpoint as to cause: 1. A difference to a degree to cause incongruity. 2. A depreciation of neighborhood values or adjacent property values. 3. A nuisance which may have characteristics related to noise, dust, odors, glare, and unsightly building exterior. h. The enclosed coop shall be built to protect the backyard chickens from extreme heat or cold. 5 i. The enclosed coop shall be at all times maintained in a good condition. j. The enclosed coop shall comply with all applicable Building Code requirements. 5. All backyard chickens shall have access to a run meeting the following minimum standards: a. The run shall be attached to and provided access to the coop. b. The run shall be setback a minimum of twenty-five (25) feet from the principal structure, at least ten (10) feet from all property lines and shall not encroach upon utility easements. c. A maximum of one (1) run per lot shall be permitted. d. The run shall have a maximum size of twenty (20) square feet per chicken. e. The run shall be fully enclosed and covered with durable materials. Structural components of the run shall be consistent with coop materials. f. Fencing materials used as run components shall be consistent with fence requirements imposed in residential zoning districts as provided in Section 11-1-5 of the City Code. g. The run shall be maintained in a good condition at all times. 6. The following minimum sanitation standards shall be observed at all times: a. The slaughtering of backyard chickens on the property is prohibited. b. No chicken or chicken byproducts shall be sold upon the subject property. c. All premises on which backyard chickens are kept or maintained shall be kept clean from filth, garbage, and any substances which attract rodents. The coop and its surrounding area shall be cleaned frequently to control odor. Manure shall not be allowed to accumulate in a way that causes an unsanitary condition or causes odors to be detectible from another property. Failure to comply with these conditions may result in the removal backyard chickens from the premises and/or revocation the backyard chicken permit 6 d. All grain and food stored for backyard chickens shall be kept indoors in a rodent-proof container. e. Backyard chickens shall be kept in such a manner which does not constitute a nuisance as provided for in Title 6, Chapter 5B of the City Code. f. Persons no longer intending to keep backyard chickens on the subject property shall notify the City in writing and remove the enclosed coop and run. g. The enclosed coop and run shall be removed from the property upon permit expiration and/or permit revocation at the property owner’s expense. SECTION 4. Section 11-2-2 of the Elko New Market City Code (Zoning Definitions) is hereby amended to add the following definition: BACKYARD CHICKEN: A female chicken or hen which serves as a source of eggs. SECTION 5. Section 11-25A-3 of the Elko New Market City Code (R-1 District - Permitted Accessory Uses) is hereby amended to add the following: Keeping of backyard chickens as regulated by Section 6-4-5-1 of the City Code. SECTION 6. Section 11-25B-3 of the Elko New Market City Code (R-2 District - Permitted Accessory Uses) is hereby amended to add the following: Keeping of backyard chickens as regulated by Section 6-4-5-1 of the City Code. SECTION 7. This Ordinance shall become effective on June 1, 2016. ADOPTED this 28th day of April, 2016, by the City Council of the City of Elko New Market. 7 CITY OF ELKO NEW MARKET BY:___________________________ Robert Crawford, Mayor ATTEST: ______________________________ Sandra Green, City Clerk STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of City Council FROM: Heidi Heller, City Clerk DATE: February 17, 2017 RE: Continued Public Hearing – Preliminary & Final Plat for a Townhome Development at 2736 & 2744 Rice Street – TABLED UNTIL MARCH 6, 2017 Cash for Houses, LLC, the applicant, has indicated that they are not ready with the required engineering items yet, and will need to continue the hearing again until the March 6th City Council meeting. The Council opened the scheduled public hearing on January 25th, continued it to February 8th and continued again until February 22nd. On February 22nd the Council should re-open the public hearing and continue it until the Monday, March 6th Council meeting. NORTHWEST ASSOCIATED CONSULTANTS, INC. __________________________________________________________________ 4150 Olson Memorial Highway, Ste. 320, Golden Valley, MN 55422 Telephone: 763.957.1100 Website: www.nacplanning.com MEMORANDUM TO: Little Canada Planning Commission FROM: Stephen Grittman DATE: February 3, 2017 RE: Little Canada – Lincoln Preserve Concept Plan Review FILE NO: 758.09 – 17.01 Background and Analysis The applicants, proposed developers of 3000 Labore Road (known commonly as the Sculley property) are seeking concept review comments on their proposed development plan. The plan consists of 11 single family lots arrayed along a cul-de-sac street from Labore Road on the parcel’s west side. The property is dominated by a large wetland complex in the middle, and the applicants have also shown a concept sketch for potential development on the east side. The sketch lots and street on the east side are not part of the current plat proposal, as they require, or would benefit from, the participation of other landowners. The City’s Subdivision Ordinance requires the sketch planning of land to show how large parcels may be re-subdivided for future reference. Purpose of Concept Plan Review. The Concept Plan level of review intended is to allow developers to illustrate potential development, and receive feedback from City officials before fully engineered plat drawings are pursued. The City’s review of such plans is designed to highlight potential issues with the project, and to provide that comment for the developer’s consideration as they continue to a more detailed design. The City does not take a formal action to recommend approval or denial of a Concept Plan; rather, the intent is to communicate those issues which may impact a decision on the subsequent Preliminary Plat request, and to indicate where additional information may be necessary for more detailed review. Lincoln Preserve Subdivision Layout. As noted above, the proposed development consists of a single cul-de-sac street from its intersection with Labore Road, extending to the south, and providing access to 11 single family lots, 6 along the west side of the street, adjacent to the boundary of the property, and 5 between the east side of the new street and the wetland. The new street, after it curves to the south, is straight and descends from its intersection at Labore at an elevation of 920, to the terminal cul-de-sac at an elevation of 880, a drop of 40 feet. The cul-de-sac street length is just over 600 feet, resulting in an average grade on the street of about 7.5%. This slope is quite steep for public streets, however, the Subdivision Ordinance accommodates street grades of 8%. The Subdivision Ordinance also limits cul-de-sac streets to a length of 500 feet, but makes exceptions for topography and other natural conditions. Due to the extensive slopes on the property, the design of the subdivision relies on significant retaining wall construction to create the building pads for the homes. Along the west boundary, a retaining wall is shown behind each of the proposed six homes, with a maximum height of 8 feet. The house pads are cut into the grade and would sit below the wall. The grading plan shows a “side walk-out” design, with what would likely be a “tuck-under” garage design as the lots follow the street grade down the hill. On the east side of the street, The lots are built up, and supported by another retaining wall. This wall is up to ten feet in height at its highest point. The homes would sit above the wall and also have a walk-out design. Lots on both sides of the street have about 110 – 120 feet of buildable depth between the right of way line to the walls. This accommodates a 30 foot front yard setback, a 50 foot deep building pad, and a 30 foot deep rear yard to the wall. The lots on the east side of the street are shown to extend to the middle of the wetland area, although most of that area is not usable due to the wetland conditions. As drawn, lot widths appear to be at least 85 feet as required by the R-1 zoning district regulations. Potential Issues. Following is a summary of potential issues for further consideration. 1. Access to, and maintenance of, lot area above or below the wall. For lots on both sides of the street, the retaining wall will prohibit access for use or maintenance to the last several feet of rear yard from the site of the house. Property owners will need to be able to address the access question to deal with maintenance of land that is inaccessible. 2. Maintenance of the wall. The wall is designed to serve as a common structure to accommodate construction and use of the individual lots, but extends across several lots. Common maintenance of the wall will need to be addressed as a part of any approval. 3. Proximity of adjacent future development. With the design of the subdivision as proposed, the adjoining property to the west will be left with little options for development other than a similar straight cul-de-sac street down the hill, but with only a single loaded street (that is, the street on this property would need to abut the rear yards of the homes in the proposed Lincoln Preserve subdivision, or the existing homes in the Gervais Woods project to the west. It is reasonable to assume that such a future street along rear lot lines would not be welcomed by established residents. Short of agreement from the neighboring property owner to cooperate in a joint development, it is not clear how to avoid this situation, or the future conflict that would result. 4. Alternative road alignment. One option to consider would be a slightly altered road alignment for the Lincoln Preserve project. This alignment would carry the street farther into the property and curve it back toward the cul-de-sac at an angle, rather than a straight, north-south alignment. A sketch of this concept is illustrated as an attachment. The intent here would be two-fold. First, by shifting the building pads on the east side of the new street farther east, the retaining wall would likewise be shifted to the east, leaving less inaccessible land below the wall. Second, this allows some of the house pads on the west side of the street to also be shifted eastward, which would accommodate a greater separation from a future abutting roadway, and the planting of an extensive landscape screen above the wall to further mitigate the impact of such a road. This is offered as a suggestion for consideration by the applicant. There are likely to be issues requiring additional attention, not least of which would be the engineering necessary to accommodate this design. Summary and Recommendation As noted, no recommendation is offered as a part of a Concept Review. The Planning Commission and City Council should consider the issues identified in this review and comments made by the City Engineer, together with others raised during the public review, and provide the applicant direction at they pursue the more formal preliminary plat application. pc: Heidi Heller Jessica Jagoe Steve Westerhaus Lee Elfering Nearby Property NAC Staff Sketch Alternative 3000 Labore Road 3000 Labore Road Lab o r e R o a d Pi n e t r e e C o u r t C h e r r y H i l l L a n e Westwind Drive Lydia Ave E. W a l t e r S t r e e t N o r t h Beam Avenue MAPLEWOOD 3000 Labore Road 3000 Labore RoadLAB O R E R O A D Pin e t r e e C o u r t C h e r r y H i l l L a n e Westwind Drive W a l t e r S t r e e t N o r t h Lydia Ave E. Beam Avenue S H E E T 1 LICENSE NO.DATE DAVID NASH, PE I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS PLAN,SPECIFICATION, OR REPORT WASPREPARED BY ME OR UNDER MYDIRECT SUPERVISION AND THAT IAM A DULY LICENSEDUNDERTHE LAWS OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA L I N C O L N P R E S E R V E C O N C E P T P L A N F O R T H E L I N C O L N G R O U P , I N C . E X I S T I N G C O N D I T I O N S PR O J E C T N O : DR A W N : DE S I G N E D : PR O J E C T T E A M D J N N S 2 1 6 - 0 0 9 7 D A T E BY QA / Q C R E V I E W PROFESSIONAL D A T E I S S U E D A T E I S S U E 233 Park Ave S, Ste 300Minneapolis, MN 55415612.758.3080 612.758.3099www.alliant-inc.com MAINFAX 1 o f 3 C O N C E P T P L A N 21836 W E T L A N D D E L I N E A T I O N C O M P L E T E D B Y B O P R A Y E N V I R O N M E N T A L S E R V I C E S - R E P O R T D A T E D O C T 2 5 , 2 0 1 6 . S H E E T 2 LICENSE NO.DATE DAVID NASH, PE I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS PLAN,SPECIFICATION, OR REPORT WASPREPARED BY ME OR UNDER MYDIRECT SUPERVISION AND THAT IAM A DULY LICENSEDUNDERTHE LAWS OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA L I N C O L N P R E S E R V E C O N C E P T P L A N F O R T H E L I N C O L N G R O U P , I N C . S I T E P L A N PR O J E C T N O : DR A W N : DE S I G N E D : PR O J E C T T E A M D J N N S 2 1 6 - 0 0 9 7 D A T E BY QA / Q C R E V I E W PROFESSIONAL D A T E I S S U E D A T E I S S U E 233 Park Ave S, Ste 300Minneapolis, MN 55415612.758.3080 612.758.3099www.alliant-inc.com MAINFAX 2 o f 3 C O N C E P T P L A N 21836 T O T A L S I T E A R E A = 2 5 . 9 2 4 A C W E T L A N D A R E A = 1 3 . 5 0 1 A C T O T A L P R O P O S E D S I T E A R E A = 1 2 . 4 2 3 A C C U L - D E - S A C L E N G T H = 6 8 0 L F C U R R E N T Z O N I N G = R - 1 S I N G L E F A M I L Y R E S I D E N T I A L R - O - W = 5 0 ' C U L - D E - S A C R A D I U S = 5 0 ' M A X C U L - D E - S A C = 5 0 0 L F ( V A R I A N C E R E Q U I R E D ) M I N I M U M A R E A = 1 1 , 0 0 0 S F M I N I M U M W I D T H = 8 5 ' C O R N E R = 1 0 0 ' S E T B A C K S F R O N T = 3 0 ' S I D E = 1 0 ' S T R E E T = 3 0 ' R E A R = 3 0 ' M I N D E P T H = 3 0 ' + 5 0 ' + 3 0 ' = 1 1 0 ' W E T L A N D A B U F F E R = 5 0 ' A V G . , 2 5 ' M I N . W E T L A N D B B U F F E R = 7 5 ' A V G . , 3 7 . 5 ' M I N . P R O P O S E D S I T E W I L L U S E W E T L A N D B U F F E R A V E R A G I N G V I C I N I T Y M A P N O T T O S C A L E S I T E P L A N D A T A R - 1 Z O N I N G ( A F T E R 2 0 0 8 ) L E G E N D P R O P O S E D R I G H T - O F - W A Y P R O P O S E D P R O P E R T Y L I N E P R O P O S E D S E T B A C K S W E T L A N D W E T L A N D B U F F E R P R O P O S E D E A S E M E N T S H E E T 3 LICENSE NO.DATE DAVID NASH, PE I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS PLAN,SPECIFICATION, OR REPORT WASPREPARED BY ME OR UNDER MYDIRECT SUPERVISION AND THAT IAM A DULY LICENSEDUNDERTHE LAWS OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA L I N C O L N P R E S E R V E C O N C E P T P L A N F O R T H E L I N C O L N G R O U P , I N C . G R A D I N G P L A N PR O J E C T N O : DR A W N : DE S I G N E D : PR O J E C T T E A M D J N N S 2 1 6 - 0 0 9 7 D A T E BY QA / Q C R E V I E W PROFESSIONAL D A T E I S S U E D A T E I S S U E 233 Park Ave S, Ste 300Minneapolis, MN 55415612.758.3080 612.758.3099www.alliant-inc.com MAINFAX 3 o f 3 C O N C E P T P L A N 21836 G R A D I N G L E G E N D W E T L A N D W E T L A N D B U F F E R P R O P O S E D C O N T O U R E X I S T I N G C O N T O U R P R O P O S E D E A S E M E N T P R O P E R T Y L I N E P R O P O S E D L O T L I N E P R O P O S E D R I G H T - O F - W A Y S E T B A C K L I N E P R O P O S E D R E T A I N I N G W A L L MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING PLANNING COMMISSION LITTLE CANADA, MINNESOTA FEBRUARY 9, 2017 Pursuant to due call and notice thereof a regular meeting of the Planning Commission of Little Canada, Minnesota was held on the 9th day of February, 2017 in the Council Chambers of the City Center located at 515 Little Canada Road in said City. Chair Bill Buesing called the meeting to order at 7:30 p.m. and the following members of the Planning Commission were present at roll call: PLANNING COMMISSION: Mr. Bill Buesing Ms. Jennifer Schletty-Flores Mr. Al Davison Mr. Chris Kwapick Ms. Catherine Beltmann ABSENT: Mr. Nick Schwalbach Mr. Nick Sandell ALSO PRESENT: Mr. Steve Grittman, City Planner Ms. Jessica Jagoe, Associate Planner Mr. Kevin Helander, Cable TV MINUTES The January 12, 2017 Planning Commission meeting minutes were approved as submitted. The City Planner gave a background of the project, explaining that the applicant is looking to subdivide the large property into 11 single family lots with a cul-de-sac on the west side of the property. He noted that the subdivision ordinance requires that any other possible development on the site be shown, even if it is not proposed at the time, which is the case with the lots shown on the east side. He explained that this is the first step in discussing the development and finding out the developer’s intentions. He stated that there are formal steps required by ordinance to subdivide and plat the property that would occur after this if there is City Council support for the project. The City Planner reported that this development is proposed with a 600 foot long cul-de-sac. He explained that even though the City Code states cul-de-sacs should be no more than 500 feet long, it does allow longer ones to accommodate topography or access issues. He stated that there is CONCEPT PLAN REVIEW OF A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AT 3000 LABORE ROAD; APPLICANT: THE LINCOLN GROUP MINUTES PLANNING COMMISSION FEBRUARY 9, 2017 - 2 - significant grade on this property, noting that from Labore Road to the end of the cul-de-sac there is about a 40 foot grade difference. He stated that the proposed street has a 7 ½ percent grade, which is steep, but is allowed per the City Code and is maintainable. He noted that to accomplish this development, the developer is relying on a lot of retaining wall, so how this wall would be maintained is something the City will have to address. He explained that the property to the west of this site is only wide enough to allow for a street with lots on one side, so if that gets developed in the future, there will likely be homes with a street in their backyard. He stated staff believes that property owner does not want to participate now, but it is anticipated that at some point in the future there will be interest in developing that parcel. The City Planner stated that he drew a slightly different street layout just to address some issues, but the applicant does not have to use his renderings. Buesing asked if there would be a requirement to have a homeowner’s association in order to address the retaining wall maintenance issue. The City Planner stated that is something that will need to be addressed, and an association is one way to do that. Buesing asked if the developer is open to the cul-de-sac suggestions from the City Planner. Mr. Dave Nash, Alliant Engineering, stated that they are not in favor of the alternative street layout because it causes more problems for them since they are dealing with grade issues and would have to install more sanitary sewer structures, but they understand there needs to be more discussion about it. Dan Lincoln, The Lincoln Group, stated he has done developments both with and without a homeowner’s associations, and he is open to having one if the City wants it. John Ryan, 981 Payne Avenue, stated he was at the meeting on behalf of his neighbor, Jim Progreba, to the east who is out of town, and asked why the additional lots were shown on the southeast corner. Mr. Nash stated that City Staff asked them to show the additional ways other areas on the property could be developed, but they have no plans to develop the east side of the property. He noted that it is essentially a ghost plan, and mainly shown in order to demonstrate that the east side is not being cut off and can be accessed if development did progress in the future. Sue Nasseff, 2997 Walter Street, asked for a corrected letter stating that only 11 lots are being proposed. The City Planner stated that when the application came in and the hearing notice was written, it appeared to be an 18 lot development. He noted that any future notices would only indicate what is being developed. MINUTES PLANNING COMMISSION FEBRUARY 9, 2017 - 3 - Dennis Unger, 2975 Walter Street, asked if this ghost lot area would be part of the plat design. Mr. Lincoln stated they would go through this concept plan process again if the east side were going to be developed, but there are a lot of challenges to developing that eastern portion of the lot, and they have no plans to do so at this time. Dan Rydel, 980 Kohlman Court East, stated there have been a lot of issues with weed growth in Kohlman Lake, and asked if there have been any studies done on how the runoff from this development would affect the lake. The City Planner stated that the City Engineer noted that most of the engineering work is not done yet, but a series of ponds are shown that would capture the site’s water runoff. Mr. Nash stated that the ponds shown meet the City’s and watershed district’s rules, and the water must be treated before it runs off. The City Planner noted that generally post- development runoff cannot be any higher than pre-development conditions. Mr. Nash noted that this site will have ponds that treat the water. Sue Unger, 2975 Walter Street, asked how big the lots really were on the eastern side of the cul-de-sac, since they appeared to be very deep and extend far into the wetlands. Mr. Nash stated that a wetland delineation study was completed and approved by the watershed district. He explained that they are proposing the lots on the east side of the street would extend well into the wetlands, but there would be required buffer zones with signs where the property owners could not encroach into the wetlands. Frank Lockman, 1131 Lydia Avenue East, stated that in the last five years there have been two attempts to eliminate some of the deer in the area. He explained that he has several deer that go through his property, and he feels that there should be another elimination effort before this development so that the deer on this property don’t starve. Buesing asked what the Commission’s next step is. The City Planner stated that for a concept plan there is no formal action taken, and the Commission only gives comments to the developer that will be passed on to the City Council during their review on February 22nd. Beltmann stated that she wanted to point out that there are other properties around this site that could be developed, and she wants to make sure that the City is thinking about that when reviewing this proposal. She noted that there has been a lot of development in the Labore Road area and the City should be mindful of those impacts to the wetlands. Schletty-Flores noted that she agrees about being aware of the development impacts to wetlands and that it takes a long time for them to rebound. MINUTES PLANNING COMMISSION FEBRUARY 9, 2017 - 4 - Buesing asked if there were height limitations on retaining walls. The City Planner stated the City Code has no limit on height, but if they are over four feet tall, they must be engineer designed. Beltmann asked if there was any more area that could be developed on the Sculley property in addition to what is already shown. The City Planner stated there is a very small area of high ground along the north side of the property, but it is inaccessible at this point, so what is shown on the plans is about the maximum this site could be developed due to the amount of low ground and wetlands. ADJOURN There being no further business, Buesing adjourned the meeting at 8:11p.m. Respectfully submitted, Heidi Heller City Clerk STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of City Council FROM: Heidi Heller, City Clerk DATE: February 17, 2017 RE: Proposed Date Change for March 8, 2017 Council Meeting Council member McGraw requested that the Council consider rescheduling the Wednesday, March 8th meetings to Monday, March 6, 2017. Staff has verified that changing to Monday will work for the others attending the workshop and Council meeting. If there is consensus from the rest of the Council to change the date, staff will reschedule the Workshop and City Council meeting to Monday, March 6, 2017. 10062 Flanders Court NE – Blaine, MN 55449 – (763) 780-0450 fax (763) 205-2341 H:\Heidi\CITY COUNCIL\2017\Packets\02-22-2017\Item - Authorize Plans & Bids for 2017 Improvements.doc Memo TO: Mayor Keis & Members of the City Council FROM: Lee Elfering, City Engineer DATE: February 16, 2017 RE: 2017 Street & Utility Improvements Project Approval of Plans & Authorization for Advertising As directed at the public hearings held on January 26, 2017, we have prepared plans and specifications for the 2017 Street & Utility Improvements project. In addition to the street improvements that were approved we have also combined other work within the City into the project to capitalize on the economy of scale of a larger project. The following improvements are included in the project: • Reconstruction of Labore Avenue (Jackson Street to the cul-de-sac) • Reconstruction of Rose Place (Jackson Street to Lake Shore Avenue) • Reconstruction of Lake Shore Avenue (Lake Street to the cul-de-sac) • Rehabilitation of Vanderbie Road (Labore Avenue to Allen Avenue) • Installation of Noel Drive Sidewalk (Little Canada Road to City Hall Driveway) • New Fire Hall lot expansion As stated at the public hearing, we are providing a design review meeting to allow affected property owners along the reconstruction streets the opportunity to review the plans and related impacts to their property. This meeting will be held on February 21, 2017 but we do not anticipate significant changes to the plans. At this time we are requesting plan approval and authorization for advertisement for bids from the City Council. It is anticipated that advertisement would begin on February 28, 2017 and bids would be received on March 22, 2017. If you have any questions please call me at (763) 780-0450 extension 3. 