Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPL PACKET 06162009 Meeting Sheet IIIIIIVIIIVIIIVIIIVIIIVIIIIIIIIIII 104976 Box: 33 Folder: PL PACKETS 2005-2011 Document: PL PACKET 06162009 CITY OF ST. ANTHONY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA TUESDAY., JUNE 16,, 2009 REGULAR PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING 7:00 P.M. COUNCIL CHAMBERS I. CALL TO ORDER. II. ROLL CALL. III. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. IV. APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA. V. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES OF MAY 19., 2009. VI. COMMUNICATION WITH CITY COUNCIL. VII. PUBLIC HEARINGS. NONE VIII. CONCEPT REVIEWS. VIII.1. Electronic Sign N Wilshire Park Elementary School IX. OTHER BUSINESS. X. REPORTS FROM STAFF. XI. COMMUNITY FORUM. Individuals may address the Planning Commission about any item not included on the regular agenda. Speakers are requested to come to the podium, sign their name and address on the form at the podium, state their name and address for the Clerk's record, and limit their remarks to five minutes. The Planning Commission may refer the matter to staff for a future report or direct the matter to be scheduled on an upcoming agenda. XI. INFORMATION AND ANNOUNCEMENTS. XIII.ADJOURNMENT. F:\P1anning\PC Agendas\2009\06162009 pc agenda.doc T 1 CITY OF ST. ANTHONY 2 3 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING 4 5 MAY 19, 2009 6 7:00 p.m. 7 8 9 I. CALL TO ORDER. 10 11 Chair Stromgren called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. 12 13 II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. 14 15 Chair Stromgren invited the Commission and the audience to join him in the Pledge of Allegiance. 16 17 III. ROLL CALL. 18 19 Commissioners Present: Chairperson Stromgren; Commissioners Jensen, Cincoski, Heinis, 20 Jenson, and Crone. 21 Absent: Commissioner Chaput. 22 Also Present: Assistant City Manager Kim Moore-Sykes. 23 24 IV. APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA. 25 26 Motion by Commissioner Jensen, second by Commissioner Jenson, to approve the Planning 27 Commission Meeting Agenda of May 19, 2009. 28 29 Motion carried unanimously. 30 31 V. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES 32 33 The following correction was requested to the April 21, 2009 Meeting Minutes: 34 Page 4, line 17: "...to plant trees and more ivy to beati€y beauti Central Park." 35 36 Motion by Commissioner Jensen, second by Commissioner Heinis, to approve the April 21, 2009 37 Meeting Minutes as amended. 38 39 Motion carried unanimously. 40 41 VI. COMMUNICATION WITH CITY COUNCIL 42 43 Commissioner Jensen will attend the May 26, 2009 City Council meeting. 44 45 VII. PUBLIC HEARINGS 46 47 VII.1. ORDINANCE AMENDMENT TO 155 SIGNS —TEMPORARY OUTFIELD SIGNS 48 (TABLED) 49 Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 2 1 Chair Stromgren opened the public hearing at 7:04 p.m. 2 3 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes introduced the item and stated the Commission has been 4 provided with a memorandum of clarification prepared by Mr. Brever, representing the 5 applicant. 6 7 Chair Stromgren stated feedback has been received from the City Council through the City 8 Manager that they would like the Commission to address the broader, more central question of 9 allowing signage in the park. The City Council felt that the Commission was getting mired in 10 details that would be handled in the conditional use permit. 11 12 Mr. Eric Brever, Foster & Brever PLLC, representing St. Anthony Baseball Association 13 (SABA), addressed the Planning Commission and provided an overview of the analysis on the 14 following conditions included in the memorandum of clarification with regards to the proposed 15 ordinance amendment: 16 o Signs may not be erected within 250 feet of a residential district 17 ° Individual signs cannot exceed 60 square feet in surface area 18 o Aggregate sign area cannot exceed 15% of the fence or wall area surrounding the field 19 (or a cumulative of 500 square foot total, whichever is less) 20 21 Commissioner Jensen stated in