Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPL MINUTES 04201964 Meeting Sheet IIIIII VIII VIII VIII VIII VIII IIII IIII ioovs Box: 15 Folder: PL MINUTES 1962-1966 Document: PL MINUTES 04201964 VILLAGE OF ST. ANTHONY PLANNING NG BOARD MINUTES April 20, 196-1e, Th:a rmeting ;;as :-abled to ..Ade:° by Lho Chairman at 7:30 PA in -he Vi11aege Hai at 2900 Kenzie Ter.-­,ace,,. Minneapolis 7S.. 61inn.. Presentt Fio,.aitz, Springer, tic —,s. Mesenbring, Emone, Englund, Coulter Absent: {lone The rai nutes of the meeti ng of Il� ..-h 1 sig 109,6 • .wage apndyoveri with tt-e fol' .tri ng co.rectiruns: a. "s tern 3 - rezoning is f.-ora single femi l y to 'tyto-fami?y resi dentia al. b. item 4 - Sp,Ji nger abstained from °�,ot i ng. t•. Siert 6 - inse-t widening drives and adjusting wete °ly pari"lnrg lot. d. Y tem 9 - Hcwi tz stepped dcrvrn 4s Chai rman. n. The Chairman announced that vies the time. and pbace to hobd a public hearing on- the request t:f Cha,-Ies Marsh to rezone the "Lemke Greenhouse Prope:-i:,yll feora Co.vrarcial to single4wrily residential. The Chairman i. cnvm:yed t1ha opinion of the Vin cage Attorney that such �ezoni ng should be ;ni bpi&ted by the Village Catuici l., M-o t4arsh muss present enough valid and justified reasons suppoeting the rezoning to ci o•vis the bcaed tc rets .•,.end that the Counei 9 initiate su,.;'h a zoning change. ' hv. Maysh and the residents who joined in the pe• it ti on felt the pr'ope,'"Ly should be vezoned for the fol la:•ring reasons: i. Area is s t'r i ta1-o y a Desi dent`j a i area and any higher use would be ncm-compatible. 2. Any hirhep use would deCreaee ptAope,'ty Values cif 4u:' - funding �r;-ape 'ty. 3. App.!-tTm:t cGmplex vto0d dengeu curly Sn�:rensa ` t-alffic. 4o Apartments inti:fease !oad on svhools. After considevable di4.cug6icn it was roved by Englund, seconded by Rocks to -close Rearing and eafer actiun unfi i completion cif next item on iha agenda. All in favor. Potion carred. 2: The Chairman announted ''.hat: this was the time and pli;ace to ho`O d a public hearing or, the request of CenWu y Capital Corp, to rezwne the "Lemke Gteenhouse Property`. frora cof=ercial to Mu"'tiple Di:elling. Fide Emil presented the proposed davolopfnent Uf the ar•eA„ 932 units of "prestige" apfsnments wit'z fi!-e- pr'cof COnStf-uLtion and comp"ate ?andscaaping. The regiested rezoning 'eras zuntinsent upgn a variance in the land atrea requiren—enbs.The .patitior19-rs for multiple dwelling stated that this type o de-'e%ptreot would be cvch mw-e conduci w to survoundi ng pvopert ' than any devesopmen`"s unite;• the present zoning. After ter hearing all the ' c:oriinents from fthe partiet, in,.,clved, the Chairman tiie hea;'ing Closed. Page 2 Planning Board Minutes April 20, 1964 ' Moved by Coulterr seconded by Englund to deny the requested rezoning on the f=ollowing basis: 1. Area is a pri ri-n I'esi dent-Pal area best suited for si rgl_ f artii l y fzori.es. 2. The proposed dawelotpment requests a 30% variance z"r-om code on minirum land requi retr.ents. 3. Majority of surrounding ouners opposed de�elo,���r�to Vo-i nq: Aye: Ya:,ai tzb Englund, Coul ter g. Rocl:LA Pesenbc°i ng. Spri nr— Play: Mone Abstair:ing: Emund Moved by Coulaef,9 seconded by Mesenbring to r°ecoarr:end ttat the Co=:i 1 initiate re�oni ng of the Ler to Property from Co=.er,;1 al to sing' e family reside nts al a The area is within a ves i denti a' di stri ct and could be developed into a "'.a-y desirable sing© :ami ay complex. Voting: Aye: Hc,:ji tz, Spr° nge '� Ccrtrltflr� RcQ!,sa Metenbri ng Hay: Englund ' Abstaining: Emond 30 The Chairman announced -that this was the time and place to 116o/d a pubiic hearing on the request of Keith Harstad,, Ha °olhd Henkel'. and She°don Morlleh on to vezc;ne lots 1a 2, 3 and 4, Sloe: 11, Bounds Viea lei:as Sec-Ond Addition from Light Industrial to Multiple 0;•rel1ingo The South 11 of Lot # is needed to obtain sufficient land auea for Mr. Nor•tenson to c:onsi:ruut 3 - 1€3 unit apa t ment buildings an lots 5v 6. 