10062 Flanders Court NE – Blaine, MN 55449 – Ph: (763) 780-0450 Fax (763) 780-0452 Memo-021617-CC (Feasibility).doc Memo TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Lee Elfering, City Engineer DATE: February 16, 2017 RE: Keller Parkway Mill and Overlay Feasibility Report As required as part of the Chapter 429 assessment process we have completed the attached feasibility report for the proposed improvement of Keller Parkway from County Road C to Arcade Street by mill and overlay. Ramsey County is completing a mill and overlay on the larger portion of Keller Parkway that is under County jurisdiction and it is proposed to have this section completed under the same contract. Keller Parkway south of County Road C has shared City ownership between Little Canada (30%) and Maplewood (70%). Ramsey County would be the lead agency for the project and they have provided the anticipated construction costs. This project is unique in the fact that the work will be completed under a County project. In addition the City has ownership of only half of the roadway for approximately 50% of the project length under City jurisdiction. The feasibility report outlines the proposed method of assessment that the Staff feels provides equitable cost sharing among the properties affected and properties within the City that have been assessed for similar improvements. The City Council should provide input on the proposed method. At this time we are requesting the City Council accept the feasibility report and call for the Improvement Hearing for Keller Parkway. Please contact me at 763-780-0450 ext. 3 with any questions or concerns regarding the report. STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of City Council FROM: Heidi Heller, City Clerk DATE: February 17, 2017 RE: Call for an Improvement Hearing for Keller Parkway Street Project Staff is recommending the Council call for an Improvement Hearing on Wednesday, March 22, 2017 at 6:30pm for the Keller Parkway street project that Ramsey County will be doing in 2017. Feasibility No. 120207E-0030 FEASIBILITY STUDY FOR KELLER PARKWAY MILL & OVERLAY LITTLE CANADA, MINNESOTA FEBRUARY 2017 Elfering & Associates Feasibility Study Project No. 120207E-0030 Keller Parkway Overlay Little Canada, Minnesota i FEASIBILITY STUDY FOR KELLER PARKWAY MILL & OVERLAY LITTLE CANADA, MINNESOTA FEBRUARY 2017 I hereby certify that this plan, specification, or report was prepared by me or under my direct supervision and that I am a duly licensed Professional Engineer under the laws of the State of Minnesota. February 16, 2017 Lee Elfering, P.E. Date License No. 41613 Elfering & Associates 10062 Flanders Court NE Blaine, MN 55449 Phone: (763) 780-0450 Fax: (763) 780-0452 - 1 - INDEX I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 2 II. SCOPE ............................................................................................................................ 2 III. NECESSITY AND COST-EFFECTIVENESS ................................................................... 2 IV. EXISTING CONDITIONS ................................................................................................ 2 V. PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS ...................................................................................... 2 VI. RIGHT-OF-WAY AND EASEMENTS............................................................................... 3 VII. PERMITS ........................................................................................................................ 3 VIII. ESTIMATED PROJECT COSTS ..................................................................................... 3 IX. FINANCING..................................................................................................................... 3 X. SUMMARY ...................................................................................................................... 4 APPENDIX A – PROJECT SITE EXHIBIT APPENDIX B – PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL - 2 - I. INTRODUCTION Ramsey County’s 2017 Resurfacing Plan includes the mill and overlay of Keller Parkway from Edgerton Street to Arcade Street. A large portion of Keller Parkway (Edgerton Street to County Road C) is a County Road, but the remaining section from County Road C to Arcade Street is not. In this section the street is within right-of-way for both the City of Maplewood and Little Canada. In general numbers for the portion of the roadway that is not within County right-of-way the two Cities share ownership of approximately 60% of the roadway with the other 40% contained solely within the City of Maplewood. The exhibit in Appendix A shows the section of Keller Parkway that has shared ownership between the City of Maplewood and the City of Little Canada. II. SCOPE The purpose of this study is to determine the feasibility of rehabilitating the section of Keller Parkway from County Road C to Arcade Street by mill and overlay of the bituminous surface. This report will include information on the existing conditions, proposed improvements, and estimated costs and property assessments as outlined in the City’s Assessment Manual. The most current estimated construction costs will be provided, along with the total project costs that will include overhead costs, such as City administration, engineering, fiscal, and legal costs. III. NECESSITY AND COST-EFFECTIVENESS The purpose of the proposed mill and overlay is to address the deteriorated pavement condition along this segment of roadway to ensure a safe and adequate transportation system for residents of Little Canada and the surrounding area. The proposed improvements will minimize future maintenance costs and the magnitude of the proposed project will ensure competitive bidding. From this standpoint, the project is cost-effective. IV. EXISTING CONDITIONS Keller Parkway between County Road C and Arcade Street has a bituminous surface with a rural section. The street has a varying width between 30 and 32 feet. That width is comprised of 11 foot drive lanes and 4 to 5 foot shoulders. Based on information from Ramsey County the roadway section includes 2” of paved bituminous surface over 4” or more of recycled pavement. V. PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS The improvement of Keller Parkway is proposed to consist of milling off 2 inches of the bituminous surface and repaving the roadway. There would be very limited to no impacts to driveways or adjacent streets as the finished elevation of the road should remain largely unchanged. It is proposed to narrow the driving lanes on the road to 10 feet and increase the shoulder width to 5 to 6 feet. - 3 - VI. RIGHT-OF-WAY & EASEMENTS It is anticipated that all work can be completed within the existing road rights-of-way so no additional easements will be necessary for the work. VII. PERMITS As stated previously the lead agency for the project is Ramsey County and they will be responsible for obtaining all necessary permits and approvals prior to project start up. Some of those approvals include Mn/DOT approval for the portion of Keller Parkway designed as County State Aid highway. VIII. ESTIMATED PROJECT COSTS The County has estimated the construction costs for the portion of Keller Parkway from County Road C to Arcade Street at $60,000.00. This figure does not include any overhead or administration costs for the City. That cost is proposed to be split out at 30% Little Canada responsibility ($18,000.00) and 70% Maplewood responsibility ($42,000.00) based on the ownership percentage of the road. If typical overhead and engineering costs are applied to the construction costs the total project costs to the City of Little Canada is $22,500.00. IX. FINANCING For the purpose of this report we will be concentrating on the City of Little Canada’s portion of the project cost. This section of Keller Parkway is on the City’s Municipal State Aid System and is therefore eligible for reimbursement through Municipal State Aid (MSA) funds. However, the MSA funds are not credited to offset assessments as they are utilized in a revenue pool fund to offset total reconstruction program costs. ASSESSMENTS Based on the City Assessment Policy that governs street reconstruction/ rehabilitation, the primary method of financing street improvements is to assess the adjacent property owners on a front foot basis. The policy has been in place since the mid 90’s and has been modified from its original version to provide more fair assessment of properties as new or changing project types have occurred. The City’s Assessment Policy outlines that the improvement of a rural roadway to a rural section, whether reconstruction or rehabilitation, is assessed 100% to the benefiting properties. It is Staff’s opinion that this section of Keller Parkway is unique in that this roadway is an old County Road turnback in which the City of Little Canada’s ownership is only 30% of the total frontage of the roadway and that ownership is only for a portion of the west half of the road. The sections to the north and south are fully controlled by Ramsey County or the City of Maplewood and are rural sections that will remain as such with this project. Due to the rural nature of the surrounding street it is not recommended to upgrade to an urban section in this area. Therefore we are recommending the City follow - 4 - the standard practice of assessing 50% of the project improvement costs of a rehabilitation. A preliminary assessment roll has been prepared and is shown in Appendix B. Table 1 below summarizes the total project cost that will be borne by the City and the cost that will be assessed to the benefited properties. Table 1 City Costs vs. Assessable Costs LOCATION TOTAL LITTLE CANADA COST CITY COST % CITY ASSESSED COST % ASSESSED KELLER PARKWAY $22,500.00 $18,750.00 83.3% $3,750.00 16.7% It should be noted that the County will be providing more detail on the cost split and a cooperative agreement for execution in the future, but they have indicated they may be able to advance fund the project for the City until January of 2019. X. SUMMARY The project is feasible from an engineering standpoint and this section of roadway has deteriorated to a level that necessitates an improvement by mill and overlay. The work would be done as part of a much larger Ramsey County project to ensure project cost effectiveness. The improvement of this segment would be another step in improving and maintaining the street infrastructure within Little Canada. APPENDIX A EXHIBIT This map is a user generated static output from an Internet mapping site and is for reference only. Data layers that appear on this map may or may not be accurate, current, or otherwise reliable. © Ramsey County Enterprise GIS Division 600.0 THIS MAP IS NOT TO BE USED FOR NAVIGATION 1: NAD_1983_HARN_Adj_MN_Ramsey_Feet 600.0300.00 Legend 3,600 Enter Map Description Notes 0 Feet City Halls Schools Hospitals Fire Stations Police Stations Recreational Centers Parcel Points Parcel Boundaries Cities Airports Start of shared ROW End of Shared ROW APPENDIX B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL PR E L I M I N A R Y A S S E S S M E N T R O L L KE L L E R P A R K W A Y Fe a s i b i l i t y TO T A L P R O J E C T C O S T = 22 , 5 0 0 . 0 0 $ AS S E S S A B L E C O S T P E R P O L I C Y ( 5 0 % ) = 11 , 2 5 0 . 0 0 $ AC T U A L A S S E S S M E N T S FR O N T UN I T S T R E E T PO L I C Y TOTAL AD D R E S S TA X I D . N U M B E R FO O T A G E AS S E S S M E N T NO T E S ASSESSMENT 25 7 1 K E L L E R P K W Y 08 - 2 9 - 2 2 - 1 1 - 0 0 2 5 80 1 Fr o n t s t o K e l l e r 1,875.00 79 6 C A R L A L N 08 - 2 9 - 2 2 - 1 1 - 0 0 2 4 80 0. 2 Ir r e g u l a r l o t , D r i v e w a y o f f o f C a r l a , M i n . 375.00 81 0 C A R L A L N 08 - 2 9 - 2 2 - 1 1 - 0 0 2 3 17 0 . 5 1 0. 2 Co r n e r L o t , D r i v e w a y o f f o f C a r l a L a n e , O d d s h a p e d Lo t 375.00 81 1 C A R L A L N 08 - 2 9 - 2 2 - 1 1 - 0 0 2 6 99 . 8 9 0. 2 Co r n e r L o t , D w o f f o f C a r l a , M a x . F o o t a g e . O w n e r P. O . B o x 3 6 6 , M o n t i c e l l o 375.00 0 K E L L E R P K W Y 08 - 2 9 - 2 2 - 1 1 - 0 0 0 2 35 5 . 2 8 0 Es t i m a t e d F o o t a g e 0.00 81 9 C A R L A L N 08 - 2 9 - 2 2 - 1 1 - 0 0 0 1 23 8 . 1 6 0. 2 Co r n e r L o t , D W o f f o f C a r l a L a n e , E s t F o o t , M i n . 375.00 82 0 C A R L A L N 08 - 2 9 - 2 2 - 1 0 - 0 0 3 2 19 4 . 1 3 0. 2 Co r n e r L o t , d w o f f o f C a r l a , I r r e g u l a r 375.00 TO T A L A S S E S S A B L E F R O N T F O O T A G E ( F T ) 11 3 7 . 9 7 2 TO T A L A S S E S S A B L E C O S T $3,750.00 STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of the City Council FROM: Joel Hanson, City Administrator Jessica Jagoe, Associate Planner DATE: February 17, 2017 RE: Organized Collection Contract Renewal Staff met with representatives of the haulers participating in our organized collection contract last week. During this meeting, city staff was very concise about our expectations with the upcoming rates given the haulers initial proposal. In addition, staff laid out the contract language changes and the justification behind the liquidated damages revisions due to service issues we’ve experienced in the past and again in just the last few weeks. From this meeting, staff is pleased to report that we have come to an agreement on the terms for a five-year (2017 through 2021) renewal contract with the haulers. With the need for contract extensions while we were still in negotiations, staff has previously briefed the Council on some of the contract discussion points. However, I’m provided below a comprehensive list of contract changes and highlights:  In 2017, the residents will see a reduction in their rate (-1.05% on 30, -2.36% on 60, -3.82% on 90, and -4.07% on up to 360 gals) with an average overall increase of 2% per year for the remaining four years. In the breakdown of the rate there is disposal, collection and recycling costs. The disposal cost is intended to be a revenue neutral component for the hauler that reflects the cost for disposal. Studies now show the average per household per year amount of waste generated is 2,000 pounds per year. Staff examined our rate in comparison to the number of accounts multiplied by the tipping fee charged to the haulers for disposal. This showed a profit of roughly $15,000 in disposal costs. As a result, staff reapportioned that $15,000 to other components of the rate which resulted in a decrease in our rates for the first year of the contract. Staff should mention that consideration was given as to whether or not a weight study should be conducted for Little Canada. By doing so it may be that the waste generated in Little Canada is less than the average, but on the flip side there is risk that it is actually higher. In addition, there are some challenges for the hauler in capturing a true picture of only our waste because our routes have combined loads in the truck with other stops. We’d either have to have the hauler perform a route that is Little Canada only (which possess an issue for them) or have them base an average on the number of Little Canada stops and other stops that were collected on that day for the truck (using this option, you are still concluding to an average assumption).  There will be no changes to the types of services provided to our residents under the renewal contract. One of the items of contention for the haulers was the bulky item pickup. During negotiations consideration was given to removing this service from the contract and going to a set fee schedule that would charge per item collected. However, staff through the years has received very positive feedback from our residents that this is a worthwhile and valuable service. Our utilization is about 25% of the customers eligible under the contract, but that number continues to increase each year as it becomes more known.  Yard waste service will remain April 1st through November 30th with language added to say “weather permitting” at the end of the season. During the previous contract, the City had two seasons where the hauler either requested the season start later due to yard waste sites not being open until April 15th or early snowfalls which shortened up the November collection weeks. For the renewal, the haulers have agreed to make arrangements on their end so that the April 1st beginning date is adhered to, but we have added language that does allow for weather to be a consideration for the season ending prior to November 30th. In the event of snow, the hauler has agreed to complete one final week of yard waste collection so that residents who may have carts full of yard waste or compostable bags are given an opportunity to dispose of them. Then as a result of the weather it is assumed that residents would no longer have the ability to rake their leaves up again until the spring.  The rate for yard waste over the term of the contract will now have yearly increases. The previous contract rate is $48 for the season and that rate had not changed for two contracts. The new rate for 2017 will start at $54 and end at $64 in 2021 (33.3% increase over 5 years). The haulers had requested a flat rate of $72 for the term of the contract. The increases each year are somewhat staggered because the amount must be divisible by eight months of service for utility billing purposes. One additional change to contract language for yard waste is that we will now have a seasonal rate for new customer. New customers electing service in April- September will be charged for a full year of service and new customers electing service in October and November would be subject to a partial year (1/2 of current yearly rate). Previous contract language had new customers only paying $6 for the months of service remaining. This was not equitable for new customers who enrolled at the end of the season for fall clean-up.  Rates for customers with 120+ (2 containers), 3 containers, and 4 containers have been combined into one service level which will now be called up to 360 gallon service. We do have roughly 45 customers at the 120+ service level and then less than ten with three or four carts. The three or four cart accounts are primarily group homes that are located in a single- family home which fall under the organized collection contract.  Schedule B of the contract which is the charge a resident would be billed after they’ve used their three bulky items is increasing for most of the items. This schedule has not been increased in the last two contracts and in comparison of other cities, the proposed charges are consistent. Overall, we probably have less than 20 items per year that would fall under this schedule. Included with this memo are two variations of the new contract rates. The spreadsheet titled Final Rates shows the breakout of the rates by Disposal, Collection, Recycling, and Bulky Item with the increases shown for each category. The spreadsheet titled Attachment A is what will be included in the contract. The final total is the same for both. During this process it was determined that a portion of our bulky items are recycled. By having bulky items as a separate line item in our rate it is subject to State and County tax as waste disposal. Attachment A has $.50 shifted to collection costs and then the remaining will fall under recycling which reflects the actual processing of bulky items. Contract language is such that the rate for collection costs includes the pickup of three bulky items per year so there is no change for the service provided to our residents. However, it will be a slight savings to our residents with only a portion of that now being subject to tax. A redlined and strikethrough copy of the contract is also attached. Note the changes in red were proposed by city staff with the changes in blue made by the haulers (those were primarily legal wording changes which staff approved of). Staff has forwarded the contract onto the City Attorney for review and he’ll have comments, if any, at Wednesday’s meeting. Should you have any comments or questions, please let us know. LITTLE CANADA REFUSE & RECYCLING SERVICE CONTRACT THIS CONTRACT, made and entered into this day of February 22, 2017, by and between the CITY OF LITTLE CANADA, a municipal corporation in the County of Ramsey, herein referred to as "City," and Republic Services, IncAllied Waste Services of North America, LLC, d/b/a Repub lic Services o f th e Twin Cities (“Repub lic”) ., a Minnesota corporation, and Gene's Disposal, Inc., a Minnesota corporation, and Waste Management of Minnesota, Inc., a Minnesota corporation, herein referred to collectively as "Contractor." R E C I T A L S: WHEREAS, the City requires the collection and disposal of garbage and rubbish, and recyclables from residences in the City of Little Canada; and Whereas, the Contractor is a group of licensed haulers in the City of Little Canada engaged in the business of collection and disposing of refuse, yard waste, and recyclables; and Whereas, the City desires to hire the services of the Contractor and the Contractor desires to provide services to the City; NOW, THEREFORE, it is agreed by and between all parties: I. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF SERVICES. The Contractor shall supply all labor, materials, and equipment necessary to make a complete collection of garbage and refuse from all residences in the City of Little Canada at least once in each calendar week during the term of this Contract, single sort recyclables once every two weeks, two so rt rec yclab les f o r cu sto mers of Gen e’ s Dispo sal on ce every week bulky items weekly as scheduled, and yard waste on a weekly basis from April 1st through November 30th, weather permitting for those participating customers. Such collections shall include all residential properties having two (2) or less dwelling units in a single building by use of individual containers. The Contractor shall provide all personnel, equipment, and facilities necessary to fulfill the terms and conditions of this Contract. The Contractor shall provide said services in compliance with all applicable laws and shall charge for said services on a volume-based schedule. II. TERM OF CONTRACT. This Contract shall be in full force and effect for a five-year period beginning January 1, 2017. III. DEFINITIONS. For purposes of this Contract, the following terms shall have the following meanings: A. Additional Collection Service. Refuse in excess of the designated volume-base per residential dwelling unit or residential dwelling units desiring collection of items from a location other than the boulevard adjoining the curb. B. Appliances. Household items such as, but not limited to, refrigerators stoves, dishwashers, electronics as defined in this contract, garbage disposers, freezers, washers and dryers, water heaters, microwave ovens, trash compactors, furnaces, air conditioners, and dehumidifiers. “Appliances” includes the industry term “white goods”. Gas ammonia appliances are not included under this definition as they are considered hazardous waste. C. Bulky Items. Large household items such as, but not limited to, bathtubs, beds, mattresses, bikes, carpet and padding (less than 4 foot bundles & less than 45 pounds), chairs, couches, doors, dressers, exercise equipment, garage door openers, gas grills (without tank), lawnmowers (drained), pallets, water softeners, wheels/rims/tires, windows, construction debris (less than 4 feet in length and less than 45 pounds), and items that are too large to fit into the garbage cart or container. D. Co-collection of Organics. The co-mingled collection of yard waste and food waste. This may also include contaminated, non-recyclable paper. E. Collection Service. Collection service is the process of collection and transportation of refuse, yard waste and recyclables. Contractor. Independent contractor means person or persons authorized by the Contract to perform refuse collection services within the City. F. Day-Certain Collection. Day-Certain collection is a City-approved plan for weekly collection services by an established day-certain schedule. This schedule requires refuse, yard waste, and recyclable collection on the same day of the week and is based on a five (5) day, Monday through Friday, workweek. The only exceptions to the "day certain" plan shall be during those weeks in which occur legal holidays, the pickup of major appliances under the Bulky Item designation or inclement weather, which the Contractor is not able to safely operate its business. The Contractor will then notify the City within a timely manner of delay and include a plan for completion of collection. The City and Contractor agree that once operations resume, the Contractor will make customers impacted by the delay due to inclement weather a top priority to minimize the service interruption to the greatest extent possible. In inclement weather conditions, the Contractor is also responsible for notifying customers covered under this contract through their phone dial-out system to make them aware of the delay in service. The only exceptions to the "day-certain" plan shall be during those weeks in which occur legal holidays or the pickup of major appliances under the Bulky