HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-16-93 CCMMINUTES APPROVED: 4-6-93
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
l MARCH 16, 1993
Mayor John called the council meeting to order at 7:03 p.m,
in the council chambers. PRESENT: John, Conlin, Johnson,
City Engineer Bohrer, City Attorney Filla and Administrator
Kueffner. ABSENT: Mottaz, Johnston.
1. AGENDA
ADD: 10F. Letter from the U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency, 10G. April 13th meeting to discuss concept plans for
annexation area.
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to approve the March 16, 1993 City
Council agenda as amended. (Motion carried 3-0).
2. MINUTES: March 2, 1993
M/S/P Johnson/John - to approve the March 2, 1993 City
Council minutes as amended. (Motion carried 2-0-1: Abstain:
Conlin).
MINUTES: March 11, 1993
M/S/P Conlin/Johnson - to approve the March 11, 1993
Emergency Council meeting minutes as amended. (Motion
carried 3-0).
3. CLAIMS:
Regarding Claim #1439, Councilman Johnson complimented the
Maintenance Dept, on a fantastic job of upgrading the used
trailer they purchased.
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to approve the March 16, 1993 Claims
#1405 thru #1448 as presented. (Motion carried 3-0).
4. PUBLIC INFORMATIONAL:
A. Washington County's Request to install methane gas
monitoring vent on city property
Doug Ryan, Environment and Land Use Division Manager,
Washington County, is requesting the city's permission to
enter on, construct and maintain three methane detection
wells on city -owned property. (the property we know as Lake
Jane Hills Park).
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 16, 1993 2
The Council amended the submitted agreement as follows:
First Paragraph Amended to read as follows:
The City of Lake Elmo, Minnesota (hereinafter "City") hereby
grants to Washington County the right to enter on, construct
and maintain three methane detection wells in the northeast
corner of Parcel 0115 in the locations as approved by the
City, Parks Supervisor or his delegate, and with minimal
damage to trees.
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to approve an agreement, as amended,
between Washington County and the City of Lake Elmo for the
installation of methane gas monitoring wells on city owned
property; contingent upon Washington County entering into an
indemnification and hold harmless agreement approved by our
City Attorney. (Motion carried 3-0).
5. OLD BUSINESS: None
6. PLANNING/LAND USE & ZONING:
A. Petition for rezoning from R1 to RE
The City received a petition from five of the seven property
owners within the R1 portion and one property owner in the
RR portion of Midland Meadows requesting a rezoning from R1
to RED. The property owners have stated that they were told
by the Realtor that the lots could not be zoned R1 which
allows for a minimum lot size of 1-1/2 acres. Tony
Collette, property owner in the R1 portion on 4.09 acres,
has applied for a minor subdivision which is scheduled to go
before the Planning Commission on March 22, 1993,
Dave Richter and Terry Erickson explained they bought these
lots with the understanding they would remain rural and
could not be subdivided. Richter also questioned driveway
access for the Collette property.
Mike Lukin felt it's a benefit to the Lake Elmo community
that the propertyowners rezone up and protect the land
around them.
Since the Planning Commission is going to look at the Comp
Plan for possible zoning changes to the bordering properties
of Lake Elmo, Denise Richter asked if they could look at
their area at the same time?
Tony Collette reported when he purchased his property, it
was zoned R1 and bought it with the intention of doing a
minor subdivision. He placed his house in an appropriate
place for when the time came to split it this opportunity
was available to him. He checked with the City for what, was
required and has met all the requirements of the Minor
Subdivision Ordinance: survey, perk tests, paid an
application fee. Lot 7, Block 1 has two driveway easements,
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 16, 1993 3
and according to his attorney, that easement runs with the
land regardless of whether or not it remains a single parcel
or is split. Joe Lux, Washington County, informed him that
all he had to do was apply for a driveway permit and the
County had no problem issuing the driveway permit.
Attorney Filla explained if the city feels that changing the
Comprehensive Plan and the corresponding rezoning for the
area is in the best interest of the city, the council has
the right to do that including Lot 7. Even if you conclude
that you want to allow these things to continue on
concurrent tracks, his recommendation would be to continue
to include the collette property in this new zoning. This
means that the collette property will become a non-
conforming use. He would not recommend that the council
carve out a parcel of R1 land surrounded by some other
designation.
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to accept the petition from the
residents for a rezoning from R1 to RED, (Comprehensive Plan
Amendment) and direct the staff to prepare a resolution
suitable to cover this matter for review at the April 6th
council meeting. Items included in Resolution: refer this
area to Planning Commission for study and direction and at
the same time the PZ set a public hearing for a Development
Moratorium for area affected to be determined by consultants
and PZ. (Motion carried 3-0).
The Planning Commission is reviewing the Ordinance on moving
buildings into the city.
B. Land Surveyor's Certificate Correction to
Midland Meadows, Lot 7, block 1
M/S/P Conlin/Johnson - to approve the request for a Land
Surveyor's Certificate of Correction of Plat, as it relates
to Lot 7, Block 1, Midland Meadows whereby the distance
along the south side of the drainage easement which is shown
as 210.00 feet be correct to show the actual dimension of
410.00 feet. (Motion carried 3-0.
