Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPL PACKET 03161993 Meeting Sheet III I III mill mill gill ioiaza Box: 20 Folder: PL PACKETS 1993 Document: PL PACKET 03161993 CITY OF ST. ANTHONY PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA March 16, 1993 7:00 P.M. CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS I. CALL TO ORDER/PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. II. ROLL CALL. III. APPROVAL OF FEBRUARY 16, 1993 MINUTES. IV. DESIGNATION OF COMMISSION REPRESENTATIVE TO THE APRIL 13, 1993 CITY COUNCIL MEETING. V. PUBLIC HEARINGS -- None. VI. MISCELLANEOUS. A. UTILITY BUILDINGS VII. STAFF UPDATE. VIII. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS. IX. ADJOURN. i 1 CITY OF ST. ANTHONY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING 4 5 FEBRUARY 16, 1993 6 7 8 1. CALL TO ORDER/PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 9 10 The meeting was called to order at 7:00 P.M. and the Pledge of Allegiance was led 11 by Chair Faust. 12 13 2. ROLL CALL 14 15 Commissionmembers Present: Thompson,Franzese,Gondorchin,Madden,and Faust 16 17 Commissionmembers Absent: Murphy and Werenicz 18 19 Staff Present: Management Assistant Urbia 20 21 3. APPROVAL OF JANUARY 19, 1993 MEETING MINUTES 22 23 Motion by Madden, second by Gondorchin to approve the minutes of the January 19, 1993 Planning Commission meeting with the following corrections: 26 page 3, line 7: Correct "the the" to "that the" 27 page 4, line 8: Delete the word "height" 28 page 4, line 44: Delete the word "Avenues" 29 page 4, line 50: Correct "MURP" to "NURP" 30 page 5, line 20: Insert "the between "of' and "New", insert "building" after "Market" 31 page 6, line 16: Correct "rearyard" to "rear yard" 32 page 12, line 41: Correct "by law" to "by-law" 33 page 12, line 42: Correct "by laws" to "by-laws" 34 35 Motion carried unanimously 36 37 4. DESIGNATION OF COMMISION REPRESENTATIVE TO THE MARCH 9, 1993 38 CITY COUNCIL MEETING 39 40 The rotation indicates it would be Commissioner Madden's turn to represent the 41 Commission at the March 9, 1993 Council Meeting. Commissioner Madden advised 42 he will not be able to attend. The rotation indicates Commissioner Gondorchin is 43 next, and Commissioner Gondorchin indicated he would attend the March 9, 1993 44 Council Meeting. 45 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING FEBRUARY 16, 1993 • PAGE 2 1 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS 2 3 A. Accessory Structure Setback Permit 4 5 The public hearing was opened at 7:06 P.M.. 6 7 Management Assistant Urbia provided a staff report. The proposed ordinance. 8 language was provided by the City Attorney, which was previously used in the City 9 of Deephaven. The proposed language will assist residents in building double 10 garages, and allows the Planning Commission and City Council to grant the building 11 of these garages without violating a State law regarding granting variances only if 12 hardship is met. 13 14 Commissioner Madden requested staff research the issue of storage sheds and draft 15 some language that could be included in an ordinance (but not the current proposal). 16 17 Chair Faust opened the public hearing to discussion. Mr. Pete Loomis, 2933 18 Crestview, questioned the difference between a permit and an ordinance. Chair 19 Faust explained how the permit would allow flexibility without having to prove 20 hardship to grant a variance. • 21 22 The public hearing was closed at 7:18 P.M.. 23 24 Commissioner Gondorchin questioned the use of 528 square feet and 24 feet width. 25 Chair Faust and Commissioner Franzese stated that these numbers meet today's 26 standards, and may have to be changed in the future. Commissioner Gondorchin felt 27 the State Building Code should be referenced to see what a standard double garage 28 is. 29 30 Motion by Franzese, second by Madden to recommend approval to the City Council 31 of the proposed Accessory Structure Setback Permit ordinance. 32 33 Commissioner Madden questioned if any reasons would need to be stated in the 34 motion. The Commission felt that would not be necessary. 35 36 Commissioner Franzese raised the concern regarding visibility and sightline issues. 37 She wanted to be sure that a permit would not be granted if it harmed a neighbors 38 visibility/sightlines. 39 40 Motion approved unanimously 41 42 • PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING • FEBRUARY 16, 1993 PAGE 3 1 6. MISCELLANEOUS 2 3 A. Redevelopment Plan -- 3901/3909 Silver Lake Road 4 5 Management Assistant Urbia discussed the TIF proposal and draft redevelopment 6 plan. Urbia stated that the project would not be a lengthy TIF, with a quick payoff. 