Item designation. G. Electronics. Computers and peripherals, televisions, video display device, printers, FAX machines, DVD players, video cassette recorders and other devices as acceptable by the Contractor and the State. Electronics does not include any device with a cathode ray tube (CRT). All definitions of electronics are as defined by State law. H. Food Waste. Garbage, as defined below, kitchen scraps, and garden waste as would be deemed acceptable by Ramsey County and their compost collection points. I. Garbage. Waste material, animal, or vegetable that results from the handling, preparation, cooking, service, and consumption of food. J. Multi-family Dwelling. Residential premises with greater than two living units and which have centralize solid waste and recyclable materials collection service for all units in the building and which are billed as one address. K. Organics. Plant materials co-mingled with food waste and contaminated, non-recyclable paper. L. Prohibited Mailings. Notices sent to residential dwelling units within the City of Little Canada advertising rates or services not available under this contract. M. Receptacle. Unless specified otherwise, whether referred to as “cart”, “garbage can”, “plastic bag”, “suitable container”, “cans”, or “containers”, means a container that shall be of such size and form as to permit collection by one customer. Solid Waste containers or carts with hinged lids are provided by the Contractor and range in size from 30 to 96 gallons. N. Recyclables. Recyclables are reusable materials approved and agreed to by the parties hereto. Recyclables shall include such items as newsprint, catalogs, magazines, phone books, junk mail, cereal boxes, corrugated cardboard, and miscellaneous paper as long as it is not contaminated with food or waste, metal and aluminum cans, plastics with a neck, and glass containers. Recyclables specifically exclude garbage, refuse and yard waste. O. Refuse. Refuse is solid waste including garbage and rubbish, and specifically excluding yard waste, recyclables, and toxic and hazardous wastes. Refuse further excludes industrial, commercial, agricultural, and construction garbage or rubbish and wastes. P. Residential Dwelling Unit. A residential dwelling unit is a separate dwelling place with a kitchen. A residential dwelling unit shall not include: mobile homes, tri-plexes, four- plexes, town homes, condominiums, or apartment buildings. Q. Rubbish. Rubbish is solid waste, including ashes, consisting of both combustible and noncombustible wastes, such as wood, bedding, crockery, and other non-reusable waste. Rubbish also includes non- recyclable types of glass, paper, cardboard, metal cans and plastics. R. Special Waste. Special Waste is any nonhazardous solid waste at City locations which, because of its physical characteristics, chemical make-up, or biological nature requires either special handling, disposal procedures including liquids for solidification at the landfill, documentation, and/or regulatory authorization, or poses an unusual threat to human health, equipment, property, or the environment. Special Waste must conform in all respects with a Contractor-approved Special Waste Profile. Special Waste includes, but is not limited to: (i) Waste generated by an industrial process or a pollution control process; (ii) Waste which may contain residue and debris from the cleanup of spilled petroleum, chemical or commercial products or wastes, or contaminated residuals; (iii)Waste which is nonhazardous as a result of proper treatment pursuant to Subtitle C of th e Resou rce Con servation and Reco very Act o f 1976 (“RCRA”); (iv) Waste from the cleanup of a facility which generates, stores, treats, recycles or disposes of chemical substances, commercial products or wastes; (v) Waste which may contain free liquids and requires liquid waste solidification; (vi) Containers that once contained hazardous substances, chemicals, or insecticides so lon g as su ch con tain ers are “emp t y” as d ef in ed b y RCRA; (vii) Asbestos containing or asbestos bearing material that has been properly secured under existing Applicable Law; (viii) Waste containing regulated polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) as defined in the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA); (ix) Waste containing naturally occurring radioactive material (NORM) and/or technologically-enhanced NORM (TENORM); and (x) Municipal or commercial solid waste that may have come into contact with any of the foregoing. S. Special Waste Profile. Contracto r’s form of documentation that the City must complete, and Contractor must approve, with respect to any Special Waste prior to Con tracto r’s acceptance of such Special Waste. The City will ensure that the Special Waste Profile includes a complete and accurate description of the waste stream, including the generating process and chemical and physical characteristics. T. Townhome. Structures containing two or more units of not more than three (3) stories each and contiguous to each other. Said units shall also be governed by an association for the entire series of structures within any such development. U. Toxic and Hazardous Wastes. Toxic and hazardous wastes are waste materials including, but not limited to, liquid paint, motor oils, batteries, poisons, pesticides, herbicides, acids, caustics, pathological wastes, radioactive materials, flammable or explosive materials, and similar harmful chemicals and wastes which require special handling and must be disposed of in a manner to conserve the environment and protect public health and safety. V. Unacceptable Waste. Hazardous, radioactive, volatile, corrosive, highly flammable, explosive, biomedical, infectious, biohazardous, toxic or listed or characteristic hazardous waste as defined by Applicable Law or any otherwise regulated waste. In addition, any Special Waste that does not conform to the Special Waste Profile supplied by Customer is Unacceptable Waste. W. Waste Materials. Waste Material is all nonhazardous Solid Waste and, if designated in this Contract, nonhazardous Special Waste and/or Recyclables that are not excluded by this Contract. Waste Material does not include any Unacceptable Waste. X. WU. Yard Waste. All organic plant material that can be composted including grass clippings, leaves, soft garden material, brush and tree limbs under four inches in diameter and four feet in length provided they are bundled with twine or other organic material. IV. SCOPE OF CONTRACT. A. Collection Service Provided by Contractor. 1. Garbage and Refuse Collection. a. Description. Refuse collection service shall include the collection of all garbage and refuse from residential dwelling units in the City of Little Canada. Recyclables, bulky items, and yard waste shall be collected separately. Included in the cost of this service is the collection of one Christmas tree (not wrapped in a plastic bag and free of ornaments and tinsel) annually from every residential dwelling unit and three bulky items per year. Cost for this service is described in Attachment “A.” b. Exclusions. Refuse collection service shall not include the collection of: 1. Toxic and hazardous waste including items such as batteries, construction material, motor oils, and paint in liquid form. 2. Major appliances, except as provided for in Bulky Item Pickup. 3. Tree limbs, brush and such other items, except as provided for in Yard Waste. 4. Animal waste and solid waste materials resulting from industrial, commercial, and agricultural operations, and from community activities. 5. Earthen fill, boulders, rock, and other materials normally handled in construction operations, solids or dissolved materials in domestic sewage or other significant pollutants in waste resources, such as silt, dissolved or suspended solids in industrial waste water effluent, dissolved materials in irrigation return flows; or other common water pollutants. 6. Electronics containing cathode ray tubes (CRT’s). c. Containers. All occupants of residential dwelling units in the City shall be required by ordinance to keep garbage and refuse in an approved container(s) of approximately 30, 60, or 90 gallons. Exempted are senior residents who qualify for the low volume bag rate. They may use stickered 30-gallon trash bags. d. Location. Residential dwelling units shall have, as required by the City ordinance, their container located at the boulevard adjoining the curb on or before 7:00 a.m. on the designated day of collection. e. Frequency. Each residential dwelling unit shall have its refuse collected a minimum of once per week. f. Additional Collection Service. Refuse in excess of the designated volume-base per dwelling unit or residential dwelling units desiring collection of items from a location other than the boulevard adjoining the curb will be subject to additional collection service charges as set forth in Attachment “B.” Collection service for white goods and bulky items must have prior arrangements with the City for collection and shall also be billed in accordance with Attachment “B”; except as provided for in Bulky Item Pickup. g. Reporting. Tonnages of refuse or garbage collected shall be reported to the City on an annual basis with said reports to be submitted by January 22nd of the following year. h. Free Pick-Up at City-Owned Properties. Waste Management of Minnesota, Inc. and Republic Republic Services, Inc. shall provide service as necessary for the collection and disposal of refuse, recyclables and yard waste from all City-owned properties, including parks and the City’s Canadian Days Celebration, at no cost to the City during the term of this Contract. This provision applies to the typical generation of waste and does not include extraordinary clean-outs. i. Disposal. The Contractor shall be responsible for the safe, legal, and environmentally sound disposal of all refuse, white goods, and any other items and materialsWaste Materials collected under this Contract. The Contractor shall dispose of all r Refuse and Ggarbage collected in Little Canada at a Refuse Derived Fuel processing facility designated by Ramsey County at which the operator has assumed all liability arising from the Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Feasibility Act, and similar Federal and State Statutes possessing the necessary permits and operated in compliance with applicable environmental laws and regulations. Any deviation of this provision shall be considered a violation and default of this Contract. The Contractor shall maintain actual Ramsey/Washington RDF (Recycling and Energy Center – R&E Center) receipts and shall provide the City with copies of such receipts. Estimated Little Canada tonnages shall be reported to the City bi-annually. All costs associated with disposal (tipping fees) shall be based upon fees net of any rebates that the Contractor may be eligible for, regardless of when (or if) received by the Contractor. It shall be understood that the disposal rate in Exhibit A shall be based upon the lowest available tipping fee charged by the RDF facility to an entity that takes all material to the RDF facility for disposal. j. Notification. If any resident of the City places any items out for pickup and the item is not taken by the Contractor, the Contractor shall provide immediate written notification to the resident and the City of reason(s) for refusal to pick up the item. Notification must be left on the item(s) in question. Notifications left for a resident must be submitted to the City by noon on the following day after collection was refused. k. Exceptions for Handicapped and/or Disabled. The Contractor shall make reasonable exceptions as to the manner of pickup for handicapped or disabled residents. 2. Yard Waste Collection. a. Description. Yard waste collection service shall include the collection of all yard waste from participating residential dwelling units in the City of Little Canada. Cost for this service is described in Attachment “A.” b. Containers. Residential dwelling units shall have their yard waste segregated from other refuse in a container clearly identified as “Yard Waste” located at the boulevard adjoining the curb on or before 7:00 a.m. on the designated day of collection. Up to two containers of at least 90 gallon capacity will be provided by the contractor at no additional cost to the resident. Additional compostable bags and/or clearly identified containers may also be placed curbside at each pickup without limit to quantity at no additional cost. Containers should not exceed 960- gallon capacity nor weigh more than 50 pounds when filled. Bags should not be filled so as to exceed their structural capacity. c. Frequency. Yard Waste Collection Service shall be provided from April 1st through November 30th, weather permitting each year and each residential dwelling unit shall have its yard waste collected a minimum of once per week on the same day as refuse collection service. d. Reporting. Tonnages or yards of yard waste collected shall be reported to the City on an annual basis by January 22nd of the following year. e. Conveyance of Yard Waste. The Contractor shall be responsible for the safe, legal, and environmentally sound conveyance of all yard waste collected under this Contract. The Contractor shall convey the yard waste to a lawfully approved compost site and shall assume all liability and responsibility for materials deposited. The Contractor shall not mix other types of refuse or inorganic materials with the yard waste or take any action so as to make the yard waste material unacceptable to the operators of the compost site. f. Notification. If any resident of the City places yard waste out for pickup and the material is not taken by the Contractor, the Contractor shall provide immediate written notification to the resident and the City of reason(s) for refusal to pick up the item. Notification must be left on the item(s) in question. Notifications left for a resident must be submitted to the City by noon on the following day after collection was refused. g. Education. It shall be the responsibility of the Contractor to assist in the education of residents on how to properly prepare yard waste. Contractor will work with City staff on a quarterly basis on a frequency as determined by the City to prepare written materials for residents. All educational materials for customers under the contract must be approved by the City prior to mailing. 3. Recycling Collection. a. Description. Recyclable collections service shall include the collection of recyclables as defined in this contract. Cost for this service is described in Attachment “A”. b. Containers. The Contractor shall supply all residential dwelling units eligible to participate in the recycling program with a single sort- recycling container on wheels, for the storage and collection of recyclable materials. The standard container for recycling under this contract will be a 60-gallon cart. Residents have the option to increase or decrease their cart size or request a second recycling cart at no additional charge for service. c. Single Sort System. Residents will be instructed to place all recyclable materials, listed in the definitions section, into the single sort container. The Contractor shall not make any changes to this single sort collection system without written approval of the City. Failure to receive City approval for any such changes to the single sort collection system shall be considered by the City as a breach of this AgreementContract subject to termination. The Contractor shall work with the City to provide necessary written educational materials on the single sort system for residents including a legible sticker placed on each container that lists approved recyclable items. d. Location. Residential dwelling units shall have their recyclables in the approved containers provided by the Contractor located at the boulevard adjoining the curb on or before 7:00 a.m. on the designated day of collection. e. Frequency. Each residential dwelling unit shall have its recyclables collected every-other week on the same day as refuse collection service. The Contractor shall provide an annual calendar to each resident by no later than December 20th that indicates the collection dates for the upcoming year. By November 30th, the hauler will provide the City with an electronic version of the annual recycling calendar which indicates the collection dates for the upcoming year. This electronic calendar will be revised to in clud e th e City lo go as well as th e City’ s co n tact in fo rmation. The City will advertise in the newsletter and on our website that the electronic calendar is available. A printed copy of the calendar will be made available upon request by the resident. f. Reporting. Tonnages of recyclables collected shall be reported to the City on an annual basis by January 22nd of the following year. These tonnages must be reported by individual materials collected and the place where the recyclables are delivered must be disclosed. If the tonnages are estimates, the method of estimation must also be disclosed and Contractor will do everything possible to ensure the accuracy of estimates. g. Conveyance of Recyclables. The Contractor shall be responsible for the safe, legal, and environmentally sound conveyance of all recyclables collected under this Contract. The Contractor shall convey the recyclables to a market that assures these materials will not be landfilled. The Contractor shall not mix other types of refuse or inorganic materials with the recyclables or take any action so as to make the recyclable material unacceptable to the operators of the recycling center. h. Material Preparation & Separation Requirements. The Contractor is responsible for immediately informing residential dwelling units of how to properly prepare recyclables for collection. If the Contractor fails to pick up recyclables at a residential dwelling unit because it was improperly prepared, it is the Contractor’s responsibility to immediately inform in writing the residential dwelling unit on how to properly prepare the recyclables so that they will be acceptable for pick up. The Contractor shall also inform the City of said notice when the residence has received multiple notices. Any change in material preparation and separation requirements must be approved by the City prior to implementing such change and the Contractor shall bear full responsibility for notifying residents of changes. i. Participation Study. The Contractor is responsible for once annually between September 1st and October 31st to inform the City of households not participating in recycling. This information will be used to target households for additional education on recycling initiatives. j. Education. It shall be the responsibility of the Contractor to assist in the education of residents on what is recyclable and how to properly prepare for proper disposal. Contractor will work with City staff on a frequency as determined by the City to prepare written materials for residents. All educational materials for customers under the contract must be approved by the City prior to mailing. k. Notification. If any resident of the City places any items out for pickup and the item is not taken by the Contractor, the Contractor shall provide immediate written notification to the resident and the City of reason(s) for refusal to pick up the item. Notification must be left on the item(s) in question. Notifications left for a resident must be submitted to the City by noon on the following day after collection was refused. 4. Bulky Item Pickup. Each residence is allowed to dispose of up to three “bulky items” per year as defined by this contract. The Contractor shall collect, transport, dispose of, and/or process these items without additional fees or charges to the resident as specified below: a. Clarification of Count. In most cases, the counting of a bulky item will be self-evident; i.e. a refrigerator will count as one item, a couch will count as one item, and a sink will count as one item. A sectional sofa consisting of three or more pieces will count as two items. However, there are instances when a set of items shall be counted as only one item such as (2) rims with/without tires or two individual tires, and a computer and related periphery with the exception of a cathode ray tube (CRT) which is prohibited. b. Frequency of Collection. Contractor shall provide service to residents as scheduled by City. Collections shall take place on the same day of the week as the resident’s refuse pickup, with the exception of appliance pickup. The City will schedule appliance pickup and the pickup day shall be arranged with each respective contractor. c. Process for Collection. The resident shall contact the City directly to request pickup of the bulky item(s). The resident shall place the item curbside for pickup on the designated day for pickup as instructed by the City. d. Reporting. The City shall be responsible for instituting a system to account for the number of items picked up per residence, per year. The City shall notify the Contractor when a residence has exceeded their allotted three bulky items to enable the contractor to bill for any items beyond three pursuant to Attachment B. e. Pickup in Excess of Three Items. The pickup of any bulky items in excess of three (3) within any calendar year shall be subject to the charges as described in Attachment B. 5. Carts. Each residence is provided cart(s) as specified in the above services at no charge when the account is established. Attachment A of the contract establishes additional fees for cart service changes. Failure by the Contractor to notify the City of cart(s) b ein g “ou t of sto ck” may be subject to a fine under the Liquidated Damages portion of the contract. B. Service Schedule. 1. Hours. The Contractor shall perform all collection services between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m., on Monday through Friday, except when an emergency exists, at which time the Contractor shall notify the City of such emergency 2. Collection Days. The Contractor shall provide Day-Certain refuse, recycling, bulky item, and yard waste collection. Unless otherwise agreed to by the parties hereto, collection services will be on Wednesdays with single sort occurring every other Wednesday. a. The Contractor may request a change in the day of pickup by requesting such change in writing to the City at least thirty (30) days from the proposed date the requested change is to take effect. A change shall become effective only upon authorization from the City and a fourteen-day notice to the residents. b. The Contractor shall bear all costs involved in notifying residents of approved schedule changes. 3. Holidays. The Contractor will observe the following legal holidays on which their offices and operations will be closed: New Year's Day, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, and Christmas Day. When holidays fall on a Monday, Tuesday, or Wednesday, the collection shall be made one (1) working day later. 4. Authorized Pickups. Only such pickups shall be made at assigned addresses and accounts as authorized by the City pursuant to the terms of this Contract, and the Contractor shall not be entitled to payment for any pickups not authorized by this Contract. 5. Street Improvements. The City reserves the right to improve any street or alley that may prevent the Contractor from traveling its accustomed route or routes for collection. The Contractor shall bear the responsibility for contacting the Public Works Director prior to each construction season to determine areas of conflict and possible alternate routes or solutions. The Contractor shall maintain regular service during street reconstruction project, regardless of access with no additional compensation for service modifications. 6. Administration. The Contractor shall maintain an office equipped with telephones and staffed with sufficient personnel to handle complaints, orders for special service, and/or to receive instructions from the City. a. The Contractor’s office shall be staffed from 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday (except holidays). b. The City and the Contractor shall follow the following administrative procedures: 1. The City shall maintain a written log of all complaints received from residents. The log will include the complaint date and the nature of the complaint. The complaints shall be forwarded no later than the following business day to the Contractor by e-mail or by phone. The Contractor will respond by e-mail or phone that the complaint has been received. If the complaint is limited to a missed pick up, no further reporting action is required of the Contractor. All other complaints must be investigated and a suggested resolution communicated to the City within 24 hours or the next business day. If suggested resolution is unsatisfactory the Contractor agrees to continue work with the City to reach a reasonable solution. 2. The City will be responsible for taking all customer service calls from Little Canada residents. This includes, but is not limited to, calls related to discontinuing/establishing disposal service, temporary stops and starts in service, changes in container sizes (including recycling), yard waste services, bulky item pick up services, appliance pick up, and any at the door pick requests and complaints. Any call taken by the Contractor for customers covered under this contract in which the customer is not referred back to the City may be subject to a fine under the Liquidated Damages portion of the contract. Liquidated damages may not be charged if the City is notified by the hauler of the call prior to any service action being taken by the hauler. 