condition no. 5 of the proposed ordinance text amendment there 22 is discussion on an aggregate total of 500 square feet, but it is not clear that the description 23 would mean per facility sign. He pointed out that presuming that the ordinance should be broad 24 and encompass all of Central Park, 500 square feet total per institution spread over all of the 25 fields would bring it to a smaller number. He requested clarification if the intent was to divide 26 the signage between the baseball and football fields. Regarding condition no. 6, all signs being 27 removed by a date certain may be a question that would come up at some time 28 29 Mr. Troy Urdahl, St. Anthony High School Athletics Director, stated in regard to condition no. 5, 30 he does not see that there will be signs at the baseball field and the football field at the same time 31 due to the nature of their seasons, so that limitation would not hamper what is being sought here. 32 The signs would be taken down from the baseball field at the end of the organized summer 33 season. 34 35 Mr. Brever stated the permit would cover the facility being used; each facility would require a 36 separate permit. He noted the ordinance text amendment is limited to educational institutions. 37 This would exclude organizations such as Village Fest or sports boosters from the conditional 38 use permit process. The Commission may want to consider expanding the amendment process to 39 include nonprofits. 40 41 Commissioner Heinis questioned whether people are nostalgic for signs, especially in the park, 42 which is a reason stated by Mr. Brever to support the ordinance rewrite. Mr. Brever replied that 43 the intent is to use signage in a way that is not inconsistent with what other cities and schools are 44 doing. The signs are intended to draw the attention of the crowd that is present for the particular 45 event and will support the local businesses. 46 Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 3 1 Commissioner Jensen questioned if "fence or wall area surrounding the field" included in 2 condition no. 5 is a statement that is specific enough. Mr. Brever replied he is open to the 3 Planning Commission modifying this statement. There is a legal technicality in which someone 4 could take the position that a tennis court or hockey rink is not a field and would not be included 5 in that definition. It is an interpretation aspect. The end result will be that of staff being 6 responsible for the enforcement. Some guidance from this body and the City Council may be 7 helpful so that staff knows what is intended. 8 9 Chair Stromgren closed the public hearing at 7:30 p.m. 10 11 Chair Stromgren noted currently no signage is allowed in the park short of trail markers and 12 informational signage put up by the City. He requested discussion by the Commission on 13 whether it appropriate to allow signage, and if so what kind of adjustments should be made. 14 15 Commissioner Jensen commented he can see the nostalgic argument as it relates to the field. The 16 proposal for being generic would have additional merit if there were a photo-shop rendering 17 created of what a maximum amount of signage would be in the field, rather than just waiting for 18 the CUP process. This would allow a contrast with someone's worst vision of the signage. He 19 pointed out that MnDOT posts signs for adoption of certain locations and he could see that the 20 City could see the need for additional signage in the future. This ordinance amendment would 21 allow a process and open the door with the CUP process. The code could be modified at this time 22 with the City Council allowed to ultimately decide on the merits of a given proposal. He 23 suggested amending the text included in condition no. 5 from "...the field" to "...any given 24 sports facility or field". He noted that good facilities end up being draws for matches of any 25 given type of sport. 