C. Petition for the Establishment of the
Cottage Grove Watershed District
The City received a copy of the draft petition for the
establishment of the Cottage Grove Ravine Watershed
District. Both Woodbury and Oakdale have approved this
petition. Attorney Filla reviewed the petition and reported
he had no concerns with the content of the petition.
M/S/P Conlin/Johnson - to approve the petition for the
establishment of the Cottage Grove Watershed District.
(Motion carried 3-0).
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 16, 1993 4
7. CITY ENGINEER'S REPORT:
1 A. Update on 1993 MSA Feasibility Study
Larry Bohrer presented the need for street improvements,
proposed street design, trail, estimated costs, funding,
assessments and project schedule.
At their March 15th meeting, it was the consensus of the
Parks Commission to not pursue a detached trail along these
streets if construction is ordered, but to look into an
alternative to a trailway in that area in the future.
Councilman Johnson indicated he was not in favor of the
separated trail, but was in favor of the proposed assessment
plan.
Bohrer explained it was his intent that the assessment does
not establish the road improvement fund. The assessment is
levied to provide for the benefit that this road improvement
provides to the adjacent property. By making an assessment,
you are able to utilize some of the state aid funds that
would be eligible for this project, but are not necessary.
It is the state aid funds that go to establish the local
road improvement fund.
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to call a Public Hearing for 1993 MSA
Improvements, Jamaca Avenue and Lake Jane Trail, for
Tuesday, April 6th at 7:40 p.m. and direct the staff to
place on the March 30th agenda for the Surface Water
Management Utility Information meeting an item to receive
the feasibility report. (Motion carried 3-0).
B. Update on Olson Lake Estates
Larry Bohrer submitted the following status report on the
condition of the Olson Lake Estates Pond as of March 10,
1993:
Present Pond Elevation
954.9
Volume at Present Elevation
16.4 ACFt
Water Content of Snow
0.7"
Pond Elevation if all ran off
957.2
Critical Elevation
962+/-
Elevation of Olson Lake
at overflow
Surface Area of Olson Lake
100 Ac
Volume of Olson Lake
1,200 ACFt
At the last council meeting, the staff was directed to
prepare a resolution stating the position of the City
regarding discharge of water from Olson Lake Estates Pond.
Attorney Filla prepared the resolution and Larry Bohrer has
reviewed it.
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 16, 1993 5
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to approve Resolution No. 93-12, A
Resolution relating to the discharge of water from Olson
Lake Estates Pond. (Motion carried 3-0).
C. Preparation for Surface Water Utility
Larry Bohrer asked for comments from the Council for his
presentation at the Surface Water Utility informational
meeting scheduled for March 30th.
**Proposed fees for mobile home parks: Because the streets
in the park are privately owned, he included that as part of
the impervious surface of the park. Whereas, the streets
when they are on public rights -of -way, are exempt. The
council requested Bohrer consider the streets in Cimarron as
we do our city streets and prepare a calculation in relation
to the land area occupied by a mobile home.
**Expected revenue and expected expenditures. Expected
revenues versus expenditures has not been done. The council
asked that this be estimated.
**Clarify the difference between paying VBWD versus this
fund.
8. CITY ATTORNEYS REPORT: None
9. CITY COUNCIL REPORTS:
Mayor John reported he met a number of the landowners in
Sections 32 & 33 to assess their current attitudes toward
Lake Elmo and their interest in returning to Lake Elmo if
the City were to provide a sewer in the area.
Mayor John provided notes on the meeting with State
Representatives and Oakdale Council members on March 12,
1993 at 1:00 p.m. in the State offices. After some
discussion it was agreed that the respective city staffs
would identify the real costs of:
a. increasing the sewer capacity to meet the needs of the
Business Park District and then the MUSA extension and
b. extension of the sewer from the NE corner of Guardian
Angels Church property to the east of CSAH 13,
In addition a date for the start of the project (the 4th
street main stem) would be established.
Larry Bohrer indicated these costs could be provided by the
end of this week.
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 16, 1993
j At Mayor Ted Bearth's suggestion, a joint session of the two
l councils was tentatively agreed for March 22 at Oakdale City
Hall. This would be confirmed following the March 16th Lake
Elmo Council meeting. It was the consensus of the Council to
support a meeting with the Oakdale City Council on March
22nd to discuss common interests.
On Saturday March 13 two teams drawn from the Council,
Administrative staff and the Planning Commission entered in
the Annual Leukemia Bowl-A-Thon sponsored by the City of Oak
Park Heights.
On Monday March 15, he met with the Metro Regional
Supervisor of the Minnesota Board of Water and Soil
Resources, Bruce Sandstrom, Board Conservationist Barbara
Ohman and Al Dornfeld, Chair of the Valley Branch Watershed
District. This was in response to a letter he had written
them on his concerns over the authorities and
responsibilities of the Watershed districts. With the
council's agreement, Mayor John will call an informational
meeting for the citizens of Lake Elmo tentatively for April
14th to be attended by representatives of the Met Council,
PCA, DNR, Board of Water & Soil Resources and the VBWD and
the City of Oakdale.
On Monday, March 15th he attended the meeting of the State
Committee on Local Government and Metropolitan Affairs
investigating the status of the Metropolitan Council held at
the Washington County Commission's offices in Stillwater.
Council member Conlin reported she attended a cable
commission meeting on March 11th held at the Birchwood City
Hall. In the future there will be funds available for
possible cable casting of our Planning Commission and Parks
Commission meetings.