3. The City will forward by e-mail or by fax all change of service requests to the Contractor once a week. The transmission date will be such so that the service change requested can be acted upon by the Contractor during that week of service. Failure by the Contractor to schedule the weekly service change(s) may result in a fine under the Liquidated Damages portion of the contract. An instance will be each change that is not scheduled accordingly. 4. The Contractor shall keep complete and accurate records in accordance with generally accepted accounting principals. Said records shall be available for the City’s inspection with reasonable notice in order that the City can ensure compliance with relevant contract terms and conditions. 5. The Contractor is responsible for providing the City with a contact(s) to handle all daily communications. This contact person needs to be available to respond on the same business day within a reasonable amount of time during the Contractor office hours. 6. The Contractor shall provide notice to the City of any change of ownership of the Contractor, and the Contractor shall provide the City with an affirmative undertaking regarding this Contract by the buyer of the Company. C. Performance Standards. The Contractor shall supply all labor, material, and equipment necessary for the carrying out of this Contract. 1. Equipment a. Vehicle Protection. All trucks or motor vehicles used by the Contractor shall be water-tight so as not to allow the leakage of liquids or refuse while hauling the same and shall be covered to prevent the scattering of its contents upon the public streets or private properties in the City. Should any garbage be dropped or spilled in collection or transporting, it shall be immediately cleaned up. A broom and shovel shall be carried on each vehicle at all times for this purpose. b. Cleaning. All vehicles shall be kept in a clean and sanitary condition. c. Painting. The packer body shall be painted and numbered, and shall have the Contractor's name and telephone number painted in letters of a contrasting color, at least three inches (3") high, on each side of the vehicle and the number painted or a decal placed on the rear. d. Maintenance. The trucks shall be maintained in good working order. They shall be equipped to meet all federal, state, and municipal regulations concerning vehicles used on public roads and maintained to meet these standards. e. Vehicle Inspection. All vehicles used in the performance of this Contract shall be made available for inspection at least once each year. However, if a vehicle has been inspected and approved by another city or governmental agency within the previous twelve (12) months, no additional inspection shall be required. f. Description of Vehicles. The Contractor shall furnish the City with a written description of all vehicles and equipment to be used within the City of Little Canada and in the performance of this Contract. The Contractor shall advise the City in writing of any withdrawal of a part of such equipment or of any change therein within one (1) week of the time of making such change. g. Safety Equipment. Each collection vehicle shall have a flashing light warning system, fire extinguisher (CO2 type), proper backup alarms as approved by the City, and otherwise shall comply with all State and Federal inspections and safety requirements. 2. Personnel Requirements. a. Responsibility. 1. There shall be no limitation on the size of the Contractor's collection crew, so long as they are sufficient to fulfill the requirements of the specifications and Contract. 2. Each collection crew shall adhere to all applicable Ordinances of the City of Little Canada, and all of those rules, regulations, and conditions for refuse collection as established by the City. b. Driver. 1. The Contractor’s personnel shall comply with all applicable laws including driving and traffic laws, relating to its performance of services under this AgreementContract. Contractor’s personnel shall comply with all Federal regulations found in Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) at 49 CFR, Part 382 as it pertains to drug and alcohol testing. Upon request, Contractor shall supply City with any results of its drug and alcohol testing program. 2. The driver must have a valid Minnesota License with proper classification and endorsements. 3. The driver must adhere to all traffic laws. c. Collector. 1. The driver and collector(s) shall at all times have a courteous attitude toward the general public. 2. The driver and collector(s) shall be of sound character, competent, and sober throughout the entire workday. 3. The driver and collector(s) shall have the ability to remember the order of collection and location of all containers on the assigned routes. 4. The driver and collector(s) shall make a concerted effort to have at all times a presentable appearance. 5. The collector(s) on each crew shall be physically able to perform their duties and be at least eighteen (18) years old. 6. The collector(s) shall perform their work in a neat and quiet manner and clean up all refuse, yard waste or recyclables spilled in collection under any circumstance. 7. All containers shall be replaced on the boulevard adjoining the curb. 8. Damage to containers or other property shall be avoided. 9. Gratuities shall not be accepted. 10. Consumption of any beverages containing alcohol or controlled substances shall be forbidden during or before work hours of any collection day. 11. Before the start of each collection day, the collection crew shall check to see that the collection vehicle is equipped with at least one broom and shovel for use in cleaning up refuse, yard waste, or recyclables spilled during collection or hauling. 3. Liquidated Damages. The Contractor agrees, in addition to any other remedies available to the City, the City may fine the an individual Contractor in the amounts specified below as liquidated damages for failure of the Contractor Contractor to fulfill its obligations (fo r th e pu rpo ses o f th is section , the “Vio latin g Con tracto r”) . The City will notify the Contractor Violating Contractor in writing documenting the nature of the violation, the history of the account, if any, and the reason for the fine. The Violating Contractor shall then have the opportunity to address and remedy the issue at which point the City shall determine if a fine is still appropriate, in their sole determination. The Violating Contractor shall notify City in writing of its remedy. a. Failure to clean up solid waste spilled by Violating Contractor within six (6) hours of oral or written notification - $50.00 each instance. b. Failure to maintain vehicle in a manner, which prevents nuisances such as leaky seals or hydraulics - $100.00 each instance. c. Failure or neglect to collect solid waste, recycling, (or yard waste, or /bulky items at those times provided by the Agreement Contract within 24-hours after either oral or written notice by City - $50.00 each instance. In the case of failure to collect, an instance shall be each residence missed. d. Failure to correct any missed pickup for refuse, recycling, yard waste or bulky item on the agreed upon schedule for resolution between the City and Contractor - $100.00 per instance per day until item is collected. An instance shall be each residence not remedied in that timeframe. e. Failure or neglect to provide notice to resident upon solid waste, recyclable, yard waste or bulky items refused for collection for cause - $25.00 each instance. f. Failure to provide, exchange, or replace a cart on the date as scheduled by the City - $50.00 per day until completed. g. In addition to above, failure or neglect to correct chronic problems will be considered a Breach of Contract - $500.00 each instance. The City prior to assessing liquidated damages under this provision will provided the hauler with notification of what problems have occurred and how future violations will be considered chronic. h. Failure to abide by the City’s regular collection hours - $250.00 each instance. Failure to collect recyclables, which are properly prepared and placed for collection as part of the collection program - $25.00 each instance. i. Missing entire blocks/neighborhoods. A missed block is defined as a block where residents from at least three (3) households within two intersections of that block or cul-de-sac report that their material was out before 7:00 a.m., the material was not picked up and the addresses did not appear on the records as unacceptable setouts - $250.00 each instance. j. District-wide collection not completed. The failure to complete a majority (50% or more) of pickups within the city or collection district on the scheduled collection day without following proper notification procedure - $2,500.00 per instance. k. The City shall impose a $250 charge per instance against the Violating Contractor payable to the City for prohibited mailings or any mailing which occurs prior to City approval of materials that are sent to residential dwelling units covered under this contract. The Contractor is also responsible to give written notice to those residents within thirty (30) days as to the error and reason for the prohibited mailing. The Contractor shall bear full responsibility and expenses incurred for notifying residents of the prohibited mailing. l. k.. The City shall impose a $2,500 charge per billing cycle should the Violating Contractor fail to notify the City, within 30 days of a reduction in tipping fees as required by this agreementContract. In addition to this charge, the Contractor shall also make a refund to the City in the next billing cycle of any amount overcharged. m. Violating Contractor’s failure to forward an account service call to the City for processing - $50.00 per instance. n. Violating Contractor’s direct billing of Little Canada residents covered by this organized collection contract - $250.00 per instance. o. Violating Contractor’s failure to notify the City of carts not being available “out of stock” for delivery - $100.00 per instance. p. Failure by the Contractor to schedule the Weekly Service Changes - $250.00 per instance. 4. Legal Compliance. a. This Contract is governed in all respects by the laws of the State of Minnesota, and all obligations are enforceable in accordance therewith; and the Contractor, where required, must obtain all licenses or permits to transact a refuse collection business in the City of Little Canada, Ramsey County, and the State of Minnesota. b. The Contractor will acquaint itself with all pertinent City Ordinances and shall comply with all health rules, regulations, and Ordinances of the City of Little Canada, Ramsey County, and the State of Minnesota in effect at this time of this contract or hereafter adopted. In the event, there is a conflict between the provisions of this contract and the pertinent ordinances, regulations, and statutes the more stringent requirements shall apply. c. The Contractor shall report all violations of ordinances pertaining to garbage and refuse collection and disposal for enforcement purposes including all unsanitary or filthy conditions to the City. 5. Safety. The Contractor shall provide and maintain all sanitary and safety accommodations for the use and protection of its employees as may be necessary to provide for their health and welfare and comply with federal, state, and local codes and regulations, as well as those of other bodies and tribunals having jurisdiction. Employee safety and sanitation facility regulations are set forth in Minnesota Statutes 182 and in the Department of Labor and Industry's Labor Safety Code (LISC 73- 75). D. Compensation. 1. Base Compensation. City and Contractor shall on a monthly basis, verify the number of households at each level of collection service and the additional billable serviced provided during the month. The verification procedure will use the prior month’s ending service counts adjusted by the weekly change reports submitted by the City plus the current month’s cumulative additional services requested through the weekly change reports, with the exception of Senior Bag Rate service pick- ups that must be accounted for by the Contractor and reported to the City in the monthly billing. The Contractor shall submit a summarized monthly bill by service level charges and a listing of other additional charges for services. A detailed report of all residences with billed services will also be submitted in support of the summarized billing. The billing documents should be submitted to the City on or before the 7th day of each month. The City will pay the Contractor within 30 days of receipt of the invoice as long as the billing is in sufficient form that the City is able to satisfactorily verify the amount due. This practice will be followed each month during the term of this contract. The City shall be responsible for the billing of individual residences for services provided and for the collection of said billings. The City shall provide the hauler with an electronic detailed report (Excel spreadsheet format) of all residences with billed services to the Contractor (between January 1st to January 15th) each calendar year in order for the Contractor to verify charge for services. The hauler has 7 days to respond with any changes to the detailed report which will be reviewed for approval by the City. The City will then submit a summary report of services and changes which impact that billing period before the 7th day of each month. The hauler has 7 days to review summary billing and changes and inform the City if billed services are satisfactory. Upon notification by the Contractor said billing is accurate;, the City will reimburse the Contractor the billed services within 30 days. This practice will be followed each month during the term of this contract. The City shall be responsible for the billing of individual residences for services provided and for the collection of said billings. Any billing by the Contractor to residences covered under this contract for services will be subject to a fine under the Liquidated Damages section of this contract. 2. Disposal Fees. The Contractor shall pay all disposal fees resulting from the collections of Little Canada refuse, yard waste, bulky items, and recyclables. 3. Fuel Surcharge Fee. The Contractor shall be eligible for a fuel surcharge fee beginning January 1, 20172. Said fee shall be calculated based on Attachment C. The City shall determine the imposition of said fee pursuant to the terms of this agreement Contract and by referencing the Department of Energy’s Midwest Average for #2 Diesel Fuel for the week preceding the end of the quarter in question upon notice from the Contractor by the 10th of the month following the completion of a prescribed quarterly period that fuel prices have triggered the imposition of said fee. Once imposed, the City will include this fee in the next billing to residents. The fuel surcharge shall be adjusted on a quarterly basis for the following quarters ending on December 31st, March 31st, June 30th, and September 30th of each year. Failure to provide proper notice of the application of the fuel surcharge within the prescribed timeframe will negate application of that fee for the City’s billing quarter. 4. Additional Collection Services. Charges for pickup of additional items and for additional service shall be made directly to the resident owner by the City at the prices stated in Attachment “B” hereto. Said prices shall be subject to change from time to time by the Contractor based on changes in disposal costs and subject to City approval. Contractor will need to include the charges for additional collection in the monthly bill detail. Charges for additional services shall be billed in the month the service is provided. 5. Unmarketable Recyclables. The Contractor shall receive one hundred (100%) percent of the gross proceeds from the sale of recyclables. In the event the Contractor and the City determine that recyclables cannot be sold or given away, the Contractor shall bear all costs associated with disposal. 6. Bulky Item Increase. If the rate for disposal for bulky items increases to a point in which the haulers feel an increase is warranted during the term of this contract, it shall be agreed that the City and hauler will meet to discuss a potential increase to the bulky item collection rate and/or Schedule B. 7. Taxes (Environmental Services, Disposal, and Sales, if any). The City will retain the responsibility for billing all appropriate taxes associated with services provided for under this contract. Furthermore, the City will be responsible for remitting all the taxes billed to the proper taxing agencies in compliance with reporting and filing requirements. V. INSURANCE, BOND & INDEMNIFICATION. The Contractor shall be licensed and bonded as required by Little Canada City Ordinances. The Contractor further agrees to take all precautions to protect the public against injury. The Contractor, each of them individually (“In d emn if yin g Con tracto r”), shall indemnify and hold harmless the City, its officers, agents, representatives, and employees from and against all damages, claims, losses, costs or expenses including reasonable attorneys' fees, which may be asserted against the City, or for which it may be held liable, to the extent resulting from any acts, omissions, or negligence of the Indemnifying Contractor, Indemnifying Contractor's agent or employees while engaged in the performance of this Contract and of damages that may arise by reason of any negligence of the Indemnifying Contractor or the Indemnifying Contractor's agents, or employees while engaged in the performance of this Contract. The Contractor will indemnify the City against all claims, liens, expenses, and claims for liens, for work, tools, machinery, materials, or insurance premiums or equipment or supplies, and against all loss by reason of the failure of the Contractor in any respect to fully perform all obligations of this Contract, including reasonable attorneys' fees. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary set forth in this Contract or otherwise, no individual Contractor shall have an obligation to (a) indemnify, defend or hold harmless the City, or any other parties indemnified under this Contract, for any such liability or claim to the extent resulting from the negligence or, willful misconduct by the City, any third party or any other parties indemnified under this Contract, or (b) indemnify, defend or hold harmless another Contractor for any such liability or claim to the extent resulting from the acts, omissions or negligence of the other Contractor. In other words, each Contractor is only liable to the extent the damages, claims, losses, costs or expenses resulted from its o wn o r its emp lo yees’ own acts, omissions or negligence. Insurance Limits. During the entire period of the contract, the Contractor shall maintain, at their expense, and file with the City, policies or certificates of Worker's Compensation, Auto Liability, and General Liability insurance. Minimum Liability Insurance coverage requirements are $1,000,000.00 bodily injury per person, $2,000,000.00 aggregate per occurrence, and $1,000,000.00 property damage. All liability policies evidencing insurance required by this paragraph shall name City and the Contractor as named additional insured (o th er th an wo rkers’ co mp en sation ) . Such policies shall be in the form and context satisfactory with the City Attorney and shall be filed with the City Administrator. A certificate showing that the Contractor has in effect the aforesaid insurance covering both the City and the Contractor shall also be provided to the City. VI. NONDISCRIMINATION. The Contractor agrees that, during the life of this Contract, the Contractor will not, within the State of Minnesota, discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, color, creed, national origin, or ancestry, and will include a similar provision in all subcontracts entered into for the performance thereof. This Contract may be cancelled or terminated by the City and all money due or to become due hereunder may be forfeited for a second or subsequent violation of the terms and conditions of this paragraph. This paragraph is inserted in this Contract to comply with the provisions of Minnesota Statutes, Section 181.59. VII. TRANSFER, ASSIGNMENT, AND LIENS. A. Transfer or Sale. The Contractor may sell, assign, convey, lease, or transfer all or part of this Contract with the City’s prior written approval. The City shall be entitled to require, except as otherwise provided in this Contract, as conditions to any such approval that: 1. Any proposed transferee shall have the qualifications and financial responsibility reasonably determined by the City, necessary and adequate to fulfill the obligations undertaken in this Contract by Contractor; and 2. The transfer does not create an anti-trust situation in the local refuse hauling industry that is contrary to the public interest of the residents of Little Canada; and 3. Any proposed transferee, by instrument in writing satisfactory to the City for itself and their successors and assigns, and expressly for the benefit of the City, have expressly assumed all of the obligations of service under this Contract and agreed to be subject to all the conditions and restrictions to which service is subject. It is the intent of this Section, together with other provisions of this Contract, that (to the fullest extent permitted by law and equity and excepting only in the manner and to the extent specifically provided otherwise in this Contract) no transfer of, or change with respect to, ownership or any part thereof, or any interest therein, however, consummated or occurring, whether voluntary or involuntary, shall operate, legally or practically, to deprive or limit the City of or with respect to any rights or remedies or controls provided in or resulting from this Contract; and 4. To the extent the Contractor is able without violating confidentiality provisions or applicable law, Tthere shall be submitted to the City for review all instruments and other legal documents involved in affecting such transfer, and if approved by the City, its approval shall be indicated to the Contractor in writing. The proposed transferee shall submit to the City for review all bonds, insurance policies, and any and all other documents required by this Contract, and if approved by the City, its approval shall be indicated to the proposed transferee in writing. B. Payment of Subcontractor and Employees. The Contractor agrees to promptly pay all persons doing work or furnishing skills, tools, machinery, or materials or insurance premiums or equipment or supplies and all just claims for such work, material, equipment insurance, and supplies in and above the performance of this Contract. VIII. OTHER PROVISIONS. A. Title. Title to all refuse, yard waste and recyclables Waste Material collected shall remain vested in the Contractor until all said solid waste is delivered to the authorized processing plant, recycling center, or yard waste site. Title to and liability for any Unacceptable Waste shall at no time pass to Contractor. B. Severability. All parts and provisions of this Contract are severable. If any part or provision shall be held invalid, the remainder of this Contract shall remain in effect. C. Independent Contractors. The Contractor is declared to be an independent contractor, and nothing in this Contract shall be construed to create the relationship of employer and employee between the City and the Contractor or its agents, or make the Contractor, its agents, or employees, subject to City Personnel Rules. D. Force Majeure. Except for th e Cit y’ s obligation to pay amounts due to contractor, any f ailu re o r d ela y in p erfo rman ce du e to con tin gen cies b eyo n d a p art y’ s reas on ab le con tro l , including strikes, riots, terrorist acts, compliance with applicable laws or governmental orders, fires, inclement weather and acts of God (“Fo rce Maj eu re Even t”), shall not constitute a breach of this Contract. Contractor shall not be liable for liquidated damages under section IV.C.3 for failure to perform as a result of a Force Majeure Event. IX. NOTICES. Except as otherwise herein, provided, all notices required to be served by either party on the other shall be in writing and forwarded by certified mail to the principal office of the party to which notice is given, as follows: To the City of Little Canada: City of Little Canada 515 Little Canada Road Little Canada, MN 55117 To the Contractor: Republic Services, Inc. 4325 E. 66th Street Inver Grove Heights, MN 55076 Waste Management of MN, Inc. 10050 Naples St. NE Blaine, MN 55449 Gene's Disposal 5661- 152nd Street North Hugo, MN. 55038 All such notices shall be effective when received. X. TERMINATION. A. The City shall have the right to terminate this Contract, as pertaining to each individual hauler, if in the City's reasonable judgment there has been a breach of any material provision thereof by the haulerContractor(“Breaching Hauler”), or if in the City's reasonable judgment there is other good cause for termination. Continuing breach or good cause shall not be deemed waived because it was followed by prompted termination. B. Upon failure of the Breaching Hauler Contractor to fulfill any of the provisions of this contract, the City shall be authorized to hire such personnel and equipment, or assign