26 27 Commissioner Jenson noted the question included on the agenda is whether to allow the 28 ordinance to allow temporary signs posted on athletic fields in Central Park of a commercial 29 education or philanthropic nature. He questioned if Commissioner Jensen's comments address 30 this statement. Commissioner Jensen replied the general concept does. However, it comes down 31 to what is adopted in the code. If the words are not consistent with the general phrase it may 32 result with word games. Chair Stromgren noted there will be a CUP process involved. He 33 indicated he would be leery of including quantified requirements if this will be more generic, 34 because it becomes a bar that becomes the limit. 35 36 Commissioner Heinis stated his position that he is not a supporter of commercial speech in the 37 City's parks. 38 39 Commissioner Crone commented it was relaxing watching a ball game today at a park without 40 signage. However, she can see the advantages of the signage and the excitement for the kids. She 41 indicated her preference for the local representation in the signage and noted this would likely be 42 covered in the details of the CUP. 43 44 Commissioner Cincoski stated his support of allowing the, signage if it is monitored and 45 controlled which would be done through the CUP process. 46 Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 4 1 Commissioner Jenson stated he likes the cleanliness of the fields, but can see advantages with 2 advertising that can bring money for the programs. He inquired about the ability to pull the 3 allowance of signage through the CUP if there is significant feedback from the residents that the 4 signage is undesired. Chair Stromgren noted this is likely easily done through the CUP process. 5 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes indicated there have been occasions where an ordinance 6 amendment was made with a sunset date and reevaluated at that point. 7 8 Commissioner Jensen stated he would propose that signage only being allowed through a CUP is 9 a sunset in and of itself. He stated his support of allowing the ordinance and text amendment to 10 move forward. 11 12 Chair Stromgren stated he does not find the signage objectionable when done under a controlled 13 environment. He has looked at it from all sides of the park and does not see it to be an issue. He 14 suggested a sunset provision of three years to allow time to see if the signage is an issue. 15 16 Commissioner Jenson indicated his support of the proposed sunset provision. 17 18 Motion by Commissioner Jensen, seconded by Commissioner Cincoski, to recommend 19 acceptance of the ordinance text amendment proposal to allow signage within the Central Park 20 area as proposed. 21 22 There was discussion on whether to include a sunset provision in the ordinance amendment. 23 Commissioner Jensen suggested recommending that the City Council determine whether to 24 include a sunset time period of four to five years in the ordinance amendment. 25 26 Consensus of the Commission was to include the following text and conditions in the ordinance 27 text amendment to Section 155, Sign Ordinance: 28 29 Subject to the approval of the City Council and as a conditional use, an educational or 30 nonprofit institution may post signs displaying commercial, educational or philanthropic 31 messages on walls or fences located around sports fields, subject to the following minimum 32 conditions: 33 1. Signs must face inward, toward the playing field; 34 2. Signs shall not be permitted to flash or contain any animation or internal illumination; 35 3. Signs may not be erected within 250 feet of a residential district; 36 4. Individual signs cannot exceed 60 square feet in surface area; 37 5. Aggregate sign area cannot exceed 15% of the fence or wall area surrounding the 38 field(or a cumulative of 500 square foot total,whichever is less; and 39 6. Signs may be displayed for up to six months per calendar year. 40 41 Commissioner Cincoski questioned if the term"sports fields" with the distance requirements will 42 allow for signage at the football field. Mr. Brever replied it would allow signs on one side of the 43 football field. 44 45 Motion carried 5-1. (Commissioner Heinis opposed). 46 Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 5 1 Chair Stromgren stated the text amendment will be included on the May 26, 2009 City Council 2 meeting agenda. 