7 In addition, the benefits to St. Anthony in providing an excellent transitional buffer 8 zone from residential to commercial and the enhancement of the tax base are 9 important to consider. 10 11 Commissioner Gondorchin questioned the hours of operation. Mr. Vogel, who 12 represents the dentist consortium, answered approximately 7 A.M. to 7 P.M., Monday 13 through Friday and something less on Saturday. Commissioner Franzese asked staff 14 what the zoning of the property was. Urbia stated it was commericial. Franzese 15 asked staff if the existing home could be used for commercial for a new business. 16 Urbia stated it could but it would need to be brought up to code if any remodeling 17 took place. Commissioner Thompson asked Mr. Vogel what the berming and foliage 18 plans would be. Mr. Vogel stated that considerable berming and trees would be 19 added to seperate the low-density commercial and residential areas. IR11 Motion by Faust, second by Madden to indicate to the City.Council that the proposed 22 TIF and redevelopment plan at 3901/3909 Silver Lake Road is viable and will 23 enhance the value to St. Anthony. 24 25 B. Concept Review -- 3901/3909 Silver Lake Road 26 27 Management Assistant Urbia explained the proposal for four additional parking 28 spaces. This proposal would require a variance of ten feet from the requirement of 29 a parking lot in a commercial area to be at least twenty feet from a residential area. 30 Urbia said the advantage could be additional parking and less visibility of the 31 refuse/recycling area. A disadvantage is the ability to prove hardship and commercial 32 area encroachment. 33 34 Mr. Vogel explained the reason his client desired a concept review. They wished to 35 "test the waters" to see if the proposal would be feasible. Mr. Vogel discussed the 36 advantages of the four additional parking spaces and the hiding of the 37 refuse/recycling area. 38 39 Commissioners Thompson and Franzese believe that a variance could be granted, as 40 the additional parking and reconfiguration of the refuse/recycling area would be 41 beneficial. Commissioners Faust, Madden, and Gondorchin believe that they could not grant a variance, as they do not see hardship and.the proposal would encroach PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING FEBRUARY 16, 1993 • PAGE 4 1 too closely into the residential area. 2 3 7. STAFF UPDATE 4 5 Members of the Planning Commission received copies of the 1993 Planning 6 Commission roster. 7 8 Management Assistant Urbia announced two Planning Commission training 9 opportunities for Commissioners to consider. Interested Commissioner members 10 should contact Urbia for registration information. 11 12 Members of the Planning Commission received copies of the 1992 Code of 13 Ordinances. Management Assistant Urbia explained the update process, where staff 14 will provide those pages with changes, and each Commissioner is responsible to 15 change their Ordinance book. 16 17 8. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS 18 19 a. Commissioner Madden's Comments 20 Commissioner Madden questioned the Northgate Office Park sign. Management • 21 Assistant Urbia explained staff enforcement efforts, including the sign in question. 22 At the time, no response was given to the staff letter, but follow up will occur. 23 24 b. Commissioner Gondorchin's Comments 25 Commissioner Gondorchin reported on the February Environmental 26 Quality/Recycling Committee Meeting. He stated the meeting was very informative 27 regarding water, sanitary sewer, and stormwater issues. Commissioner Gondorchin 28 stated he will be unable to attend the May 13th meeting due to a conflict, and hoped 29 another Planning Commissioner would be able to fill-in. 30 31 Commissioner Gondorchin stated his displeasure in the manner the City Council 32 handled the RV parking issue in relation to the Planning Commission. He felt for 33 the Commission to work on the issue and then the City Council to indicate it may not 34 want to consider an ordinance. Urbia stated that the Council provided this 35 information, at the request of the City Manager, so that the Planning Commission 36 would know the Council's feelings on the matter so that the Commission may 37 determine the direction to take on the issue. Urbia further stated that the Council 38 did not wish to offend the Commission in any way. 39 40 C. Commissioner Franzese's Comments 41 Commissioner Franzese reported City Council actions at the February. 