Laserfiche WebLink
SCVACFC Site Selection Task Force August 18, 2006 <br />Page 17 <br />As is shown, the weighting values shift the totals for the sites, sometimes substantially. In <br />reviewing the weighting totals and the criteria, it is our opinion that the current value ranges and <br />weighting criteria reflect the characteristics of the sites based on the perceived value of the <br />criteria. <br />Conciusimn <br />The revised weighting assessment ranks the individual sites from highest to lowest as follows: <br />1=Lake Elmo Site <br />2=Oak Park Station Site <br />3=Xcel Fly Ash Site (nearly tied with Oak Park Station) <br />4=Bergman Property <br />S=Bayport Sites <br />6=Nass Buberal Properties <br />7=Neal Avenue Property <br />In addition to the numerical totals assigned to each of the sites, additional qualitative criteria <br />were noted but not entered into the weighting. Questions were asked of owners/contacts for each <br />of the sites identifying if any environmental issues were known and the extent of those <br />issues/impacts. <br />Other than the Xcel Fly Ash site, the Buberal portion of the Nass-Buberal properties is the only <br />property that is known to potentially have environmental issues. In further considering the Xcel <br />Fly Ash or Nass-Buberal sites, further detailed analysis and environmental assessments must be <br />undertaken to identify the scope of potential clean-up actions on the Nass-Buberal sites or the <br />potential future responsibilities for environmental issues that may remain with a tenant operating <br />on the Xcel Fly Ash site. In fact, all sites are likely to require additional due diligence to ensure <br />that all existing site conditions are fully understood and analyzed. <br />MAXFIELD RESEARCH INC. <br />