3 4 VII.2 LOT SPLIT REQUEST 4017 SILVER LAKE ROAD 5 6 Chair Stromgren opened the public hearing at 7:53 p.m. 7 8 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes presented the staff report for the proposed lot split for 9 4017 Silver Lake Road to create two single-family residential lots; 4017 Silver Lake Road and 10 proposed 4016 Penrod Lane. She stated earlier this year, Ms. Susan Lindberg contacted staff 11 looking for information about applying for a lot split of 4017 Silver Lake Road. Ms. Lindberg 12 had inherited this property and has had it on the market for sale. The marketing of this property 13 has produced an interested buyer for the portion of the current lot that would be vacant should 14 the lot split be approved by the City Council. 15 16 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes stated a recent survey of the lot as it currently exists shows 17 it to be an interior lot of 21,214 square feet or .487 acres. Of this 21,214 square feet, 99 square 18 feet is reserved as a right-of-way for Silver Lake Road and 1,117 square feet that was originally 19 intended for an easement for an alley that was never used. The resultant lots, if the lot split 20 application is approved, would have Parcel A with 11,166 square feet, including the alley 21 easement and Parcel B with 10,048 square feet. Both parcels will be conforming lots as required 22 by the City's Zoning Ordinance with a minimum of 9,000 square feet. Parcel A will retain the 23 address of 4017 Silver Lake Road and Parcel B will be 4016 Penrod Lane. The buyer proposes to 24 build a single family structure once he closes on the purchase of Parcel B. Staff has asked the 25 City Attorney if it is necessary for the City to vacate the alley easement. He indicated that since 26 it is wholly contained within the lot and of no use, it is not necessary to vacate it. 27 28 Ms. Susan Lindberg, applicant, addressed the Planning Commission. She noted that the first time 29 the lot was split it was split up the middle of the house. 30 31 Commissioner Jensen questioned if there has been any discussion about having the back lot line 32 of the new vacant lot match the comers of the other lots on Penrod Lane. He pointed out that this 33 would create a bigger lot for the single family home fronting on Silver Lake Road that is more 34 likely to convert to something else in the future, and that the County sometimes requests more 35 frontage on Silver Lake Road. He stated his position that it would be wise for the applicant to 36 have the alley vacated while going through the recording of the property. 37 38 Chair Stromgren noted the property is currently zoned R-1; any future development would 39 require a rezoning of the property. Commissioner Jensen commented that the Guide Plan 40 identifies a slightly more intense use of the property. 41 42 Chair Stromgren closed the public hearing at 8:05 p.m. 43 44 Motion by Commissioner Jensen, seconded by Commissioner Crone, to recommend approval of 45 the lot split for 4017 Silver Lake Road to create two single-family residential lots; 4017 Silver 46 Lake Road and proposed 4016 Penrod Lane. Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 6 1 2 Motion carried unanimously. 3 4 Chair Stromgren stated the lot split will be included on the agenda of the May 26, 2009 City 5 Council meeting agenda. 6 7 VII.3 CUP—IKAM CHILD CARE, LLC; 3055 OLD US HWY 8 8 9 Chair Stromgren opened the public hearing at 8:05 p.m. 10 11 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes presented the staff report for the conditional use permit 12 application for Ikram Child Care, LLC; 3055 Old US Hwy 8. She stated Ms. Kalthum Jama, 13 Ikram Childcare, LLC, has requested a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow Ikram Daycare to 14 be located at 3055 Old US Hwy 8, also known as the St. Anthony Business Center. The subject 15 property is zoned Light Industrial. The applicants presented a CUP application to the Planning 16 Commission in a concept review held at the March 17, 2009 Planning Commission meeting. 