City employees and equipment, as may be necessary to do such work, and the cost of such expenses thereof may be charged and deducted from any monies due the the Breaching ContractorHauler, collected from the Breaching Contractor Hauler, for collected by recourse to the Breaching Contractors Hau ler’ s financial guaranty. C. Notwithstanding the foregoing paragraphs, the no Contractor hauler shall will not be considered in breach and the City will have no right to terminate the agreementContract unless Contractor the hauler fails to cure said breach or failure to perform within thirty (30) days of receipt by the Contractor hauler of written notice from the City. The breach or failure must be cured to the satisfaction of the City Administrator. D. The City shall also have the right to terminate the contract at any time, subject to ninety (90) days written notice to the Contractor, should Ramsey County undertake an organized collection program and if the City determines at its sole discretion, it would be in the City’s best interest to utilize said County programs. E. Any individual Contractor shall have the right to suspend or terminate this Contract, if the City is in material breach and has failed to cure such breach within 30 days of receipt by the City of written notice of the breach. XI. ENTIRE AGREEMENT. This Contract with Attachments “A”, “B”, and “C” incorporated herein by reference is the entire agreement between the parties. No modification of this Contract shall be valid or effective, unless made in writing and signed by the parties hereto: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have set their hands on the day of ___________20167. CITY OF LITTLE CANADA By______________________________ John Keis, Mayor By______________________________ Joel R. Hanson, City Administrator CONTRACTORS By____________________________ Republic Services of the Twin Cities REPUBLIC SERVICES, INC. Bryan Zimmerman, Area President Jeff Marone, General Manager By_____________________________ Gene’s Disposal Gene Wegleitner Jr., President By____________________________ Waste Management of MN, Inc. Michael E. Fleming, Vice President Thomas Beaulieu, Area Vice President 2016 Disposal 3.14 4.93 7.39 9.86 Collection -Haulers 5.18 5.57 5.73 5.52 Recycling 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 Bulky Items 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 2016 w/o tipping fees 11.18 11.57 11.73 11.52 2016 14.32 16.50 19.12 21.38 2017 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal (2,000 lbs/yr/res)2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 *Collection 5.84 6.24 6.40 6.40 Recycling 5.63 5.63 5.63 5.63 Total 14.17 16.11 18.39 20.51 -1.05%-2.36%-3.82%-4.07% % Change w/o Disposal 2.59%2.59%2.56%4.43% 2018 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 *Collection 5.95 6.35 6.52 6.52 Recycling 5.76 5.76 5.76 5.76 Total 14.41 16.35 18.64 20.76 % Change 1.69%1.49%1.36%1.22% % Change w/o Disposal 2.09%2.02%2.08%2.08% 2019 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 *Collection 6.06 6.47 6.64 6.64 Recycling 5.89 5.89 5.89 5.89 Total 14.65 16.60 18.89 21.01 % Change 1.67%1.53%1.34%1.20% % Change w/o Disposal 2.05%2.06%2.04%2.04% ATTACHMENT A February 8, 2017 2020 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 *Collection 6.17 6.59 6.76 6.76 Recycling 6.02 6.02 6.02 6.02 Total 14.89 16.85 19.14 21.26 % Change 1.64%1.51%1.32%1.19% % Change w/o Disposal 2.01%2.02%2.00%2.00% 2021 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 *Collection 6.28 6.71 6.89 6.89 Recycling 6.15 6.15 6.15 6.15 Total 15.13 17.10 19.40 21.52 % Change 1.61%1.48%1.36%1.22% % Change w/o Disposal 1.97%1.98%2.03%2.03% New Service YARD WASTE Annual Partial Year 2016 $48.00 $24.00 % Change 2017 $54.00 $27.00 12.50% 2018 $56.00 $28.00 3.70% 2019 $58.00 $29.00 3.57% 2020 $62.00 $31.00 6.90% 2021 $64.00 $32.00 3.23%33.3% Total weather permitting. Annual billing amounts will be charged during the eight months of service. New customers electing service in April - September will be the customer opts out of service before April 1st. A customer discontinuing service Yard Waste Service provides for up to two (2) carts of up to 90 gallons in size. A customer may also place additional, customer owned containers weighting no adjacent to the yard waste container(s) as part of this service. *Note: "Collection" includes the allowance that each customer may have up to three bulky items diposed of at no additional charge per calendar year. Any bulky items beyond three (3) shall be charged according to Schedule B. Yard waste service will be automatically renewed for the next full season unless during the yard waste season will be charged on a pro-rated monthly basis with any partial counting as a full month of service. more than 50 pounds, at the curb. Compostable bags may also be placed at the curb Seasonal Yard Waste service runs from April 1st through November 30th; subject to a full year's charge. New customers electing service in October or November will be subject to the partial year charge noted above and must become full year's customers in the following year or become ineligible for the service. 2016 Disposal 3.14 4.93 7.39 9.86 Collection -Haulers 5.18 5.57 5.73 5.52 Recycling 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 Bulky Items 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 2016 w/o tipping fees 11.18 11.57 11.73 11.52 2016 14.32 16.50 19.12 21.38 2017 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal (2,000 lbs/yr/res)2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 Collection - 3% 5.34 5.74 5.90 5.90 Recycling - 2%5.10 5.10 5.10 5.10 Bulky Items - 3%1.03 1.03 1.03 1.03 Total 14.17 16.11 18.39 20.51 -1.05%-2.36%-3.82%-4.07% % Change w/o Disposal 2.59%2.59%2.56%4.43% 2018 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 Collection - 2%5.45 5.85 6.02 6.02 Recycling - $.10 5.20 5.20 5.20 5.20 Bulky Items - $.03 1.06 1.06 1.06 1.06 Total 14.41 16.35 18.64 20.76 % Change 1.69%1.49%1.36%1.22% % Change w/o Disposal 2.09%2.02%2.08%2.08% 2019 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 Collection - 2%5.56 5.97 6.14 6.14 Recycling - +$.10 5.30 5.30 5.30 5.30 Bulky Items - $.03 1.09 1.09 1.09 1.09 Total 14.65 16.60 18.89 21.01 % Change 1.67%1.53%1.34%1.20% % Change w/o Disposal 2.05%2.06%2.04%2.04% Final Proposal February 7, 2017 2020 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 Collection - 2%5.67 6.09 6.26 6.26 Recycling - +$.10 5.40 5.40 5.40 5.40 Bulky Items - $.03 1.12 1.12 1.12 1.12 Total 14.89 16.85 19.14 21.26 % Change 1.64%1.51%1.32%1.19% % Change w/o Disposal 2.01%2.02%2.00%2.00% 2021 30 60 90 Up to 360 Gal $58/ton Disposal 2.70 4.24 6.36 8.48 Collection - 2%5.78 6.21 6.39 6.39 Recycling - +$.10 5.50 5.50 5.50 5.50 Bulky Items - $.03 1.15 1.15 1.15 1.15 Total 15.13 17.10 19.40 21.52 % Change 1.61%1.48%1.36%1.22% % Change w/o Disposal 1.97%1.98%2.03%2.03% New Service YARD WASTE Annual Partial Year 2016 $48.00 $24.00 % Change 2017 $54.00 $27.00 12.50% 2018 $56.00 $28.00 3.70% 2019 $58.00 $29.00 3.57% 2020 $62.00 $31.00 6.90% 2021 $64.00 $32.00 3.23%33.3% Total weather permitting. Annual billing amounts will be charged during the eight months of service. New customers electing service in April - September will be the customer opts out of service before April 1st. A customer discontinuing service Yard Waste Service provides for up to two (2) carts no larger than 90 gallons in size. A customer may also place additional, customer owned containers weighting no adjacent to the yard waste container(s) as part of this service. Yard waste service will be automatically renewed for the next full season unless during the yard waste season will be charged on a pro-rated monthly basis with any partial counting as a full month of service. more than 50 pounds, at the curb. Compostable bags may also be placed at the curb Seasonal Yard Waste service runs from April 1st through November 30th; subject to a full year's charge. New customers electing service in October or November will be subject to the partial year charge noted above and must become full year's customers in the following year or become ineligible for the service. "Bulky Items" rate provides for up to three (3) items to be collected per customer per calendar year. Any items that exceed three (3) will be charged based on Schedule B attached. Attachment B Additional Collection Services for 2017 Agreement Miscellaneous Bulk items Must be less than 40lbs Longer items must be cut in lengths of 4-5 feet and be manageable for the drivers Per the contract, each residence is allowed three (3) bulk items to be removed and disposed of per year, as provided for in Little Canada’s Refuse and Recycling Contract. Description Price Appliance (Refrigerator, washer, dryer, air conditioner, freezer, etc.) $ 50.00 Automobile Seat bench $ 50.00 bucket $ 25.00 Bathtubs fiberglass $ 40.00 cast iron (must be broken up) $ 100.00 Beds bed frame $ 10.00 headboard $ 10.00 footboard $ 10.00 box spring $ 35.00 mattress $ 35.00 waterbed frame $ 15.00 waterbed mattress (drained) $ 15.00 baby crib $ 15.00 Bikes child $ 10.00 adult $ 15.00 Book Case $ 15.00 Car Seats baby or booster seat $ 10.00 large/regular $ 10.00 Carpet - average room size 12 feet x 12 feet per room (5 ft length cut and rolled) $ 35.00 pad (5 ft length cut and rolled) $ 25.00 area rugs (3 feet by 5 feet average) $ 10.00 Chairs dining room/desk/kitchen/stool/high chair $ 20.00 stuffed $ 25.00 recliner $ 25.00 Childrens toys (doll house, big wheels) $ 10.00 Couch love seat $ 25.00 sofa $ 35.00 hide-a-bed $ 50.00 *hide-a-bed mattress = 1 item $ 35.00 futon $ 50.00 sectional = 2 items $ 60.00 Desk child $ 15.00 metal $ 40.00 wood (medium) (ie computer desk, student) $ 20.00 wood (large) $ 30.00 Door interior hollow $ 10.00 interior solid $ 20.00 exterior $ 20.00 screen $ 10.00 sliding glass (each piece) $ 50.00 bi-fold $ 20.00 shower door $ 10.00 Dresser Child’s or a night stand $ 20.00 chest $ 30.00 large $ 40.00 Exercise equipment $ 50.00 Floor Lamp $ 10.00 Garage Door Opener(rail must be broken down) $ 15.00 Gas Grill (no tank) $ 20.00 Lawn Mower (gas and oil must be drained) $ 30.00 Medicine Cabinet small or no mirrors $ 10.00 large or with mirrors $ 15.00 Mirrors $ 15.00 Sink bath (single) $ 15.00 bath (pedestal) $ 25.00 bath (vanity-by size) $ 30.00 kitchen $ 30.00 laundry tub $ 50.00 Snow Blower (gas and oil must be drained) $ 30.00 Stereo $ 20.00 Stereo Speaker $ 10.00 Table kitchen $ 25.00 large dining room $ 50.00 coffee $ 15.00 Tire Car with rim $ 15.00 Car without rim $ 10.00 Truck with rim $ 30.00 Truck without rim $ 20.00 Toilet with tank $ 25.00 without tank $ 15.00 Trampoline (must be broken down) small $ 10.00 large $ 50.00 Vacuum Cleaner $ 10.00 Water Softener (empty only) $ 50.00 Windows single $ 15.00 double $ 30.00 triple or larger $ 45.00 screens $ 5.00 Yardwaste yardwaste on call per bag $ 5.00 per month if needed Walk-Up Service (A Distance of No Greater Than 200 feet) $ 15.00 STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of City Council FROM: Bill Dircks, Public Works Director DATE: February 16, 2017 RE: Purchase of Used Sewer Camera Trailer Unit The City’s Public Works Department maintains the sanitary sewer system, which consists of around 36 miles of pipe and hundreds of manholes. Part of our agreement with the League of Minnesota Cities Insurance Trust is that we will inspect and clean our entire system every three years. Following that schedule is deemed to be reasonable maintenance and helps us prevent blockages, which, in turn, prevents costly litigation from sewage backups into homes and businesses. In the past the City has utilized a jetting machine of some sort to clean the pipes. Currently, a Vactor combination jetter/vacuum truck is used. The truck has been an excellent addition to the City’s fleet and has done a tremendous job of maintaining the sewer lines. However, there are times when a perfectly clean line is getting jetted and that means unnecessary hours are being put on the truck as well as thousands of gallons of water are being wasted. The Vactor can only be used in temperatures above freezing and that limits the sewer maintenance work to the busy summer months. Another option for inspecting sewer lines is to televise them. The City last had its entire system televised over the course of three years in 1996-98. All of the existing lines at the time were televised and the City owns the VHS tapes and inspection books from this project. Since that time the City has done some spot televising for inflow and infiltration (I&I) problems as well as prior to street reconstruction projects. The City currently owns a camera that can be fitted on the end of the water hose of the Vactor and sent up the sewer pipes using water pressure. The footage can be unclear due to the water spray from the hose, the camera cannot pan and tilt to look up services, and the footage is recorded on VHS tapes, which are bulky to store and in short supply for purchase. Flexible Pipe Tool Company in St. Joseph, MN sells sanitary sewer cameras. The cameras are on the state contract so everything is set for pricing. One of the options Flexible Pipe offers is a 6’ by 10’ trailer with the camera and other equipment mounted inside. The trailer is set up at a manhole and the camera is strategically deployed so that multiple runs between manholes can be accomplished with one set up. There are 1000 feet of cable on the reel and mast manholes are 300-400 feet apart. Ideally, the camera heads upstream for two or three straight runs and then heads downstream for two or three more runs. Not every run is neat and tidy but routes can be set up to limit the number of set ups. The camera can be deployed in the winter as there is a heater in the trailer. A Public Works employee sits at an operator station in the trailer and runs the camera from there. This would allow the City to inspect its mains in the winter months to free up more time in the summer for other maintenance activities. The majority of the mains in the City are “clean” in that they don’t have significant sediment or root build up in them so televising would satisfy the inspection requirement the City has. This would also give the City a better idea of the condition of its system with regard to cracked pipes, I&I, bad joints, dips, and other pipe imperfections which can cause problems. Having its own camera will allow the City to check for I&I in real time. If there is a significant rain event the camera can be deployed to investigate suspected trouble areas to see how much clear water is flowing while the operator is inside a dry trailer. In the City’s constant efforts to rid the system of I&I a camera can be a valuable tool. The camera itself has tires and “drives” along the sewer pipes with the cable connecting it back to the trailer. The camera can pan and tilt giving it the ability to look up sewer services, which can be big contributors to I&I. It may also show a large mass of roots in the first few feet of the service and the property owner could be notified that the service should be cleaned. All of the footage is recorded either directly onto a laptop hard drive or onto a flash drive, so storage of the footage is easy and does not require nearly as much space as the VHS tapes. The trailer package that is offered by Flexible Pipe ranges from $80,000 to $100,000 depending on some of the accessories selected. The City of Owatonna purchased a trailer unit from Flexible Pipe in 2006 and has used it for the last ten years. The camera got to be permanently foggy and they had a ten year service life for the trailer in their budget so they purchased a new trailer unit last month. The old unit is available for sale by Flexible Pipe. The camera was sent to the manufacturer and completely re- built. Staff had a demonstration of the unit last week on County Road C. The temperature was 5 degrees but the sheltered trailer allowed the operator to run the camera comfortably. The image from the camera was crystal clear with no fogging. Sometimes cold weather will fog up the lens but that was not the case last week. The price of the used unit is $42,000. There are some modifications that will be necessary, such as the addition of a cold weather hatch on one of the rear doors to allow the camera cable to run out of the trailer while the door remains closed to keep it warm. A lifting rig may also need to be added to the back of the trailer which would enable one person to set up the camera. As it currently is set up it takes two people to set it up. $3500 should cover the cost of those two additions. The only unknown at this point is the camera reader software that needs to be purchased to allow the camera and laptop to work together and also to integrate the footage onto the City’s GIS mapping system. There are options for this and staff wants to make sure the City gets the best value. The software expert for Flexible Pipe has recommended the Pipe Scan software. He is on vacation this week but staff will talk to him next week prior to the meeting and determine the best software for the unit. The maximum price for the unit, software, and additions noted above would be $59,000, which is significantly less expensive than a new unit. Staff has budgeted $100,000 for a camera in the Water and Sewer Capital Improvement Fund. Staff recommends authorizing the purchase of the used 2006 sewer camera trailer, the additional equipment, and the software for a price not to exceed $60,000. STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of City Council FROM: Bill Dircks, Public Works Director DATE: February 15, 2017 RE: Purchase of a John Deere Tractor with Flail Mower The Public Works Department currently uses a 1987 Case 585 tractor with a flail mower on it to mow boulevards throughout the City. The tractor was purchased from Ramsey County in 2001 and has served the City well during its time. It is starting to require extra maintenance and the lack of a cab has caused problems for employees mowing with it in extreme heat and with all of the pollen and other allergy-inducing particles flying around. The lack of a cab also limits the use of the tractor to warmer months. Staff has researched tractors available on the state contract to replace the current tractor. Staff went to the City of White Bear Lake and looked at its 2016 John Deere tractor. While it is bigger than what Little Canada needs it is comparable in what it is used for. White Bear uses it to mow boulevards, aerate, and fertilize in the summer months and it is used to plow alleys and cul-de-sacs in the winter months with a six-way V-plow. White Bear did extensive research in looking for a new tractor and they came to the conclusion that the John Deere was the best tractor available. They raved about how comfortable it is and how well it rides over whichever surface it is on. They had an older John Deere previous to the new one and it worked well for them and maintenance was not a problem. Staff feels that a John Deere 5085M tractor with a cab will offer many more options for using it. A flail mower is proposed to be purchased with it for mowing boulevards. Other possibilities for the tractor include aeration, fertilization, plowing, and putting a loader on it to load salt or anything else. The mower component is a Berti TA/S200 swing mower. It has very sturdy large blades that hold up well under the rough boulevard conditions. It is offset from the tractor to allow mowing close to MNDot right-of-way fences and can mow while at both upward and downward angles to better follow the contours of the boulevards. Staff recommends the purchase of a John Deere 5085M tractor from Minnesota Equipment for the MN state contract price of $61,362.69. Staff also recommends purchasing a Berti TA/S200 flail mower from Minnesota Equipment for the state contract price of $10,074.75. That amounts to a total expenditure of $71,437.44. $75,000 was budgeted for the purchase of a tractor in the 2017 Capital Improvement Fund. Staff plans to sell the 1987 Case tractor and feels it can be sold for $3500. STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis & Members of the City Council FROM: Joel Hanson, City Administrator DATE: February 16, 2017 RE: Fire Truck Purchase Attached is correspondence from the Little Canada Fire Department relating to the purchase of a new fire truck. This truck is a pumper and will be replacing a unit that was purchased back in 1994. In addition to the truck, they will also be purchasing additional equipment to property outfit the truck (a listing of that equipment is attached). It should be noted that the equipment purchase was not budgeted in the General Capital Improvement Fund #400. We have been budgeting over $100,000 a year for a number of years now to help fund the replacement of fire apparatus. At the end of 2016, we projected that fund to have over $1,132,000 available for this purpose. The cost of the truck is $636,786 if we pay 100% of the cost up front and before the end of February. In doing the math, the discount for a cash payment warrants the use of this option given that rate of return is higher than we can currently earn by investing the cash ourselves. With the additional loose equipment, estimated at $60,000, and some additional equipment mounting brackets that will be needed, the total price of the new truck after equipping it will total $702,286. There will be a future recovery associated with the sale of the 1994 Pumper, but that number is unknown at this time. Staff recommends authorize the purchase of the truck and related equipment from the Fire Equipment Replacement Fund #457 at a total cost of $702,286 and subject to any sale proceeds from the 1994 Pumper being received by Fund #457. cc: LCFD Steve Peters of Masterpiece Homes, Inc. will be present at Wednesday’s workshop to discuss the possible development of the Twin Lake Boulevard land we own. Their concept layout is attached for your review. Some of the issues to be clarified if this process moves forward include the following: • Density of development • Access points to Twin Lake Boulevard • Screening along the north property line. • Sanitary Sewer connection (lift station versus Vadnais Heights tie in) • Cost of land • Cost of improvements • Public or private improvements - we could make this a public project given it is our land which should save on engineering costs because Lee would design and not just review. We could also assess improvement costs for a short period of time similar to Pine Tree pond which may help with financing. • Unit design and pricing • Other To date, staff has not had any major discussions with the developer on these topics. These may not be ready to be resolved at this workshop, but they are considerations we will need to address. cc: Steve Peters Little Canada Fire Department Memo To: Joel Hanson: City Administrator From: Don Smiley: Fire Chief Date: February 16, 2017 Joel, here is a summary of the new truck proposal. The committee has been working on this process since the spring of 2016. We have spent countless hours working on this specification and I believe we have come up with a great solution for the fire department and the city. Attached is the truck pricing and discount breakdowns. As per your recommendation our best option is to pay the contract in full at the time of contract signing. The apparatus build time is roughly 9 months from time of contract signing. This truck will be purchased thru the Houston Galveston consortium. The fee assessed by the consortium is included in the pricing from Pierce. Also attached is a detailed list of loose equipment that we will need to equip this new vehicle. Most all of the equipment on the truck that we are replacing is also 23 years old and is in need of replacement. The only real unknown at this point is the cost of the tool and equipment mounting and supplies done by the dealer once the truck is finished. We anticipate this cost to be a maximum of $3,500. Here is summary of all the costs: New truck with discounts $638,786.00 Truck loose equipment $ 60,000.00 Loose equipment brackets and mounting $3,500.00 Total cost $702,286.00 The fire department is recommending this truck purchase along with the additions of the loose equipment and the tool brackets and mounting. Respectfully, Don Smiley, Fire Chief NEW ENGINE ESTIMATE FOR LOOSE EQUIPMENT • Thermal Imaging Camera & Truck Charger - $10,000.00 • Auto Extrication Equipment - $30,000.00 • Supply Hose - $6252.00 • Hand Nozzles & Wye - $7000.00 • Electric Ventilation Fan - $2662.00 • Portable Scene Light - $550.00 • Hand Tools - $750.00 • Tool Box - $250.00 • Truck Winch - $2000.00 Total - $59464.00 We are requesting no more than $60,000.00 to cover the above costs since they are a best guess estimate and the pricing may change by the time the purchases are made. Date: February 13, 2017 Customer: Little Canada Fire Department Description: One (1) 2017 Pierce Velocity™ Pumper HGAC Price Breakdown: 2017 Velocity™ Pumper $ 668,072 Performance Bond $ 1,786 Pierce Additional Discount $ 6,700 Chassis Prepayment Discount $ 9,172 Full Prepayment Interest Discount $ 15,200 Unit Total w/Discounts $ 638,786 Full Payment 15 Days after Contract Main Unit Features:  Velocity 7020 Cab – 5 Seats – Hands Free Air Pack Brackets  E-Coated Frame Rails and Substructure – Standard Rust Inhibitor  TAK-4 Independent Suspension  19” Bumper Extension w/Tray  4 Point Winch Receiver Ports  Cummins ISL 9 450 HP Engine – 3000 Series Transmission  Command Zone III Electronics – (3) Touch Screens –Hand Held Device Connection  Aluminum Length Body – 750 Gallon Water 30 Foam  Hydraulic Ladder