7 and the South 1-a of Tot Ir-. The abutting oane,­s (Hantcel & liarbtad) feel that any f L�rth6v veduc;tion in the size of the Licht I ndt;s t�,i a1 zoning in Sloek 113 would seriously hine':e.9 poSsi?Ae light industy?ial davelaprrent of this at-ea. and therefore Feel that the reintainder of Block 11 should also be eezored. Paved by Ru4>krs„ sebonded by Springer to defer action until exarai ni r,g proposed dev°alop=_nt in item 4. A21 in favor. Motion ear-tied. too Sheldion Purtenson presented final glans for construction of 3 - ea unit apartment buildings on '00ts 5$ 6v 7 and the South �a of lot 4, b'Jo,�;E; 1'ir tloL;nd. View Acres Second Add i t i ons The cor;ip1ex irxvl d require a va.i ince from the atiniruu.a aiaea requirements of gcYA sq. ft. Also requested was Pe.—mission to use a c:owhi nati c,n on brick. and stucco on the exterior surfs ece a the buildings. 3lovcd by Rocks, seconded by Springer to recon-mend rezoning Of the Sout,�'J of lot 4, Bloc!, 110 Mounds View Acres., Second Addition f6Q.m Light Industrial, to multiple levelling for the fol€titling reasons: Page 3 Planning Booed Minutes Apr i 1 207 109-54 ' Present: zcn i ng, causes cne c,;mers oro;arty to fall within ILA-.-o zoni;ag -lassi j i eati ons -auszng an undue hardship i n ee^velapi ng pro€:erty. 2,. Propell,ty can be bas'd used along %,lith rwltip`Je development to the South. Voting: Are: Coulter, Rocdks„ Mesenbr;ng;, Englund, Sp?inger Play: Howi tz, Emond motion Carried. €oved by Rccks, seconded by Era:cnd to recc-, end denying request to rezune Totes 1, 2, 3 and ff-j of lot 4, Block 11, Hounds View Aires Second Addition fron Light Indus-wial to tau ipde Dvrell inn because -his would seg iously reduce the size or the E i ght i ndustei al tract i n blo%fk 16j. AT l in favor. Motion car,-Ied. Moved by Sps,incgar, seconded by E-ncdlund to appscve plans fo,­ eanseruQtion of 3 - 18 unit apartment buildings on lots 5, 6b 7 and SLI of Tot 4D Block 11, t<icunds Vie;i Acus Second Addition along with the vaeil anc a of 9,9 6 squa a feet in land area requirements and !n o so to allow exLQ, i or suz face to be :.J i elft and stucco. The plums to be appecved subject to appra al of the Vis;age engineers and Build- ing Ynspector , Val-;arse should be granted for the follu.-Ang eentions: 1. The bui wdi rags as i l'Wstrated on the plot Plan al io4<r eagle space for parking, dr°ivwv ays and Breen area. ' 2. Stucdo is net essney to achieve the e;fejt of the ar,;hi teeturai design: and is more comgiatible with the appearan;;e than brick c1' titan could be. Voting: Aye: € o,,Atz, Springer, Pocks, Coulton, Ewiond3 Englund Hay: Mesenbr i rag Potion carried. 5d Bobesu t Christen requested permission to const;-urot a 4 foot by 4 fool: sign advor i si ng tris soil busi nest. at 3501 S i aver Lake Road. Moved by Rucks, seconded by Springer to eeny the request berause commercial operations should noL be advertised in a c=esidonHal district and such signs de- tract, from the beauty cf any residential distriut. All in i7avory. klotion car,led. Mooed by Coulter, bo;:cnded by Englund to request that tho Village Council teke appropeiate action to eliwi',rzate aTl signs in vicnation of Ordinance #66. AT1 in favor. Potion carried. 