2014 Planning Commission Packets

Home Browse Search

Item No: 5A MOUNDS OT TA DS VfE— j Meeting Date: May 21, 2014 V1�IlJ ♦ L � � Type of Business: Public Hearing City of Mounds View Staff Report To: Mounds View Planning Commission From: Heidi Heller, Planning Associate Item Title/Subject: Consideration of a Variance to Allow an Eight -Foot Tall Fence in the Front Yard of 7701 Bona Road; Planning Case VR2014-002 Introduction: The applicant, Mike Winkel, is requesting a variance to install an 8 -foot tall fence in the "second front yard" of his corner lot located at 7701 Bona Road. The property is located at the southeast corner of Bona Road and County Road I. Since two streets border corner lots, they have two front yards. As such, the City Code requirement for front yard applies to two sides of the property, which means that corner lots to have additional limitations. The Zoning Code indicates that no fence in front of the front line of a building in a residential district may exceed four feet in height. The applicant would preferto have an 8 -foot tall wood fence for screening from County Road I since his yard is a little lower than the sidewalk, and thus has applied for the variance. Discussion: The applicant currently has a 6 -foot fence in the second front yard area but it needs to be replaced, and he wants to expand the fence to the front line of the garage (see attached site plan). A permit for the existing fence was issued by the City in 1981. According to the Municipal Code, Section 1103.08, Subdivision 3, fences of a height greater than 48 inches (4 feet) are not allowed in the front yard of a property without a variance. The Zoning Code also establishes a sight triangle that limits all obstructions within the area at the corner of intersections, measured thirty (30) feet from the point where the property lines meet at the intersection of two streets. The proposed fence would not be located within the sight triangle. Variance Considerations: For the City to approve this variance, as with any variance request, there needs to be demonstrated practical difficulty associated with the property that makes a literal interpretation of the Code overly burdensome or restrictive to a property owner. State statutes require that the governing body (the Planning Commission) review a set of specified criteria for each application and make its decision in accordance with these criteria. The City has set these criteria in Section 1125.02, Subdivision 2, of the City Code. The Code clearly states that a hardship exists when all of the criteria are met. The individual criteria and a staff comment about each are as follows: a. The variance is in harmony with the general purposes and intent of these regulations. The property at 7701 Bona Road is a corner lot, which is not in itself unique; however, the applicant seeks permission to have an 8 -foot tall fence for the purpose of privacy and screening from busy County Road I. This property is across the street from several apartment buildings which create a lot of vehicle and pedestrian traffic, and there is a sidewalk along County Road I, adjacent to the applicant's property. The applicant's yard is a couple of feet below the sidewalk level, so he would like to install an 8 -foot fence to compensate for the grade difference. The taller fence would provide privacy and security for this property.