HomeMy WebLinkAbout#03 - Open Space PUD1
Error! Unknown document property name.
STAFF REPORT
DATE: 6/11/2024
Item#: 02
Workshop
TO: City Council
FROM: Jason Stopa, Community Development Director
Ashley Monterusso, Planning Assistant
AGENDA ITEM: Zoning Text Amendment – OP-PUD
REVIEWED BY: Nathan Fuerst, Bolton and Menk Planning Consultant
Sophia Jensen, City Planner
Jack Griffin, Focus Engineering
Marty Powers, Public Works Director
BACKGROUND:
Reviewing the Open Space Planned Unit Development (OP-PUD) Ordinance is an item on
Planning Commission’s 2024 work plan. After reviewing recent concept plan applications,
discussing challenges with developers, and reviewing the language with Engineering and Public
Works, staff have identified several areas of the ordinance that could be corrected, updated, and
clarified. Staff are proposing a general cleanup of the ordinance along with new standards for
consideration.
ISSUE BEFORE COUNCIL:
The City Council is being asked to consider the proposed language and amendments and give staff
guidance on the proposed OP-PUD standards changes.
PROPOSAL DETAILS:
City Zoning Code Sections under review:
• 1.08.010 (General Provisions - Terms Defined)
• 105.12.1120 (Zoning Code – Planned Unit Development Regulations)
• 105.12.980-105.12.1110 (Zoning Code – Open Space Planned Unit Developments)
REVIEW AND ANALYSIS
See attached.
1. 1.08.010 (General Provisions - Terms Defined)
• Staff is proposing adding a definition for “open space area” as referenced in
105.12.1050 (7)(a) under Open Space and park land adjustments. While open space
is defined, there currently is not a definition for “open space area” or “cluster
development” in the city code. Adding definitions is suggested to give clarity to the
section since the developer is required to calculate the open space area.
• Proposed definitions:
Open space area means the measurement of all undeveloped land and natural
features within a subdivision or planned unit development. Trails outside of the
2
Error! Unknown document property name.
road rights-of-way and agricultural buildings are included in the open space area.
Road rights-of-way and buildable lots are not considered open space area.
2. 105.12.980-105.12.1110 (OPEN SPACE PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENTS)
A. Add clarity to primary uses and setbacks for accessory use - 105.12.1040
• Staff identified confusing language around single-family attached and
setbacks within the OP-PUD for accessory structures. The language
combines single-family attached and townhouses. The added language and
accompanying table reduce setbacks since the lot area requirements are
reduced. Rural Residential requires a 10-acre minimum lot size. Adding new
language to the sections is intended to offer clarity.
B. Update Open Space PUD Design Standards - 105.12.1050
1. Density.
• Staff are suggesting increasing the density from .45 units per acre to .8
units per acre. The reason for increasing density is two-fold. First, the
existing density is based on 1 acre lots and many of the developments
are less than 1 acre with a communal drain field. Secondly, increasing
density should make development in Lake Elmo more economically
competitive.
2. Density bonus.
• Staff are also proposing a 10% density bonus for sites with considerable
wetlands or natural area or stormwater reuse for irrigation. Currently
there is a 20% density bonus for similar sites outlined in the standard
PUD section. For clarity, this bonus is outlined in the OP-PUD section
of code. The reduction in percentage from 20% to 10% is based on the
newly proposed increase to the base density.
3. Septic design identification.
• Based on feedback from the city engineer, staff have added low pressure
sewer guidance to sites proposing communal drain field.
4. Identification of required buffers.
Staff are proposing amending the language in this section for conciseness
and clarity.
5. Placement of streets.
• Based on feedback from the city engineer, staff added clarifying
language to permit 28-foot-wide streets with parking on one side of the
road. This language is meant to add flexibility for developers while
maintaining high design standards and connectivity for the city.
6. Lot creation.
• Staff is suggesting that single-family lots that are served by individual
septic tanks, utilizing communal drain fields, decrease in size from
21,780 square feet to 16,000 square feet. Staff also propose a 100’
minimum lot width and a 160’ minimum lot depth. These changes are
meant to encourage development, while preserving natural land.
• Lots designed with rear-loaded parking through a secondary access
(alley), may reduce the required front lot width to 80’. These changes
are meant to encourage development, while preserving more open space
area. Additionally, this can be more space-efficient and environmentally
friendly compared to each lot having a separate drain field.
C. Update Open Space PUD Development Standards – 105.12.1060
3
Error! Unknown document property name.
1. Building standards.
• Staff are proposing adding an attached garage standard to be more
consistent with the city’s design standards. Staff are proposing that the
width of the garage shall not exceed 40 percent of the width of the entire
building façade that is fronting the primary street.
2. Impervious surface standards.
• Impervious surface is based on a percentage of the lot area not the entire
development.