Rack  Waterous CMU 2000 Dual Stage Pump – Cold Climate Package  Two (2) Rear 2.50” Hose Bed Discharges  Foam Pro 2001 Foam System – Seven Compatible Discharges  Waterous Full Flow Valves – Electric Valve Controls  Whelen MSeries Lighting Package – With new Freedom IV Light Bar  6KW Harrison Generator  Command Light Shadow 4 Light Head  Black Protective Coating Package  LED Backlit Hansen Handrails  Three Customer Visits to Factory during build process This price quote is good till February 28th. These units would have a 9-month lead time from the time of contract. STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor Keis and Members of City Council FROM: Joel Hanson, City Administrator DATE: February 16, 2017 RE: 2017 Goals On Monday, February 13, 2017, the Council held their annual goal setting session with representatives from City Staff, Planning Commission, Parks & Rec Commission, Fire Department, Ramsey County Sheriff’s Department and citizen representatives. Thirteen goals were identified and voted on by all attendees. The summary of the voting is attached, along with the list of the thirteen goals, which have been added to the master goals list. The Council should adopt the goals they feel are appropriate for 2017. Goals Total Points # of Votes Total Points # of Votes Total Points # of Votes Finding new sustainable businesses for reuse of vacant properties/empty storefronts 1 1 20 7 21 8 Seek funding for the I-694 Trout Brook Trail connections for Little Canada 0 0 6 2 6 2 Comp Plan Update - Mobile Home Parks Zoning, Discussion on residential property development, plan to develop city-owned properties, 10 3 25 8 35 11 "Greening" of Little Canada - effective/efficient multi-family recycling - 0 0 8 5 8 5 Parks Master Plan - Rehab Spooner Park playground, increase wifi in parks, build dog park, Evaluate current use of park equipment and playgrounds 16 5 38 13 54 18 Expand City's Channel 16 cable offerings 2 1 0 0 2 1 Stimulate Rice Street Business District rehabilitation 2 1 12 3 14 4 Continue to enhance relationship with Fire Dept 5 1 3 1 8 2 Review City mission statement, vision, core values 3 2 14 5 17 7 Increase efforts on crime prevention on forcused areas w/higher crime rates 10 2 22 9 32 11 Work with the Sheriff's Dept on how they are hiring/training/response action plan for race relations 10 3 26 9 36 12 Develop a comprehensive digital media plan 2 2 6 2 8 4Community Engagement - increase voter turnout, community input on Comp Plan, Re-establish Community Pride Committee, Outreach to diverse populations, Youth engagement - connect volunteers to opportunities, more youth activities, intergenerations connections, Website link for local resources to help seniors in the community, Promote LC Business Registry List, Ensure public input on county road improvement projects, 14 4 45 11 59 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Elected Officials Non-Elected Participants Total Participants 2017 GOAL SETTING SUMMARY Priority Ranking By All Participants 1 2017 GOAL SETTING WORKSHOP MONDAY, FEBRUARY 13, 2017 LITTLE CANADA CITY CENTER FACILITATED BY MARK NAGEL PARTICIPANTS: John Keis, Mayor Christian Torkelson, Council Member Tom Fischer, Council Member Michael McGraw, Council Member Rick Montour, Council Member Steve Morelan, Little Canada Assistant Fire Chief Rich Clark, Ramsey County Sheriff’s Department Commander Catherine Beltmann, Planning Commission Jennifer Schletty-Flores, Planning Commission Rose Chu, Parks & Recreation Commission Tom Ray, Parks & Recreation Commission Joel Hanson, City Administrator Sharon Provos, Finance Director Bill Dircks, Public Works Director Jessica Jagoe, Planner/Code Enforcement Officer Derek Anderson, Supervisor – Parks Katie McGinnity, Recreation Supervisor Heidi Heller, City Clerk Sharon Gooch, Resident Taelor Johnson, Resident 2 2017 Goals: Listed in order of total points received 1. Community Engagement: a. Increase voter turnout b. Community input on the Comp Plan Update c. Re-establish Community Pride Committee d. Outreach to diverse populations e. Youth engagement – connecting volunteers & youth to more activities, more youth activities f. Intergenerational connections g. Website link for local resources to help seniors in the community h. Promote the Little Canada Business Registry List i. Ensure public input on county road improvement projects 2. Parks Master Plan: a. Rehab Spooner Park playground b. Increase wifi in city parks c. Build a dog park d. Evaluate the current use of park equipment and playgrounds 3. Work with Ramsey County Sheriff’s Department on how they are hiring deputies, training deputies, and planning for a response action plan if an race involved police event occurs in a contract jurisdiction as well as any current actions/plans for improving race relations 4. Comp Plan Update: a. Zoning of Mobile Home Parks b. Discussion on residential property development c. Plan to develop city-owned properties 5. Increase efforts on crime prevention in focused areas with higher crime rates 6. Finding new sustainable businesses for reuse of vacant properties/empty storefronts 7. Review City mission statement, vision and core values 8. Stimulate Rice Street Business District rehabilitation 9. Greening of Little Canada – effective/efficient multi-family housing recycling (tie 9-11) 10. Continue to enhance the relationship between the City and the Fire Department (tie 9-11) 11. Develop a comprehensive digital media plan (tie 9-11) 12. Seek funding for the I-694 Trout Brook Trail connections for Little Canada 13. Expand City’s Channel 16 cable offerings 3 Goals Yet To Be Accomplished: 2016 Goals – 1. Develop an integrated communications plan focusing on an update website and social media usage to improve communications with our resident. – Social Media policy adopted and website review still on-going. 2. Implement a business retention/expansion survey program – Questionnaire not yet finalized. Will be implemented in 1st Quarter of 2017. Fire Marshal has been having discussions with businesses. Lapham Hickey Steel’s potential expansion came about through this process. However, they have now put that project on hold. 3. Evaluate options for improvements to our organized collection system to be considered during contract renewal – Negotiations are nearing completion with the haulers. Delays occurred due to personnel changes with two of the haulers. It is expected that a five-year contract will be presented at the February 22nd meeting. 4. Investigate process for regionalization of fire department services/equipment – Determined Fire Department was best entity to initiate. This will be a long-term undertaking. 5. Conduct a community survey – Not a pressing immediate need not pressing – will be considered in the future – Continued. Other Goals To Be Accomplished:  Fire Department Long-Term Strategic Plan (On-Going)  Determine whether or not to use Video Surveillance for Crime Prevention – Sheriff’s Department needs to lead this. They have implemented a system whereby business can choose to have their video used by Sheriff’s Department on a voluntary basis. This does not help our surveillance issues for areas like Ryan Industrial Park. We may have to do this one on our own.  Shared Multi-Family Housing Patrol Position (Vadnais Heights not ready)  Funding for Rice Street/694 Bridge Project ($7 million obtained for bridge. Seeking $23.5 million in 2017 legislature.)  Complete Pedestrian/Bike Trail System – Should be revisited by Commission in 2017 to re-prioritize. Remaining areas have challenges in terms of land assembly due to unwilling sellers or the need for future development. We did complete the sidewalk connection on Centerville Road between Eli and Allen Avenue plus added paved shoulders from Allen to Edgerton. 4  Continue to Find a Hotel/Motel Project for Little Canada (Desired site not available)  Focus on Redevelopment (long-term) (Need to secure properties along Owasso – Avison Young Proposal may have merit.)  Purchase remaining Round Lake Properties (Purchased two in 2015. One of initial targets still remains and one additional could be considered for the future)  Complete Country Drive Redevelopment (Relative to hotel option and key parcel not available but an opportunity may exist to purchase remaining house along Country Drive in 2015. Did purchase last remaining parcel on Country Drive - 2801)  Develop Plan for Owasso/Woodlyn Redevelopment Area – In Process  Business Retention-Expansion Program – In Process  Update City Web Site – Still Evaluating Best Approach ACCOMPLISHED GOALS 2002 THROUGH 2016 2016 1. Investigate the feasibility of a housing rehab loan program – 2017 Implementation in question due to Greater Minneapolis Housing Corporation financial evaluation. 2. Institute a process for commercial property maintenance for vacant properties – Revised Nuisance Code to Address – Goal Completed but requires on-going enforcement. 3. Seek Assisted Living Project (Cardigan Ridge project should be ready for occupancy in mid-2017.) 2015 – Different Process – Staff is revising approach for Council’s Consideration 2014 – No Goal Setting Session 2013 – 1. Marketing Rice Street/Highway 36/Viking Drive Site (Property Sold in 2014) 2. Determine whether or not to use Video Surveillance for Crime Prevention (RCSD does not have system available to accomplish this) 3. Public Works Garage Project (New Building Occupied in summer of 2015) 4. Seek Assisted Living Project (Hearth Development will be starting construction in 2016 for 120 Unit Project) 5. Evaluate “Spot-Zoned” Properties, i.e. Norm’s, Bring’s, Arcade Electric, etc. (Norm’s redeveloped to catering business, Brings became new Public Works garage, Arcade Electric – no change). 5 6. Northeast Residential Redevelopment Project (Property at 3046 Labore sold as standalone lot. 15 Lot Pine Tree Pond moved forward in 2013. Sculley, Himmelbach, and Battista properties are not yet in play.) 7. Evaluate Traffic Safety Improvements (enhanced signage and visibility for Labore Road associated with Pine Tree Pond project, deemed 4-way stop at Arcade & Labore inappropriate) 8. Conduct Financial Scenario Planning – “What ifs?” 9. Remodel City Center 10. Increase Community Involvement – Diversity 11. Re-evaluate Commission Appointment process & Develop By-Laws 12. Develop Plan for Owasso/Woodlyn Redevelopment Area (favored single user concept versus multiple parcels and higher development costs) 13. Develop Policy regarding Burying of Power Lines 6 2012 – 1. Social Media Upgrade (Decided not to proceed at this time – but revisited again in 2015) 2. Park Enhancement Plan 3. Little Canada Road Corridor Redevelopment. 2011 – 1. Develop long term Financial Plan for Little Canada that maintains current service levels. 2. Set Financial Policy that does not include Local Government Aid. 3. Evaluate renewal options for Organized Collection Contract. 4. Conduct citywide survey. 2010 – 1. Develop long term financial plan for Fire Truck replacement. 2. Develop Animal Control Policy. 3. Develop Streetscape plan for Little Canada Road. 4. Develop fee schedule for fire re-inspections. 2009 – 1. Revise Street Assessment Policy. 2. Fra-Dor Recycling Interim Use Permit. 3. Explore shared facilities options with other public/private entities. 4. Conduct Little Canada Road Corridor Study. 5. Evaluate Business Licensing Program. (Changed to Fire Re-inspection Fee) 2008 – 1. Pursue funding for Rice Street/36 Bridge 2. Enact Multi-Family Housing Ordinance. 3. Explore utility options for northeast Little Canada. 4. Test Emergency Management Program. 5. Enhance County Road B-2/Rice Street intersection. 2007 – 1. Conduct outdoor storage study in industrial zoned properties and enforce study results. 2. Develop Fiscal Policy. 3. Implement Montreal Court Crime Prevention Program. 2006 – 1. Focus on redevelopment projects. 2. Explore Capital View 10-acre site development options. 3. Implement no parking policy on City streets from 2 a.m. to 6 a.m. 4. Aggressively pursue funding for Rice Street bridge reconstruction. 5. Increase use of email to communicate with citizens. 6. NEMO standards for street standards implementation. 7. Multi-housing Crime Prevention. 7 2005 – 1. Redevelopment Initiatives – Country Drive, Gateway Area Expansion, including City role, open lot catalogue. 2. Upgrade 35E/Little Canada Road ramp area. 3. Enhance website by online bill payments and registration. 4. Conduct Emergency Management Training with Council and staff. 5. Develop sidewalk plan. 6. Upgrade Land use Plans & ordinance 7. Multi-housing License Review 2004 – 1. Explore options for water system agreement with St. Paul. 2. Re-evaluate/dispose of unneeded City property. 3. Continue aggressiveness in code enforcement. 4. Reassess City role in charitable gambling operations. 5. Create home improvement program. 6. Assist Ramsey County Sheriff’s Department in crime prevention efforts. 7. Manage Unweave The Weave 2003 – 1. Explore cooperative agreements with other public/private entities. 2. Maintain current service levels. 3. Complete redevelopment project on Rice Street. 4. Negotiate lower water rates with St. Paul. 5. Conduct City Survey 2002 – 1. Complete Country Drive Redevelopment – Completed RAB/South site not available. 2. Little Canada Road Corridor Redevelopment – Much accomplished but others are long- term). ADDITIONS TO AGENDA COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 22, 2017 OLD BUSINESS 1. Chicken Permit Workflow Example Correspondence Page 2 2. Updated Plan for Lincoln Preserve dated February 20, 2017 Correspondence Pages 3-4 3. Organized Collection Contract – City Attorney’s Review with Comments Correspondence Pages 5-24 1 Resident submits permit application. In Person Email/Web FormBy Mail City Receives Application City Staff: Permit application is reviewed for completeness Permit is incomplete, return to applicant. Permit application is complete. Resident requests permit application City Provides: Permit Form Ordinance Code Chicken Packet City Intake Orientation: In person or phone conversation about city standards, encourages neighbor to neighbor conversation, and stresses how easy it is to go wrong with chicken keeping. Myth vs Reaility. Resident: Evaluates city recommendations and does independent research on chicken keeping. Resident: Declines to proceed. Resident: Engages neighbors about their intent to raise chickens. Resident: Declines to proceed. Neighbors: Do Support Neighbors: Do Not Support City Staff: Verifies applicant received intake orientation. Orientation occurred. Orientation did not occur or applicant has not engaged neighbors. City Staff : Review coop proposal. Coop does not meet standards, return to applicant. Coop meets standards City Staff: Permit approved. Applicant notified. Chicken Permit Workflow Recommended Path Discouraged Path LEGEND 2 From:Dave Nash To:Heidi Heller; Joel Hanson Cc:Steve Grittman; Dan Lincoln (idolife@gmail.com) Subject:Lincoln Preserve Date:Monday, February 20, 2017 11:04:36 AM Attachments:20170220101301364.pdf Heidi / Joel: attached is a revised site plan Lincoln Group would like to present to the City Council on Wednesday night. Due to soil information we received last week - requiring extensive subgrade correction on the site- Lincoln Group needs to change the product type and increase the density to make the project feasible to proceed with. In summary - we are proposing 55 foot wide lots- increasing the unit count on the west side of the property from 11 lots to 17 lots. The 55 foot wide lots would accommodate a 40 foot wide by 65 feet deep detached - single family product. We are also asking for a reduction in the standard front setback ( from 30 feet to 25 feet) and the side yard setback (from 10 feet on both sides - to 10 feet and 5 feet). We assume to proceed with this type of development we would have to request a re-zoning to PUD. Please let us know if you need anything else form us before the council meeting on Wednesday Night. Dave Nash, PE (MN, WI, ND) SENIOR PROJECT MANAGER Alliant Engineering, Inc. 612.767.9327 DIRECT | 612.758.3080 MAIN 612.242.0530 CELL EMAIL | dnash@alliant-inc.com www.alliant-inc.com -----Original Message----- From: Dave Nash Sent: Monday, February 20, 2017 10:27 AM To: Dan Lincoln (idolife@gmail.com) <idolife@gmail.com> Subject: FW: Simple and quick - here is what at minimum I think we need to send the City for consideration. I suggest we ask for 25 foot front setback in luie of 30 - since we are going to smaller lot width. Review and call me - or send off to City to add to the packet for council. Dave Nash, PE (MN, WI, ND) SENIOR PROJECT MANAGER Alliant Engineering, Inc. 612.767.9327 DIRECT | 612.758.3080 MAIN 612.242.0530 CELL EMAIL | dnash@alliant-inc.com www.alliant-inc.com -----Original Message----- From: tschrag@alliant-inc.com [mailto:tschrag@alliant-inc.com] Sent: Monday, February 20, 2017 10:13 AM To: Dave Nash <dnash@alliant-inc.com> Subject: This E-mail was sent from "RNP43BF36" (Aficio MPW7140en). Scan Date: 02.20.2017 10:13:01 (-0600) 3 4 LITTLE CANADA REFUSE & RECYCLING SERVICE CONTRACT THIS CONTRACT, made and entered into this day of February 22, 2017, by and between the CITY OF LITTLE CANADA, a municipal corporation in the County of Ramsey, herein referred to as "City," and Republic Services, IncAllied Waste Services of North America, LLC, d/b/a Repub lic Services o f th e Twin Cities (“R epub li c”) ., a Minnesota corporation, and Gene's Disposal, Inc., a Minnesota corporation, and Waste Management of Minnesota, Inc., a Minnesota corporation, herein referred to collectively as "Contractor." R E C I T A L S: WHEREAS, the City requires the collection and disposal of garbage and rubbish, and recyclables from residences in the City of Little Canada; and Whereas, the Contractor is a group of licensed haulers in the City of Little Canada engaged in the business of collection and disposing and disposal of refuse, yard waste, and recyclables; and Whereas, the City desires to hire the services of the Contractor and the Contractor desires to provide services to the City; NOW, THEREFORE, it is agreed by and between all parties: I. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF SERVICES. The Contractor shall supply all labor, materials, and equipment necessary to make a complete collection of garbage and refuse, rubbish, yard waste and recyclables from all residences in the City of Little Canada at least once in each calendar week during the term of this Contract, single sort recyclables once every two weeks, two so rt rec yclab les fo r cu stomers of Gen e’ s Dispo sal on ce every week bulky items weekly as scheduled, and yard waste on a weekly basis from April 1st through November 30th, weather permitting for those participating customers. Such collections shall include all residential properties having two (2) or less dwelling units in a single building by use of individual containers. The Contractor shall provide all personnel, equipment, and facilities necessary to fulfill the terms and conditions of this Contract. The Contractor shall provide said services in compliance with all applicable laws and shall charge for said services on a volume-based schedule. II. TERM OF CONTRACT. This Contract shall be in full force and effect for a five-year period beginning January 1, 2017. III. DEFINITIONS. For purposes of this Contract, the following terms shall have the following meanings: A. Additional Collection Service. Refuse in excess of the designated volume-base per residential dwelling unit or residential dwelling units desiring collection of items from a location other than the boulevard adjoining the curb. B. Appliances. Household items such asincluding, but not limited to, refrigerators stoves, dishwashers, Formatted: Font color: Red Comment [TB1]: Kelly Change Comment [TB2]: Kelly Change Comment [TB3]: Kelly Change 5 electronics as defined in this contract, garbage disposers, freezers, washers and dryers, water heaters, microwave ovens, trash compactors, furnaces, air conditioners, and dehumidifiers. “Appliances” includes the industry term “white goods”. Gas ammonia appliances are not included under this definition as they are considered hazardous waste. C. Bulky Items. Large household items such asincluding, but not limited to, bathtubs, beds, mattresses, bikes, carpet and padding (less than 4 foot bundles & less than 45 pounds), chairs, couches, doors, dressers, exercise equipment, garage door openers, gas grills (without tank), lawnmowers (drained), pallets, water softeners, wheels/rims/tires, windows, construction debris (less than 4 feet in length and less than 45 pounds), and items that are too large to fit into the garbage cart or container. D. Co-collection of Organics. The co-mingled collection of yard waste and food waste. This may also include contaminated, non-recyclable paper. E. Collection Service. Collection service is the process of collection and transportation of refuse, yard waste and recyclables. Contractor. Independent contractor means person or persons authorized by the Contract to perform refuse collection services within the City. F. Day-Certain Collection. Day-Certain collection is a City-approved plan for weekl y collection services by an established day-certain schedule. This schedule requires refuse, yard waste, and recyclable collection on the same day of the week and is based on a five (5) day, Monda y through Friday, workweek. The only exceptions to the "day certain" plan shall be during those weeks in which occur legal holidays, the pickup of major appliances under the Bulky Item designation or inclement weather, which the Contractor is not able to safely operate its business. The Contractor will then notify the City within a timely manner of delay and include a plan for completion of collection. The City and Contractor agree that once operations resume, the Contractor will make customers impacted by the delay due to inclement weather a top priority to minimize the service interruption to the greatest extent possible. In inclement weather conditions, the Contractor is also responsible for notifying customers covered under this contract through their phone dial-outcommunications system to make them aware of the delay in service. The only exceptions to the "day-certain" plan shall be during those weeks in which occur legal holidays or the pickup of major appliances under the Bulky Item designation. G. Electronics. Computers and peripherals, televisions, video display device, printers, FAX machines, DVD players, video cassette recorders and other devices as acceptable by the Contractor and the State. Electronics does not include any device with a cathode ray tube (CRT). All definitions of electronics are as defined by State law. H. Food Waste. Garbage, as defined below, kitchen scraps, and garden waste as would be deemed acceptable by Ramsey County and their compost collection points. I. Garbage. Waste material, animal, or vegetable that results from the handling, preparation, cooking, service, and consumption of food. J. Multi-family Dwelling. Residential premises with greater than two living units and which have centralize solid waste and recyclable materials collection service for all units in the building and which are billed as one address. K. Organics. Plant materials co-mingled with food waste and contaminated, non-recyclable paper. L. Prohibited Mailings. Notices sent to residential dwelling units within the City of Little Canada Comment [TB4]: Kelly Change Comment [TB5]: Need to specify Comment [TB6]: Kelly Change 6 advertising rates or services not available under this contract. M. Receptacle. Unless specified otherwise, whether referred to as “cart”, “garbage can”, “plastic bag”, “suitable container”, “cans”, or “containers”, means a container that shall be of such size and form as to permit collection by one customer. Solid Waste containers or carts with hinged lids are provided by the Contractor and range in size from 30 to 96 gallons. N. Recyclables. Recyclables are reusable materials approved and agreed to b y t he parties hereto. Recyclables shall include such items as newsprint, catalogs, magazines, phone books, junk mail, cereal boxes, corrugated cardboard, and miscellaneous paper as long as it is not contaminated with food or waste, metal and aluminum cans, plastics with a neck, and glass containers. Recyclables specifically exclude garbage, refuse and yard waste. O. Refuse. Refuse is solid waste including garbage and rubbish, and specifically excluding yard waste, recyclables, and toxic and hazardous wastes. Refuse further excludes industrial, commercial, agricultural, and construction garbage or rubbish and wastes. P. Residential Dwelling Unit. A residential dwelling unit is a separate dwelling place with a kitchen. A residential dwelling unit shall not include: mobile manufactured homes, tri-plexes, four- plexes, town homes, condominiums, or apartment buildings. Q. Rubbish. Rubbish is solid waste, including ashes, consisting of both combustible and noncombustible wastes, such as wood, bedding, crockery, and other non-reusable waste. Rubbish also includes non- recyclable types of glass, paper, cardboard, metal cans and plastics. R. Special Waste. Special Waste is any nonhazardous solid waste at City locations which, because of its physical characteristics, chemical make-up, or biological nature requires either special handling, disposal procedures including liquids for solidification at the landfill, documentation, and/or regulatory authorization, or poses an unusual threat to human health, equipment, property, or the environment. Special Waste must conform in all respects with a Contractor-approved Special Waste Profile. Special Waste includes, but is not limited to: (i) Waste generated by an industrial process or a pollution control process; (ii) Waste which may contain residue and debris from the cleanup of spilled petroleum, chemical or commercial products or wastes, or contaminated residuals; (iii)Waste which is nonhazardous as a result of proper treatment pursuant to Subtitle C of the Resou rce Con servation and Reco very Act o f 1976 (“R C R A”); (iv) Waste from the cleanup of a facility which generates, stores, treats, recycles or disposes of chemical substances, commercial products or wastes; (v) Waste which may contain free liquids and requires liquid waste solidification; (vi) Containers that once contained hazardous substances, chemicals, or insecticides so lon g as su ch con tain ers are “emp t y” as d efin ed b y RCRA; (vii) Asbestos containing or asbestos bearing material that has been properly secured under existing Applicable Law; (viii) Waste containing regulated polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) as defined in the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA); Comment [TB7]: In other areas of the contract it refers to 90 gallons. Comment [TB8]: Kelly Change 7 (ix) Waste containing naturally occurring radioactive material (NORM) and/or technologically-enhanced NORM (TENORM); and (x) Municipal or commercial solid waste that may have come into contact with any of the foregoing. S. Special Waste Profile. Contracto r’s form of documentation that the City must complete, and Contractor must approve, with respect to any Special Waste prior to Con tracto r’s acceptance of such Special Waste. The City will ensure that the Special Waste Profile includes a complete and accurate description of the waste stream, including the generating process and chemical and physical characteristics. T. Townhome. Structures containing two or more units of not more than three (3) stories each and contiguous to each other. Said units shall also be governed by an association for the entire series of structures within any such development. U. Toxic and Hazardous Wastes. Toxic and hazardous wastes are waste materials including, but not limited to, liquid paint, motor oils, batteries, poisons, pesticides, herbicides, acids, caustics, pathological wastes, radioactive materials, flammable or explosive materials, and similar harmful chemicals and wastes which require special handling and must be disposed of in a manner to conserve the environment and protect public health and safety. V. Unacceptable Waste. Hazardous, radioactive, volatile, corrosive, highly flammable, explosive, biomedical, infectious, biohazardous, toxic or listed or characteristic hazardous waste as defined by Applicable Law or any otherwise regulated waste. In addition, any Special Waste that does not conform to the Special Waste Profile supplied by Customer is Unacceptable Waste. W. Waste Materials. Waste Material is all nonhazardous Solid Waste and, if designated in this Contract, nonhazardous Special Waste and/or Recyclables that are not excluded by this Contract. Waste Material does not include any Unacceptable Waste. X. WU. Yard Waste. All organic plant material that can be composted including grass clippings, leaves, soft garden material, brush and tree limbs under four inches in diameter and four feet in length provided they are bundled with twine or other organic material. IV. SCOPE OF CONTRACT. A. Collection Service Provided by Contractor. 