10. CITY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT:
A. League Conference
Administrator Kueffner asked that the Council notify her if
they plan on attending the June 8-11th League Conference in
St. Cloud.
B. Resignation of Parks Commission Member
The City has received a letter of resignation from Gary Lee
from the Parks Commission.
M/S/P Conlin/Johnson - to accept Gary Lee's resignation and
appoint Steve Peterson (first alternate) to serve out his
term. The second alternate, Kevin Heichel should be moved
up to first alternate and solicit applications for the
second alternate vacancy in the City's newsletter. (Motion
carried 3-0).
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 16, 1993 7
Resignation of MAC member
The City has received a letter of resignation from Jim
Peterson from the Maintenance Advisory Commission. With Mr.
Peterson's resignation, there are four members on the
committee.
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to accept Jim Peterson's resignation
from the MAC and advertise the vacancy for the Maintenance
Advisory Commission. (Motion carried 3-0).
C. St. Croix Animal Shelter's Request for a
"Community Support Agreement"
M/S/P Conlin/Johnson - to table this item until the April
6th council meeting. (Motion carried 3-0).
D. Pay Increase Request by A.C.O.
Agreement for Services
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to table this item until the April
6th council meeting. (Motion carried 3-0).
E. Employees Pay Increase
M/S/P Conlin/Johnson - to approve the pay increases as
proposed retroactive to January 1, 1993. (Motion carried 3-
0) .
F. Letter from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
The City received a letter from Todd A. Cayer, Chief, Water
Compliance Branch Disputes Decision Official, regarding
certain costs incurred by the city for land acquisitions are
allowable for Federal Grant funding under the provision of
the Treatment Works Grant.
G. April 13th meeting to discuss concept plans
The city received an invitation to attend a meeting at the
Oakdale City Hall, Tuesday, April 13, 1993 at 5:00 p.m.
where the city council will review the two proposed concept
plans for the annexation area. The City of Oakdale will
send copies of the proposed plans to the City Administrator
as soon as they receive them.
M/S/P Johnson/Conlin - to adjourn the city council meeting
at 11:15 p.m. (Motion carried 3-0).
-----------------
Resolution No. 93-12, A Resolution relating to the discharge of
water from Olson Lake Estates Pond
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
REGION 5
77 WEST JACKSON BOULEVARD
CHICAGO, IL 60604-3590
REPLY TO THE ATTENTION OF:
WCT-15J
MAR 1 0 1993
CERTIFIED MAIL P250 801 247
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Mary Kueffner, City Administrator
City of Lake Elmo
3800 Laverne Avenue North
Lake Elmo, Minnesota 55042
Subject: Treatment Works Grant
Step 2+3, C271411-02
Dear Ms. Kueffner:
This is in reference to your request that we review the June 13,
1990 determination rendered by the Minnesota Pollution Control
Agency (MPCA), that the budget period for the subject grant could
not be extended and that certain costs incurred by the City for
land acquisition are not allowable for Federal grant funding
under the provisions of the subject grant.
We have completed review of the information accompanying your
request, the official Federal grant project files, the Federal
laws including implementing regulations applicable to the issues,
as well as applicable policy and guidance in effect on
September 2, 1983, the date of grant award. Based on this
review, we find nothing precluding the extension of a grant
budget period after its expiration. Further, we find that all
the disputed cost of acquiring land, even though the magnitude of
that cost was not known until after the end of the budget period,
was effectively,.legally incurred when the City of Lake Elmo
exercised its right of eminent domain, which was well within the
existing approved budget period. Consequently, the matter of a
budget period extension is moot.
Correspondingly, based on an assessment of the facts against the
fundamental grant allowability criteria of necessity, reasonabil-
ity and allocability of costs to the grant project, it is my
Printed an Recycled Paper
-2-
determination, as this Agency's authorized Disputes Decision
official, that:
1. $86,453.70, the amount determined by the Minnesota
State District Court as the amount to be paid as full
and just compensation to the respondents in the eminent
domain proceedings, is allowable for Federal grant
funding;
2. $3,150, the cost of the City's appraiser services to
provide additional documentation for the eminent domain
appeal process, is allowable;
3. $7,182.91, the cost of legal services associated with
the eminent domain process is allowable and $135.00 of
legal services was for normalgovernmental operating
expenses and, as such is unallowable pursuant to 40 CFR
Part 35, Appendix A, Miscellaneous Costs, Item 2(a);
and,
4. $3,003.87, the cost for engineering services related to
the eminent domain land acquisition is allowable and
$589.29 of engineering overhead costs was unnecessary
and, therefore, unallowable pursuant to 40 CFR 30.135-3.
In summary, $99,790.45 of the $100,514.77 claimed by the City, or
$50,190.48 of the $50,914.77 determined unallowable in the MPCA
determination, is allowable for Federal grant funding. The
determination expressed above is an official disputes decision
pursuant to 40 CFR, Part 30, Subpart L, and absent a request from
the City for review by registered mail, return receipt requested,
within 30 calendar days of the date of this decision will
constitute final Agency action. You must file your request for
such a review with the Regional Administrator, Mr. Valdas V.
Adamkus, at the letterhead address, in accordance with 40 CFR 30
Subpart L, which also contains further information regarding your
rights.
If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact
me.