3. Trail and sidewalk standards.
• Staff is proposing adding “sidewalk” to this section of code to
encourage both trails and sidewalks in Open Space PUDs. Adding
sidewalks to this section allows developers to choose a combination of
trails and/or sidewalks for their project.
• Staff propose changing language in this code to encourage that
sidewalks be constructed along the lot frontage on one side of the road.
• Staff also propose additional language to encourage trail connections to
other developments and public places.
o There is flexibility in the language in this area of code to require
more than the sum of the centerline length of all public roads in
the development at the discretion of the community development
director or the city engineer.
D. Update Open Space PUD Review Procedure, 105.12.1080
• Staff are proposing cleaning up language in this section for consistency.
See attached language.
E. 105.12.980-105.12.1110
• Staff is proposing updates for all mentions of “planning director” to
“community development director”.
4. 105.12.1120 (Zoning Code – Planned Unit Development Regulations)
Add clarification to the intent of Planned Unit Developments. It specifies
differences between standard and OP PUDs. See attached for proposed
update.
FISCAL IMPACT:
None.
NEXT STEPS:
• Public hearing at Planning Commission meeting on 6/24/2024
• City Council recommendation 7/16/2024
ATTACHMENTS:
• Draft ordinance language with existing language
Red underlined text is new language. Strikethrough text is removed existing language.
Blue text edits are changes from the last workshop.
DEFINITIONS
New
1.08.010 Terms Defined
Open space area means the measurement of all undeveloped land and natural features
within a subdivision or planned unit development. Trails outside of the road rights-of-way
and agricultural buildings are included in the open space area. Road rights-of-way and
buildable lots are not considered open space areas.
Cluster development means a pattern of subdivision development which places dwelling
units into compact groupings while providing a network of commonly owned or dedicated
open space. Lots within a cluster development typically do not meet minimum lot width
and area requirements.
105.12.980 Purpose
The purpose of open space planned unit developments is to provide greater development
flexibility within rural portions of the community while maintaining the rural character by
preserving agricultural land, woodlands, wildlife or natural corridors, pollinator and
wildlife habitat, and other significant natural features consistent with the goals and
objectives of the city's comprehensive plan. The city reserves the right to deny
establishment of an open space PUD overlay district and direct a developer to re-apply
under standard zoning provisions if it is determined that proposed benefits of the open
space PUD do not justify the requested flexibilities.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.990 Intent
It is the intent of the city that open space planned unit developments will offer needed
development flexibility within the agricultural, rural residential, and rural estate zoning
districts to provide for:
A. A variety of lot configurations and housing styles that may not otherwise exist
within the city's rural areas;
B. An avenue to provide a development density equal to or greater than what could be
achieved via underlying zoning;
C. A reduction in the costs to construct and maintain public facilities and
infrastructure in a rural setting;
D. Protected open space to enhance and preserve the natural character of the
community;
E. The creation of distinct neighborhoods that are interconnected within rural areas;
F. To preserve large contiguous open spaces.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1000 Definitions
Unless specifically defined in LEC 105.12, art. II, common definitions, words, and phrases
used in this article shall be interpreted so as to give them the same meaning as they have
in common usage throughout this Code and as may be found in LEC 1.08.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1010 Initiation Of Proceedings
The owner of property on which an open space PUD is proposed shall file the applicable
application for a PUD by paying the fees set forth in LEC 1.12.010 and submitting a completed
application form and supporting documents as set forth on the application form and within
this section. Complete applications shall be reviewed by city commissions as deemed
necessary by the director of planning community development director and be acted upon
by the city council. If a proposed open space PUD is denied, any subsequent application for
a substantially similar PUD within one year of the date of denial shall fully address all
findings which supported the denial prior to being accepted as complete.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1020 Reflection On The Official Zoning Map
A. PUD provisions provide an optional method of regulating land use which permits
flexibility from standard regulating provisions. Establishment of a PUD shall require
adoption of an ordinance creating an overlay zoning district atop the boundaries of
the development area. For each PUD district, a specific ordinance shall be adopted
establishing all rules which shall supersede underlying zoning. Issues not
specifically addressed by the PUD overlay district shall be governed by the
underlying zoning district regulations.
B. All open space preservation developments approved prior to October 4, 2016 shall be
allowed to continue per the original conditions of approval.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1030 Prerequisites For Open Space PUDs
A. Only land zoned as agricultural, rural residential, or rural estate may be considered
for establishment of an open space planned unit development.
B. The minimum land area for establishment of an open space planned unit
development is a nominal contiguous 20 acres.
C. Establishment of an open space planned unit development will be considered only
for areas of land in single ownership or control. Alternatively, multiple party
ownership, in the sole discretion of the city, is acceptable when legally sufficient
written consent from all persons and entities with ownership interest is provided at
the time of application.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1040 Uses Within Open Space PUDs
A. Primary uses.
1. Permitted.
a. Single-family, detached;
b. Preserved open space;
c. Conservation easements;
d. Agriculture;
e. Suburban farms;
f. Private stables;
g. Single-family, attached and Townhouses (no more than 25 percent in
any development);
h. Townhouses (no more than 25 percent in any development);
h. Wayside stand; and
i. Public parks and trails.