6. Mobie Swan submitted a request for re?poa'tiun of trei cert within €.oviry Cat ove Mobi Te Mano.e Howi t` stepped dean as C;rai m an Grid appointed Cou 4 teu to Salva as temporary Chai rman� during discussion oft this item. Moved by Sprirtg*r-, seconded by 'Englund to hold a public as required by Crdina,sce 666 at thal naxt regular moetinrg on My US, 19,64. Voting: Aye. Sprillsiqrs Coulter, Rodes, Cncglunl, C„ond, Mes`nbring Abstaining: Howitz Motion carried. Page 4 Planning Board Minutes April 20, 1964 7. The C'nairman eccepted a pet tion from the property owners on the north side of Silver Lane and G:vsi or Silver Lala: Road requesting that before any multiple devalop:�nt by considered on the Apache residential bu-I -i7cr, all possibilities of single family residencas be completely exhausted. 8. Pocks is asked to rsviet: the setback requircimnts as proposed in Ordinanca No. 668 and report at next neeting. 9. Scholz llomes presented a reque-st ;or permission to construct a sign at 33rd Ave. ESE and Highway #$ aovcrtising their r^odel hor,-.t-- on Croft Drive. Moved by Coulter, seconded by Hesenbring to deny permission because the sign would be on residential property. All in favor. Notion carried. 10. Foved by Springer, seconder ry Rocks to request that the Council take appropriate steps to require t,albon 4:;cavating Company to clean up L11air aroa and confinathe non-conforming usage with property designated as suc*�-i. All in favor. Motion carried. ll . Harold Partridge submitted a request for rezoning of property at 37th and Silver LaUe Road to Co,%-mrclal . Moved by Rocks, seconded by C and to table this matter unti 1 Mr. Partridge can attend rrn-eiting and ex.piain his proposal . All in favor. Motion carried. ' 12. The following is the scb:-adule for Planning Board representativas to e�ttend the Council -matings: April 28, 1964 - Thomas Coulter May 26, 1964 - Tronas Emond June 23, 1964 -- Curt Englund July 23, 1964 - Louis Howitz August 25, 1964-Robert Flesenbri ng September 22, 1964 - Erie: Rocks October 27, 1964 - Clem Springer Moved by flesenbring, seconded by Rocks to adjourn. All in favor. motion carried. RCC0iT1tE ' ED COUNCIL ACTION 1. iso action. - 2. Deny request for rezoning to multiple dwelling as outlined. initiata rezoning from Co rcial to R-1 single family residential . 3. No action. 4. Rezone Sig of tot 4 to multiple ch-sailing as outlined. Deny requ3sted razonirg on lots 1, 2, 3 and UJI or lot 4 as outlined. Approve building plans and variances as outlined. 5. Deny request for construction of sign es outlined. Review existing signs and correct violations of Ordinance #66. 6. No action. 7. No action. S. No action. ' 9. Deny request to construct sign. 10. Inform Walbon Excavating Company of violation of non-conforming use restrictions. 11. No action. 12. No action. PLANNING BQRRO 1964 Zone 1 - Louis Howitz, Chairman, 2700 - 27th Ave. N.E. Zone 2 - Erik Rocks, 2907 - 30th Ave. N.E. Zone 3 - Clem Springer, 3304 - 31st Ave. N.E. Zone 4,- Dr. Thomas Emond, 3330 Belden Drive Zone 5 - Thonas Coulter, 3424 Maplewood Drive Zone 6 - Robert Mesenbring, 4000 Fordham Drive At Large - Curt Englund, 2601 Silver Lane PARK & RECREATION BOARD Robert Eagle, Chairman, 2513 Wes t Armour Terrace Robert Bailey, Vice Chairman, 3207 Silver Lake Rd. Frances Kidd, 2704 - 27th Ave. N.E. John Adnrychowicz, 2809 Coolidge St. N.E. George DeAngelo, 3300 Wendhurst Ave. N.E. INDUSTRIAL ADVISARY BOARD Peter Bromme, Chairman, 1826 Maryland Ave. , St. Louis Park Dan Burrill , 3600 Penrod Lane • Robert Dircks, 2712 St. Anthony Blvd.