17 The applicant has followed the procedure in applying for a CUP as outlined in Section 152.243 18 (Conditional Use Permits). An application for the CUP was made on forms provided to Ms. Jama 19 by staff. The application was signed and dated and the fee in the amount as specified in Chapter 20 33 of the City Code was attached to the completed application. The public hearing notice for the 21 May Planning Commission meeting was published in the City's legal newspaper and notices 22 were mailed to property owners adjacent to the property, according to Sections 30.45 through 23 30.48. The application is scheduled for the May 26, 2009 City Council meeting for 24 consideration. Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes reviewed the items for consideration of the 25 CUP. She stated staff received no calls or emails opposing this CUP application. 26 27 Ms. Madera Jama, representing the applicant, addressed the Planning Commission and stated the 28 following regarding the conditions of the CUP: 29 13 Licensing: They have been in contact with the Fire Marshals and they are reviewing the 30 plan. Before they get their license from the State to operate a licensed childcare the Fire 31 Marshal will need to inspect and approve the building. They have also been in contact 32 with the Health Inspector and the City's Building Inspector to inspect the building. 33 o Traffic control and parking_ They have two parking lots, one at the main front entrance 34 that will be used specifically for buses. The second parking lot is in back and will be used 35 by parents, visitors, employees, and other people with business at the childcare. 36 13 Play Area: The playground is a little over 2,500 square feet and will be fenced. The 37 building and playground are connected. 38 39 Ms. Jama stated the building is about 2,700 square feet. There will be a total of three doors; one 40 as an emergency exit in the back, the second is for teachers to lead the children to the 41 playground, and the third is the main entrance where there will be a receptionist. 42 43 Chair Stromgren requested the applicant to provide a plan showing the corrected location of the 44 daycare in the building and highlighting the playground area when the CUP request is reviewed 45 by the City Council. 46 Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 7 1 Ms. Jama stated the daycare director informed her that there will be fence around the building 2 and parking lot. A blueprint of the parking lot can be provided. 3 4 Chair Stromgren closed the public hearing at 8:17 p.m. 5 6 Commissioner Jenson suggested the applicant complete a survey that shows the interior section, 7 parking section, and playground section to show how they are linked and how it will be laid out 8 in a safe manner. 9 10 Motion by Commissioner Jensen, seconded by Commissioner Crone, to recommend approval of 11 the Conditional Use Permit for Ikram Daycare Centers, 33055 Old US Hwy 8, with the following 12 with conditions: 13 1. Appropriate Licensure Required. City Ordinance defines daycares as facilities regulated 14 by state law where adult supervision and care is provided for three or more children 15 (Section 152.008). Chapter 245A of the Minnesota Statutes requires licensure for such 16 facilities. 17 2. Traffic Control. Off-street loading areas shall be provided on site and designated for the 18 forward travel of vehicles both on entering and leaving the premises. This access should 19 be easily navigated in and out but allow for the safe drop-off or pick-up of children. This 20 pick-up and drop-off area shall be close to the building. Walkways should be available to 21 provide safe movement between the facility and the loading and/or parking areas. 22 3. Parking. Required parking shall include one space for each employee on the largest shift; 23 all spaces must be at least 9 feet by 19 feet and must be clearly marked and outlined; and 24 at minimum, one visitor space for every ten children is suggested by staff. This figure is 25 based on language from similar ordinances from Metro cities. 