Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC PACKET 07282009H.R,A. Meeting immediately following regular meeting CITY OF ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE CITY COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA July 28, 2009 7:00 p.m. Call to Order. Pledge of Allegiance. Roll Call. Consideration, Discussion, and Possible Action on All of the following items: I. Approval of the July 28, 2009, City Council Meeting Agenda. (action requested) II. Proclamations and Recognitions. A. Minnesota "Night to Unite" Proclamation. (p. 1) B. "Fill -the -Boot" for Muscular Dystrophy Proclamation. (pp. 2 -7) III. Consent Agenda. These items rare consideird routine alid will be enacted by we motion. 'I bele will be no separate disaassion of !Dere items unless a Counadmember or cifi it so lrquest , in which erent fix item will be irmored from the Consent Agen&s and placed elsewlxae on 11m agenda. A. Approval of June 23, 2009, Council Meeting Minutes. (pp. 8-13) B. Licenses and Permits. (pp. 14-16) C. Claims. (pp. 17-22) D. Resolution 09-063; Accepting the Grant from CenterPoint Energy for the St. Anthony Fire Department. (pp. 23-24) IV. Public Hearing. V. Reports from Commission and Staff. (Paul Cincosld, Planning Commissioner reporting) A. Resolution 09-064; Conditional Use Permit for an Antenna for 2601 Kenzie Terrace. (pp. 25-45) B. Resolution 09-065; Fence Height Variance for 2912 Silver Lake Court. (pp. 46-56) C. Resolution 09-066; Conditional Use Permit for Placement of an Electronic Sign at 3303 — 3316 Avenue. (pp. 57-68) D. Resolution 09-067; Conditional Use Permit for Placement of an Electronic Sign at 3600 I lighcrest Avenue. (pp. 69-83) VI. General Business of Council. A. Ordinance 09-005; Section 72.36; Parking During Snow Removal. nal nading) (pp. 84-87) VII. Reports from City Manager and Council members. VIII. Community Forum. Irldiadifals may addlrss Vie C y Conndl ahonl any item not included on 115e regular agetlda. .Speaker) an IYalnested to come to 11m padimn. J°t�11 their name and aCId1YJS On 1lJe fOrili a1 the podilem stale their nine and address for Ilk (-,lerk'S rtcorr4 and limit then' mmarks to f a'e mingles. %enewly, the Criy C'oundl hill nol take O§Ieial adioll on ilems aism sed al this lime, but may ypi'cally refer t1m matter to slafffor a future report or direct 1he mailer to be sclxduled on an;Ocomtng agenda. IX. Information and Announcements. X. Adjournment. Our Mission is to be a progressive and livable community, a walkable village, which is safe and secure. ZACouncil Meetings120091072820091agendapg#.doe 1 PROCLAMATION WHEREAS, the Minnesota Crime Prevention Association, AAA of Minnesota and the St. Anthony Police Department are sponsoring a statewide crime and drug prevention program on August 4, 2009, called "Night to Unite", and WHEREAS, this is the "Is' Annual Night to Unite" in Minnesota and it provides a unique opportunity for St. Anthony to join forces with hundreds of other communities across Minnesota in promoting cooperative, police -community crime and drug prevention efforts; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony plays a vital role in assisting the St. Anthony Police Department through joint crime and drug prevention efforts in St. Anthony and is supporting "Night to Unite 2009" locally; and WHEREAS, it is essential that all citizens of the City of St. Anthony be aware of the importance of crime prevention programs and impact that their participation can have on reducing crime and drug abuse in the City of St. Anthony; and WHEREAS, police -community partnerships with neighborhood safety, awareness and cooperation are important themes of the "Night to Unite"program. NOW, THEREFORE, we, the St. Anthony City Council, do hereby call upon all citizens of the City of St. Anthony to join the St. Anthony Police Department, the Minnesota Crime Prevention Association, and AAA of Minnesota in supporting the 1" Annual "Night to Unite " on August 4, 2009, FURTHER, LE T IT BE RESOL VED, THAT WE, THE ST. A NTHONY CITY CO UNCIL, do hereby proclaim Tuesday, August 4, 2009, as "NIGHT TY UNITE" in the City of St. Anthony. Mayor July 28 2009 Date 'ai � 1 �C% PROCLAMATION WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony Village Fire Department is affiliated with the International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF); and WHEREAS, the IAFF has been committed to the Muscular Dystrophy Association by raising funds to help eliminate neuromuscular diseases with their Annual "Fill -the -Boot" campaign; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony Village Fire Department will be participating in the 2009 Annual "Fill -the - Boot" campaign by having collection sites throughout the City of St. Anthony on August 24th thru August 26th. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the St. Anthony Village City Council hereby designates August 24th thru August 26th as "Fill -the Boot" Days. St. Anthony Fire Department "Fill -the -Boot" Days Mayor fitly 28, 2009 2 3 Staff Report To: Mike Mornson From: John Malenick, Fire Chief Date: July 15, 2009 Re, Muscular Dystrophy Fill the Boot campaign Background: The International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) is the labor organization that represents the full time St. Anthony Fire Fighters as well as 280,000 other Fire Fighters throughout the United States and Canada. They are also the single largest national sponsor of the Muscular Dystrophy Association and its annual Labor Day telethon. Through their Fill the Boot campaign, the IAFF has raised over $275 million toward the world wide research efforts of the MDA as well as many summer camps for children, public health education and other programs. For many years the St. Anthony Fire Fighters have contributed to this campaign both monetarily and in time spent answering phones at the telethon. Consideration: For the first time this year, our Fire Fighters are hoping to expand their involvement to include donation collections on the street as well as the sidewalks at the Cub Food Store and the Wal-Mart shopping center. They are proposing a three day event, Monday Aug. 24, Tuesday and Wednesday, beginning late afternoon into early evening (rush hour). Fire Fighters will greet motorists, shoppers and others to collect donations of money to the MDA in their fire boots. Other issues considered: Fire Fighters will conduct their Fill the Boot activities in a manner that neither interferes with or precludes the performance of their regular duties nor detracts from other work-related obligations to the public. In the event of a large scale incident during the collection times, the MDA will provide back up in the form of volunteer family members of children suffering from Muscular Dystrophy. Part time Fire Fighters will be invited to join the IAFF members in this fundraising effort. Event is insured by the Muscular Dystrophy Association Thank you for your consideration. Staff involved: Joe Basara, Mark Sitarz, John Malenick 0 Page 1 4 WMA Muscular Dystrophy Association 7401 Metro Boulevard #325•M Edina, MN 55439 Phone: 952-832-5517 Fax: 952-831-7131 Helping Jerry's Kids Wednesday, June 24, 2009 Dear Michael, Thank you for taking the time to speak with the St. Anthony Fire department and me in regards to the Fill the Boot campaign. I have enclosed some basic information on the program. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at 952-697-3249 or 1 fisher(amdausa. org. You had also request the cities in Minnesota that do on street, on duty, Fill the boot and they are: 1. Duluth 2. Virginia 3. Minneapolis 4. Coon Rapids 5. South Metro 6. St. Paul 7. St. Louis Park 8. Faribault 9, Cloquet Thank you again for your time. Sincerely, A�l Lisa Fisher Minneapolis District Director JERRY -LUIS, National Chairman • R. RODNGY I-IOWBLL, MD, Chairman of the Board • Q RAID C. W1=INBhRC, President c CEO OUNI f. MORRIS, lixeanive Committee Chairman • SLIZANNh: I.pWDf.N, Treasurer • TIM.MI MM TRS, Sca'ctaiy IAFF HISTORY/BACKGROUNo The tradition began in 1952, when a father in desperate need ran to IAFF member George Graney's Fire Engine Company 1 in South Boston, IAFF Local 718 immediately rounded up 20 fire fighters and set in motion a door-to-door canister drive that raised $5,000. In 1953, Graney launched a citywide fundraising campaign with the help of Boston fire fighters and made appeals across Massachusetts in behalf of children with muscular dystrophy. Realizing the potential that fire fighters had to offer the cause and their excellent image in the community, Graney approached and persuaded IAFF members to support MDA. In August 1954, Graney raised his voice at the IAFF's biannual convention in Miami and proposed that MDA be established as the International's "charity of choice." MDA Goodwill Ambassador Luis Grant, who had a form of muscular dystrophy, gave an emotional presentation to (AFF members, helping to gain unanimous approval of Groney's proclamation. This marked the beginning of a formal bond between the IAFF and MDA. Since then, fire fighters have taken this vision and made it their mission, raising funds a thousand ways: by placing collection jars in stores and restaurants, sponsoring charity softball games and running auctions. These days, their signature fundraising activity is the MDA Fill -the -Boot drive. The IAFF has emerged as the single -largest sponsor of MDA, contributing more than $350 million since 1954. The International has renewed that commitment to MDA under the leadership of General President Harold A. Schaitberger, who is also an MDA national vice president. Nearly 300,000 IAFF members in the United States and Canada continue to break their fundraising record year after year — all to benefit Jerry's Kids. E 6'M77 IMPORTANT FACTS TO SHARE 0 • MDA does not receive funding from state, federal or local governments, nor does it seek or receive fees for services. ov • MDA maintains 215 hospital -affiliated clinics and 36 MDA/ALS centers for diagnostic and follow-up care. z n T • More than 40 neuromuscular diseases are covered by MDA, including ALS, commonly known as Lou Gehrig's disease. •MDA funds some 330 research projects by leading scientists around the world. �+ What Your Dollars Will Buy: • The Association is the world's leader in research and services for neuromuscular diseases. • More than 78 cents of every dollar raised is spent on services. • The American Medical Association has recognized MDA -supported research projects for pioneering breakthroughs that may lead to therapies for heart disease, cancer, AIDS, Alzheimer's, Huntington's, Parkinson's, cystic fibrosis, as well as neuromuscular diseases. $30 Flu Shot $82 One minute of research $100 One support group session $150 One physical, occupational, respiratory or speech therapy consultation $200 Professional fees related to initial diagnostic work-up at an MDA clinic $500 Assists one person for one year with the repair of a wheelchair, leg braces or communication device $800 Sends.one child to MDA summer camp $2,000 Assists one person with the purchase of a wheelchair, leg braces or communication device HOW FILL -THE -BOOT DOLLARS CAN BE SPENT Here is one way that money raised from a $10,000 BOOT DRIVE event could be translated into services for children and adults served in your community. 2 Initial clinic visits @ one of the 215 MDA clinics or 36 MDA/ALS centers @ $200 400 2 Complete set of chest & spine x-rays @ $375 750 1 Assistance with purchase of communication device or a wheelchair @ $2,000 2,000 1 Assistance with purchase of leg braces @ $2,000 2,000 2 Physical therapy evaluations @ $150 each 300 2 Occupational therapy evaluations @ $150 each 300 2 Respiratory therapy evaluations @ $150 each 300 4 Minutes of research @ $82 each 328 2 Follow-up clinic visits @ $100 each 200 3 Support group sessions @ $100 each 300 8 Annual flu shots @ $30 each 240 4 Children to MDA Summer Camp @ $800 each 3,200 $10,318 DID YOU KNOW ... • More than 78.4% of every dollar MDA spends goes directly to research, health care services & education. • In 2009, MDA will provide $91.7 million a year for health care services, $42 million for research with some 330 projects worldwide, and $25.3 million on professional and public health education programs. N. I CITY OF ST. ANTHONY 2 CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES 3 JUNE 23, 2009 4 5 CALL TO ORDER. 6 7 Mayor Faust called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. 8 9 PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. 10 11 Mayor Faust invited the Council and audience to join him in the Pledge of Allegiance. 12 13 ROLL CALL. 14 15 Present: Mayor Faust; Councilmembers Gray, Roth, Stille, and Thuesen 16 Absent: None 17 Also Present: City Manager Mike Monson and Fire Chief John Malenick. 18 19 20 CONSIDERATION, DISCUSSION, AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON ALL OF THE FOLLOWING 21 ITEMS. 22 23 L APPROVAL OF JUNE 23, 2009 CITY COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA. 24 25 Motion by Councilmember Thuesen, seconded by Councilmember Gray, to approve the City 26 Council Meeting Agenda of June 23, 2009. 27 28 Motion carried unanimously. 29 30 IL PROCLAMATIONS AND RECOGNITIONS. 31 32 A. Presentation of CenterPoint Energy Grant for the City of St Anthony Fire Department 33 Jay Hibbard, Centerpoint EnergYpresenting 34 35 Fire Chief Malenick announced that the City has been awarded a CenterPoint Energy 36 Community Partnership grant. The grant will be used for the replacement of dispatch pagers 37 carried by firefighters. The new pagers will be more reliable and will allow them to take 38 advantage of new technology. 39 40 Mr. Jay Hibbard, CenterPoint Energy, addressed the City Council and provided information 41 about the CenterPoint Energy Community Partnership grant. Mr. Hibbard presented Mayor Faust 42 and Fire Chief Malenick with the $2,000 grant. 