J,Respectfully,
. C ger, Chief
Water Compliance Branch
Disputes Decision Official
cc: Patty Burke, MPCA
City of Oakdale, Minnesota
1584 Hadley Avenue North/55128
612/739-5086
FAX 730-2820
March 9, 1993
NOTICE
REGARDING
ANNEXATION
YOU
ARE
INVITED
TO
ATTEND
a
meeting
at:
OAKDALE CITY HALT, CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
1584 Hadley Avenue North
Tuesday, April 13, 1993
r 5:00 p.m.
A R E A
where the City Council will review two (2) proposed CONCEPT plans
for the annexation area.
The plans each propose development of single family dwelling
units generally located north of 4th Street and east of Helmo
Avenue.
Persons wishing to view the plans prior to the meeting may
contact Brent Brommer, Community Development Director, at City
Hall, 739-5086.
CITY OF OAKDALE PLANNING DEPARTMENT
tal/LTR.ANN
Recyclable Oakdah, dne. net di,verinann[e on the he.,.., of rrrrr, ruler, nnlinnal er(ain, ,Rex, reihtinu.
PRIM IfN Wall
age rued hnnrlicnp x(alu.R inuntylnvrnrnl ur prm•iaiun uj'si�rrirr'. SOVINK,•
Notes on meeting with State Representatives and Oakdale Council
( members on March 12, 1993 at 1.00 p.m. in the State Offices:
Pam Neary's office.
Present: Pam Neary, State Representative
Ted Bearth, Mayor, Oakdale
Sheri Timmerman, Oakdale Councillor
Wyn John, Mayor, Lake Elmo
Rita Conlin, Lake Elmo Councillor
Wyn John circulated notes he had made on the March 2 meeting.
Pam Neary then summarized her understanding of the position as at the
end of the last meeting:
1. That Oakdale and Lake Elmo were agreed on the need to provide a
sewer, along 4th Street, in Sections 32 & 33, to be jointly funded by
the cities.
2. That sewer capacity would be transferred from the MinDoT land
areas to support Lake Elmo's Business Park District. The sewer
would be sized to be adequate for this additional capacity, and for
potential longer range extension of the MUSA along I-94. The
additional costs would be borne by Lake Elmo.
3. The question of land transfer to Oakdale was unresolved. Lake Elmo
was reluctant to hand over the land to Oakdale without some
recompense for the loss in revenue that this transfer
represented. It was agreed that Lake Elmo would approach the
landowners to see whether they were still interested in transfer to
Oakdale, provided a sewer were made available. This would permit
a boundary adjustment between the cities to be considered.
Wyn John then reported on the results of contacts with a number of the
Section 32 & 33 landowners. This indicated that some did not mind in
which city they were located as long as sewer were available at the
earliest. Some felt that after being in conflict with Lake Elmo for so long,
they did not wish to rejoin the city which had resisted their requests for
sewer and water service. Others did not want their land to be within two
cities after a boundary relocation. There were some on small lots, who had
not petitiuoned in the first place, who wanted to stay in Lake Elmo.
From this, Pam Neary tried to see if an agreement could be reached
( whereby the land was transferred to Oakdale, but that Lake Elmo would
receive some compensation in relation to sewer costs as an exchange.
Both Rita Conlin and Wyn John emphasised that Lake Elmo was interested
in ensuring that the sewer reached the East side of CSAH 13 within this
project. Also, that it was technically feasible for Lake Elmo to install the
sewer along 4th Street to CSAH 13 as a stand alone project, since all the
relevant land was still in Lake Elmo. In addition, that Helmo Avenue was
still a Lake Elmo street, as all assessments had not been fully paid by the
landowners. Consequently, another portion of the Oakdale sewer project
could not proceed without Lake Elmo approval.
Ted
Bearth would not agree to any support of sewer
costs, as he
felt that
the
benefitting parties should pay their share of the
project. He
did not
see
that
enabling the project to proceed in a timely manner,
saving the costs of litigation to order the land
into Oakdale,
or
having land transferred into Oakdale with the
potential of
additional
tax capacity,
were benefits for Oakdale. He felt that the bill had
been submitted and
that
the legislative action should take its course.
After some discussion, it was agreed that the respective City Staffs.would
identify the real costs of:
a) increasing the sewer capacity to meet the needs of the Business Park
District, and then the MUSA extension and
b) extension of the sewer from the NE corner of Guardian Angels Church
property to the east of CSAH 13
In addition, a date for the start of the project (the 4th Street main stem)
would be established.
At Ted Bearth's suggestion, a joint session of the two councils was
tentatively agreed for March 22 at Oakdale City Hall. This would be
confirmed following the March 16 Lake Elmo Council meeting.
Mayor's report March 16, 1993
Since the last council meeting, I met a number of the landowners in
Sections 32 & 33 to assess their current attitudes towards Lake Elmo, and
their interests in returning to Lake Elmo if the City were to provide a
sewer in the area. Understandably, their response was mixed, but it did
give me some background to help in our further discussions with Oakdale,
which took place on March 12. I have made notes of our meeting at the
State Offices, which can form part of the minutes.
On Saturday March 13, two teams drawn from the Council, Administrative
staff, and the Planning Commission, entered in the Annual Leukemia Bowl-
A-Thon sponsored by the City of Oak Park Heights. We were not as
successful as we had hoped, but the Leukemia Society benefited by $
which was donated by our teams' sponsors.