9, 1993 42 Council Meeting. The City Council did not approve by a 2 to 1 vote the • PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING FEBRUARY 16, 1993 PAGE 5 1 recommendation to amend ordinance language requiring identification signs to face 2 the frontage they are allowed for. The City Council deferred discussion of sign 3 amortization to the March 2, 1993 Council Work Session. Upon the request of the 4 City Manager, the City Council discussed its feelings towards the proposed parking 5 ordinance. The Council did not feel an ordinance would be appopriate, as the 6 problem has addressed itself, probably from further awareness by exposure in the 7 media. 8 9 Commissioner Franzese asked staff the meaning of the Mayor's desire to see the 10 Planning Commission amend its by-laws so that abstension votes may not be taken. 11 Commissioner Madden stated that he voted this way so as not to offend the business 12 community and not approve illegal signs. Urbia stated that Robert's Rules of Order 13 allow for abtension votes, so the Planning Commission technically cannot amend its 14 by-laws to prohibit abstension voting. However, Urbia stated it is a good idea to vote 15 yes or no to assist the Council in a recommendation. 16 17 Commissioner Franzese asked staff if there is funding for membership in the 18 Minnesota Planning Association (MPA). Urbia will check with the City Manager. 19 Other 1 Five to six residents were present to discuss the public hearing for the proposed 22 accessory structure setback permit. The residents missed the public hearing, as the 23 St. Anthony Bulletin had an error in the Notice of Hearing stating the starting time 24 as 7:35 P.M. instead of 7:05 P.M.. The Planning Commission spent time explaining 25 the proposal, what was discussed at the public hearing, and answered questions from 26 the residents. Mr. Jack Novak,who previously received a variance to build a garage, 27 spoke strongly in favor of the proposal. In addition, he complemented the City for 28 taking this sort of action to help St. Anthony residents. 29 30 9. ADJOURNMENT 31 32 Motion by Madden, second by Franzese to adjourn the meeting at 8:35 P.M.. 33 34 Motion carried unanimously 35 36 37 38 Respectfully submitted, 39 40 41 David Mark Urbia, Management Assistant STAFF REPORT DATE: February 24, 1993 TO: Planning Commission FROM: David Mark Urbia, Management Assistant ITEM: UTILITY BUILDINGS The Planning Commission requested information regarding sheds and utility buildings. These items are defined as accessory uses in the following sections: (1) 1615.04 (h); (2) 1616.04 (e); (3) 1620.04; (4) 1625.04 (a); and (5) 1630.04. The Building Inspector, Larry Hamer, requires a building permit to construct these structures. In addition, a cement slab or treated wood base is required so that the bottom of the structure does not decay. Dimensional regulations are covered in the zoning ordinance. Maintenance of these structures are covered in the recently adopted housing maintenance ordinance; especially • the painting procedures. If the Planning Commission is thinking of some other restrictions, they may be presented for consideration to the City Council. STAFF REPORT DATE: February 24, 1993 TO: Planning Commission FROM: David Mark Urbia, Management Assistant ITEM: AGENDA ITEM VII -- STAFF REPORT At the February 23, 1993 City Council meeting, the Council discussed various Planning Commission issues. A summary of the discussion is as follows: Sign Amortization A majority of the Council did not feel this proposal is necessary in the sign ordinance. Further, some members expressed a desire to leave the recently adopted sign ordinance as is for now, and to place no further restrictions upon businesses. Regarding informational signs, a majority of the City Council felt that these signs are not a significant problem at this time. It was suggested that perhaps informational signs could be defined under the sign • ordinance, but that the number of signs and size of signs could be left'to the discretion of the Zoning Administrator. Parking Ordinance A majority of the Council believed that this issue should not be discussed at this time. • CITY OF ST. ANTHONY 3 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 4 5 FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 6 7 8 9 1 . CALL TO ORDER/PLEDGE -OF ALLEGIANCE 10 11 The meeting was called to order at 7 : 00 p .m. by Mayor Ranallo 12 who led the Pledge of Allegiance . 