43 44 Mayor Faust thanked CenterPoint Energy on behalf of the City Council and citizens of St. 45 Anthony. 46 47 I11. CONSENT AGENDA. 48 49 A. Consider June 9 2009 Council meeting minutes City Council Regular Meeting Minutes June 23, 2009 Page 2 1 B. Consider licenses and permits. 2 C. Consider payment of claims. 3 D. Resolution 09-059; Renewal of Municipal Insurance Coverage and the Waiver of Tort 4 Liability Limits for the League of Minnesota Cities Insurance Program. 5 E. Resolution 09-060; 6 7 Motion by Councilmember Gray, seconded by Councilmember Roth, to approve the Consent 8 Agenda items. 10 Motion carried unanimously. 11 12 IV. PUBLIC HEARING. 13 14 None. 15 16 V. REPORTS FROM COMMISSION AND STAFF. 17 18 None. 19 20 VI. GENERAL BUSINESS OF COUNCIL. 21 22 A. Consider Resolution 09-061; Approving the Contract Agreement for Police Services with 23 the City of Falcon Heights and Authorizes the Mayor and City Manager to Execute Said 24 Agreement. Mike Mornson, City Manager, presenting. 25 26 City Manager Mornson provided an overview of the contract agreement for police services with 27 the City of Falcon Heights. 28 29 Motion by Councilmember Roth, seconded by Councilmember Stille, to adopt Resolution 09- 30 061; Approving the Contract Agreement for Police Services with the City of Falcon Heights and 31 Authorizes the Mayor and City Manager to Execute Said Agreement. 32 33 Motion carried unanimously. 34 35 B. Consider Resolution 09-062; Approving the Contract Agreement for Police Services with 36 the City of Lauderdale and Authorizes the Mayor and City Manager to Execute Said 37 Agreement. Mike Mornson, City Manager, presenting. 38 39 City Manager Mornson provided an overview of the contract agreement for police services with 40 the City of Lauderdale. 41 42 It was noted that a lot of negotiation was involved in the contract agreements with the cities of 43 Falcon Heights and Lauderdale. 44 D City Council Regular Meeting Minutes June 23, 2009 Page 3 Motion by Councilmember Stille, seconded by Councilmember Roth, to adopt Resolution 09- 062; Approving the Contract Agreement for Police Services with the City of Lauderdale and Authorizes the Mayor and City Manager to Execute Said Agreement. Motion carried unanimously. C. Consider Ordinance 2009-005; Section 72.36; Parking during Snow Removal (2°a reading). 10 City Manager Morrison reviewed the ordinance with the Council and indicated this is the second 11 reading of Option 2. This option proceeds with the current ordinance. 12 13 Motion by Councilmember Gray, seconded by Councilmember Roth, to approve the Second 14 Reading of Ordinance 2009-005; Section 72.36; Parking during Snow Removal (Option 2). 15 16 Mayor Faust noted the proposed ordinance states that no person shall park a vehicle on any city 17 street for a period of 48 hours, commencing immediately after 2 inches or more of continuous 18 snowfall or until snow removal has been completed curb to curb. This ordinance was in place 19 last year. Prior to that there was a parking ban from 3 a.m. to 7 a.m., November ls` to April 1". 20 21 Councilmember Stille stated his opposition to Option 2. He stated his position that it is easier to 22 implement the snow plowing exercise with the previous parking ban from 3 a.m. to 7 a.m. He 23 stated it is more efficient, there are safety considerations, and the effects are positive to the 24 integrity of the community. He requested support from the Council in encouraging staff to follow 25 the parking ordinance. He pointed out that there are times after snowfalls where cars have been 26 parked on the street for two to three days, which violates the snowplowing ordinance and the 27 parking ordinance prohibiting vehicles from being parked on the street for more than 24 hours. 28 He stated if these ordinances are enforced it will go a long way towards mitigating negative 29 impacts from proceeding with Option 2. He stressed that the streets should be used to park 30 vehicles, not to store them. 31 32 City Manager Morrison indicated he would recommend giving discretion to the Police 33 Department on when vehicles are towed. 34 35 Councilmember Stille clarified that he is encouraging that the Police Department be more 36 forceful in towing vehicles in accordance with the parking ordinance, but not at the expense of 37 being difficult for the citizens. 38 39 Councilmember Gray stated his agreement with enforcing the parking ordinance to ensure that 40 vehicles are not parked on the street long term. 41 42 Councilmember Thuesen stated he is not in favor of allowing vehicles to be parked on the street 43 until there is a snowfall. He stated his support of the previous ordinance restricting parking at 44 certain times. It is easy to implement and enforce and it has been proven in the past that it works. 45 im City Council Regular Meeting Minutes June 23, 2009 Page 4 Mayor Faust noted the consensus of the Council to direct staff to proceed with greater enforcement of the current parking regulations. Ayes — 3, Nays — 2 (Stille and Thuesen). Motion carried. D. Consider Ordinance 2009-006; Amending Current Code to Allow Background Checks. Mike Morrison, City Manager, presenting (1St reading). 9 City Manager Mornson reviewed the ordinance with the Council and indicated that as part of the 10 recodification of the City Code, the attorneys assisting staff with the process advised that it was 11 not necessary to codify the City's Personnel Policy as most of the regulations and laws were 12 originated and supported by State or Federal statutes and legislation, and that no need existed to 13 codify them as part of the City's Code. However, because the City's authority to request 14 background checks of prospective new hires and liquor license holders existed as a part of the 15 codified City's Personnel Policy, it was inadvertently removed when the City's recodified Code 16 of Ordinances was approved and adopted by the City Council. Staff is requesting that this 17 language be returned to the City's Code of Ordinances so that the Police Department may be 18 again authorized to conduct Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) criminal background 19 checks on prospective new hires and licenses. 20 21 Councilmember Roth requested staff to look into how many years into the past the background 22 checks go. He noted there was an incident in the news where a gentleman became an apartment 23 complex manager, and the background check did not uncover information about his past 14 years 24 ago because the check only went back 10 years. He asked if employees have been hired recently 25 without background checks being done as a result of the City not having the necessary authority. 