1. Garbage and Refuse Collection. a. Description. Refuse collection service shall include the collection of all garbage and refuse from residential dwelling units in the City of Little Canada. Recyclables, bulky items, and yard waste shall be collected separately. Included in the cost of this service is the collection of one Christmas tree (not wrapped in a plastic bag and free of ornaments and tinsel) annually from every residential dwelling unit and three bulky items per year. Cost for this service is described in Attachment “A.” b. Exclusions. Refuse collection service shall not include the collection of: 1. Toxic and hazardous waste including items such as batteries, construction material, Comment [TB9]: ? What are you referring to, the aforementioned? Comment [TB10]: Kelly Change Comment [TB11]: Does this include paper bags? 8 motor oils, and paint in liquid form. 2. Major appliances, except as provided for in Bulky Item Pickup. 3. Tree limbs, brush and such other items, except as provided for in Yard Waste. 4. Animal waste and solid waste materials resulting from industrial, commercial, and agricultural operations, and from community activities. 5. Earthen fill, boulders, rock, and other materials normally handled in construction operations, solids or dissolved materials in domestic sewage or other significant pollutants in waste resources, such as silt, dissolved or suspended solids in industrial waste water effluent, dissolved materials in irrigation return flows; or other common water pollutants. 6. Electronics containing cathode ray tubes (CRT’s). c. Containers. All occupants of residential dwelling units in the City shall be required by ordinance to keep garbage and refuse in an approved container(s) of approximately 30, 60, or 90 gallons. Exempted are senior residents who qualify for the low volume bag rate. They may use stickered 30-gallon trash bags. d. Location. Residential dwelling units shall have, as required by t he City ordinance, their container located at the boulevard adjoining the curb on or before 7:00 a.m. on the designated day of collection. e. Frequency. Each residential dwelling unit shall have its refuse collected a minimum of once per week. f. Additional Collection Service. Refuse in excess of the designated volume-base per dwelling unit or residential dwelling units desiring collection of items from a location other than the boulevard adjoining the curb will be subject to additional collection service charges as set forth in Attachment “B.” Collection service for white goods and bulky items must have prior arrangements with the City f or collection and shall also be billed in accordance with Attachment “B”; except as provided for in Bulky Item Pickup. g. Reporting. Tonnages of refuse or garbage collected shall be reported to the City on an annual basis with said reports to be submitted by January 22nd of the following year. h. Free Pick-Up at City-Owned Properties. Waste Management of Minnesota, Inc. and Republic Republic Services, Inc. shall provide service as necessary for the collection and disposal of refuse, recyclables and yard waste from all City-owned properties, including parks and the City’s Canadian Days Celebration, at no cost to the City during the term of this Contract. This provision applies to the typical generation of waste and does not include extraordinary clean-outs. i. Disposal. The Contractor shall be responsible for the safe, legal, and environmentally sound disposal of all refuse, white goods, and any other items and materialsWaste Materials collected under this Contract. The Contractor shall dispose of all r Refuse and Ggarbage collected in Little Canada at a Refuse Derived Fuel processing facility desi gnat e d b y R amse y C ount y at which the operator has assumed all liability arising from the Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the Comment [TB12]: 96? Comment [TB13]: Week or Calendar days? Description of Services 9 Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Feasibility Act, and similar Federal and State Statutes possessing the necessary permits and operated in compliance with applicable environmental laws and regulations. Any deviation of this provision shall be considered a violation and default of this Contract. The Contractor shall maintain actual Ramsey/Washington RDF (Recycling and Energy Center – R&E Center) receipts and shall provide the City with copies of such receipts. Estimated Little Canada tonnages shall be reported to the City bi-annually. All costs associated with disposal (tipping fees) shall be based upon fees net of any rebates that the Contractor may be eligible for, regardless of when (or if) received by the Contractor. It shall be understood that the disposal rate in Exhibit A shall be based upon the lowest available tipping fee charged by the RDF facility to an entity that takes all material to the RDF facility for disposal. j. Notification. If any resident of the City places any items out for pickup and the item is not taken by the Contractor, the Contractor shall provide immediate written notification to the resident and the City of reason(s) for refusal to pick up the item. Notification must be left on the item(s) in question. Notifications left for a resident must be submitted to the City by noon on the following day after collection was refused. k. Exceptions for Handicapped and/or Disabled. The Contractor shall make reasonable exceptions as to the manner of pickup for handicapped or disabled residents. 2. Yard Waste Collection. a. Description. Yard waste collection service shall include the collection of all yard waste from participating residential dwelling units in the City of Little Canada. Cost for this service is described in Attachment “A.” b. Containers. Residential dwelling units shall have their yard waste segregated from other refuse in a container clearly identified as “Yard Waste” located at the boulevard adjoining the curb on or before 7:00 a.m. on the designated day of collection. Up to two containers of at least 90 gallon capacity will be provided by the contractor at no additional cost to the resident. Additional compostable bags and/or clearly identified containers may also be placed curbside at each pickup without limit to quantity at no additional cost. Containers should not exceed 960- gallon capacity nor weigh more than 50 pounds when filled. Bags should not be filled so as to exceed their structural capacity. c. Frequency. Yard Waste Collection Service shall be provided from April 1st through th November 30 , weather permitting each year and each residential dwelling unit shall have its yard waste collected a minimum of once per week on the same day as refuse collection service. d. Reporting. Tonnages or yards of yard waste collected shall be reported to the City on an annual basis b y January 22nd of the following year. e. Conveyance of Yard Waste. The Contractor shall be responsible for the safe, legal, and environmentally sound conveyance of all yard waste collected under this Contract. The Contractor shall convey the yard waste to a lawfully approved compost site and shall assume all liability and responsibility for materials deposited. The Contractor shall not mix other types of refuse or inorganic materials with the yard waste or take any action so as to make the yard waste material unacceptable to the operators of the compost site. Comment [TB14]: Conflicts with (g) Reporting above. Comment [TB15]: 96? Comment [TB16]: ? Comment [TB17]: Paper/Plastic defined in yard waste? Comment [TB18]: Work or Calendar week? 10 f. Notification. If any resident of the City places yard waste out for pickup and the material is not taken by the Contractor, the Contractor shall provide immediate written notification to the resident and the City of reason(s) for refusal to pick up the item. Notification must be left on the item(s) in question. Notifications left for a resident must be submitted to the City by noon on the following day after collection was refused. g. Education. It shall be the responsibility of the Contractor to assist in the education of residents on how to properly prepare yard waste. Contractor will work with City staff on a quarterly basis on a frequency as determined by the City to prepare written materials for residents. All educational materials for customers under the contract must be approved by the City prior to mailing. 3. Recycling Collection. a. Description. Recyclable collections service shall include the collection of recyclables as defined in this contract. Cost for this service is described in Attachment “A”. b. Containers. The Contractor shall supply all residential dwelling units eligible to participate in the recycling program with a single sort- recycling container on wheels, for the storage and collection of recyclable materials. The standard container for recycling under this contract will be a 60-gallon cart. Residents have the option to increase or decrease their cart size or request a second recycling cart at no additional charge for service. c. Single Sort System. Residents will be instructed to place all recyclable materials, listed in the definitions section, into the single sort container. The Contractor shall not make any changes to this single sort collection system without written approval of the City. Failure to receive City approval for any such changes to the single sort collection system shall be considered by the City as a breach of this AgreementContract subject to termination. The Contractor shall work with the City to provide necessary written educational materials on the single sort system for residents including a legible sticker placed on each container that lists approved recyclable items. d. Location. Residential dwelling units shall have their recyclables in the approved containers provided by the Contractor located at the boulevard adjoining the curb on or before 7:00 a.m. on the designated day of collection. e. Frequency. Each residential dwelling unit shall have its recyclables collected every-other week on the same day as refuse collection service. The Contractor shall provide an annual calendar to each resident by no later than December 20th that indicates the collection dates for the upcoming year. By November 30th, the hauler will provide the City with an electronic version of the annual recycling calendar which indicates the collection dates for the upcoming year. This electronic calendar will be revised to in clud e th e City lo go as well as th e City’ s co n tact in formation. The City will advertise in the newsletter and on our website that the electronic calendar is available. A printed copy of the calendar will be made available upon request by the resident. f. Reporting. Tonnages of recyclables collected shall be reported to the City on an annual basis by January 22nd of the following year. These tonnages must be reported by individual materials collected and the place where the recyclables are delivered must be Comment [TB19]: Work or Calendar week? 11 disclosed. If the tonnages are estimates, the method of estimation must also be disclosed and Contractor will do everything possible to ensure the accuracy of estimates. g. Conveyance of Recyclables. The Contractor shall be responsible for the safe, legal, and environmentally sound conveyance of all recyclables collected under this Contract. The Contractor shall convey the recyclables to a market that assures these materials will not be landfilled. The Contractor shall not mix other types of refuse or inorganic materials with the recyclables or take any action so as to make the recyclable material unacceptable to the operators of the recycling center. h. Material Preparation & Separation Requirements. The Contractor is responsible for immediately informing residential dwelling units of how to properly prepare recyclables for collection. If the Contractor fails to pick up recyclables at a residential dwelling unit because it was improperly prepared, it is the Contractor’s responsibility to immediately inform in writing the residential dwelling unit on how to properly prepare the recyclables so that they will be acceptable for pick up. The Contractor shall also inform the City of said notice when the residence has received multiple notices. Any change in material preparation and separation requirements must be approved by the City prior to implementing such change and the Contractor shall bear full responsibility for notifying residents of changes. i. Participation Study. The Contractor is responsible for once annuallyshall provide annual notice to the City between September 1st and October 31st to inform the City of households not participating in recycling. This information will be used to target households for additional education on recycling initiatives. j. Education. It shall be the responsibility of theThe Contractor to shall assist in the education of residents on what is recyclable and how to properly prepare for proper disposal. Contractor will shall work with City staff on a frequency as determined by the City to prepare written materials for residents. All educational materials for customers under the contract must be approved by the City prior to mailing. k. Notification. If any resident of the City places any items out for pickup and the item is not taken by the Contractor, the Contractor shall provide immediate written notification to the resident and the City of reason(s) for refusal to pick up the item. Notification must be left on the item(s) in question. Notifications left for a resident must be submitted to the City by noon on the following day after collection was refused. 4. Bulky Item Pickup. Each residence is allowed to dispose of up to three “bulky items” per year as defined by this contract. The Contractor shall collect, transport, dispose of, and/or process these items without additional fees or charges to the resident as specified below: a. Clarification of Count. In most cases, the counting of a bulky item will be self-evident; i.e. a refrigerator will count as one item, a couch will count as one item, and a sink will count as one item. A sectional sofa consisting of three or more pieces will count as two items. However, there are instances when a set of items shall be counted as only one item such as (2) rims with/without tires or two individual tires, and a computer and related periphery with the exception of a cathode ray tube (CRT) which is prohibited. b. Frequency of Collection. Contractor shall provide service to residents as scheduled by City. Collections shall take place on the same day of the week as the resident’s refuse pickup, Comment [TB20]: Kelly Change Comment [TB21]: Kelly Change Comment [TB22]: Kelly Change Comment [TB23]: Work or Calendar week? 12 with the exception of appliance pickup. The City will schedule appliance pickup and the pickup day shall be arranged with each respective contractor. c. Process for Collection. The resident shall contact the City directly to request pickup of the bulky item(s). The resident shall place the item curbside for pickup on the designated day for pickup as instructed by the City. d. Reporting. The City shall be responsible for instituting a system to account for the number of items picked up per residence, per year. The City shall notify the Contractor when a residence has exceeded their allotted three bulky items to enable the contractor to bill for any items beyond three pursuant to Attachment B. e. Pickup in Excess of Three Items. The pickup of any bulky items in excess of three (3) within any calendar year shall be subject to the charges as described in Attachment B. 5. Carts. Each residence is provided cart(s) as specified in the above services at no charge when the account is established. Attachment A of the contract establishes additional fees for cart service changes. Failure by the Contractor to notify the City of cart(s) b ein g “o u t of sto ck” may be subject to a fine under the Liquidated Damages portion of the contract. B. Service Schedule. 1. Hours. The Contractor shall perform all collection services between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m., on Monday through Friday, except when an emergency exists, at which time the Contractor shall notify the City of such emergency 2. Collection Days. The Contractor shall provide Day-Certain refuse, recycling, bulky item, and yard waste collection. Unless otherwise agreed to by the parties hereto, collection services will be on Wednesdays with single sort occurring every other Wednesday. a. The Contractor may r equest a change in the day of pickup by requesting such change in writing to the City at least thirty (30) days from the proposed date the requested change is to take effect. A change shall become effective only upon authorization from the City and a fourteen-day notice to the residents. b. The Contractor shall bear all costs involved in notifying residents of approved schedule changes. 3. Holidays. The Contractor will observe the following legal holidays on which their offices and operations will be closed: New Year's Day, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, and Christmas Day. When holidays fall on a Monday, Tuesday, or Wednesday, the collection shall be made one (1) working day later. 4. Authorized Pickups. Only such pickups shall be made at assigned addresses and accounts as authorized by the City pursuant to the terms of this Contract, and the Contractor shall not be entitled to payment for any pickups not authorized by this Contract. 5. Street Improvements. The City reserves the right to improve an y str eet or alley that ma y prevent the Contractor from traveling its accustomed route or routes for collection. The Contractor shall bear the responsibility for contacting the Public Works Director prior to each construction season to determine areas of conflict and possible alternate routes or solutions. The Contractor shall Comment [TB24]: Veterans Day, Presidents Day, Martin Luther King Day? 13 maintain regular service during street reconstruction project, regardless of access with no additional compensation for service modifications. 6. Administration. The Contractor shall maintain an office equipped with telephones and staffed with sufficient personnel to handle complaints, orders for special service, and/or to receive instructions from the City. a. The Contractor’s office shall be staffed from 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday (except legal holidays). b. The City and the Contractor shall follow the following administrative procedures: 1. The City shall maintain a written log of all complaints received from residents. The log will include the complaint date and the nature of the complaint. The complaints shall be forwarded no later than the following business day to the Contractor by e-mail or by phone. The Contractor will respond by e-mail or phone that the complaint has been received. If the complaint is limited to a missed pick up, no further reporting action is required of the Contractor. All other complaints must be investigated and a suggested resolution communicated to the City within 24 hours or the next business day. If suggested resolution is unsatisfactory the Contractor agrees to continue work with the City to reach a reasonable solution. 2. The City will be responsible for taking all customer service calls from Little Canada residents. This includes, but is not limited to, calls related to discontinuing/establishing disposal service, temporary stops and starts in service, changes in container sizes (including recycling), yard waste services, bulky item pick up services, appliance pick up, and any at the door pick requests and complaints. Any call taken by the Contractor for customers covered under this contract in which the customer is not referred back to the City may be subject to a fine under the Liquidated Damages portion of the contract. Liquidated damages may not be charged if the City is notified by the hauler of the call prior to any service action being taken by the hauler. 3. The City will forward by e-mail or by fax all change of service requests to the Contractor once a week. The transmission date will be such so that the service change requested can be acted upon by the Contractor during that week of service. Failure by the Contractor to schedule the weekly service change(s) may result in a fine under the Liquidated Damages portion of the contract. An instance will be each change that is not scheduled accordingly. 4. The Contractor shall keep complete and accurate records in accordance with generally accepted accounting principals. Said records shall be available for the City’s inspection with reasonable notice in order that the City can ensure compliance with relevant contract terms and conditions. 5. The Contractor is responsible for providing the City with a contact(s) person(s)to handle all daily communications. This contact person needs to be available to respond on th e sam e busi ness da y within a reasonable amount of time during the Contractor office hours. 6. The Contractor shall provide notice to the City of any change of ownership of the Contractor, and the Contractor shall provide the City with an affirmative undertaking regarding this Contract by the buyer of the Company. Comment [TB25]: Kelly Change Comment [TB26]: Kelly Change 14 C. Performance Standards. The Contractor shall supply all labor, material, and equipment necessary for the carrying out of this Contract. 