13 14 15 2 . ROLL CALL: 16 17 Council Present : Mayor Ranallo and Councilmembers Marks , 18 Enrooth, Fleming and Wagner 19 20 Staff Present : City Manager Burt and Management Assistant 21 Urbia 22 23 24 3 . APPROVAL OF FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA 25 6 Motion by Marks , second by Wagner to approve the agenda for the February 23 , 1993 Council Meeting as presented with the addition of a resident request for the keeping of three dogs 29 to be heard after the approval of license applications . 30 31 32 Motion carried unanimously 33 34 35 4 . APPROVAL OF FEBRUARY 9, 1993 COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES 36 37 Motion by Marks , second by Enrooth to approve the minutes of 38 the February 9, 1993 Council Meeting as presented and there 39 were no corrections . 40 41 42 Motion carried unanimously 43 44 45 5 . LICENSES/PERMITS/PETITIONS 46 47 Motion by Marks , second by Wagner to approve the following 48 license applications : 49 50 • 1 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING • 2 FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE, 2 4 5 6 7 Garbage Haulers 8 9 Waste Management - Blaine, commercial /residential 10 Vasko Rubbish Removal , Inc . , commercial 11 Twin City Sanitation , Inc . , commercial /residential 12 Aagard Environmental Services , commercial 13 14 15 Service Station 16 17 Mico Oil Company, Inc . 18 19 20 Cigarette Retail 21 22 Mico Oil Company, Inc . 23 24 25 Vending Machines 26 •27 Manor 'Wash 'N' • Dry 28 29 30 Motion carried unanimously 31 32 33 34 _Resident Request for Keeping of Three Dogs 35 36 A letter was received from Dick and Natalie Sitarz, 3205 37 Armour Terrace, requesting a permit to keep three dogs . 38 39 City Ordinance permits a total of two dogs in a household and 40 to keep more than two would require a kennel license. 41 42 Mr . & Mrs . Sitarz were present at the Council Meeting. It was 43 explained that the third dog is owned by .the Sitarz' son and 44 is being housed at their home on a temporary basis . It is 45 their hope that this dog will be going back to live with their 46 son within six months . They also explained that their yard is 47 fenced and that the animal ' s barking is controlled so their 48 neighbors will not be disturbed. 49 50 • 1 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 0 FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE 3 4 5 6 7 Discussion continued regarding what action could be taken by 8 the Council to accommodate their request and not violate the 9 ordinance . It was noted that if there are any complaints 10 received regarding these three dogs the family would be 11 notified . 12 1.3 The City Manager suggested that a temporary kennel license 14 could be issued or a variance could be granted for six months . 15 16 Motion by Marks , second by Enrooth to grant a temporary kennel 17 license to Dick and Natalie Sitarz, 3205 Armour Terrace, for 18 six months and that the license fee be waived . 19 20 21 Motion carried unanimously 22 23 24 6 . PRESENTATION OF CLAIMS 25 26 4 A. Julee Quarve-Peterson , Inc . 29 Motion by Wagner , second by Marks to approve payment in the 30 amount of $1 , 797 . 50 to Julee Quarve-Peterson , Inc . for the 31 handicapp accessibility audit for St . Anthony. 32 33 The City Manager advised that all of the fees due this firm 34 will be paid for from Community Development Block Grant funds . 35 He also stated there wi 11 be a public hearing held in the near 36 future regarding handicap accessibility. 37 38 39 Motion carried unanimously 40 41 42 B. Verified Claims 43 44 Motion by Wagner, second by Marks to .approve the six pages of 45 verified claims 'as submitted by the Finance Director . 46 47 48 Motion carried unanimously 49 50 • 1 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 2 FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE 4 4 5 6 7 7 . REPORTS 8 9 10 A. Council Reports 11 12 13 1 . Report of Councilmember Wanner 14 15 Councilmember Wagner brought greetings from the Special 16 Olympians from St . Vincent . He noted they all were at the 17 airport to say good-bye when he and his wife left for 18 home . He will bring the photos he took to share with 19 members of the Council . 20 21 Councilmember Wagner attended the Ramsey County League of 22 Local Government Meeting. Tax Increment was discussed and 23 he noted there is still confusion between cities and 24 counties . Nothing regarding this matter was resolved. 