26 City Manager Morrison replied that due to the hiring freeze, the only hiring being done at this 27 time is part-time liquor employees. There have not been any employees hired until this is taken 28 care of. Liquor licenses have been approved, as the City has the ability to do a partial 29 background check. The biggest concern is to have background checks done on solicitors going 30 door to door. 31 32 Motion by Councilmember Gray, seconded by Councilmember Roth, to approve the First 33 Reading, Waive the Second and Third Readings, and adopt Ordinance 2009-006; Amending 34 Current Code to Allow Background Checks. 35 36 Motion carried unanimously. 37 38 VII. REPORTS FROM CITY MANAGER AND COUNCIL MEMBERS. 39 40 City Manager Mornson reported on the following: 41 • There are no agenda items scheduled for the July 14, 2009 City Council meeting. The 42 third reading of Ordinance 2009-005 could be scheduled for the July 18, 2009 City 43 Council meeting if the Council chooses. 44 • June 16, 2009— Roseville meeting to discuss Higherest Overlay Project 45 • June 17, 2009 — New Brighton meeting to discuss sharing of resources equipment, 46 purchasing, and employee training. 11 City Council Regular Meeting Minutes June 23, 2009 Page 5 1 Silver Lake Village Update: 2 o Condos: 130 total of which 115 are sold. 7 of these sold this year. Total value of 3 $1,651,746. 4 o Cottages: 26 total of which 23 are sold. 6 of these sold this year. Total value of 5 41,553,293. 6 o Co-op: 42 total, 20 reserved; 78 unit rental 7 Workman's Comp Rate is .78, the lowest it has ever been. 1.00 is considered the normal. 8 The Fire Department will be volunteering with Muscular Dystrophy this year. 9 Officer Huddle received the following awards for his work with the Roseville Swat 10 Team: MN Police Officer Association Police Officer of the Year Award Honorable 11 Mention; Department Medal of Honor, SOTA Swat Officer of the Year; Minnesota 12 Police Chiefs Medal of Honor; and Minnesota Police and Peace Officers Association 13 Honorable Mention. 14 15 Consensus of the Council was to direct staff to cancel the July 14, 2009 City Council meeting 16 and to schedule the third reading of ordinance 2009-005 for the July 28, 2009 City Council 17 meeting. 18 19 Mayor Faust noted that insurance costs were $4,000 lower this year and commended staff for the 20 efforts associated with the workman's comp rate. 21 22 Councilmember Stille reported on this attendance at the Family Services Collaborative Board 23 meeting prior to the City Council meeting. He explained that the organization currently serves at 24 risk kids that are generally middle school and up in age. Due to the desire of the County for the 25 funds to be used for early childhood there may be a change in focus. 26 27 Councilmember Thuesen reported that recent speakers at the Vital Aging Council were Andy 28 Parrish of AARP, and Bob Roepke, former Mayor of Chaska. Mr. Parrish spoke about health 29 care reform, financial security, home emergencies, and maintaining health and long term care. 30 Mr. Roepke spoke about communities supporting residents as they age. 31 32 Councilmember Gray: No report. 33 34 Councilmember Roth: No report. 35 36 Mayor Faust reported on his attendance at the following: 37 June 15, 2009 Vital Aging Council meeting. Mr. Bob Roepke spoke about a community 38 for a lifetime. He discussed a master plan for aging, as well as putting the human element 39 into comprehensive planning. There is some sentiment that St. Anthony may not have 40 enough community space for the senior component, and this may need to be looked into 41 in the future. However, the City has been amenable to requests by the seniors to use space 42 at city hall, audio visual equipment, etc. He note there may be areas where the Vital 43 Aging Council can be enhanced. 44 League of Minnesota Cities (LMC) Board meeting prior to the City Council meeting. It 45 was his last meeting as a board member; if elected on Thursday he will be an officer. He 46 encourages membership on LMC policy committees. 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 City Council Regular Meeting Minutes June 23, 2009 Page 6 VIII. COMMUNITY FORUM. Mayor Faust invited residents to come forward at this time and address the Council on items that are not on the regular agenda. Hearing none, Mayor Faust moved forward with the agenda. IX. INFORMATION AND ANNOUNCEMENTS. Councilmember Thuesen announced the St. Anthony Civic Orchestra summer pops concert events: • Thursday, June 25t", 7:15 p.m. at Chandler Place with an ice cream social ■ Sunday, June 28"', 7:00 p.m. at Como Park Lakeside Pavilion • Thursday, July 2nd, 7:00 p.m. at Salo Park Amphitheatre ■ Thursday, July 9`h, 7:00 p.m. at the Abiding Savior Lutheran Church, 8211 Red Oak Drive in Mounds View, with an ice cream social. X. ADJOURNMENT. Mayor Faust adjourned the meeting at 7:37 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Carol Hamer TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. ATTEST: City Clerk Mayor 13 Saint Anthony Village DATE: July 28, 2009 Approved: TO: Mayor and Councilmembers FROM: License Clerk ITEM: License and Permits for Approval: General Contractors License: Kerkes Concrete, Ramsey, MN Northeast Tree, Minneapolis, MN Premier Contracting, Maple Grove, MN Steiner Construction Services, Wayzata, MN Heating & Air Conditioning License: Air Quality Services, St Louis Park, MN Aurora Mechanical, Inver Grove Heights, MN Cashion HVAC Services, St Michael, MN Centerpoint Energy Minnesota Gas, Coon Rapids, MN Craig's Heating & Air, Isanti, MN Custom Refrigeration, Golden Valley, MN Dakota Mechanical, St Paul, MN Golden Valley Heating & Air, Crystal, MN Home Energy Center, Plymouth, MN Royalton Heating & Cooling, Brooklyn Park, MN Sedgwick Heating & Air Conditioning, Bloomington, MN West Air Heating, Hanover, MN Yale Mechanical, Bloomington, MN Rental License: Applicant: Thomas Kringstad Location: 2516 29th Ave Applicant: Jason & Nikki Mason Location; 2702 37th Ave Applicant: Mark & Julie Toboll Location: 2407 39'b Ave #413 Applicant: Lee Trasamar Location: 3104 39th Ave Applicant: Amy Shih Location; 3200 -3202 39th Ave Applicant: Gary Peterson Location; 2601 Kenzie Ter #204 14 Applicant: Merrill Properties Location: 3912 Macalaster Dr Applicant: Julie Koss Location: 2912 Old Hwy 8 Applicant: Greg Steiner Location: 3016 Old Hwy 8 Applicant: Scott Roadfeldt Location: 2924 Rankin Rd Applicant: Erich Young Location: 3113 Rankin Rd Applicant: Donald Doeksen Location: 3226 — 3228 Roosevelt St Applicant: Erik Seres Location: 3929 Shamrock Dr Applicant: AA Alta Vista Location: 3409 Skycroft Cir Applicant: Jason Amundsen Location: 2816 St Anthony Blvd Applicant: Tom Fitzen Location: 3143 Stinson Blvd Applicant: Lorraine Weinmeyer Location: 3323 Stinson Blvd Applicant: David Loch Location: 3605 Stinson Blvd Applicant: Daniel Geer Location: 3637 — 3639 Stinson Blvd Temporary 3.2 Beer Permit: Applicant: Mary Ann Thuesen Location: Central Park Date: August 10, 2009 Applicant: Teresa Kay Wang Location: Central Park Date: August 13, 2009 15 Applicant: Wayne Kafka Location: Central Park Date: December 9, 2009 16 U.S. BANK ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE 17 CHECK REGISTER VENDOR# PAYEE CHECK# DATE AMOUNT 9182 SAM'S CLUB 9737 6/25/2009 $201.38 8270 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE 9738 7/2/2009 $700.00 8242 AFFILIATED COMPUTER SERV 9740 7/15/2009 $3,200.00 8471 AIRGAS NORTH CENTRAL 9741 7/15/2009 $113.33 9486 AIRPORT TAXI & TOWN TAXI 9742 7/15/2009 $204.46 8621 ALLIANCE MECHANICAL 9743 7/15/2009 $8,953.00 8268 AMERICAN PAYMENT CENTERS 9744 7/15/2009 $78.00 8945 ANCOM COMMUNICATIONS 9745 7/15/2009 $97.39 8450 ANIMAL CONTROL SERVICES, 9746 7/15/2009 $86.00 7201 APACHE GROUP 9747 7/15/2009 $381.01 8794 ARCTIC GLACIER INC. 9748 7/15/2009 $929.22 4687 ASPEN WASTE SYSTEMS INC 9749 7/15/2009 $61.27 320 BEISSWENGER'S 9750 7/15/2009 $17.13 4293 BELLBOY CORP. 9751 7/15/2009 $19,598.60 9060 BLAINE LOCK & SAFE INC. 9752 7/15/2009 $199.33 9648 BOUND TREE MEDICAL LLC 9753 7/15/2009 $39.62 7253 BRAKE & EQUIPMENT WAREHO 9754 7/15/2009 $260.49 7157 BROCK WHITE COMPANY, LLC 9755 7/15/2009 $102.24 4231 CAPITOL BEVERAGE SALES 9756 7/15/2009 $34,784.70 9100 CAT & FIDDLE BEVERAGE 9757 7/15/2009 $596.66 610 CATCO 9758 7/15/2009 $24.07 9362 CENTRAL WOOD PRODUCTS 9759 7/15/2009 $36.50 4080 CHISAGO LAKES DISTRIBUTI 9760 7/15/2009 $2,038.03 9302 CITY OF MAPLE GROVE 9761 7/15/2009 $275.00 8542 CITY OF MOUNDS VIEW 9762 7/15/2009 $39.00 9209 CLOSE LANDSCAPE ARCHITEC 9763 7/15/2009 $8,438.57 4095 COCA COLA BOTTLING COMPA 9764 7/15/2009 $800.60 4101 COMMERS CONDITIONED WATE 9765 7/15/2009 $140.37 4107 COMPTON'S COMMERCIAL CLN 9766 7/15/2009 $3,810.57 9726 CRIME STOPPERS OF MINNES 9767 7/15/2009 $150.00 7178 D -ROCK CENTER & SMALL EN 9768 7/15/2009 $38.46 9721 DAMA-MP INC. 9769 7/15/2009 $154.43 4127 DANIMAL DISTRIBUTING INC 9770 7/15/2009 $406.50 9343 DEPARTMENT OF LABOR & IN 9771 7/15/2009 $4,279.43 8429 DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAF 9772 7/15/2009 $510.00 8437 DIRECTV INC 9773 7/15/2009 $31.94 8411 DRIVER & VEHICLE SERVICE 9774 7/15/2009 $20.00 9034 EBERT CONSTRUCTION 9775 7/15/2009 $167,123.32 4135 ELECTRO WATCHMAN INC 9776 7/15/2009 $195.58 9725 EULL'S MANUFACTURING CO. 9777 7/15/2009 $375.73 8697 EXTREME BEVERAGE 9778 7/15/2009 $239.50 9395 FACTORY MOTOR PARTS CO 9779 7/15/2009 $29.22 9667 FLAT EARTH BREWING CO 9780 7/15/2009 $287.92 9236 FSH COMMUNICATIONS 9781 7/15/2009 $63.90 1030 G & K SERVICES INC 9782 7/15/2009 $1,231.79 1110 GENERAL INDUSTRIAL SUPPL 9783 7/15/2009 $12.78 9646 GRAHAM CONSTRUCTION SERV 9784 7/15/2009 $7,740.09 4172 GRAPE BEGINNINGS, INC. 9785 7/15/2009 $997.50 4175 GRIGGS COOPER & CO INC 9786 7/15/2009 $17,215.84 9498 HAMLINE AUTO BODY 9787 7/15/2009 $4,458.00 U.S. BANK ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE 18 CHECK REGISTER VENDOR # PAYEE CHECK # DATE AMOUNT 1420 HAWKINS, INC 9788 7/15/2009 $5,644.66 9422 HD SUPPLY WATERWORKS 9789 7/15/2009 $574.44 8813 HEALTHPARTNERS 9790 7/15/2009 $2,299.23 8221 HEDBACK, ARENDT, KOHL 9791 7/15/2009 $5,000.00 9160 HEWLITT PACKARD COMPANY 9792 7/15/2009 $1,637.97 4207 HOHENSTEIN'S, INC 9793 7/15/2009 $6,346.55 8252 HOME DEPOT CREDIT SERVIC 9794 7/15/2009 $99.13 9335 HUMANADENTAL 9795 7/15/2009 $39.13 8016 INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE 9796 7/15/2009 $125.00 4125 JJ TAYLOR DISTRIBUTING 9797 7/15/2009 $38,705.73 4220 JOHNSON BROTHERS LIQUOR 9798 7/15/2009 $43,814.64 9351 LANGUAGE LINE SERVICES 9799 7/15/2009 $11.33 9722 LIBERTY TIRE RECYCLING S 9800 7/15/2009 $217.50 8229 LOFFLER BUSINESS SYSTEMS 9801 7/15/2009 $253.47 9114 M. AMUNDSON LLP 9802 7/15/2009 $2,760.25 2100 MACQUEEN EQUIPMENT CO 9803 7/15/2009 $140,600.00 4265 MARK VII SALES INC 9804 7/15/2009 $37,395.43 2160 MARSHALL CONCRETE PROD 9805 7/15/2009 $967.26 2240 METROPOLITAN COUNCIL 9806 7/15/2009 $42,725.85 8279 METROPOLITAN COUNCIL 9807 7/15/2009 $7,920.00 9459 MIDC ENTERPRISES 9808 7/15/2009 $137.03 8467 MIDWAY FORD 9809 7/15/2009 $110.05 2280 MIDWEST ASPHALT CORP 9810 7/15/2009 $51.75 8269 MINNESOTA SHREDDING LLC 9811 7/15/2009 $57.00 9195 MISTER CAR WASH 9812 7/15/2009 $242.35 8808 MN CITY COUNTY MGMT ASSO 9813 7/15/2009 $110.87 2360 MN CONWAY FIRE & SAFETY 9814 7/15/2009 $660.47 2395 MTI DISTRIBUTING, INC 9815 7/15/2009 $460.08 5232 MURPHY'S SERVICE CENTER 9816 7/15/2009 $37.96 9084 MUZAK LLC 9817 7/15/2009 $55.41 7370 MYERS TIRE SUPPLY COMPAN 9818 7/15/2009 $21.29 8996 NEEDHAM DISTRIBUTING CO 9819 7/15/2009 $431.20 9475 NEOPOST LEASING 9820 7/15/2009 $123.29 8326 NEWMAN TRAFFIC SIGNS 9821 7/15/2009 $611.63 9672 NORTHERN SAFETY TECHNOLO 9822 7/15/2009 $224.72 9266 NORTHERN WATER WORKS SUP 9823 7/15/2009 $51.95 9523 NORTHSTAR INSPECTION SER 9824 7/15/2009 $87,847.75 45 OFFICE DEPOT 9825 7/15/2009 $1,387.08 8528 PACE ANALYTICAL SERVICES 9826 7/15/2009 $380.00 9615 PAETEC 9827 7/15/2009 $241.50 4354 PAUSTIS & SONS 9828 7/15/2009 $2,634.24 9563 PETTY CASH - U.S. BANK 9829 7/15/2009 $103.61 4360 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRITS 9830 7/15/2009 $35,608.98 9370 PREMIUM BUSINESS PRODUCT 9831 7/15/2009 $120.00 9180 PROFESSIONAL TURF & RENO 9832 7/15/2009 $798.75 9139 PROPERTY KEY, INC. 9833 7/15/2009 $50.00 9723 PUGLEASA COMPANY, INC. 9834 7/15/2009 $1,598.00 4385 QUALITY WINE CO 9835 7/15/2009 $21,208.27 4492 QWEST 9836 7/15/2009 $145.19 9119 RECHECK 9837 7/15/2009 $15.00 9187 RUTTGERS BAY LAKE LODGE 9838 7/15/2009 $368.50 U.S. BANK ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE 19 CHECK REGISTER VENDOR # PAYEE CHECK # DATE AMOUNT 9127 SIMPLEXGRINNELL 9839 7/15/2009 $149.69 9259 SPRINT 9840 7/15/2009 $327.92 9705 SPRINT - SUBPOENA COMPLI 9841 7/15/2009 $30.00 4782 ST ANTHONY VILLAGE CENTE 9842 7/15/2009 $1,869.58 9083 ST. ANTHONY RETAIL DEVEL 9843 7/15/2009 $1,139.74 9167 ST, ANTHONY -NEW BRIGHTON 9844 7/15/2009 $26,087.78 8448 ST. CLOUD STATE UNIVERSI 9845 7/15/2009 $492.00 4780 SURLY BREWING CO 9846 7/15/2009 $2,039.00 3260 T A SCHIFSKY & SONS 9847 7/15/2009 $2,785.95 5273 TESSMAN SEED INC. 9848 7/15/2009 $228.12 7337 TIMESAVER OFF SITE SECRE 9849 7/15/2009 $458.25 9724 TOOLS PLUS INDUSTRIES 9850 7/15/2009 $154.23 3560 TRACY PRINTING 9851 7/15/2009 $3,271.68 8824 TRI -COUNTY BEVERAGE, INC 9852 7/15/2009 $425.00 .00256 U OF M PLNT DISEASE CLNC 9853 7/15/2009 $45.00 8010 UNIFORMS UNLIMITED 9854 7/15/2009 $854.48 8336 UNITED ELECTRIC COMPANY 9855 7/15/2009 $101.44 4490 VAL-PAK OF MINNESOTA 9856 7/15/2009 $740.00 9727 VANDENBOOM/PAUL 9857 7/15/2009 $43.00 9382 VEOLIA ES VASKO SOLID WA 9858 7/15/2009 $463.15 8227 VERIZON WIRELESS 9859 7/15/2009 $726.99 9126 VINO SOURCE 9860 7/15/2009 $98.00 4451 VINOCOPIA 9861 7/15/2009 $1,000.70 8388 W. W. GOETSCH ASSOCIATES 9862 7/15/2009 $2,566.81 4494 WASTE MANAGEMENT - BLAIN 9863 7/15/2009 $511.84 8316 WINE COMPANY/THE 9864 7/15/2009 $3,166.75 8310 WINE MERCHANTS INC 9865 7/15/2009 $2,771.41 4499 WORLD CLASS WINES, INC. 9866 7/15/2009 $1,210.70 2680 XCEL ENERGY 9867 7/15/2009 $10,653.49 9711 Z WINES USA LLC 9868 7/15/2009 $499.50 830 ZEE MEDICAL SERVICE 9869 7/15/2009 $149.42 TOTAL $849,861.58 U.S.BANK ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE CHECK REGISTER 20 VENDOR PAYEE CHECK # DATE AMOUNT 8964 ACCLAIM BENEFITS 9882 7/29/2009 $130.00 8471 AIRGAS NORTH CENTRAL 9883 7/29/2009 $84.08 9486 AIRPORT TAXI & TOWN TAXI 9884 7/29/2009 $237.85 9453 ALEXANDRA STILLMAN, PH.D 9885 7/29/2009 $375.00 8621 ALLIANCE MECHANICAL 9886 7/29/2009 $9,364.00 9250 AMERICAN MESSAGING 9887 7/29/2009 $262.08 8945 ANCOM COMMUNICATIONS 9888 7/29/2009 $13.31 8450 ANIMAL CONTROL SERVICES, 9889 7/29/2009 $86.00 7835 ARCH WIRELESS-METROCALL 9890 7/29/2009 $41.59 8794 ARCTIC GLACIER INC. 9891 7/29/2009 $1,158.43 8511 AT&T MOBILITY 9892 7/29/2009 $84.40 320 BEISSWENGER'S 9893 7/29/2009 $117.61 4293 BELLBOY CORP. 9894 7/29/2009 $15,150.74 8555 BIFFS, INC. 9895 7/29/2009 $309.82 9148 BRW ENTERPRISES 9896 7/29/2009 $180.00 4231 CAPITOL BEVERAGE SALES 9897 7/29/2009 $28,038.57 2380 CENTERPOINT ENERGY 9898 7/29/2009 $4,832.72 4065 CENTRAL LOCK & SAFE CO 9899 7/29/2009 $75.48 4080 CHISAGO LAKES DISTRIBUTI 9900 7/29/2009 $4,139.65 9378 CITY OF FALCON HEIGHTS 9901 7/29/2009 $2,876.01 9379 CITY OF LAUDERDALE 9902 7/29/2009 $1,517.76 9056 CITY OF ROSEVILLE 9903 7/29/2009 $1,932.65 8275 CITY OF ST. PAUL 9904 7/29/2009 $320.00 4095 COCA COLA BOTTLING COMPA 9905 7/29/2009 $894.03 741 CONNELLY ELECTRONICS 9906 7/29/2009 $846.40 8557 DAILEY DATA & ASSOCIATES 9907 7/29/2009 $151.23 4127 DANIMAL DISTRIBUTING INC 9908 7/29/2009 $448.40 9174 DAY DISTRIBUTING CO 9909 7/29/2009 $128.00 9730 DEERY AMERICAN CORPORATI 9910 7/29/2009 $4,242.22 807 DIAMOND VOGEL PAINTS 9911 7/29/2009 $704.39 4110 DICKSON ELECTRIC 9912 7/29/2009 $4,414.00 7371 DISCOUNT STEEL, INC. 9913 7/29/2009 $8.55 820 DORSEY & WHITNEY 9914 7/29/2009 $825.00 4135 ELECTRO WATCHMAN INC 9915 7/29/2009 $572.58 8697 EXTREME BEVERAGE 9916 7/29/2009 $33.50 9654 FRECHETTE/BRENDA 9917 7/29/2009 $146.21 1030 G & K SERVICES INC 9918 7/29/2009 $701.82 9646 GRAHAM CONSTRUCTION SERV 9919 7/29/2009 $65,974.45 1250 GRAINGER 9920 7/29/2009 $28.81 4172 GRAPE BEGINNINGS, INC. 9921 7/29/2009 $130.25 4175 GRIGGS COOPER & CO INC 9922 7/29/2009 $31,591.96 1420 HAWKINS, INC 9923 7/29/2009 $439.19 8944 HENN CNTY INFO TECH DEPT 9924 7/29/2009 $2,986.96 1505 HENNEPIN COUNTY SHERIFF 9925 7/29/2009 $225.00 4207 HOHENSTEIN'S, INC 9926 7/29/2009 $5,337.75 8252 HOME DEPOT CREDIT SERVIC 9927 7/29/2009 $408.38 8438 INSIGNIA SYSTEMS, INC. 9928 7/29/2009 $615.52 8658 INSTRUMENTAL RESEARCH, 1 9929 7/29/2009 $85.50 8707 J. SPANJERS CO., INC. 9930 7/29/2009 $2,600.00 4125 JJ TAYLOR DISTRIBUTING 9931 7/29/2009 $58,074.73 U.S.BANK ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE CHECK REGISTER 21 VENDOR PAYEE CHECK # DATE AMOUNT 8349 JOHN'S SOD 9932 7/29/2009 $111.82 4220 JOHNSON BROTHERS LIQUOR 9933 7/29/2009 $40,791.96 9733 KUSSKE CONSTRUCTION, INC 9934 7/29/2009 $120,602.89 9150 LABOR AND INDUSTRY 9935 7/29/2009 $20.00 4229 LARSON/MICHAEL 9936 7/29/2009 $288.28 9729 LIFT BRIDGE BEER CO. 9937 7/29/2009 $780.00 2040 LILLIE SUBURBAN NEWSPAPE 9938 7/29/2009 $810.52 8418 LMCIT %BERKLEY RISK SVCS 9939 7/29/2009 $35,720.50 8229 LOFFLER BUSINESS SYSTEMS 9940 7/29/2009 $1,463.67 9114 M. AMUNDSON LLP 9941 7/29/2009 $1,472.43 4265 MARK VII SALES INC 9942 7/29/2009 $13,394.92 2160 MARSHALL CONCRETE PROD 9943 7/29/2009 $138.67 9459 MIDC ENTERPRISES 9944 7/29/2009 $108.94 8467 MIDWAY FORD 9945 7/29/2009 $44.46 5010 MINN CONWAY FIRE & SAFET 9946 7/29/2009 $45.74 7340 MINNEAPOLIS FINANCE DEPT 9947 7/29/2009 $3,843.70 2355 MINNESOTA GFOA 9948 7/29/2009 $225.00 8850 MINNESOTA HIGHWAY SAFETY 9949 7/29/2009 $1,464.00 8494 MINNESOTA MUNICIPAL 9950 7/29/2009 $5,000.00 8269 MINNESOTA SHREDDING LLC 9951 7/29/2009 $57.00 2360 MN CONWAY FIRE & SAFETY 9952 7/29/2009 $163.26 4299 MPLS. OXYGEN CO. 9953 7/29/2009 $10.26 2395 MTI DISTRIBUTING, INC 9954 7/29/2009 $421.01 7370 MYERS TIRE SUPPLY COMPAN 9955 7/29/2009 $9.50 8883 NEW FRANCE WINE COMPANY 9956 7/29/2009 $347.00 9266 NORTHERN WATERWORKS SUP 9957 7/29/2009 $485.84 9715 NORTHWEST ASPHALT, INC. 9958 7/29/2009 $337,289.46 45 OFFICE DEPOT 9959 7/29/2009 $587.17 1230 ONE CALL CONCEPTS, INC. 9960 7/29/2009 $315.60 4354 PAUSTIS & SONS 9961 7/29/2009 $1,214.75 4360 PHILLIPS WINE & SPIRITS 9962 7/29/2009 $8,591.14 4161 PREMIUM WATERS, INC 9963 7/29/2009 $120.00 9139 PROPERTY KEY, INC. 9964 7/29/2009 $50.00 4385 QUALITY WINE CO 9965 7/29/2009 $23,438.46 4492 QWEST 9966 7/29/2009 $491.65 9550 RAMSEY COUNTY 9967 7/29/2009 $230.00 0257 SILVER LAKE CONDOMINIUMS 9968 7/29/2009 $565.00 8983 SOULO DESIGN, INC 9969 7/29/2009 $85.00 9259 SPRINT 9970 7/29/2009 $327.92 1810 ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE KIWA 9971 7/29/2009 $165.00 9731 STERTIL-KONI USA, INC. 9972 7/29/2009 $25,845.68 4780 SURLY BREWING CO 9973 7/29/2009 $819.00 3260 T A SCHIFSKY & SONS 9974 7/29/2009 $237.38 9218 THREE D SPECIALTIES 9975 7/29/2009 $727.55 7337 TIMESAVER OFF SITE SECRE 9976 7/29/2009 $136.85 7196 TRANSPORTATION SUPPLIES 9977 7/29/2009 $18.46 8824 TRI -COUNTY BEVERAGE, INC 9978 7/29/2009 $270.00 9732 U OF M PLANT DISEASE 9979 7/29/2009 $225.00 8859 U.S. BANK 9980 7/29/2009 $23,516.25 9590 U.S. BANK 9981 7/29/2009 $21.15 U.S.BANK ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE CHECK REGISTER 22 VENDOR PAYEE 8561 UNITED RENTALS NORTHWEST 8227 VERIZON WIRELESS 4451 VINOCOPIA 8388 W. W. GOETSCH ASSOCIATES 9702 W.D. LARSON COMPANIES LT 9292 WELLS FARGO BANK 8316 WINE COMPANY/THE 8310 WINE MERCHANTS INC 9734 WIRTZ BEVERAGE MINNESOTA 4499 WORLD CLASS WINES, INC. 8273 WSB & ASSOCIATES, INC. 2680 XCEL ENERGY CHECK# DATE AMOUNT 9982 7/29/2009 $455.97 9983 7/29/2009 $58.98 9984 7/29/2009 $165.00 9985 7/29/2009 $225.51 9986 7/29/2009 $0.76 9987 7/29/2009 $230,039.37 9988 7/29/2009 $222.30 9989 7/29/2009 $842.66 9990 7/29/2009 $11,843.35 9991 7/29/2009 $92.00 9992 7/29/2009 $40,489.50 9993 7/29/2009 $25,748.02 TOTAL $1,217,235.80 23 (:!00(7 12.6�2FS7- ©R GO NG(L CQ 51��12.4-T"lUN Report Date: July 23, 2009 Meeting Date: July 23, 2009 Agenda Section: III. D. ITEM DESCRIPTION: Resolution 09-063; Accepting a Grant from CenterPoint Energy for the St. Anthony Fire Department. MANAGER'S REVIEW: The St. Anthony Fire Department applied for a Community Partnership Grant with CenterPoint Energy for assist in the costs of new pagers. CenterPoint Energy accepted their application and presented the funds to the Fire Chief at the June 23, 2009 City Council meeting. This resolution is accepting the funds for the finance department. City Manager Attachments: • Resolution 09-063; Accepting a Grant from CenterPoint Energy for the St. Anthony Fire Department, ZACouncil Meetings12009W7282009\staffgrantcenterpoint.doe - 1 - CITY OF ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE RESOLUTION 09-063 A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A GRANT FROM CENTERPOINT ENERGY FOR THE ST. ANTHONY FIRE DEPARTMENT WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony's Fire Department applied for a Community Partnership Grant with CenterPoint Energy; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony's Fire Department received notification that their application was accepted; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony's Fire Department was presented with a check from CenterPoint Energy at the June 23, 2009 City Council meeting; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony's Fire Department will apply the grant for purchasing new pagers. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of St. Anthony hereby accepts the Grant from the CenterPoint Energy for the St. Anthony Fire Department. Adopted this 28tt, day of Luly 2009. Mayor ATTEST: City Clerk Review for Administration: City Manager Z9Council Meetings\2009\07282009\resgrantecnterpoinlLdoc 24 STAFF REPORT 5 To: Mayor and Council City Manager From; Kim Moore -Sykes, Assistant City Manager Date: July 28, 2009 Subject: Conditional Use Permit for T -Mobile, 2601 Kenzie Terrace (§90.06) Requested Action: Public Hearing on Conditional Use Permit Application — T -Mobile Date Application Deceived: May 18, 2009 Property Address: 2601 Kenzie Terrace, Kenzington Condominiums Zoning District: PUD 60 -Day Expires: July 16, 2009 Waiver Letter Required: X Yes; Sent: May 26, 2009 No Future Action: Council Action: July 28, 2009 Council Meeting. Background: Jed Kruchten, T -Mobile, contacted Staff about the process for obtaining a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow for the placement of cell phone antennas on the roof of the Kenzington of St. Anthony, a condominium planned unit development (PUD) at 2601 Kenzie Terrace. Mr. Kruchten reported to Staff that he had met with the Board regarding a telecommunication antenna proposal and the Board ultimately voted to allow the installation of the antenna and related equipment. After receiving approval from the Kenzington Board, Mr. Kruchten met with Staff to further discuss the CUP process. Staff advised Mr. Kruchten of the timeline for the approval process and encouraged him to schedule a concept review of the project. A concept review was held for T -Mobile at the April 21, 2009 Planning Commission meeting. The T -Mobile application was submitted to City and received by Staff on May 18, 2009, with a public hearing scheduled for June 16, 2009. Staff received information from T -Mobile that due to a backup in their workload, T- Mobile wanted to reschedule the public hearing for their application for July 21, 2009. The 60 - Day Rule expired on July 17, 2009 and a letter was sent to Mr. Kruchten on May 26, 2009, advising him that the City would require an extension to the 60 -Day Rule in order to provide a review of the CUP application at a public hearing on July 21, 2009 with the Planning Commission and with City Council action on the Planning Commission recommendation at the July 28, 2009 City Council meeting. Application Review: The applicant has followed the procedure in applying for Conditional Use Permit (CUP) as outlined in Section 152.243 Conditional Use Permits. The applicant responded to the following criterion as part of their application process. These responses were provided to the Planning Commission for the public hearing in a letter from Mr. Kruchten. Criteria #1 The use is one of the Conditional Uses specifically listed for the district in which the property is located and is not in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan. 07212009 CUP T -Mobile 2601 Kesizie Public Hearing.doc Criteria #2 The use will not be detrimental to the health, safety, or general welfare of persons residing o12 6 working in the vicinity or to the values of property in the vicinity. Criteria #3 The use will provide a service or a facility, which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare, Criteria #4 The City Council has specified all conditions, which the Council deems necessary to make the use compatible with other uses in the area. The CUP application was reviewed and also considered with the following items: A. Generally. Unless it is a permitted use in accordance with §90.05, a tower or WRF shall be permitted only if a conditional use permit (CUP) has been issued for that use by the City Council. The following provisions shall govern the issuance of a CUP for towers or WFTs by the City Council. 1. In granting a CUP, the City Council may impose conditions to the extent necessary to minimize any adverse effect of the proposed tower or WTF on adjoining properties. 2. Any information of an engineering nature that the applicant submits, whether civil, mechanical, or electrical, shall be certified by a licensed professional engineer. B. Towers & Wireless Telecommunication Towers. A scaled site plan clearly indicating the location, type, and height of the proposed tower, on-site land uses and zoning, adjacent land uses and zoning, adjacent roadways, proposed means of access, setbacks from property lines, elevation drawings of the proposed tower and any other structures, topography, parking, and any other information deemed by the City Staff to be necessary to access compliance with Section §90.04. 2. The legal description of the subject property on which the proposed tower is to be constructed. 3. The setback distance between the proposed tower and the nearest residential property. 4. The separation distance from other towers and the type of construction for the existing towers and the identity of the owners/ operators of the existing towers. 5. Landscape plan showing specific landscape materials. 6. Method of fencing, finished color, and if applicable, the method of camouflage. 7. A statement of compliance with all applicable Federal, State or local laws. 8. A notarized statement by the applicant as to whether construction of the tower will accommodate collocation of additional antennas for future users. 9. A description of the suitability of the use of the existing towers, other structures, or alternative technology not requiring the use of a tower or new structure to provide the services to be provided through the use of the proposed new tower. 07212009 CUP T -Mobile 2601 Kenzie Public I-Iearing.doc 10. A description of the feasible locations of future towers or WTFs within the City based2 7 upon existing physical, engineering, technological or geographical limitations in the event the proposed tower is erected. C. Factors Considered in Granting a Conditional Use Permit for Towers & WTFs. 1. Height of the proposed tower. 2. Proximity of the tower to residential structures and residential district boundaries. 3. Nature of uses on adjacent and nearby properties. 4. Design of the tower, with particular reference to design characteristics that have the effect of reducing or eliminating visual obtrusiveness. 5. Proposed ingress and egress. No other existing tower or structure is located within the geographic area that meets the applicant's engineering requirements. 7. If existing towers or structures are within the geographic area but do not have sufficient structural strength to support the applicant's proposed WTF and related equipment. 