HomeMy WebLinkAboutPL MINUTES 01171989 Meeting Sheet
IIIIIIVIIIVIIIVIIIVIIIVIII III
IIII
101579
Box: 21
Folder: PL MINUTES AND AGENDAS 1989
Document: PL MINUTES 01171989
C 2 TY OF _C397
_ ANTHONY
P LANN 2 NG COMM= S S 2 ON M 2 NUTE S
,TANUARY 1 7 1 9 8.9
1 The meeting opened at 7: 32 P.M. with the Pledge of Allegiance led by
2 Chair Wagner.
3 ROLL CALL
4 Present for roll call : Brownell , Franzese, Hansen, Wagner, Werenicz,
5 Madden. London arrived at 7: 33 P.M.
& Also present: David Childs, City Manager
7 Sue VanderHeyden, Assistant to the City Manager
8 DECEMBER 20, 1988 PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
9 Motion by Hansen, seconded by Brownell to approve the above with the
10 following changes:
11 Page 5, line 2: Delete one "and" after "month" .
12 Page 5, line 13 : Substitute 116" for 114" before "inch" .
13 Page 6, line 32: Substitute "Overlook" for "Overload" .
Page 7, line 20: Correct typo "no" before "state rules" .
Page 7, line 30: Substitute "trainees" for "massagers" .
16 Page 8, line 43 : Make "treatment" singular.
17 Motion carried unanimously.
18 COMMISSIONER MADDEN TO REPRESENT PLANNING COMMISSION AT JANUARY 24TH
19 COUNCIL MEETING
20 PUBLIC HEARINGS
21 Conditional Use Permit Recommended for Slick's Alternative at 2450 -
22 38th Avenue N.E.
23 At 7.:40 P.M. Chair Wagner read aloud the Notice of Hearing to consider
24 a request from Diane and Robert :Slick for a conditional use permit to
25 allow operation of the Alternative, a non-alcoholic lounge at the above
26 address in the space located immediately west of the Salvation Army
27 Thrift Store as provided in a "C" Commercial zoning classification.
28 The Notice of Hearing had been published in the January 4th Bulletin and
29 mailed to all property owners of record within 350 feet of the subject
30 property. No one present reported failure to receive the notice or
31 objected to its content.
32 Staff Report - Dave Childs
• 1
1 Mr. Childs reiterated much of the information he had provided the
Commissioners in his January 13th memorandum, including:
3 *that the lounge had been forced to relocate from the St. Anthony
4 Village Shopping Center when the H.R.A. acquired that center as part
5 of the Kenzie Terrace Redevelopment Project;
6 *the proposed use met all three criteria outlined in his memorandum
7 required for a conditional use permit for a recreational
8 establishment;
9 *the success of the lounge in its former location and the fact that
10 the Manager was aware of only one police call to the establishment in
11 five years and no other complaints during that period seemed to
12 indicate no problem for the City having the lounge move to the new
13 location
14 *staff received no calls following. the publication of the Notice of
15 Hearing;
16 *the hours of operation have already been established by City Code
17 which requires all recreational establishments to be closed from 1:00
18 to 6:00 A.M. ;
19 *adequate parking space is available to conform with code
20 requirements.
0 A sketch of the proposed signage for the establishment had been sent
22 around for all the Commissioners to view and the City Manager indicated
23 he anticipated that those plans could be adjusted, if necessary, so as
24 not to require a variance. If a variance is required, however, that
25 request could be presented at the next or another future Commission
26 meeting.
27 Proponent - Robert Slick, 3400 Buchanan Street N.B. , Minneapolis, RN
'28 *discussed the site plans in the agenda packet, telling Commissioner
29 Werenicz that there would be 7,758 square feet of space in the new
30 location to accommodate the 68 tables for seating for up to 272
31 persons as compared to the 5,000 square feet in the St. Anthony
32 Village Shopping Center location, which seated about 210 persons where
33 the City Code allowed 300 occupancy;
34 *confirmed that the middle two numbers in the address on his
35 application and repeated in the Notice of the Hearing had been
36 transposed;
37 *pointed out that the St. Anthony location had raised roughly
38 $200,000.00 for Charitable purposes during the five and a half years
39 they had been in operation and had also worked with the community
40 schools to create drug awareness for the students;
2
I *told the Commissioners he and his wife liked St. Anthony and wanted
Wto keep their business in the Village;
3 *reported they were putting together a franchise to go nationwide with
4 the non-alcoholic lounge concept and would want to make the new lounge
5 a prime example of what could be accomplished with that concept;
6 *said he perceived that not only the owners would benefit by upgrading
7 the new establishment, but the whole community would now be offered
8 the "best of all worlds in recreational alternatives" with this non-'
9 alcoholic lounge and the City's liquor operation which is second to
10 the most successful in the state.