25 26 27 2 . Report of Councilmember Fleming. • 28 29 Councilmember Fleming attended the recent meeting of the 30 Northwest Youth and Family Services . The need for more 31 space and perhaps a new location was discussed. Locating 32 adjacent to a specific building in New Brighton is being 33 considered. 34 35 Councilmember Fleming quoted from the Northwest 36 Counseling Center ( a division of Northwest Youth and 37 Family Services ) 1992 yearend annual report . She noted 38 that out of a total of 295 new cases for 1992 , only 14 39 were from the St . Anthony School District . 40 41 42 3 . Report of Councilmember Marks 43 44 Councilmember Marks had nothing to report at this time . 45 46 47 4 . Report of Councilmember Enrooth 48 49 Councilmember Enrooth attended the February 22nd Village 50 Fest meeting and he noted that there were many new people W REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE 5 4 5 6 in attendance . At its March meeting, the committee will 7 address a theme, decide on a logo or a variation of a 8 logo and discuss other ideas for identifying the 9 celebration . An ice cream social will be held on Sunday . 10 11 Mayor Ranallo inquired if having a tennis tournament is 12 being considered . He recalled that previously there had 13 been discussion regarding holding a tennis tournament 14 which would be the Clyde Paul Memorial Tournament . 15 16 The Mayor stated that Mr . Paul had been an instrutor at 17 the St . Anthony tennis courts and had perhaps chaired the 18 first Village Fest . Although , he had not been a resident 19 of St . Anthony he had spent significant time 20 participating in community events . He was killed in St . 21 Paul . His widow and father have indicated their 22 willingness to participate in a tennis tournament held in 23 his honor. 24 25 The City Manager will attend the March 2nd Chamber of 6 Commerce Meeting representing the Mayor . 8 Also, the Council will be receiving a letter advising of 29 two scholarships which will be given to St . Anthony 30 students from the Chamber of Commerce. 31 32 The City Manager was requested to advise the Cable 33 Commission that no one will be attending the February 34 25th meeting from St . Anthony . 35 36 Mayor Ranallo advised that March 13th is the date of the 37 Chamber of Commerce City Dance . Tickets are $10 . 00 and 38 will be available at City Hall . Ernie ' s Catering will 39 serve the dinner . 40 41 Discussion followed regarding the availability of wine 42 and beer at -this Chamber function as well as the City' s 43 potential liability . 44 45 The Mayor will be out of town from February 24 through 46 March 6th. 47 48 49 B. Report of the City Manager 50 • 1 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 2 FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE 6 4 5 6 7 1 . Insurance Survey 8 9 The City Manager reminded members of the Council of the 10 need to turn in their insurance survey. 11 12 2 . Goalsettina Session 13 14 March 19th and March 20th are the dates selected for the 15 Council ' s Goalsetting Session . It will be held at the 16 Northland Inn. Karen Ray will be the Facilitator . 17 18 3 . Appreciation Dinner 19 20 The City Manager noted he had contacted the speaker 21 recommended by Councilmember Fleming. The honorarium fee 22 was very expensive . 23 24 The Mayor recalled that Mary Jo Palerento had been the 25 guest speaker at the last Chamber of Commerce Dinner. 26 Some members of the Council felt this was too recent and • 27 some did not feel she was effective . Councilmember Marks 28 had suggested Bob Terry. The' City Manager will continue 29 to look for a speaker for the Appreciation Dinner . 30 31 32 4 . Sian Ordinance - Amortization 33 34 The City Manager advised that the Planning Commission had 35 requested this item be reviewed and then discussed it as 36 a concept . 37 38 The City Attorney had written in his opinion of 39 amortization it would be difficult to justify as the 40 enforcement would begin in ten years ; that is 2003 . 41 42 Councilmember Marks observed that signs which do not get 43 taken down usually need maintenance. The City Manager 44 noted that the City Code does address maintenance . 45 46 The Mayor stated he does not want to bind future councils 47 with legislation . Councilmember Enrooth felt this item 48 was on the agenda only because members of the Planning 49 Commission have voted to support it . 50 • REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE 7 4 5 6 7 Councilmember Wagner recalled that the City Attorney had 8 discouraged approval of amortization when it was 9 previously discussed by - the City Council . 