2. Conditionally permitted. None.
3. Interim permitted. None.
B. Accessory uses.
1. Permitted. Uses deemed by the director of planning community development
director to be typically accessory to an established permitted use on the
property as listed in subsection (a)(1) of this section. Setbacks are established
in LEC 105.12.1050 subsection (b)(6) and other standards shall conform with
the requirements in LEC 105.12.660-690.
2. Conditionally permitted. None.
3. Interim permitted. None.
C. Prohibited uses. All other uses not listed in subsection (a) or (b) of this section are
hereby prohibited.
D. Use restrictions and allowances. The final PUD overlay district ordinance for an
open space PUD may include specific provisions governing uses which supersede
underlying zoning and the general PUD regulations herein.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1050 Open Space PUD Design
Open space PUDs shall comply with all of the following minimum design standards unless
modifications are authorized for consideration by the city council via a super-majority vote.
For applying development standards, projects within an Open Space PUD shall be
considered either a traditional or a cluster development. By default, a project shall be
considered a traditional development. If 10 percent of the single-family lots within the
proposed project do not meet the standards for a traditional development, the project shall
be determined to be a cluster development. Cluster developments shall be located south of
the Union Pacific RR line.
A. Density. The maximum dwelling unit density within an open space planned unit
development shall be 18 32 units per 40 acres of buildable land (0.45 0.8 dwelling
units/acre) on the undeveloped parcel; however, the total number of dwelling units
shall not exceed the density limitations contained in the comprehensive plan for
open space preservation development. A 10% density bonus can be granted for sites
with considerable wetlands or natural areas that reduce the buildable area or
inclusion of stormwater reuse for irrigation. The maximum dwelling unit density
within an open space planned unit development, in a Rural Single Family (RSF)
future land use area, shall be 1 dwelling unit/acre.
B. Lot design. Lot locations and configurations within open space planned unit
developments shall be derived utilizing the following methodology. An applicant
must be able to demonstrate how these steps resulted in the plan being proposed.
1. Soils analysis conducted. A certified septic designer or soils scientist shall
complete a review of the soils on the site, and categorize all areas as highly
suitable for septic systems, moderately suitable for septic systems, or poorly
suited for septic systems.
2. Septic design identification. Based on the soils analysis, an applicant must
identify whether the proposed development will be serviced by individual
septic tanks and drain fields, or via a system of individual septic tanks which
utilize one or more communal drain fields.
a. If individual septic tanks and drain fields can be supported by the
available soils and is the chosen methodology to serve the
development, all proposed lots must be able to provide primary and
secondary drain field sites on each lot (outside of drainage and utility
easements), and must meet the minimum lot size standards outlined
herein.
b. If individual septic tanks which utilize a communal drain field (or
fields) is the chosen methodology to serve the development, then the
locations for communal drain fields shall be identified within the
areas deemed the most suitable on the site for supporting septic
utilities according to the soils analysis. All such areas shall be clearly
denoted on provided plan sets.
c. Low pressure sewer should only be allowed in special circumstances
as deemed necessary by the city engineer. When low pressure sewer
is deemed necessary by the city engineer, it must be installed outside
of the street pavement such that street excavation is not required for
repairs or replacement.
3. Identification of required buffers. No build zones from each property
boundary shall be derived as follows: A no build zone (buffer) between the
proposed buildable lots and the PUD boundary shall be derived as follows:
a. A 100-foot buffer from all adjacent property lines; and
b. A 200-foot buffer from all existing residential dwellings within an
abutting residential development.
c. A 200-foot buffer from all adjacent property lines that abut an existing
residential development or a parcel of land not eligible for future
development as an open space planned unit development due to
insufficient parcel area.
d. A 100-foot buffer from all adjacent property lines that abut land that is
eligible for future development as an open space planned unit
development.
e. If the development site is adjacent to an existing or approved OP
development, the required buffer shall be equivalent to the buffer that
was required of the adjacent development (See LEC 105.12.170(b)).
4. Identification of preferred building pad locations. Building pad locations, up
to the maximum number of units permitted by LEC 105.12.1050(a), which
preserve natural topography and drainageways, minimize tree loss, protect
historic sites or structures, and limit the need for soil removal and/or grading
shall then be identified. The orientation of individual building sites shall
maintain maximum natural topography and ground cover.
a. Building pads shall be located outside of required buffers, and shall be
sited so as to provide ample room for accessory structures on each
proposed lot.
b. If individual septic tanks and drain fields for each lot are to be utilized,
locations for primary and secondary facilities for each proposed
building pad shall also be identified. All such sites must be verified as
being viable as a component of PUD preliminary plan review.
c. If individual septic tanks utilizing communal drain fields is intended,
the plan must clearly identify which communal drain field will
service each of the proposed building pads.