it When Commissioner Werenicz asked the applicant what type of security
12 he had at his previous location, Mr. Slick told him the establishment
13 only had a few rules but they were so stringently enforced that he had
14 never needed to hire outside security. He said the only incident of a
15 disagreement which had arisen in the five and a half years he had been
16 in the other shopping center had been over a pool table which had been
17 settled immediately by four other customers in the lounge at that time.
18 Mr. Slick reported that his clientele had always followed the
19 establishment's direction to "treat the lounge like their own living
20 rooms". He said the average age of his customers was between 30 and
21 35 years and no one under 18, even if accompanied by an adult, was
22 allowed in the establishment.
No alcohol or drugs or persons under the influence are allowed on the
premises, according to the applicant, even the bands who play there
25 on weekends are given to understand that if they can't play for four
26 hours without using, they needn't bother to show up at all.
27 Mr. Slick assured the Commissioners that if the increased capacity
28 created problems which couldn't be handled internally, he certainly
29 wouldn't hesitate for a minute to hire as much security as would be
30 necessary. Commissioner Werenicz indicated he perceived the
31 establishment's past history in that area spoke for itself.
32 The proponent reported the lounge would continue to be open from 9:00
33 P.M. to midnight, Monday through Thursday, and from 4:00 P.M. to 1:00
34 A.M. on Fridays and Saturdays when they have a band playing. A disc
35 jockey program is planned for Wednesday nights which would be over by
36 midnight. The owners plan to continue to be open on Sundays from noon
37 to 6:00 P.M. only during the football season.
38 Mr. Slick told the Chair he wanted to be in and operating the new
39 establishment by March 3rd. He told Commissioner Brownell they would
40 not be taking all the vacant space in that building because he
41 understood there were still between 28,000 and 30,000 square feet left,
42 including the loading dock area on the southwest side. There would
43 be new bronzed double doors into the establishment close to the
• 3
1 northwest end of the building and he planned to keep both existing fire
exits open as well , the applicant indicated.
3 Diane Slick and the couple's daughter, Lisa, were also present but
4 didn't speak. When no one accepted Chair Wagner's invitation to
5 provide further input, either for or against the proposal , he closed the
6 hearing at 7 :55 P.M.
7 Commission Recommendation
8 Motion by Madden, seconded by Brownell to recommend that the City
9 Council grant the conditional use permit requested by Diane and Robert
10 Slick to operate the proposed non-alcoholic lounge at 2450 - 38th Avenue
11 N.E. , finding that:
12 1. the questions statutorily required to be answered in the affirmative
13 had been answered properly in the application;
14 2 . there were no calls either for or against the permit prior to the
15 meeting and no one spoke in opposition during the hearing;
16 3 . parking is in conformance with code requirements and the Fire Marshall
17 will be checking out the establishment to assure that all fire codes
18 are met;
19 4. this establishment is perceived to have provided a positive
contribution to the community inasmuch as the operation has been
41 successfully managed without problems for the City for over five years
22 and at. the same time it offered a recreational alternative to the
23 City's liquor operation.
24 Motion carried unanimously.
25 Commission Perceives Variance for Tenant Directory as a Good Trade-off
26 for Long Overdue Improvements to the St. Anthony Shopping Center
27 At 8:00 P.M. the Chair opened the public hearing on the request for the
28 above variance by reading aloud the Notice of the Hearing which had
29 been published in the January 4th Bulletin and sent to all property
30 owners of record within 200 feet of the subject property listed in the
31 agenda packet. No one present reported failure to receive the notice
32 or objected to its content.
33 Staff Report - David Childs
34 *reiterated much of his January 13th memorandum which also was the
35 basis for the motion of approval;
36 *indicated the pylon which was part of the "signage package" would
37 be much more attractive than the existing center identification;
• 4
1 *said the uniform signage plan was something the Council and
Commission had been seeking for a long time prior to granting any
more sign variances for center businesses;
4 *recommended the Commission consider approval of the variance with
5 installation of the tenant directory allowed only after the building
6 facia and new pylon sign have been installed;
7 *agreed with the Eberhardt Company's reasoning that center
8 identification is also needed from Kenzie Terrace from which most St.