10 11 Two signs which have received considerable discussion are 12 those of Dairy Queen and Happy ' s Potato Chips . 13 14 The City Manager feels the new sign ordinance will 15 address signs not in compliance with the Comprehensive 16 Sign Plan. 17 18 The Mayor inquired what the problem is with the Happy' s 19 sign . The City Manager responded it has been in place 20 since 1968 and has always been well-maintained . 21 Councilmember Marks noted it did not comply but was 22 grandfathered in . 23 24 Mayor Ranallo felt there could be considerable problems 25 resulting from requesting this business to take their 6 sign down after being in place for twenty-five years . He also noted that this sign may comply as there are no 8 actual sales, made out of the building. The signs are 29 directional and informational . 30 31 The City Manager advised that these types of signs , 32 directional and informational , are not defined in the 33 sign ordinance nor are these types of signs controlled. 34 35 Most signs are controlled as to shape, size, and height , 36 but signs which contain menu lists , hours , gas pump 37 directions , etc . are not defined in the sign ordinance . 38 39 The Mayor felt some thought should be given as to what 40 would most benefit the business community . He observed 41 that some of. the commercial and business areas in the 42 City could use some help . He does not support 43 amortization . 44 45 The City Manager advised that the Planning Commission 46 will not hold a public hearing if there is no interest 47 from the City Council regarding amortization . 48 49 50 1 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 2 FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE 8 4 5 6 The Mayor felt maintenance should be enforced . 7 Councilmember Enrooth suggested that the issue has been 8 addressed sufficiently and no further action should be 9 taken . 10 11 12 5 . Parkina Ordinance 13 14 The City Manager advised that the Planning Commission had 15 indicated that some of the most blatant parking problems 16 previously in evidence appear to have disappeared. It was 17 felt the accessory structure/double garage section of the 18 code would help alleviate some of the problems people 19 have been experiencing. With this addition to the code, 20 property owners would be allowed to. construct a two-car 21 garage without having to justify a hardship. 22 23 The City Manager noted that only five people attended the 24 public hearing called by the Planning Commission to 25 discuss this matter . 26 27 Councilmember Wagner felt action should be held off for 28 awhile. The Mayor felt the situation had improved . 29 Councilmember Fleming suggested this issue be evaluated 30 after the spring and summer seasons . 31 32 The City Manager noted that an on-going evaluation would 33 remove this issue from the Planning Commission ' s 34 consideration . 35 36 8 . PUBLIC HEARINGS 37 38 There were no public hearings . 39 40 41 9 . NEW BUSINESS 42 43 A. Approval of 1991/1992 Recycled Content Annual Report 44 45 Motion by Marks , second by Enrooth to approve the 1991 and 46 1992 Annual Report for the use of materials with recycled 47 content in publicly funded construction and remodeling 48 projects . This report was prepared by Dave Urbia , Management 49 Assistant . 50 Motion carried unanimously REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 41 FEBRUARY 23 , 1993 3 PAGE 9 4 5 6 7 10 . UNFINISHED BUSINESS 8 9 A. Liguor Store Prices 1.0 11 The City Manager advised that the prices of liquor store 12 merchandise had been adjusted and there may be an increase in 13 business . He cautioned that anticipated profits may not be 14 realized. 15 16 B. Watershed District Public Hearing 17 18 On February 24th at the Shoreview City Hall the Rice Creek 19 Watershed District will hold a public hearing. 20 21 The City Manager advised that the Silver Lake Property 22 Homeowners Association will present a petition at the public 23 hearing requesting a water quality study of the lake. 24 25 It was noted by the City Manager that the CUB project will not 26 change any water runoff at Apache Plaza as no non-pervious surface will be added. Barr Engineering has been hired to address this matter. 29 30 31 11 . ADJOURNMENT 32 33 Motion by Enrooth, second by Wagner to adjourn at 7 : 50 p.m. 34 35 36 Motion carried unanimously 37 38 39 Respectfully submitted, 40 41 42 Jo-Anne Student , Council Secretary 43 44 45 46 Mayor Clarence Ranallo 47 48 49 ATTEST: 50 City Clerk