5. Placement of streets.
a. Streets shall then be designed and located in such a manner as to:
1) Maintain and preserve natural topography, groundcover,
significant landmarks, and trees;
2) Minimize cut and fill;
3) Preserve and enhance both internal and external views and
vistas;
4) Promote road safety;
5) Ensure adequate access for fire and rescue vehicles; and
6) Ensure and promote adequate vehicular circulation both
within the development and with adjacent neighborhoods.
b. The design of streets and the dedication of right-of-way shall be in
compliance with the city's current engineering design standards and
specifications as may be amended. 28-foot-wide streets with parking
on one side are permitted.
c. Streets shall not encroach into a required buffer area unless it can be
demonstrated that such an alignment is necessary to achieve the
goals outlined above, and that no equivalent option exists outside of
the buffer. Driving surfaces that cross the buffer area at a 90 degree
angle to provide current or future access to an adjacent property or
boundary road shall be the only exception.
6. Lot creation. Based on the street locations, building pad locations, and septic
system locations; lines to delineate individual lots shall then be identified in
accordance with the following:
a. Lots.
1) Single-family lots being served by individual septic tanks and
drain fields shall be a minimum of one acre in size;
2) In a traditional development, Ssingle-family lots being served
by individual septic tanks utilizing communal drain fields
shall be a minimum of one-half acre (21,780 square feet) 16,000
square feet in size with a 100’ minimum lot width and 160’
minimum lot depth. Lots designed with rear-loaded parking
through a secondary access (alley), may reduce the required
front lot width to 80’.
3) In a cluster development, single-family lots being served by
individual septic tanks utilizing communal drain fields shall
be a minimum of 12,800 square feet in size with an 80’
minimum lot width and 160’ minimum lot depth. Lots
designed with rear-loaded parking through a secondary
access (alley), may reduce the required front lot width to 60’
for a cluster development.
4) All land reserved for communal septic system use shall be
located within a dedicated outlot to be owned by the
homeowners' association (HOA) of the development; and
5) Base lots for townhomes shall be large enough such that
individual unit lots can meet all required structure setbacks
contained herein.
b. Lot specific buildable areas.
1) The buildable area on each proposed lot which remains after
consideration of each of the following shall be shown:
a) Required buffers from adjacent lands (See LEC
105.12.170(b));
b) Required setbacks from waterbodies and non-buildable
land per shoreland district regulations (See LEC 105.12,
art. XIX);
c) Steep slopes;
d) Easements; and
e) Land within the following setbacks:
Housing Type
Single-Family Homes Townhomes Accessory Structures
Front yard 30 20 Not permitted
Side yard 15 feet or ten percent of lot width, whichever is
greater
10
Corner lot
front yard
30 Not permitted
Corner lot
street side
yard
30 15
Rear yard 20 20
2) Proposed buildable area on each lot shall be sufficient to
accommodate primary and accessory structures that are
normal and customary to the type of development being
proposed.
7. Open space and park land adjustments.
a. Open space.
1) The total preserved open space area within an open space
planned unit development shall be no less than 50 percent of
the total gross land area, as defined by LEC 1.08. If this threshold
is not achieved after following the first six steps of lot design,
the proposed lot areas will need to be adjusted or lots
eliminated until this requirement is met. The open space area
in a cluster development shall be no less than 60 percent of the
total gross land area.
2) Land needed for stormwater facilities as required by other
provisions of this Code may count towards required open space
for the purposes of open space PUD design, but must ultimately
be placed in outlots to be dedicated to the city.
3) Excluding land needed for compliant stormwater facilities, not
less than 60 percent of the remaining preserved open space
shall be in contiguous parcels which are five acres or more in
size.
4) Preserved open space parcels shall be contiguous with
preserved open space or public park land on adjacent parcels.
b. Park land.
1) Parks and recreational facilities shall be provided in the open
space PUD (or cash-in-lieu contributions must be made) in
addition to preserved open space as specified in the city parks
plan.
2) Determination of whether a land dedication or cash-in-lieu
contribution will be required to fulfill park land requirements
will be at the discretion of the city council after it receives a
recommendation from the city parks commission. If a required
park land dedication causes overall open space to drop below
the minimum threshold, the proposed lot areas will need to be
adjusted or lots eliminated until the open space requirement is
once again met.
3) Any park dedication shall be consistent with the dedication
and fee-in-lieu standards specified in LEC title 103.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
Amended by Ord. 2024-03 on 2/20/2024
105.12.1060 Open Space PUD Development Standards
Open space PUDs shall comply with all of the following development standards unless
modifications are authorized for consideration by the city council via a super-majority vote.