On Monday March 15, I met with the Metro Regional Supervisor of the
Minnesota Board of Water and Soil Resources, Bruce Sandstrom, Board
Conservationist Barbara Ohman, and Al Dornfeld, Chair of the Valley
Branch Watershed District. This was in response to a letter I had written
them on my concerns over the authorities and responsibilities of the
Watershed districts. We had a constructive discussion, resulting in my
agreeing to call an informational meeting for the citizens of Lake Elmo,
tentatively for April 14, to be attended by representatives of the Met
Council, PCA, DNR, Board of Water & Soil Resources, and the Valley Branch
Watershed District and the City of Oakdale. This will discuss surface water
issues as well as the implications of the 509 Water Management Project.
With the council's agreement tonight, I will call this meeting for April 14,
1993.
Last night, my wife and I attended the meeting of the State Committee on
Local Government and Metropolitan Affairs investigating the status of the
Metropolitan Council. This was held at the Washington County
Commission's offices in Stillwater. There were many presentations, some
of which were in support of the Met Council, others in support of bills
which modified its function, structure and responsibilities. I was
impressed by the smooth way the procedures were conducted, and the
way the meeting was structured to give a degree of automatic formality.
We left before proceedings had finished, but this subject is one which will
go on for some' time before recommendations are made.
2
To: Mayor and City Council
From: Mary Kueffner
Date: March 15, 1993
Re: Lake Elmo Municipal Water Supply
Routine Inspection Report
Attached is a copy of the above referenced report from the Minnesota Department of
Public Health. Please note that the first recommendation of the Health Department is
that the City consider constructing another well to serve as an emergency standby.
Since there has been some discussion, at least by the Planning Commission, of an
extension of the "Old Village", I think it would be prudent for the City to consider this
additional well in those plans. If those plans go no where, the Council should still
consider this recommendation in the not -to -distant future.
There was a "Water Study Committee" a few years ago. If anyone in interested in
seeing that report, or would like this issue put on the Council agenda for discussion,
please let me know,
The chlorination issue has also been brought up before by the Health Department, but
according to our maintenance foreman, who has looked into this for previous councils,
chlorinating now could reek havoc on our system and could be very expensive. We
would have to retrofit our well house to accommodate a separate room for the
chlorination equipment and probably have to replace at least some of the watermains
because the buildup of residue now in the pipes would be loosened by the chlorination
and could cause plugging of meters and weakening of the pipes (Dan says this has been
the case in other cities). The costs involved should not be a reason to not chlorinate,
but the council should be aware of the costs involved.
Any new well that would be instructed has to have chlorination, but as of yet they have
not made that law retroactive to existing wells. I suppose we should also be prepared
for that possibility.
Additional or on -going training is offered to our staff, and we will continue to
encourage the staff to attend these classes.
Minnesota Department of Health
Division of Environmental Health
925 Delbware Street Southeast
P.O. Box 59040
Minneapolis, MN 55459.0040
(612) 627.5100
FEB 19m3
Lake Elmo City Council
c/o Ms. Sharon Lumby, Deputy Clerk
City Hall
3800 Laverne Avenue North
Lake'Elmo, Minnesota 55042
Dear Council Members:
'Pea P 4 1993
Subject: Lake Elmo Municpal Water Supply, City of Lake Elmo, Washington
We are enclosing a copy of the report of our district office covering a
routine inspection of your community water supply.
If you have any questions concerning the information contained in this report,
please contact Mr. Bassam Banat, Public Health Engineer at 612/627-5173.
Also, enclosed for your information is a copy of the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency's fact sheet on the new Lead and Copper Rule. Please
familiarize yourself with the rule because you will be responsible for
selecting the sample sites and collecting the samples.
Sincerely,
Richard D. Clark, P.E., Supervisor
Public Water Supply Unit
Section of Water Supply
and Well Management
RDC:BHB:sls
Enclosure
cc: Lake Elmo Water Superintendent
Washington County Community Health Services
An Equal Opportunity Employer
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
REPORT ON INVESTIGATION OF PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY
Name of Water Supply
PWS ID Number
Lake Elmo Municipal Water Supply
1820009
Street
Telephone Numbers:
3800 Laverne Avenue
City:
City
State
Zip Code
Lake Elmo
MN
55042
Operator:
Engineer:
County
District
Washington
Metropolitan
Otnar:
Water Superintendent Classification
Plant Classification
Owner Type
Dan Olinger D
D
Municipal
Other Operators Classification
Plant Type
Plumbing Permits and u�
Inspections ❑
Community
Required yk4
es No
Mike Bouthilet C
Date of Previous Survey
Date of Survey
Mike Buckles D
Richard Gustafson N.C.