1. Equipment a. Vehicle Protection. All trucks or motor vehicles used by the Contractor shall be water-tight so as not to allow the leakage of liquids or refuse while hauling the same and shall be covered to prevent the scattering of its contents upon the public streets or private properties in the City. Should any garbage be dropped or spilled in collection or transporting, it shall be immediately cleaned up. A broom and shovel shall be carried on each vehicle at all times for this purpose. b. Cleaning. All vehicles shall be kept in a clean and sanitary condition. c. Painting. The packer body shall be painted and numbered, and shall have the Contractor's name and telephone number painted in letters of a contrasting color, at least three inches (3") high, on each side of the vehicle and the number painted or a decal placed on the rear. d. Maintenance. The trucks shall be maintained in good working order. They shall be equipped to meet all federal, state, and municipal regulations concerning vehicles used on public roads and maintained to meet these standards. e. Vehicle Inspection. All vehicles used in the performance of this Contract shall be made available for inspection at least once each year. However, if a vehicle has been inspected and approved by another city or governmental agency within the previous twelve (12) months, no additional inspection shall be required. f. Description of Vehicles. The Contractor shall furnish the City with a written description of all vehicles and equipment to be used within the City of Little Canada and in the performance of this Contract. The Contractor shall advise the City in writing of any withdrawal of a part of such equipment or of any change therein within one (1) week of the time of making such change. g. Safety Equipment. Each collection vehicle shall have a flashing light warning system, fire extinguisher (CO2 type), proper backup alarms as approved by the City, and otherwise shall comply with all State and Federal inspections and safety requirements. 2. Personnel Requirements. a. Responsibility. 1. There shall be no limitation on the size of the Contractor's collection crew, so long as they are sufficient to fulfill the requirements of the specifications and Contract. 2. Each collection crew shall adhere to all applicable Ordinances of the City of Little Canada, and all of those rules, regulations, and conditions for refuse collection as established by the City. 15 b. Driver. 1. The Contractor’s personnel shall comply with all applicable laws including driving and traffic laws, relating to its performance of services under this AgreementContract. Contractor’s personnel shall comply with all Federal regulations found in Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) at 49 CFR, Part 382 as it pertains to drug and alcohol testing. Upon request, Contractor shall supply City with any results of its drug and alcohol testing program. 2. The driver must have a valid Minnesota License with proper classification and endorsements. 3. The driver must adhere to all traffic laws. c. Collector. 1. The driver and collector(s) shall at all times have a courteous attitude toward the general public. 2. The driver and collector(s) shall be of sound character, competent, and sober throughout the entire workday. 3. The driver and collector(s) shall have the ability to remember the order of collection and location of all containers on the assigned routes. 4. The driver and collector(s) shall make a concerted effort to have at all times a presentable appearance. 5. The collector(s) on each crew shall be physically able to perform their duties and be at least eighteen (18) years old. 6. The collector(s) shall perform their work in a neat and quiet manner and clean up all refuse, yard waste or recyclables spilled in collection under any circumstance. 7. All containers shall be replaced on the boulevard adjoining the curb. 8. Damage to containers or other property shall be avoided. 9. Gratuities shall not be accepted. 10. Consumption of any beverages containing alcohol or controlled substances shall be forbidden during or before work hours of any collection day. 11. Before the start of each collection day, the collection crew shall check to see that the collection vehicle is equipped with at least one broom and shovel for use in cleaning up refuse, yard waste, or recyclables spilled during collection or hauling. 16 3. Liquidated Damages. The Contractor agrees, in addition to any other remedies available to the City, the City may fine the an individual Contractor in the amounts specified below as liquidated damages for failure of the Contractor Contractor to fulfill its obligations (fo r the pu rpo ses o f th is section , the “Vio latin g Con tracto r”) . The City will notify the Contractor Violating Contractor in writing documenting the nature of the violation, the history of the account, if any, and the reason for the fine. The Violating Contractor shall then have the opportunity to address and remed y the issue at which point the City shall determine if a fine is still appropriate, in their sole determination. The Violating Contractor shall notify City in writing of its remedy. a. Failure to clean up solid waste spilled by Violating Contractor within six (6) hours of oral or written notification - $50.00 each instance. b. Failure to maintain vehicle in a manner, which prevents nuisances such as leaky seals or hydraulics - $100.00 each instance. c. Failure or neglect to collect solid waste, recycling, (or yard waste, or /bulky items at those times provided by the Agreement Contract within 24-hours after either oral or written notice by City - $50.00 each instance. In the case of failure to collect, an instance shall be each residence missed. d. Failure to correct any missed pickup for refuse, recycling, yard waste or bulky item on the agreed upon schedule for resolution between the City and Contractor - $100.00 per instance per day until item is collected. An instance shall be each residence not remedied in that timeframe. e. Failure or neglect to provide notice to resident upon solid waste, recyclable, yard waste or bulky items refused for collection for cause - $25.00 each instance. f. Failure to provide, exchange, or replace a cart on the date as scheduled by the City - $50.00 per day until completed. g. In addition to above, failure or neglect to correct chronic problems will be considered a Breach of Contract - $500.00 each instance. The City prior to assessing liquidated damages under this provision will provided the hauler with notification of what problems have occurred and how future violations will be considered chronic. h. Failure to abide by the City’s regular collection hours - $250.00 each instance. Failure to collect recyclables, which are properly prepared and placed for collection as part of the collection program - $25.00 each instance. i. Missing entire blocks/neighborhoods. A missed block is defined as a block where residents from at least three (3) households within two intersections of that block or cul-de-sac report that their material was out before 7:00 a.m., the material was not picked up and the addresses did not appear on the records as unacceptable setouts - $250.00 each instance. j. District-wide collection not completed. The failure to complete a majority (50% or more) of pickups within the city or collection district on the scheduled collection day without following proper notification procedure - $2,500.00 per instance. k. The City shall impose a $250 charge per instance against the Violating Contractor payable 17 to the City for prohibited mailings or any mailing which occurs prior to City approval of materials that are sent to residential dwelling units covered under this contract. The Contractor is also responsible to give written notice to those residents within thirty (30) days as to the error and reason for the prohibited mailing. The Contractor shall bear full responsibility and expenses incurred for notifying residents of the prohibited mailing. l. k.. The City shall impose a $2,500 charge per billing cycle should the Violating Contractor fail to notify the City, within 30 days of a reduction in tipping fees as required by this agreementContract. In addition to this charge, the Contractor shall also make a refund to the City in the next billing cycle of any amount overcharged. m. Violating Contractor’s failure to forward an account service call to the Cit y for processing - $50.00 per instance. n. Violating Contractor’s direct billing of Little Canada residents covered by this organized collection contract - $250.00 per instance. o. Violating Contractor’s failure to notify the City of carts not being available “out of stock” for delivery - $100.00 per instance. p. Failure by the Contractor to schedule the Weekl y Service Changes - $250.00 per instance. 4. Legal Compliance. a. This Contract is governed in all respects by the laws of the State of Minnesota, and all obligations are enforceable in accordance therewith; and the Contractor, where required, must obtain all licenses or permits to transact a refuse collection business in the City of Little Canada, Ramsey County, and the State of Minnesota. b. The Contractor will acquaint itself with all pertinent City Ordinances and shall comply with all health rules, regulations, and Ordinances of the City of Little Canada, Ramsey County, and the State of Minnesota in effect at this time of this contract or hereafter adopted. In the event, there is a conflict between the provisions of this contract and the pertinent ordinances, regulations, and statutes the more stringent requirements shall apply. c. The Contractor shall report all violations of ordinances pertaining to garbage and refuse collection and disposal for enforcement purposes including all unsanitary or filthy conditions to the City. 5. Safety. The Contractor shall provide and maintain all sanitary and safety accommodations for the use and protection of its employees as may be necessary to provide for their health and welfare and comply with federal, state, and local codes and regulations, as well as those of other bodies and tribunals having jurisdiction. Employee safety and sanitation facility regulations are set forth in Minnesota Statutes 182 and in the Department of Labor and Industry's Labor Safety Code (LISC 73- 75). 18 D. Compensation. 1. Base Compensation. City and Contractor shall on a monthly basis, verify the number of households at each level of collection service and the additional billable serviced provided during the month. The verification procedure will use the prior month’s ending service counts adjusted by the weekl y change reports submitted by the City plus the current month’s cumulative additional services requested through the weekly change reports, with the exception of Senior Bag Rate service pick- ups that must be accounted for by the Contractor and reported to the City in the monthly billing. The Contractor shall submit a summarized monthly bill by service level charges and a listing of other additional charges for services. A detailed report of all residences with billed services will also be submitted in support of the summarized billing. The billing documents should be submitted to the City on or before the 7th day of each month. The City will pay the Contractor within 30 days of receipt of the invoice as long as the billing is in sufficient form that the City is able to satisfactorily verify the amount due. This practice will be followed each month during the term of this contract. The City shall be responsible for the billing of individual residences for services provided and for the collection of said billings. The City shall provide the hauler Contractor with an electronic detailed report (Excel spreadsheet format) of all residences with billed services to the Contractor (between Januar y 1st to January 15th) each calendar year in order for the Contractor to verify charge for services. The hauler Contractor has 7 days to respond with any changes to the detailed report which will be reviewed for approval by the City. The City will then submit a summary report of services and changes which impact that billing period before the 7th day of each month. The hauler Contractor has 7 days to review summary billing and changes and inform the City if billed services are satisfactory. Upon notification by the Contractor said billing is accurate;, the City will reimburse the Contractor the billed services within 30 days. This practice will be followed each month during the term of this contract. The City shall be responsible for the billing of individual residences for services provided and for the collection of said billings. An y billing by the Contractor to residences covered under this contract for services will be subject to a fine under the Liquidated Damages section of this contract. 2. Disposal Fees. The Contractor shall pay all disposal fees resulting from the collections of Little Canada refuse, yard waste, bulky items, and recyclables. 3. Fuel Surcharge Fee. The Contractor shall be eligible for a fuel surcharge fee beginning January 1, 20172. Said fee shall be calculated based on Attachment C. The City shall determine the imposition of said fee pursuant to the terms of this agreement Contract and by referencing the Department of Energy’s Midwest Average for #2 Diesel Fuel for the week preceding the end of the quarter in question upon notice from the Contractor by the 10th of the month following the completion of a prescribed quarterly period that fuel prices have triggered the imposition of said fee. Once imposed, the City will include this fee in the next billing to residents. The fuel surcharge shall be adjusted on a quarterly basis for the following quarters ending on December 31st, March 31st, June 30th, and September 30th of each year. Failure to provide proper notice of the application of the fuel surcharge within the prescribed timeframe will negate application of that fee for the City’s billing quarter. Comment [TB27]: Kelly Change Comment [TB28]: Kelly Change Comment [TB29]: Kelly Change 19 4. Additional Collection Services. Charges for pickup of additional items and for additional service shall be made directly to the resident owner by the City at the prices stated in Attachment “B” hereto. Said prices shall be subject to change from time to time by the Contractor based on changes in disposal costs and subject to City approval. Contractor will need to include the charges for additional collection in the monthly bill detail. Charges for additional services shall be billed in the month the service is provided. 5. Unmarketable Recyclables. The Contractor shall receive one hundred (100%) percent of the gross proceeds from the sale of recyclables. In the event the Contractor and the City determine that recyclables cannot be sold or given away, the Contractor shall bear all costs associated with disposal. 6. Bulky Item Increase. If the rate for disposal for bulky items increases to a point in which the haulers feel an increase is warranted during the term of this contract, it shall be agreed that the City and hauler will meet to discuss a potential increase to the bulky item collection rate and/or Schedule B. 7. Taxes (Environmental Services, Disposal, and Sales, if any). The City will retain the responsibilit y for billing all appropriate taxes associated with services provided for under this contract. Furthermore, the City will be responsible for remitting all the taxes billed to the proper taxing agencies in compliance with reporting and filing requirements. V. INSURANCE, BOND & INDEMNIFICATION. The Contractor shall be licensed and bonded as required by Little Canada City Ordinances. The Contractor further agrees to take all precautions to protect the public against injury. The Contractor, each of them individually (“In d emn if yin g Con tracto r”), shall indemnify and hold harmless the City, its officers, agents, representatives, and employees from and against all damages, claims, losses, costs or expenses including reasonable attorneys' fees, which may be asserted against the City, or for which it may be held liable, to the extent resulting from any acts, omissions, or negligence of the Indemnifying Contractor, Indemnifying Contractor's agent or employees while engaged in the performance of this Contract and of damages that may arise by reason of any negligence of the Indemnifying Contractor or the Indemnifying Contractor's agents, or employees while engaged in the performance of this Contract. The Contractor will indemnify the City against all claims, liens, expenses, and claims for liens, for work, tools, machinery, materials, or insurance premiums or equipment or supplies, and against all loss by reason of the failure of the Contractor in any respect to fully perform all obligations of this Contract, including reasonable attorneys' fees. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary set forth in this Contract or otherwise, no individual Contractor shall have an obligation to (a) indemnify, defend or hold harmless the City, or any other parties indemnified under this Contract, for any such liability or claim to the extent resulting from the negligence or, willful misconduct by the City, any third party or any other parties indemnified under this Contract, or (b) indemnify, defend or hold harmless another Contractor for any such liability or claim to the extent resulting from the acts, omissions or negligence of the other Contractor. In other words, each Contractor is only liable to the extent the damages, claims, losses, costs or expenses resulted from its o wn o r its emp lo yees’ own acts, omissions or negligence. Insurance Limits. During the entire period of the contract, the Contractor shall maintain, at their expense, and file with the City, policies or certificates of Worker's Compensation, Auto Liability, and General Liability insurance. Minimum Liability Insurance coverage requirements are $1,000,000.00 bodily injury per person, 20 $2,000,000.00 aggregate per occurrence, and $1,000,000.00 property damage. All liability policies evidencing insurance required by t his paragraph shall name Cit y and the Contractor as named additional insured (other than workers’ compensation ). Such policies shall be in the form and context satisfactory with the City Attorney and shall be filed with the City Administrator. A certificate showing that the Contractor has in effect the aforesaid insurance covering both the City and the Contractor shall also be provided to the City. VI. NONDISCRIMINATION. The Contractor agrees that, during the life of this Contract, the Contractor will not, within the State of Minnesota, discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, color, creed, national origin, or ancestry, and will include a similar provision in all subcontracts entered into for the performance thereof. This Contract may be cancelled or terminated by the City and all money due or to become due hereunder may be forfeited for a second or subsequent violation of the terms and conditions of this paragraph. This paragraph is inserted in this Contract to comply with the provisions of Minnesota Statutes, Section 181.59. VII. TRANSFER, ASSIGNMENT, AND LIENS. A. Transfer or Sale. The Contractor ma y sell, assign, convey, lease, or transfer all or part of this Contract with the City’s prior written approval. The City shall be entitled to require, except as otherwise provided in this Contract, as conditions to any such approval that: 1. Any proposed transferee shall have the qualifications and financial responsibility reasonably determined by the City, necessary and adequate to fulfill the obligations undertaken in this Contract by Contractor; and 2. The transfer does not create an anti-trust situation in the local refuse hauling industry that is contrary to the public interest of the residents of Little Canada; and 3. Any proposed transferee, by instrument in writing satisfactory to the City for itself and their successors and assigns, and expressly for the benefit of the City, have expressly assumed all of the obligations of service under this Contract and agreed to be subject to all the conditions and restrictions to which service is subject. It is the intent of this Section, together with other provisions of this Contract, that (to the fullest extent permitted by law and equity and excepting only in the manner and to the extent specifically provided otherwise in this Contract) no transfer of, or change with respect to, ownership or any part thereof, or any interest therein, however, consummated or occurring, whether voluntary or involuntary, shall operate, legally or practically, to deprive or limit the City of or with respect to any rights or remedies or controls provided in or resulting from this Contract; and 4. To the extent the Contractor is able without violating confidentiality provisions or applicable law, Tthere shall be submitted to the City for review all instruments and other legal documents involved in affecting such transfer, and if approved b y the City, its approval shall be indicated to the Contractor in writing. The proposed transferee shall submit to the City for review all bonds, insurance policies, and any and all other documents required by this Contract, and if approved by the City, its approval shall be indicated to the proposed transferee in writing. B. Payment of Subcontractor and Employees. The Contractor agrees to promptly pay all persons doing work or furnishing skills, tools, machinery, or materials or insurance premiums or equipment or supplies and all just claims for such work, material, equipment insurance, and supplies in and above the performance of this Contract. VIII. OTHER PROVISIONS. 21 A. Title. Title to all refuse, yard waste and recyclables Waste Material collected shall remain vested in the Contractor until all said solid waste is delivered to the authorized processing plant, recycling center, or yard waste site. Title to and liability for any Unacceptable Waste shall at no time pass to Contractor. B. Severability. All parts and provisions of this Contract are severable. If any part or provision shall be held invalid, the remainder of this Contract shall remain in effect. C. Independent Contractors. The Contractor is declared to be an independent contractor, and nothing in this Contract shall be construed to create the relationship of employer and employee between the Cit y and the Contractor or its agents, or make the Contractor, its agents, or employees, subject to City Personnel Rules. D. Force Majeure. Except for th e Cit y’ s obligation to pay amounts due to contractor, any failu re or d ela y in p erfo rman ce du e to con tingen cies b eyo n d a p art y’ s reas on ab le con tro l , including strikes, riots, terrorist acts, compliance with applicable laws or governmental orders, fires, inclement weather and acts of God (“Fo rce Maj eu re Even t”), shall not constitute a breach of this Contract. Contractor shall not be liable for liquidated damages under section IV.C.3 for failure to perform as a result of a Force Majeure Event. IX. NOTICES. Except as otherwise herein, provided, all notices required to be served by either party on the other shall be in writing and forwarded by certified mail to the principal office of the party to which notice is given, as follows: To the City of Little Canada: City of Little Canada 515 Little Canada Road Little Canada, MN 55117 To the Contractor: Republic Services, Inc. 4325 E. 66th Street Inver Grove Heights, MN 55076 Waste Management of MN, Inc. 10050 Naples St. NE Blaine, MN 55449 Gene's Disposal 5661- 152nd Street North Hugo, MN. 55038 All such notices shall be effective when received. 22 X. TERMINATION. A. The City shall have the right to terminate this Contract, as pertaining to each individual hauler, if in the City's reasonable judgment there has been a breach of any material provision thereof by the haulerContractor(“Breaching Hauler”), or if in the City's reasonable judgment there is other good cause for termination. Continuing breach or good cause shall not be deemed waived because it was followed by prompted termination. B. Upon failure of the Breaching Hauler Contractor to fulfill any of the provisions of this contract, the City shall be authorized to hire such personnel and equipment, or assign City employees and equipment, as may be necessary to do such work, and the cost of such expenses thereof ma y be charged and deducted from any monies due the the Breaching ContractorHauler, collected from the Breaching Contractor Hauler, for collected by recourse to the Breaching Contractors Hau ler’ s financial guaranty. C. Notwithstanding the foregoing paragraphs, the no Contractor hauler shall will not be considered in breach and the City will have no right to terminate the agreementContract unless Contractor the hauler fails to cure said breach or failure to perform within thirty (30) days of receipt by the Contractor hauler of written notice from the City. The breach or failure must be cured to the satisfaction of the City Administrator. D. The City shall also have the right to terminate the contract at any time, subject to ninety (90) days written notice to the Contractor, should Ramsey County undertake an organized collection program and if the City determines at its sole discretion, it would be in the City’s best interest to utilize said County programs. E. Any individual Contractor shall have the right to suspend or terminate this Contract, if the City is in material breach and has failed to cure such breach within 30 days of receipt by the City of written notice of the breach. XI. ENTIRE AGREEMENT. This Contract with Attachments “A”, “B”, and “C” incorporated herein by reference is the entire agreement between the parties. No modification of this Contract shall be valid or effective, unless made in writing and signed by the parties hereto: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have set their hands on the day of 20167. CITY OF LITTLE CANADA By John Keis, Mayor By Joel R. Hanson, City Administrator Comment [TB30]: Contractor? 23 CONTRACTORS By Republic Services of the Twin Cities REPUBLIC SERVICES, INC. Bryan Zimmerman, Area President Jeff Marone, General Manager By Gene’s Disposal Gene Wegleitner Jr., President By Waste Management of MN, Inc. Michael E. Fleming, Vice President Thomas Beaulieu, Area Vice President 24