9 Anthony customers approach the center.
10 Proponents - Joseph DiSanto, representing the center owners
11 Rod Johnson, Eberhardt Manager of the center
12 Clayton P. Gosswiller and Dick Horst of Coast to Coast
13 Mr. DiSanto told the Commissioners that the owners intend to continue
14 renovating the center investing a quarter of a million dollars in the
15 project. He said:
16 *they would be installing a new sign band all along the facia of the
17 center buildings as indicated in the photos and sign plans distributed
18 for Commission viewing;
19 *the center owners had contracted with Sign Graphics of Dallas, Texas
20 to write the sign criteria and develop a sign design which would be
followed for this center. The same plan is being followed for a
is similar 20 year old center in Dallas which the owners are also
23 renovating;
24 *the sign company had offered a bulk price for individual signs which
X25 the tenants could avail themselves of or contract for signs from a
26 local sign company;
27 *the sign band installation would be a joint project with a local sign
28 company and would serve to back light the individual signs;
29 *their intent would be to totally redo all the existing canopy facia
30 covering that with the sign band to include the library for which his
31 company would be paying for the signage as well as the Mobil station
32 from whom the owners have gotten some preliminary indication that they
33 would cooperate;
34 *the Dairy Queen would not be included because their signage is the
35 company logo.
36 Mr. DiSanto indicated the pylon sign would have the same
37 characteristics as the tenant signage and directory and he gave
38 detailed descriptions of each. He requested that the City allow the
39 directory to be illuminated at night. He also reported that the owners
40 were very close to signing an agreement with Coast to Coast to come into
41 the vacant Penny grocery store and serve as the anchor business for the
0 5
I center. The center owner representative indicated one of the basic
concerns the prospective business representatives had was whether their
store would be provided some sort of visibility from Kenzie Terrace
4 which he said was the main reason he was requesting the variance for
5 the tenant directory on the side of the buildings which now contains
6 no indication to the public of what's inside the center. He said with
7 the proposed directory, this business as well as other businesses in the
8 center who chose to be on the directory will have much needed exposure
9 on that side.
10 Mr. DiSanto indicated further that:
11 *the renovation is planned to start this April and he estimates would
12 take at least a month to complete;
13 *this doesn't mean all center tenants would have their new signs up
14 by then because they have to pay for their own signage and many of
15 the smaller stores may have to have more time to get the money to
16 pay for the sign;
17 *in the meantime the owners are proposing they be allowed to put
18 up temporary "good quality" canvas lettering to identify those stores
19 between the time the facia goes up and the tenants order their
20 individual signs;
21 *although he hoped all the tenants would realize the benefit of having
the new signage, he was not guaranteeing that, would be the case right
away and he pleaded on their behalf for the City to allow such
24 temporary signage.
25 Mr. DiSanto indicated the Eberhardt Manager had already gone around to
26 the 25 tenants in the center with signage packages and designs. He
27 showed as an example the blueprints for the library signage which the
28 owners would be paying for. He indicated Mr. Johnson had already
29 experienced success with some of the larger tenants like Snyders Bros. ,
30 Curtis Mathes, Nationwide Sewing Machine, etc. , who they expected to
31 "jump on the bandwagon right away".
32 Chair Wagner told him he had talked to one of the tenants who might be
33 expected to "drag their feet" on signage and found he and many of the
34 others are planning to put up the new signage.
35 There was a discussion of whether the sign band would be wrapped around
36 the end buildings for stores which already had signage on the sides
37 of their buildings, with Mr. DiSanto saying the band might be expanded
38 past the current signage if the tenants lobbied as he expected them to
39 retain those signs. However, he said Cokesbury had not yet volunteered
40 to put up the new signage but he hoped that once they saw the other
41 stores putting up their signs, they would also do so. The center owner
42 assured the Commissioners that he intended to eliminate all existing
43 signage to ' get "a really contemporary look" for the center with the
44 existing blue color band, and new facia and signs being proposed in the
• 6
1 rendering he presented and what was shown in the pictures of the Dallas
center which he had also passed around. Mr. DiSanto said:
3 *the overhang would be completely covered;
4 *the basic facia color would be a light cream color;
5 *the blue canvas that goes across the top would remain but the yellow
6 would be eliminated with only blue facia and blue on the bottom
7 showing;
8 *at some time further down the road, he would like to talk Snyder
9 Bros. into putting a very good looking prescription sign on the wall
10 between that store and the Fun Center;
11 *the facia would cover that portion of the upright in that area which
12 sticks out now and the portion which Commissioners had expressed
13 concern would be covered up with a color which would blend in with
14 the colors on the building now;
15 *the same color scheme would be carried out in the pylon sign as would
16 be used in the sign band with lettering also to match that for the
17 stores;
18 *the signs would be made up with white background and colored letters
19 and the pylon sign would be interiorly lit.