09-10-91
12-21-92
City Engineer
Tom Prew
SERVICE AREA CHARACTERISTICS:
Aa Municipai ❑ School or College ❑ Recreation Area
❑ Mobile Home Park ❑ Hotel/Motel ❑ Campground
❑ Company Town ❑ Resort ❑ Housing Development
❑ Institution ❑ Restaurant ❑ Other
Population Served
Service Connections
Storage Capacity:
800
246
(List Separately)
75,000-gallon elevated
Design Capacity (gal/day)
Average Daily Production (gal/day)
740,000
50,000
Emergency Capacity (gal/day)
Highest Daily Production (gal/day)
1
150,000
Total: 75,000 gallons
TREATMENT
WELL DATA
G
G
c
m
c
a
c
2
a
d
5
y
II
u
O
d
C
n
C
G
rh
O
m
J
O
-
5
E
o`
a
c
c
; S E
u
3
a
Source Name
o
y
Q
"'
O
v
Q
a
U
v
N
=
11
`o :
84
`c
N
W
f
E
Q
2
LL
c
O
v
Y
'�
,�
u
"'S
E
U
Vl
3
tpLL
N
O
y
1/208448
G
P
Va
1961
20
277
805
Franconie
Hinckley
102
40
VT
500
Remarks:
AMPLING SITES:
Surveyedby: RaccaM Ranat
1 City Hall
2 Fire Hal 1
Approved by:
H E•008Q-02
Lake Elmo Municipal Water Supply December 21, 1992
PWSID 1820009
Recommendations:
1. The city of Lake Elmo should consider constructing an additional well to
serve as a standby or emergency water source.
2. The city of Lake Elmo should consider installing permanent chlorination
equipment and maintaining a free chlorine residual of at least 0.2 to
0.6 milligrams per liter on all points of the distribution system.
3. The opportunity for additional training in water supply work should be
made available to the operator(s). Attendance at the annual waterworks
operators seminar, held in the area, is a valuable experience for anyone
engaged in this field.
Bassam H. Banat, P.E.
Public Health Engineer
Section of Water Supply
and Well Management
i;
502.4 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH - CHEMICAL LABORATORY
1
.` VOLATILE
HYDROCARBONS (code 465)
r,a t F
t'jSAMPLED: 12/21/92
LAB SAMPLE #:
9227698
A" ANALYZED: 01/01/93
tt.JREPORTED: 01/04/93
FIELD BLANK #:
NONE
kREPORTING
AMOUNT REPORTING
AMOUNT
LIMIT
FOUND -
LIMIT FOUND
COMPOUND
(UG/L)
(UG/L) COMPOUND
(UG/L) (UG/L)
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamaaaaasaaamaaaaamaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaagaaamaaaaaamsaaaamaaa
Df6 hlorodifluoromethane<
1.0
11122-Tetrachloroethane<
0.2
Chloromethane
<
2.0
1123-Trichloropropane
< 0.5
Vinyl Chloride
<
1.0
lBromobenzene
< 0.2
Btomomethane
<
2.0
12-Chlorotoluene
< 0.5
Clloroethane
<
1.0
14-Chlorotoluene
< 0.5
D2chloroflueromethane
<
1.0
11,3-Dichlorobenzene
< 0.2
Tri.chlorofluoromethane
<
2.0
1,4-Dichlorobenzene
< 0.2
Trichloro-
1,2-Dichlorobenzene
< 0.2
11
trifluoroethane
<
0.2
11,2-Dibromo-
11-Dichloroethene
<
0.5
1 3-Chloropropane
< 2.0
Allyl Chloride
<
0.5
1124-Trichlorobenzene
< 0.5
Methylene Chloride
<
0.5
IHexachlorobutadiene
< 0.5
t-,1,2-Dichloroethene
<
0.1
1123-Trichlorobenzene
< 0.5
1,1-Dichloroethane
<
0.2
jEthyl Ether
< 2.0
2t27dichloropropane
<
0.5
jAcetone
< 20
c"1,2, Dichloroethene
<
0.2
(Methyl tertiary -
Chloroform
<
0.1
1 Butyl Ether
< 2.0
BFomochloromethane
<
0.5
Methyl Ethyl Ketone
< 10
1',A ,'S-Trichloroethane
<
0.2
Tetrahydrofuran
< 10
11-Dichloropropene
<
0.2
(Benzene
< 0.2
Carbon Tetrachloride
<
0.2
(Methyl Isobutyl Ketone<
5.0
102-Dichloroethane
<
0.2
(Toluene
< 0.2
T4ichloroethene
<
0.1
jEthyl Benzene
< 0.2
1)'2-Dichloropropane
<
0.2
lm+p-Xylene
< 0.2
BAomodichloromethane
<
0.2
o-Xylene
< 0.2
Dibromomethane
<
1.0
Styrene
< 0.5
<
0.2
1Isopropyl Benzene
< 0.5
J"1,3-Dichloropropene
1,3-Dichloropropene
<
0.2
In-Propyl Benzene
< 0.5
1�1,2-Trichloroethane
<
0.2
1135-Trimethylbenzene
< 0.5
1.3-Dichloropropane
<
0.2
Itert-Butyl Benzene
< 0.5
Tetrachloroethene
<
0.2
1124-Trimethylbenzene
< 0.5
C'icrodibromomethane
<
0.5
sec-Butylbenzene
< 0.5
1-Dibromoethane
<
1.0
1p-Isopropyltoluene
< 0.5
dH orobenzene
<
0.2
In-Butylbenzene
< 0.5
41 2-Tetrachloroethane
<
0.2
Naphthalene
< 0.5
BrQmoform
<
1.0
1
T"T-------------------------
.---------------------------.-------------------
,.COMMENTS:
Lakes!.bmo Municipal Water Supply,
Well
No. 1, PWSID 1820009, Date Sampled:
12-21-92
Legend:
t; < = less than
PP = peak present
j
:a
# Fi
Lake Elmo Municipal Water Supply, Well No. 1, PWSID 1820009, Date Sampled: 12-21-92
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH PROGRAM: HC
CHEMICAL LABORATORY SAMPLE: 9227691
PAGE: 1
( REPORT OF ANALYTICAL RESULTS DATE RECEIVED: 12/21/92
FINAL REPORT — CLIENT COPY DATE GENERATED: 12/22/92
PROGRAM NAME: COMM WATER SUPPLIES (SAN.)