A. Preserved open space standards.
1. With the exception of stormwater facilities which must be dedicated to the
city, all preserved open space within an open space planned unit
development shall be subject to a conservation easement and used for the
purposes listed in LEC 105.12.980.
2. Preserved open space land shall be controlled in one or more of following
manners as determined at the sole discretion of the city council:
a. Owned by an individual or legal entity who will use the land for a
specific set of purposes which is subject to a permanent conservation
easement (in accordance with M.S.A. ch. 84C.01-.05, as it may be
amended from time to time), which is held by a holder as defined by
M.S.A. ch. 84C.01(2) as approved by the city; and/or
b. A conservation easement conveyed to the city;
c. Owned as an outlot by the city (this option may only be used for land
being dedicated to the city for stormwater maintenance and
conveyance purposes).
3. Preserved open space land shall be maintained for the purposes for which it
was set aside. If preserved open space was set aside for agricultural purposes
or for natural habitat, a plan shall be submitted which will indicate how the
land will be maintained or returned to a natural state and who will be
responsible for plan implementation. Developers shall provide copies of
proposed homeowners’ association declarations and conservation
easements to the city describing land management practices to be followed
by the party or parties responsible for maintaining the preserved open space
for the city’s review prior to recording of these documents.
4. Where applicable, a homeowners’ association shall be established to
permanently maintain all residual open space and recreational facilities. The
homeowners’ association’s declaration must guaranty continuing
maintenance and give assessment rights to the city if there is lack of the
maintenance. The homeowners’ association declaration shall be submitted
to the city as part of the documentation requirements of LEC 105.12.1080(c) for
an open space PUD final plan.
B. Septic system design standards.
1. In general. The placement and design of all septic systems shall conform to
the requirements of the county.
2. Individual septic drain fields. Sites for individual septic drain fields, both
primary and secondary, must be located entirely within each lot and cannot
be located within any easement.
3. Communal drain fields.
a. Communal drain fields may be partially or completely located in an
area designated as preserved open space, provided the ground cover is
restored to its natural condition after installation, and recreational
uses are prohibited above or within 50 feet of communal drain fields
or as approved by the city engineer.
b. Communal drain fields, if installed, shall be professionally
maintained, and are acceptable once legally sufficient documentation
has been provided by the developer to ensure such maintenance will
continue in perpetuity.
C. Building standards.
1. Principal structures within open space PUDs shall not exceed 2 1/2 stories or
35 feet in height.
2. It is desired that the structures within neighborhoods convey a particular
architectural style with similar building components, materials, and roof
pitches. The PUD overlay ordinance crafted for each individual open space
PUD should establish minimum architectural standards for the
neighborhood.
3. All wells shall be located a minimum of 50 feet from septic tanks and septic
drain fields.
4. The width of an attached garage shall not exceed 40 percent of the width of
the entire principal building facade (including garage) fronting the primary
street.
D. Landscaping standards.
1. A landscape plan for the entire site is required and shall consist of at least ten
trees per building site; and trees shall not be not less than 1.5 inches in caliper
measured at 54 inches above grade level.
2. Boulevard landscaping is required along all streets to consist of at least one
tree per every 30 feet or placed in clusters at the same ratio.
E. Impervious surface standards. The maximum impervious surface allowable within
an open space planned unit development shall be not exceed 25 percent of the lot in
traditional developments. land area not dedicated as preserved open space subject
to the following:
1. Impervious surfaces created by roads, trails, and other planned impervious
improvements shall count against the maximum allowed impervious
coverage.
2. Remaining allowed impervious surface acreage may be distributed between
the planned building sites, and maximums for each lot shall be clearly
documented within the overlay district ordinance governing the
development.
F. Trail and sidewalk standards. A trail system or with sidewalks shall be established
within open space planned unit developments in accordance with the following:
1. The linear footage of sidewalks and trails provided shall be at least equal in
length to the sum of the centerline length of all public roads within the
development.
a. A trail and sidewalk shall be constructed along the lot frontage on one
(1) side of the road.
b. Additional asphalt trails shall be required to create connections to
other developments and public places. Trails may be required to
exceed the sum of the centerline length at the discretion of the
community development director or city engineer.
2. All trails shall be constructed of asphalt or concrete in compliance with the
standard city design for trails.
3. Proposed trails shall provide connections between and access to the
buildable land areas and preserved open space land being created by the
development.
4. Proposed trails shall connect to existing, planned, or anticipated trails or
roads adjacent to the development site and on adjacent parcels.
5. If applicable, trails shall be linked (or be designed to provide a future link) to
the Old Village to emphasize the connection between existing and new
development.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1070 Open Space PUD Review Criteria
The following findings shall be made by the city council prior to approval of a new or
amended open space planned unit development:
A. The proposed development is consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of
the comprehensive plan.