0 Mr. Childs told Mr. DiSanto he would be recommending that if the
21 directory signage were approved, that sign also be lit from the inside
22 rather than externally. The response was that although it would cost
23 more money, that was the way the center representative would also like
24 to go.
25 Mr. DiSanto told Chair Wagner the sign band would be five feet in height
26 but over the Coast to Coast, the band would be taken to seven feet just
27 to accentuate their being the anchor business in the center. This
28 would be the only store for which this would be done. The sign channels
29 themselves would not be changed geometrically, he said.
30 The Chair told Mr. DiSanto 'he was concerned about extending the sign
31 band around the end building tops and perceived it would be very
32 necessary to get rid of the small signs under the canopy on the walkway.
33 He said he perceived the buildings' facing would not be changed but the
34 store fronts would 'now go from white to stone to brick and different
35 colors like blue on Schwinn's; white for the sewing center and brick for
36 Wycoff's and stone for other stores. However, he wondered what was
37 going to happen regarding store signs which are now under the canopy.
38 Mr. DiSanto indicated that his intent was to have only the signs on the
39 facia; as well as those on the pylon and the directory in the center.
40 He -said he would need City help to enforce the elimination of the
l existing wall signs because he perceived by adopting the proposed sign
7
1 criteria, all existing signage would automatically become non-
conforming. Commissioner Franzese pointed out that the City had already
granted variances for the signs on the sides of the Cokesbury and
4 National Sewing Machine buildings which she already regretted and
5 wondered whether those variances could be overridden. Mr. DiSanto he
6 might seek further financing for extending the sign band around the
7 buildings to include that signage if that became a problem.
8 Mr. DiSanto said he wouldn't like to see large letters go up on the side
9 of those buildings, but would consider those options if the City wanted
10 him to. Commissioner Franzese indicated she perceived a "cleaner look"
11 would result from not having that signage at all. Mr. Childs said he
12 would talk the matter over with the City Attorney but thought that if
13 the City granted the new signage for the center because there is a
14 single ownership of that center, those previous variances would not
15 maintain their standing. He suggested one of the conditions for
16 approving the directory and pylon signs be that all resultant non-
17 conforming signs to the sign criteria must be removed, including all the
18 wall signs. He then suggested the Commissioners recommend a time limit
19 be imposed on the temporary signage being proposed by the center owners
20 under which, if the tenant opts for not buying new signage which is in
21 conformance with the sign criteria, they not be allowed to put up
22 signage after a set time.
23 Mr. DiSanto confirmed that the owners would be paying for the directory
24 and the pylon and would be making space as available to those tenants
who want to be featured on either sign. That signage would also have
to conform with the overall signage for the center, he told Commissioner
27 Franzese. He confirmed that the three empty lines in the pylon
28 rendering duplicated space the center Merchants Association reserved on
29 the existing pylon to promote activities like sidewalk sales, etc. in
30 the center. He also indicated that of course there wouldn't be adequate
31 room on either the pylon or directory for all 25 tenants in the center
32 now, most of whom probably wouldn't want to pay what it would cost to
33 have their names on either sign.
34 Mr. Gosswiller indicated he perceived it would be essential for the
35 directory to identify the center specifically. Mr. DiSanto indicated
36 his intent had been to utilize the upper panels for that purpose with
37 the rest of the space reserved for those tenants who want to be on the
. 38 same sign. The Coast to Coast Manager indicated the market survey his
39 company had taken of the area had indicated that anywhere from 60% to
40 80% of the center traffic comes from Kenzie Terrace, which made him
41 applaud the request for the directory sign which he perceived should
42 identify the center.