DATE REPORTED:
ANALYSIS/COMMENTS RESULT
UNIT: BACTICHEM
327 PA TOTAL COLIFORM—DW (COLILERT) A /100 ml
Absent
Lake Elmo Municipal Water Supply, Parks Bldg., PWSID 1820009, Date Sampled: 12-21-92
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH PROGRAM: HC
CHEMICAL LABORATORY SAMPLE: 9227692
PAGE: 1
( REPORT OF ANALYTICAL RESULTS DATE RECEIVED: 12/21/92
FINAL REPORT - CLIENT COPY DATE GENERATED: 12/22/92
PROGRAM NAME: COMM WATER SUPPLIES (SAN.)
DATE REPORTED:
ANALYSIS/COMMENTS RESULT
UNIT: BACTICHEM
327 PA TOTAL COLIFORM-DW (COLILERT) A
Absent
/100 m1
Lake Elmo Municipal Water Supply, Lake Elmo Elementary School, PWSID 1820009,
Date' Sampled: 12-21-92
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH PROGRAM: HC
CHEMICAL LABORATORY SAMPLE: 9227692
PAGE: 1
REPORT OF ANALYTICAL RESULTS DATE RECEIVED: 12/21/92
FINAL REPORT — CLIENT COPY DATE GENERATED: 12/22/92
PROGRAM NAME: COMM WATER SUPPLIES (SAN.)
DATE REPORTED:.
ANALYSIS/COMMENTS RESULT
BACTICHEM —
UNIT
327 PA TOTAL COLIFORM—DW (COLILERT) A /100 m1
Absent
Lake Elmo Municipal Water Supply, City Hall, PWSID 1820009, Date Sampled: 12-21-92
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH PROGRAM:
CHEMICAL LABORATORY SAMPLE:
PAGE:
REPORT OF ANALYTICAL RESULTS DATE RECEIVED:
FINAL REPORT — CLIENT COPY DATE GENERATED
PROGRAM NAME: COMM WATER SUPPLIES (SAN.)
DATE REPORTED:
ANALYSIS/COMMENTS RESULT
-------------------------------------------- ------
UNIT: DACTICHEM
327 PA TOTAL COLIFORM—DW (COLILERT) A
Absent
HC
9227694
1
12/21/92
12/22/92
/100 m1
"Lead may
leach into the
water from
some kinds
of home
plumbing."
United States Office of Water
Environmental Protection WHS50A
Agency
EPA 570/19.91-400
June1991
Lead avind Coper Rule
The Lead and Copper Rule was published in the Federal Register on June 7,
1991. It becomes effective on November 7, 1992. This rule requires treatment
when lead and/or copper in drinking water exceeds certain levels:
Lead enters drinking water mainly from the corrosion of lead -containing house-
hold plumbing. Since lead.and capper contamination generally occurs after water
has left the public water system, the best way for the water system operator to
find out if customer water is contaminated is to test water that has come from a
household faucet. This type of contamination can be prevented by controlling the
corrosiveness of the water supply. If corrosion wntrol is not sufficient, lead -
containing materials may have to be replaced.
Water Quality Standards
Maximum Contaminant Level Goals (MCLG): Water systems should try to
supply water which is free of lead and has no more than 1.3 milligrams of copper
per liter. This is a non -enforceable health goal.
' '' ' Action Levels: When the concentration of lead or copper reaches the
MCLG Action Level action level in ten percent of the total number of required samples, the
(mg1L) (mgrL) water system is required to carry out the water treatment requirements of
Lead 0 0.015 the rule. These enforceable treatment requirements are described below..
Copper 1.3
1.3 Monitoring Requirements
Lead/copper monitoring at high -risk homes.
Water systems must complete a materials evaluation of their distribution
system. and/or review other information to target homes that are at high risk of
lead/copper contamination. Monitoring is to be conducted at the tap in these
homes, with the number of tap -sampling sites based on the population served.
One sample is required at each site.
• Number of Initial Sampling Sites
# at home
System taps for
size Pb/Cu
9 within
dist. for
other factors
>100,000
100
50
10,001-100,000 60
10
3,301-10,000
40
3
501.3,300
20
2
101-500
10
1
5100
5
1
Additional monitoring for other factors affecting corrosion
is required to optimize treatment and determine compliance with
State lead/copper standards. Two types of systems must perform
this monitoring under the following conditions:
• Large systems serving more than 50,000 Dermas, regardless of
the lead/copper levels in tap samples.
• Smaller systems serving less than 50,000 persons, if the action
levels are exceeded in tap samples.
Two types of sampling sites are specified for this purpose:
• Within the distribution system, with the number of sites
based on population served (sites may be same as for coli-f-
orm sampling). Two samples are required from each site.
• One sample at each entry point to the distribution system.