B. All prerequisites for an open space PUD as outlined in LEC 105.12.1030 are met.
C. All open space PUD design standards (as outlined in LEC 105.12.1050) and all open
space development standards (as outlined in LEC 105.12.1060) are met; or if
deviations are proposed, that all such deviations are supported because they achieve
the following three goals:
1. The deviations allow for higher quality building and site design that will
enhance aesthetics of the site;
2. The deviations help to create a more unified environment within the project
boundaries by ensuring one or more of the following: architectural
compatibility of all structures, efficient vehicular and pedestrian circulation,
enhanced landscaping and site features, and/or efficient use of utilities; and
3. The overall design provides appropriate solutions to eliminate adverse
impacts that proposed deviations may impose on surrounding lands.
D. If the proposed PUD involves construction over two or more phases, the applicant
has demonstrated that each phase is capable of being a stand-alone development
independent of other phases.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1080 Open Space PUD Review Procedure
All requests to establish an open space planned unit development shall be initiated by
following the steps below:
A. PUD preliminary plan.
1. Pre-application conference. Before filing of an application for OP planned unit
development with the city, the applicant of the proposed OP planned unit
development shall arrange for and attend a conference with the planning
director, city engineer and other city staff. The primary purpose of the
conference shall be to provide the applicant with an opportunity to gather
information and obtain guidance as to the general suitability of his proposal
for the area for which it is proposed and its conformity to the provisions of
this subchapter before incurring substantial expense in the preparation of
plans, surveys and other data. No application for an open space PUD
preliminary plan will be accepted by the city unless an applicant's proposal
is distinctly similar to one reviewed by city staff in the required pre-
application conference.
2. PUD preliminary plan submittal requirements. Except as may be waived by
the director of planning community development director, the following
information shall constitute a complete application for an open space PUD
preliminary plan.
a. All required information for a preliminary plat per LEC 105.12.1200(c)
and LEC 105.12.1210.
b. A separate open space PUD preliminary plan which includes the
following information:
1) Administrative information including identification of the
drawing as an open space PUD preliminary plan, the proposed
name of the project, contact information for the developer and
individual preparing the plan, signature of the surveyor and
civil engineer certifying the document, date of plan preparation
or revision, and a graphic scale and north arrow;
2) Area calculations for gross land area, wetland areas, right-of-
way dedications, and proposed public and private parks or
open space and net land area for calculating project residential
density;
3) Existing zoning districts on the subject land and all adjacent
parcels;
4) Layout of proposed lots with future lot and block numbers. The
perimeter boundary line of the subdivision should be
distinguishable from the other property lines. Denote outlots
planned for public dedication and/or open space schools, parks,
etc.;
5) The location of proposed septic disposal areas;
6) Area calculations for each parcel;
7) Proposed setbacks on each lot forming the building pad. and
calculated buildable area;
8) Proposed gross hardcover allowance per lot if applicable.;
9) Existing contours at intervals of two feet. Contours must
extend a minimum of 200 feet beyond the boundary of the
parcels in question;
10) Delineation of wetlands, wetland buffers, and/or watercourses
over the property;
11) Delineation of the ordinary high water levels of all water
bodies;
12) Location, width, and names of existing and proposed streets
within and immediately adjacent to the subdivision parcel;
13) Easements and rights-of-way within or adjacent to the
subdivision parcels;
14) The location and orientation of proposed buildings;
15) Proposed sidewalks and trails;
16) Vehicular circulation system showing location and dimension
for all driveways, parking spaces, parking lot aisles, service
roads, loading areas, fire lanes, emergency access, if necessary,
public and private streets, alleys, sidewalks, bike paths,
direction of traffic flow and traffic control devices;
17) Lighting location, style and mounting and light distribution
plan;
18) Proposed parks, common areas, and conservation easements
(indicate public vs. private if applicable); and
19) Location, access and screening detail of large trash handling
and recycling collection areas.
c. Proposed architectural theming and performance standards for the
development;
d. A grading drainage and erosion control plan prepared by a registered
professional engineer providing all information as required by the City
Engineering Design Standards; by public works, the city engineer,
and/or the director of planning
e. A utility plan providing all information as required by the City
Engineering Design Standards; public works, the city engineer, and/or
the director of planning
f. Results of deep soil test pits and percolation tests, at the rate of no fewer
than two successful test results for each proposed septic disposal area;
g. The location and detail of signage providing all pertinent information
necessary to determine compliance with LEC 105.12.430;
h. A tree preservation plan as required by LEC 105.12.470;
i. A landscape plan, including preliminary sketches of how the
landscaping will look, prepared by a qualified professional providing
all information outlined in LEC 105.12.480;
j. A traffic study containing, at a minimum, the total and peak hour trip
generation from the site at full development, and the effect of such
traffic on the level of service of nearby and adjacent streets,
intersections, and total parking requirements;
k. A plan sheet or narrative clearly delineating all features being modified
from standard open space PUD regulations;
l. Homeowners’ association documents including declarations,
covenants, articles of incorporation, and bylaws;
m. Proposed conservation easement documents; and
n. Any other information as directed by the director of planning
community development director.