43 Mr. DiSanto confirmed that it was the owners' intent to get all the
44 store owners to agree to maintain the same hours for sign lighting and
45 said he would be willing to put that proposal into written form if that
46 was what the City wanted. He also said there might be one or two other
47 colors allowed for signs other than the red, blue, green and orange
48 specified in the sign criteria. He told Commissioner Madden he was
8
1 going to try to get a complementary pattern for that signage but would
be unable to force conformity for stores whose corporate colors might
now allow conformance. He agreed that probably only the four largest
4 tenants would be featured on a directory the size that would be
5 allowed. He reiterated that which tenants appear on the pylon sign
6 would depend on their ability for pay for that signage and the
7 availability of space on the sign. Again the major tenants would
8 probably want to be recognized on that sign which would accommodate only
9 up to about ten names. Commissioner Franzese said she agreed with the
,10 Coast to Coast representative that the directory would be most important
11 because most of the customers would probably come from Kenzie Terrace
12 and need to know the shopping center is there and which stores are in
13 it. She was told that trying to put all the tenant names on one ,sign
14 would tend to diminish the sign's impact much as had happened when the
15 City had acceded to the Apache Medical Building's desire to have all the
16 different businesses listed on their directory, which most Stinson
17 Boulevard drivers hardly noticed at all .
18 Commission Reaction
19 Commissioner Hansen commented that he was "very pleased" with the
20 proposals the owners were making that evening for improvements which
21 were long overdue for that center.
22 Chair Wagner agreed and indicated he perceived a willingness on the
23 Commission's part to do what they could to "clean up some of the loose
ends" like persuading the tenants to take down their existing signs.
25 Mr. DiSanto indicated his appreciation of their comments saying he
26 recognized that, up until he visited the Council in September there had
27 been a lack of good relations between the City and the owners. He
28 said he expected to provide direct supervision of the renovation project
29 and would probably visit the City on a weekly basis until the job was
30 completed. He clarified that the only reason a second sign for a
31 tenant had been mentioned in the Sign Criteria had been because he
32 hadn't understood Coast to Coast's corporate trademark, which was vital
33 to their going into that space, would be considered a part of their
34 sign.
35 Mr. Childs told him that with 78 feet of frontage on the store they
36 would be going into, Coast to Coast should have no problem fitting all
37 that into the 150 square feet of sign surface they would be allowed.
38 He also said the City would count both the lettering and the symbol
39 depicted on the sketch of the proposed sign for that store as one sign.
40 The Commissioners were then told that each tenant would control the
41 power to the individual signs which might make uniformity of hours of
42 lighting difficult with some stores not staying open as long as other
43 businesses in the center.
9
1 Mr. DiSanto told Commissioner Werenicz that he expected some tenant
resistance to the uniform signage at the outset, but if experience with
other centers hold true to form, he really didn't envision a lot of
4 temporary signs remaining up on the fascia once that "new look" is
5 complete. He perceived those store owners who are at first reluctant
6 would eventually feel out of place with signage less attractive than
7 their neighbors. The center spokesman said he knew all those tenants
8 recognized the value of good signage and would think they would want to
9 "jump on the band wagon" as soon as their neighbors but conceded that
10 might not be true of every one of them. He said he could make no
11 promises that compliance would come easily. Mr. Disanto indicated the
12 bulk rate would be offered to each tenant to order signage from the
13 Dallas sign company but each would be given the option of contracting
14 for his own sign as long as it conformed to the specifications for
15 lettering and fit on the anchor bolts on the fascia. He also indicated
16 the Eberhardt people would be "out in full force" after final approval
17 to inform the existing tenants that the Commission had given preliminary
18 approval to the concept and if final approval by the Council follows,
19 uniform signage would be enforced come April . Mr. Johnson indicated
20 he had held a first meeting to present the plan to at least 90% of the
21 tenants and the second meeting would just reconfirm that the sign plan
22 is going into effect and to work out specific lettering for each store.
23 When Commissioner Werenicz asked for guidance related to what he
24 perceived would be a reasonable time limit for getting the temporary
25 removed, Mr. DiSanto said he thought the tenants should at least be
allowed three or four months after April to make up their minds because
he perceived many of the merchants they would be dealing with might not
28 be in a financial position to put up the new signage right away and it
29 might not be fair to force them to comply any sooner.
30 No one present responded to the Chair's invitation to speak either pro
31 or con related to the variance and he closed the hearing at 9:00 P.M.
32 Motion by Franzese, seconded by Madden to recommend the City Council
33 grant a variance from the City's Sign Ordinance to the Eberhardt Co.