26 4. Signs. Signs are permitted as allowed in Title XV, Section 155.29 (C) of the City's 27 Code. 28 5. Play Area. The area for a designated play area must be adequate for the number of 29 children at the daycare facility and according to any requirements of state licensure. This 30 area must be fenced and secure. Walkways should be designated to provide safe 31 movement between the facility and the play area. 32 33 Motion carried unanimously. 34 35 Chair Stromgren stated the CUP application will be included on the May 26, 2009 City Council 36 meeting agenda. 37 38 Commissioner Jensen requested verification that condition no. 3 requires one visitor space for 39 every ten children. Assistant City manager Moore-Sykes responded in the affirmative. 40 41 VIII. CONCEPT REVIEWS 42 43 VIII.1 FENCE VARIANCE— 2912 SILVER LAKE COURT 44 45 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes presented the staff report for the fence height variance 46 concept review for 2912 Silver Lake Court. She stated the owner of 2912 Silver Lake Court, Mr. Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 8 1 Ronald Severson, contacted staff asking about the process for obtaining a two (2)-foot variance 2 to the City's fence ordinance Title XV, Subsection 150.072, (C) Fence Size. She advised that the 3 City's ordinance restricts the height of fences at the building setback or behind to six (6) feet. 4 Mr. Severson reported that his property is adjacent to 2916 Silver Lake Court, the owners of 5 which were granted a 2-foot variance in 2008 to install an 8-foot back fence to block out traffic 6 noise and street lights from Silver Lake Road. Mr. Severson indicated that he too has to deal with 7 the same traffic noise and street lights. 8 9 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes stated staff provided Mr. Severson with information about 10 the application and approval process for obtaining a variance including a timeline. He agreed to 11 come to a concept review to explain his request and receive input from the Planning 12 Commission. 13 14 Mr. Ronald Severson, applicant, addressed the Planning Commission and stated the fence was 15 last replaced in 1984. His neighbors at 2916 Silver Lake Court put in a new fence and received a 16 variance to go eight feet; however, they are a little closer to Silver Lake Road than his property 17 is. There is also an eight foot fence at the next lot, 2920 Silver Lake Court. He stated his fence 18 sits down due to a drainage area, so the current six foot height does not come up as high. A 19 somewhat taller fence would help with the noise from Silver Lake Road and to screen the things 20 in the yard at the house behind his. The primary reason for the fence request is for the screening 21 and the noise from Silver Lake Road. 22 23 Chair Strom en suggested a depiction at the public hearing of the elevation of the lot and how 8x' gg � p g 24 much it dips. 25 26 Commissioner Jenson verified with Mr. Severson that his adjacent neighbor and the next 27 neighbor have eight foot fences. 28 29 Commissioner Jensen stated visually the screening and the uniformity makes sense in this case, 30 and the hardship is not caused by the applicant. One thing to be aware of is if there is a drainage 31 easement in the area preserving the ability for water to move. 32 33 Chair Stromgren stated he understands the applicant's desire for the fence and that topography 34 would be an important consideration. 35 36 Commissioner Jensen noted this slightly higher fence would be for a property within 150 feet of 37 a major collector street. He does not believe they will be setting themselves up for fence 38 applications throughout the City. He suggested through housekeeping they may want to allow 39 fencing to be two feet higher than the six foot limit for properties that are a certain amount of 40 feet from a major collector,which could be done through staff. 41 42 Chair Stromgren noted the rationale for the variance for the adjacent property at 2916 had to do 43 with the direct noise and traffic issues, as well as light from the Laundromat located in New 44 Brighton that is open late. 45 46 IX. OTHER BUSINESS. Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes May 19, 2009 Page 9 1 2 IX.1 ADOPTION OF 2009 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN UPDATE 3 4 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes stated this is the last in many steps proposed by the 5 Metropolitan Council for approval of the City's Comprehensive Plan Update. There are a few 6 ongoing work items that will be ultimately included in the document and adopted as part of a 7 future update. The City has been given the go ahead by the Metropolitan Council to do a formal 8 acceptance or approval of the City's current 2008 Comprehensive Plan. 9 10 Motion by Commissioner Jensen, seconded by Chair Stromgren, to recommend approval of the 11 City's 2008 Comprehensive Land Use Plan Update, subject to changing the picture on the front 12 cover to be something in St Anthony such as an aerial of Central Park, schools or city facilities. 13 14 Motion carried unanimously. 15 16 X. REPORTS FROM STAFF 17 18 Assistant City Manager Moore-Sykes reported the June meeting agenda will include a public 19 hearing on a Conditional Use Permit application by T-Mobile for antenna placement and 20 equipment storage placement at Kenzington and a public hearing on the fence variance 21 application at 2912 Silver Lake Court. 22 23 XI. COMMUNITY FORUM. 24 25 None. 26 27 XII. INFORMATION AND ANNOUNCEMENTS. 28 29 None. 30 31 XIII. ADJOURNMENT. 32 33 Motion by Commissioner Jensen, second by Commissioner Crone, to adjourn the meeting at 34 8:35 p.m. 35 36 Motion carried unanimously. 37 38 Respectfully submitted, 39 Carol Hamer 40 TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. STAFF REPORT To: Planning Commission Report No.: VIII.1 From: Kim Moore-Sykes,Assistant City Manager Date: June 16,2009 Subject: CUP Proposal for Electronic Signs for SAMS/SAHS and Wilshire Elementary School Requested Action: Concept Review for CUP Request for Electronic Signs Date Application Received: N/A Property Address: 3303 - 33,d Avenue NE and 3600 Highcrest Road Zoning District: Recreational/Open Space 60-Day Expires: No Application Received Waiver Letter Required: Yes Date Sent: No Future Action: Public Hearing on submitted CUP application at a Planning Corniwsion meeting. Background: Linn Bjomrud, Wold Architects and Engineers,contacted Staff to ask about the process for obtaining a Conditional Use Permit (CUP). He advised that his firm had been hired by the ISD 282 to design and install electronic signs at the St. Anthony Middle School /High School property on 33rd Avenue NE and at Wilshire Park Elementary located at the corner of Highcrest Road and 37th Avenue NE. Staff advised Mr. Bjornrud of the process and the City's sign ordinance regarding electronic signs (155.29 DISTRICT SCHEDULES, (D),electronic signs are permitted with an approved CUP;flashing and animation are prohibited; (2)(a) and hours of operation restrictions (2)(b) ). Mr. Bjornrud indicated that originally, animation had been planned as part of the software program the school district was interested in using for the electronic signs. The School District have since reconsidered and removed the animation from the plan. Mr. Bjornrud initially attended a concept review at the April 21st Planning Commission meeting to discuss the School District's initial proposal. Since that meeting,the School District has reconsidered their initial electronic sign proposal to add an additional electronic sign for Wilshire Park Elementary School. Mr. Bjornrud is here again to report on those changes. Action: None;no application has been submitted to the City. Attachments: • Design Drawings of the Proposed Signs • Aerial Photo of ISD 282 Properties re: Proposed Sign Placements 06162009 concept review animated electronic sign.doc DETAIL OF • • MINNESOTA 305 ST. PETER STREET A ILINOIS WOLD ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS O ST.PAUL,MN 55102 MICHIGAN COLORADO 6 6 R 2'-0' 6'-8" 2'-0' PREGAST SHAPE #1 I ELECTRON IG MESSAGE SIGN m BRICK 1, TYPICAL SURFAGE MOUNTED LOC70 WITH "HALO" BAGK LIGHTING zo St.Anthony bm New Brighton C4 INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 282 PREGAST SHAPE #2 MONUMENT V CGN EAST/WEST ELEVATION 4 26.1 SF NOTE: PROP05ED SIGN SURFAGE COPY AREA SHONN HATCHED. TOTAL = 31A 5F PER SIDE 11.2 5F TOTAL = 15.8 5F 6RAND TOTAL 1�1.2 5�F TOTAL = < ALLOWED 80 S.F. SIGN SUI IFA DOPY ARE, 2 1/4" = 1'-0" PROJECT: SAINT ANTHONY SECONDARY SCHOOL 2009 IMPROVEMENTS DATE: 2/18/09 COMMISSION NO: 082150 21010 REVISIONS: Q REV.DATE: G\zvttpra]etLfil-\SL Anti"New Brighton 614rA"105306 AN N5 H5(Ibj0mrud).M LE SN SR RON wak, MW a� r C3rlcr \��\\�� IN MX IN E Nil \\ Cz: \\�\ .