3. PUD preliminary plan review.
a. As part of the review process for an open space PUD preliminary plan,
the director of planning community development director shall
generate an analysis of the proposal against the expectations for PUDs,
and make a recommendation regarding the proposed overlay district
for planning commission and city council consideration.
b. The director of planning community development director shall
prepare a draft ordinance to establish the potential overlay district to
be established as a component of the PUD final plan.
c. The planning commission shall hold a public hearing and consider the
application's consistency with the goals for PUDs, the PUD review
criteria, and applicable comprehensive plan goals. The planning
commission shall make recommendations to the city council on the
merit, needed changes, and suggested conditions to impose on the PUD.
d. In approving or denying the PUD preliminary plan, the city council
shall make findings on the PUD review criteria outlined in LEC
105.12.1070.
e. As a condition of PUD preliminary plan approval; finalization, adoption,
and publication of an overlay district ordinance shall need to occur
prior to the filing of any future final plat.
4. Effect of a PUD preliminary plan review. Preliminary plan approval governs
the preparation of the PUD final plan which must be submitted for final
approval in accordance with the requirements of this section.
5. Limitation of approval. The city council's review of an open space PUD
preliminary plan shall remain valid for a period of one year. The city council,
in its sole discretion, may extend the validity of its findings for an additional
year.
B. PUD final plan.
1. Application deadline. Application for an open space PUD final plan shall be
submitted for approval within 180 days of city council approval of the open
space PUD preliminary plan unless a written request for a time extension is
submitted by the applicant and approved by the city council.
2. PUD final plan submittal requirements. Except as may be waived by the
director of planning community development director, the following
information shall constitute a complete application for an open space PUD
final plan.
a. All required information for a final plat per LEC 103.00.080.
b. All required PUD preliminary plan documents, other than the
preliminary plat, shall be updated to incorporate and address all
conditions of PUD preliminary plan approval.
c. Any deed restrictions, covenants, agreements, and articles of
incorporation and bylaws of any proposed homeowners’ association or
other documents or contracts which control the use or maintenance of
property covered by the PUD.
d. A final staging plan, if staging is proposed, indicating the geographical
sequence and timing of development, including the estimated start and
completion date for each stage.
e. Up-to-date title evidence for the subject property in a form acceptable
to the director of planning community development director and the
city attorney.
f. Warranty deeds for property being deeded to the city for all parks,
stormwater ponds, open space, etc., free from all mortgages, liens and
encumbrances.
g. All easement documents for easements not being dedicated on the
final plat including those for trails, ingress/egress, etc., together with
all necessary consents to the easements by existing encumbrancers of
the property.
h. Any other information deemed necessary by the director of planning
community development director to fully present the intention and
character of the open space PUD.
i. If certain land areas or structures within the open space PUD are
designated for recreational use, public plazas, open areas or service
facilities, the owner of such land and buildings shall provide a plan to
the city that ensures the continued operation and maintenance of such
areas or facilities in a manner suitable to the city.
3. PUD final plan review.
a. The director of planning community development director shall
generate an analysis of the final documents against the conditions of
the open space PUD preliminary plan approval, and make a
recommendation as to whether all conditions have been met or if
additional changes are needed.
b. Staff should once again identify any information submittals that were
waived so the city council may determine if such is needed prior to
making a final decision.
c. The director of planning community development director shall
finalize the ordinance to establish the proposed overlay district for
consideration by the planning commission and the city council.
d. The planning commission shall hold a public hearing on the proposed
overlay district ordinance and open space final PUD plans, and shall
submit a recommendation to the city council for consideration.
Because an open space PUD preliminary plan was previously approved,
the planning commission's recommendation shall only focus on
whether the ordinance and open space PUD final plan are in
substantial compliance with the open space PUD preliminary plan and
the required conditions of approval.
e. The city council shall then consider the recommendations of the
director of planning community development director, the public, and
the planning commission; and make a decision of approval or denial,
in whole or in part, on the open space PUD final plan. A denial shall
only be based on findings that an open space PUD final plan is not in
substantial compliance with the approved open space PUD preliminary
plan and/or the required conditions of approval.
f. As a condition of PUD final plan approval, publication of the overlay
district ordinance or a summary thereof shall be required prior to filing
of the approved final plat.
g. Planned unit development agreement.
1) At its sole discretion, the city may as a condition of approval,
require the owner and the developer of the proposed open space
PUD to execute a development agreement which may include,
but not be limited to, all requirements of the open space PUD
final plan.
2) The development agreement may require the developers to
provide an irrevocable letter of credit in favor of the city. The
letter of credit shall be provided by a financial institution
licensed in the state and acceptable to the city. The city may
require that certain provisions and conditions of the
development agreement be stated in the letter of credit. The
letter of credit shall be in an amount sufficient to ensure the
provision or development of improvement called for by the
development agreement.
h. As directed by the city, documents related to the PUD shall be recorded
against the property.