...34 on behalf of the St. Anthony Shopping Center for a 6 foot, 6 inch by 6
35 foot, 1 inch (total 39.6 square foot) tenant directory sign to be
36 mounted on the northwest wall of the former Brown Photo location facing
37 Kenzie Terrace as shown in the drawing in the Planning Commission's
38 January 17, 1989 agenda packet.
39 Included in the variance would be:
40 1. The allowance of the new 260 foot pylon sign for the center also
41 included in the agenda packet which would be 40 square feet below the
42 maximum allowed size, and
43 2. Signage criteria for the center tenants which will be used in
44 conjunction with the new sign band for buildings which would allow
45 only individual lettering and has limits on the size and number of
signs.
10
1 The Planning Commission further recommends that the following conditions
be imposed on the granting of this variance:
3 a. The temporary canvas lettering proposed to be put up when the sign
4 band is installed on the fascia sometime around April 1, 1989 to
5 identify those tenants who have not yet signed up for permanent
6 signage would be allowed to remain on the sign band only three months
7 after completion of the sign band.
8 b. All current signage on the building fascia including underhanging
9 signs and wall signs will have to be removed with the installation of
10 the new sign band.
11 c. All sign lighting except that on the pylon sign and the tenant
12 directory will have to be turned off at midnight.
13 d. The variance is valid for a period of 24 months from date of approval
14 after which time it becomes invalid if the project is not started.
15 In recommending this variance be granted, the Planning Commission finds
16 the following special circumstances support the variance request:
17 1) The shopping center fronts on both Highway 88 and Kenzie Terrace but
18 no identification of the center or its tenants is currently available
19 on Kenzie Terrace.
2) The center buildings have their backs on Kenzie Terrace, further
screening their visibility.
22 3) The 39.5 square foot directory when coupled with the 260 square foot
23 pylon sign is still less than the center would be allowed if there
24 were a pylon sign only.
25 4) No calls either for or against the variance were received by staff
26 prior to the hearing and there were no expressions of opposition
27 during the hearing.
28' 5) The three conditions required to be met have been met in this
29 request.
30 In recommending that this variance be granted, the Planning Commission
31 wishes to go on record as commending the owners for making these long
32 overdue improvements to the St. Anthony Shopping Center.
33 Mo ion carried unanimously.
34 Mr. DiSanto advised that another appointment in another city would
35 prevent his ,attendance at the Council meeting where the Commission
36 recommendation would be presented, but indicated Mr. Johnson would be
37 going in his stead.
• 11
1 The discussions between the Commissioners which followed indicated they
perceived it would be only fair to give the tenants most of the summer
to get financing for the signs. The possibility that lighting the
4 signs all night might prove to be an annoyance for the residents in the
5 new apartment buildings going up next to this shopping center who can
6 ' see some of the stores from their windows was explored.
7 MISCELLANEOUS
8 PLANNING WORKSHOP
9 Commissioner Brownell asked Ms. VanderHeyden to make reservations for
10 him to attend the special workshop to be held at the Breezy Point
11 Resort, February 9th. Commissioner Werenicz indicated interest in
12 attending the February 23rd workshop at the Earle Brown Center.
13 ELECTION OF OFFICERS FOR 1989
14 The Commissioners based the following on the indication from the City
15 Manager that although the Council had not been able to officially
16 appoint the incumbents to their same seats on the Commission which were
17 vacated by law at the end of December, he had sensed that was their
18 intent following the interviews of candidates the Council had conducted
19 the previous Thursday evening.
20 Commissioner Madden Unanimously elected to Serve as Planning Commission
Chair
22 Motion by Werenicz, seconded by Franzese to nominate John Madden as
23 Commission Chair for 1989.
24 Motion by Franzese, seconded by Werenicz to elect by acclamation.
25 Motion carried unanimously.
26 Commissioner Hansen to Continue Service as Vice Chair for 1989
27 Motion by Franzese, seconded by Madden to nominate Ron Hansen to serve
28 as Planning Commission Vice Chair during 1989.
29 Motion by Franzese, seconded by Werenicz to elect by acclamation.
30 Motion carried unanimously.
31 ADJOURNMENT
32 Motion by Hansen, seconded by Werenicz to adjourn the Planning
33 Commission at 9:35 P.M.
64Notion carried unanimously.
Respectfully submitted, - -
Helen Crowe, Secretary
12