\\ �`\\�gg\\r`.k\\g\ ::: `\ \\tea\ �\\�\ r■• A A r■a A - • RAP` au.'....a qpt ru• • ♦ ■ ■ s •Ii�U111110 �'�� a�ZZ� ��� NN •�• yrm,��`° :.^ys.ay��'a'�v; y ys � $,'� 1� .;,F� �3?�,,0•■ � ��\��y.-4,1 l Re t NOME Nunn NomeIlliolo AAA FiSiam MEN 11000 00.2 14090 A f MEMO MEMO AAS omen DETAILOF CONSTRUCTION � WOLD ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS ANDERSON-JOHNSON O ASSOCIATES� 305 ST.PETER STREET ST.PAUL,MN 55102 INC AefAFAX: 651.223.5646 TEL: 651.227.7773 LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE SITE PLANNING • CIVIL ENGINEERING 110 N.BROCKWAY,SUITE 220 7575 GOLDEN FALLEYRO ID SbJTE 2011 511NNE IPOLI.S.AIN 55427 1'.IX Phi/5444J531 PHI7631544-712Y PALATINE,IL 60067 FAX: 847.241.6105 TEL: 847.241.6105 / 2R1GA BULLYNC 4 CRASS w ro L- ,o ±0.5 126.5 "I n -' Sr ANTHONY HIGN SCNOIX � 1 �o FT CHAIN 4K FENCE O -EMT JA) 8e.7 ;4 251.6 !� caYacrT CRASS 1 CRASS - -' KEYSTONE WALL { 4"WIDE PAINT d"WIDE PAINT STRIPE @ 3'0.(TYP) STRIPE(TYP.) DROP OFF/VISITOR PARKING ' PAINTED ACCESSIBLE 5.� SYMBOL(TYP) { IAR-WHITE +•i'v"N 2d OP BAR, HITE 4 FT CHAIN f " MONUMENT SIGN tUR( FENCE '- r I N<Y IC41 YY15 OF]AVC. P(7 YO3 CO. S[C} S CONCRETE o ° P L � � lY LW£ IK KMY 1/4 Kr_OE T7►.=.t=• 33rc� � C N C R E T E A 6 0 25 50 SUBJECT: MONUMENT SIGN LOCATION DATE: 02/18/2009 COMMISSION NO: 082130 rRb REVISIONS A REV. DATE 06/10/09 ��4 Print,- Maps Page 1 of 1 Bing Maps. s ` SA Middle School/High School — i Electronic Sign Placement =; - FREE' Use Live Search 411 to find rnnuies, businesses rnote: 800-CALL-411. 33rd Ave NE i a Ave NE r 0 a e � na db9 a o t i � ifI r ' r - .b-, - 33rd Ave NE 33rd Ave NE Bird's eye view maps can't be printed, so another map view has been substituted. http://www.bing.com/maps/print.aspx?mkt=en-us&z=2&s=b&cp=rh46wk76ywdq&pt=pb 6/11/2009 .ty d���n.�dF r�� rf�// ��'�ii���i��i��%�A.`.� �'�►� Qz:'�._my�f �fr'Ji.• ` ^� 'J/+Ylr.rl'� 1JF} �Vi S fj C� I.�.����� .�... ♦ �.�.�A��♦ �.��i�.i% f����r. � t' . 04 510 �tYttttttttttttttl�ttttHtttttt\'. � A 'A3' �%� �����_�_ .. t• W 1 %6. ©^lull:-�E;�ii lid SEEMS soon MEMO I .�►:-'v=]V�ttttllt � '.-..�,...n.�-::++i..^--rte-��-��� Il W il• V t- II •llpl �.� mos III ti� � �_ �•... � '�' � � � I� ���� �•,� •: l '� �. t^ _�. ^gill;,��`I �� all►.. �'� ,.,,�' �-' ,ISA. �l IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIillllllfll.+�• [Aiii ' IhIf=11-11=1f.=f OEM mono 11MOM !EOMEMO Inomm MOMM Room iii DETAIL OF • • ANDERSON-JOHNSON WOLD ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS E ASSOCIATES, 305 ST.PETER STREET _ ST.PAUL,MN 55102 INC. �� � FAX: 651.223.5646 TEL: 651.227.7773 LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE SITE PLANNING CIVIL ENGINEERING 110 N.BROCKWAY,SURE 220 LD 7575 GOLDEN P:ILLEYRO:ID .SUITE 7187 AIIKNEIPOLLS AIN 53477 F.IX 063)544-0531 PH 1763)544.7129 PALATINE,IL 60067 FAX: 847.241.6105 TEL: 847.241.6105 J , �37 allummous - - - - - - - - - - - 0 / -wi FD""a" ° A55— ° NUMENJ SIGN • I I nn+c",war ��1j1! So,Oa sa r COW GRASS GRASS v orswo 1606 134.6 ''• ' K' _ cow I n �.h� m 4.9 --- Y_' O 11 COK J2C.7w 2 9Li di 0 0 25 50 SUBJECT: MONUMENT 516N LOGATION DATE: 02/18/2009 COMMISSION NO: 082129 R REVISIONS REV.DATE 06/10/09 G 14 Print - Maps Page 1 of 1 Bing Maps LL Wilshire Park Elementary School nr,St sVV� Electronic Sign Placement • 79 FREE!Use Live Search 411 to find rnoAes, businesses ;v more: 800-CALL-411, O i VKN �, 'drasoft • I IL 19 !93 37th Ave I ;:.. County Ro i T rn Brenner St ABird's eye view maps can't be printed, so another map view has been substituted. http://www.bing.com/maps/print.aspx?mkt=en-us&z=2&s=b&cp=rh58td76zc0q&pt=pb 6/11/2009