`..Pii6GcEdiicvtiortFaelSfieet5erirs�
Monitoring Frequencies.
Initially, small and medium systems must collect home tap
amples for lead and copper analysis every six months. Samples
'or other factors must be taken from within the distribution
ystem every six months, and from entry points to the distribu-
ion system every two weeks. Both the number of'sampling sites
aid the frequency may be reduced if, for three years, the action
evel is met or the system maintains optimal treatment.
Water Treatment Requirements
• Frequency of Sampling
t4
Monitoring
Home
within
at entry
Period
taps
dist.
to dist.
Initial
6 mo.
6 mo. i
.6 mo.
After corrosions
fi mo.
6 mo. 1
2 wk-
treatment
Reduced
—Conditional #-
1 yr.
6 mo.
2 wk.
—Final
3 yr.
3 yr. i
2 wk.
Four types of action are required to remedy high lead/
opper levels. Once a system finds that more than 10 percent of all tap monitoring
-isults exceed the action levels, the system must begin to carry out the first three
..ctions.
O Corrosion control treatment. Depending on its size, a system may be
required to first monitor as described above and/or recommend a corrosion
control treatment to. the State. Upon the approval of the State, treatment is to
be installed and demonstrated to be effective according to criteria set by the
State. Treatment options are: pH and alkalinity adjustment, calcium adjust-
ment, and silica or phosphate -based corrosion inhibition.
9 Source Water Treatment. Systems must first monitor their source water for
the presence of lead/copper, and, if necessary, recommend a treatment to the
State. Treatment options are: ion exchange, lime softening, reverse osmosis,
and coagulation/filtx-ation. Once the State approves a treatment, systems will
have 2 years to install it and 1 more year to conduct follow-up monitoring. If
treatment is not required, or if the treated water does not exceed the maxi-
mum lead/copper levels permitted by the State, source water monitoring will
be synchronized with the system's other monitoring schedules.
® Public Education. Public education materials developed by EPA will inform
customers about the health effects of lead, and explain what they can do at
home to reduce their exposure. ate s5 ntem must begin
delivering the materials within 60 days of the lead Compliance Deadlines
action level exceedance. The materials include public NOTE: assumes action levels exceeded in initial monitoring
service announcements to be submitted periodically to
television and radio stations, and other pamphlets to
be delivered directly to customers, newspapers, hospi- Large Medium Small
tals, etc. Action >50K 3,300.50K 53,300
LF a system continues to exceed the lead action level
after installing optimal corrosion control and source water
treatment, the fourth action must be taken:
O Lead Service Line Replacement. Lead service lines
that contribute more than 0.015 mg/L to tap water
lead levels must be replaced. A system must replace
seven percent of its lead lines each year, and must
replace all lines within 15 years.
For More Information
Call the Safe Drinking Water Hotline at:1-800-426.4791.
Lead
Copper
pH
alkalinity
Calcium
Conductivity
Orthophosphate
Silica Temperatcue
Begin monitoring Jan92 I
Ju192
Ju193
Complete treatment study Ju194. i
Ju195
Ju196
(if required by State)
Recommend treatment to State
• study not required- N/A
Jan93
Jan94
• study required- ' Ju194
Ju195 i
Ju196
Complete treatment installation i
i
• study not required- N/A
Ju196 i
JaK
• study required- Jan97
Jan98 !
Jams
I
Complete follow-up monitoring
i
• study not required- N/A
Ju197
Jan99
• study required- Jan98 '.
Jan99
Jan2000
Since we do not have time to discuss every point presented, it
may seem that decisions are preconceived. However, background
information is provided for the City Council on each agenda item in
advance from City Staff and appointed Commissions; and decisions are
based on this information and past experiences. In addition, some
items may also have been discussed at previous Council meetings.
If you are aware of information that hasn't been discussed,
please fill out a "Request to Appear Before the City Council', slip;
or, if you came late, raise your hand to be recognized. Comments that
are pertinent are appreciated. Items requiring excessive time may be
continued to another meeting.
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1993
7:00 P.M. MEETING CONVENES
1. AGENDA
2. MINUTES: March 2, 1993
March 11, 1993 Emergency Meeting
3. CLAIMS
4. PUBLIC INFORMATIONAL
A. Washington County's Request to install
methane gas monitoring vent on city property
B. Other
5. OLD BUSINESS:
6. PLANNING/LAND USE & ZONING:
A. Petition for rezoning from R1 to RE
B. Land Surveyor's Certificate of Correction to
Midland Meadows, Lot 7, Block 1
C. Petition for the Establishment of the
Cottage Grove Watershed District
D. Other
7. CITY ENGINEER'S REPORT:
A. Update on 1993 MSA Feasibility Study
B. Update on Olson Lake Estates
C. Preparation for Surface Water Utility (over)
LAKE ELMO CITY COUNCIL AGENDA March 16, 1993 2
8. CITY ATTORNEY'S REPORT:
9. CITY COUNCIL REPORTS:
A. Mayor John
B. Council Member Conlin
C. Johnson
D. Johnston
E. Mottaz
10. CITY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT:
A. League Conference
B. Resignation of Parks Commission Member
Resignation of MAC member
C. St. Croix Animal Shelter's Request for a
"Community Support Agreement"
D. Pay Increase Request by A.C.O.
Agreement for services
E. Employees Pay Increase
E. Other
11. ADJOURN
C