09-21-2005 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Mounds View Planning Commission September 21, 2005 Regular Meeting Page 10 ________________________________________________________________________ Mr. McCarty asked for a copy of the report from Bonestroo. He also asked what the casing of well 4 told and if it was televised. He added in 1982 there was a crack in the well and it was shut down because the water was becoming contaminated. He noted in terms of the utilities, unless the ordinance has changed, the company is responsible for connections from the building to the curb stop and everything else belongs to the City. Director Ericson replied the feasibility study was done, but he is not prepared to address issues with well 4. Commissioner Hegland asked, regarding action tonight, if the financial analysis is a requirement for approval. Director Ericson replied based on a review of code and previous cases, he believes there is sufficient documentation to make a decision and the specific financials are not a prerequisite to action. Commissioner Hegland asked who is responsible for the financial part. Director Ericson replied City Council. Commissioner Hegland stated he agrees. He added the Commission should not ignore this part and should prepare this information for the Council. Commissioner Zwirn stated reminders of Commission responsibility with regard to the Medtronic project disturb him. Director Ericson replied it is justifiable to confirm what is the role of the Commission. He added Council has had concerns with Commission comments regarding items such as the land sale, which strayed from the Commission’s role and responsibility. Commissioner Scotch stated she has the right to request information needed on which to base a decision. She added she hopes the City is not making a bad decision. Acting Chair Miller closed the cases for public comment at 9:15 p.m. MOTION/SECOND: Zwirn/Scotch. To deny Resolution 815-05, a Resolution Recommending Approval of a Preliminary Plat Review, Rezoning, and Development Stage Plan Review Associated with the Medtronic CRM Project; Planning Case No. MA2005-002 and PD2005-002. Ayes – 2 (Scotch, Zwirn) Nays – 3 (Hull, Meehlhause, Miller) Abstain – 1 (Hegland) Motion failed. MOTION/SECOND: Miller/Meehlhause. To approve Resolution 815-05, a Resolution Recommending Approval of a Preliminary Plat Review, Rezoning, and Development Stage Plan Review Associated with the Medtronic CRM Project; Planning Case No. MA2005-002 and PD2005-002. Ayes – 3 (Hull, Meehlhause, Miller) Nays – 3 (Hegland, Scotch, Zwirn) Motion failed. Director Ericson asked since the Commission neither approved nor denied the resolution, was there something that Staff can bring back to the Commission to address concerns.