4. Time limit.
a. A planned unit development shall be validated by the applicant
through the commencement of construction or establishment of the
authorized uses, subject to the permit requirements of this Code, in
support of the planned unit development within one year of the date of
open space PUD final plan approval by the city council. Failure to meet
this deadline shall render the open space PUD final plan approval void.
The city council may approve extensions for validation of the PUD of
up to one year if requested in writing by the applicant; extension
requests shall be submitted to the director of planning community
development director and shall identify the reasons why the extension
is necessary along with an anticipated timeline for validation of the
planned unit development.
b. An application to reinstate an open space PUD that was voided for not
meeting the required time limit shall be administered in the same
manner as a new open space PUD beginning at open space PUD
preliminary plan.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1090 Open Space PUD Amendments
Approved open space PUDs may be amended from time to time as a result of unforeseen
circumstances, overlooked opportunities, or requests from a developer or neighborhood. At
such a time, the applicant shall make an application to the city for an open space PUD
amendment.
A. Amendments to existing open space PUD overlay districts. Amendments to an
approved open space PUD overlay district shall be processed as one of the following:
1. Administrative amendment. The director of planning community
development director may administratively approve minor changes to an
approved open space PUD if such changes are required by engineering or
other circumstances, provided the changes conform to the approved overlay
district intent and are consistent with all requirements of the open space PUD
ordinance. Under no circumstances shall an administrative amendment
allow additional lots, or changes to designated uses established as part of the
PUD. An administrative amendment shall be memorialized via letter signed
by the planning director.
2. Ordinance amendment. A PUD change requiring a text update to the adopted
open space PUD overlay district language shall be administered in
accordance with adopted regulations for zoning code changes in LEC
105.12.280. Ordinance amendments shall be limited to changes that are
deemed by the director of planning community development director to be
consistent with the intent of the original open space PUD approval, but are
technically necessary due to construction of the adopted overlay district
language.
3. PUD amendment. Any change not qualifying for an administrative
amendment or an ordinance amendment shall require an open space PUD
amendment. An application to amend an open space PUD shall be
administered in the same manner as that required for a new PUD beginning
at open space PUD preliminary plan.
B. Pre-existing OP developments.
1. Pre-existing OP developments authorized prior to October 4, 2016 shall
continue to be governed per the original conditions of approval until the OP
development is cancelled by the city, or the OP development is converted to
an open space PUD overlay district.
2. An application to amend an existing OP development shall require the
development to be converted into an open space PUD beginning at open space
PUD preliminary plan.
a. Replatting of lots will only be required if the director of planning
community development director determines such is necessary to
implement the requested change.
b. The resulting overlay zoning district shall be applied to all properties
within the OP development being amended.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1100 PUD Cancellation
An open space PUD shall only be cancelled and revoked upon the city council adopting an
ordinance rescinding the overlay district establishing the PUD. Cancellation of a PUD shall
include findings that demonstrate that the PUD is no longer necessary due to changes in
local regulations over time; is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan or other
application land use regulations; threatens public safety, health, or welfare; or other
applicable findings in accordance with law.
HISTORY
Adopted by Ord. 08-253 on 11/3/2021
105.12.1110 Administration
In general, the following rules shall apply to all open space PUDs:
A. Rules and regulations. No requirement outlined in the open space PUD review
process shall restrict the city council from taking action on an application if
necessary to meet state mandated time deadlines.
B. Preconstruction. The city shall not grant a building permit for any building on land
for which an open space PUD plan is in the process of review, unless the proposed
building is allowed under the existing zoning and will not impact, influence, or
interfere with the proposed open space PUD plan.
C. Effect on conveyed property. In the event that any real property in an approved open
space PUD is conveyed in total, or in part, the new owners thereof shall be bound by
the provisions of the approved overlay district.
105.12.1120 Intent
The intent of the Planned Unit Development (PUD) overlay zoning district is to provide
greater flexibility in the use of land and the placement and size of buildings within the
development of residential and nonresidential areas in order to achieve more creative
development outcomes while remaining economically viable and marketable and to better
utilize site features and obtain a higher quality of development. Approval of a planned unit
development shall result in a zoning change to a specific PUD overlay district, with specific
requirements and standards that are unique to that development. The City reserves the
right to deny establishment of a PUD overlay district and direct a developer to re-apply for
City approval under the standard applicable zoning district if the City determines the
proposed benefits do not justify requested flexibilities. A Planned Unit Development (Article
XVIII) shall be within the Metropolitan Urban Service Areas (MUSA). Planned Unit
Developments, outside of the MUSA and within certain rural zoning districts, shall follow
standards in Open Space Planned Unit Developments (Article XVII).