8. The applicant's proposed WTF would not cause electromagnetic interference with 1 or more WTFs on existing towers or structures, or a WTF on the existing towers or structures would cause interference with the applicant's proposed WTF. The fees, costs, or contractual provisions required by the owner in order to share an existing tower or structure of to adapt an existing tower or structure for sharing are unreasonable. Costs exceeding new tower development are presumed to be unreasonable. 10. The applicant demonstrates that an alternative technology that does not require the use of towers or structures is unsuitable. Costs of alternative technology that exceed new tower or antenna development shall not be presumed to render the technology unsuitable. 11. All towers for which a CUP is required shall be separated by an minimum of 750 feet between the proposed tower and any pre-existing tower, unless however, that the City Council, after considering any recommendations of the City Staff, may reduce the standard separation requirements if the purposes of this Chapter would be better served by doing so. Staff received no calls or emails opposing this CUP application. Attachments: • Site Map • Application • Applicant Letter 07212009 CUP T -Mobile 2601 Kenzie Public Hearing.doc W. July 17, 2009 City of St. Anthony Planning Commission c/o Ms. Kim Moore -Sykes Assistant City Manager Request: Conditional Use Permit to locate Telecommunications Antennas or as defined by the City of St. Anthony, in Section 1680.03, Subd. 7: a Wireless Telecommunications Facility (WTF), for T -Mobile on the existing building located at 2601 Kenzie Terrace in the City of St. Anthony. T -Mobile's agent Integrated Wireless Development, is respectfully requesting approval of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to be granted to T -Mobile to locate a WTF on an existing building as outlined in Section 152.243, and has outlined and addressed the issues facing T -Mobile in finding a site that meets the coverage objectives for this area. Necessity of Proposed Location: T -Mobile is one of the nations leading providers of wireless services with an established footprint in the Minneapolis — St. Paul region. As the request for services has grown, T -Mobile has realized the need to improve coverage in order to meet their customer's needs and frequency requirements set forth by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). The proposed site at 2601 Kenzie Terrace, in the City of St. Anthony fills coverage gap along CR136 & St. Anthony Parkway. Compliance: Per section 1680.04 Subd. 10, T -Mobile has searched to find the best site for coverage as well as the guidelines set forth by the city of St. Anthony. Per Section 152.243 Conditional Use Permits: T -Mobile responds to the following: Criterion #1: the proposed location is on an existing building located in a PUD and as per discussion with the City is requesting a CUP for the WTF antennas installation. T -Mobile does not believe that the location of these antennas is in conflict with the comprehensive plan. Criterion #2: The use will not be detrimental to the health, safety, or general welfare of persons residing or working within the vicinity or to the 2s values of property in the vicinity. T -Mobile is in compliance with all FCC requirements. Criteriion #3: With the installation of this WTF T -Mobile will be providing the coverage needed which is in the interest of the public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare. Criterion #4: T -Mobile will comply with all conditions as set forth by the City Council should this application be approved. T -Mobile has worked to locate the antennas on an existing building whose current height works for T -Mobile's coverage objectives. The Kenzington Condominium Association as well as the Gittleman Management Company are in agreement with the proposed collocation of antennas on this structure. Other uses in the area are commercial in nature or have been noticed through the application process without any response. There are no other towers in the area that meet T -Mobile's RF design criteria. T -Mobile's proposed WTF will not cause any electromagnetic interference and has not noted any applications in the surrounding area which would cause interference at the proposed location. T - Mobile's network supports the installation of antennas on towers or existing structures. Thank you very much for your consideration. T -Mobile is working diligently to continue to provide seamless coverage in the City of St. Anthony. Sincerely, Jed Kruchten Integrated Wireless Development for T -Mobile 214-882-6630 �c ,^.CCain thon 31 V. X11 e C 3301 Silver Lake Road, St. Anthony, Minnesota 55418-16.99 Office: (612) 782-3301 • Fax (612) 782-3302 • Www.d.saint-anthony.mn.us May 26, 2009 Mr. Joey Gay, T•Mobile Agent :2601 Kenzie Terrace St. Anthony, MN 55418 RE: Conditional Use Permit for Installation of Antennas; 2601 Kenzie .Terrace Dear Mr. Gay: This letter is being sent as a notice to advise you that the City of St. Anthony will be extending the time requirements of the 60 -Day Rule to include July 28, 2009, at which time the City Council will be taking action on your Conditional Use Permit request. This extension of time will also include the Planning Commission meeting scheduled for July 21, 2009. Minnesota State Statutes require that any land use or zoning -related applications be approved or denied by the governing body within 60 days of receipt of the completed application by the political subdivision. The Statutes also allow an extension of an additional 60 days, provided that the political subdivision submits to the applicant(s) a written notice of this extension. Your application was received on May 18, 2009 and was initially scheduled to be reviewed and considered at a public hearing on June 16, 2009 by the Planning Commission, with the City Council taking up your request at their June 23, 2009 meeting. Due to the Memorial Day weekend and the need for the local newspaper to move up their publication schedule, I was not able to publish the public hearing notice for the required 10 business days prior to the scheduled public hearing with the Planning Commission. Therefore, I have rescheduled the pubic hearing for July 21, 2009 at 7:OOpm. This rescheduled public hearing is after the 60 -day deadline of July 17, 2009. You or a representative are be required to attend both the Planning Commission meeting and City Council meeting. If a representative is not present at or is unable to attend these meetings on the above -referenced dates, the Planning Commission and/or the City Council reserve the right to table this request until their next meeting. If you have questions or concerns regarding this process or your application, please feel free to contact me at 612-782-3312 or via e-mail, kmoore-sykes@cisaint-anthony.nui.us. Smcerel n Kim ooze -Sykes Assistant City Manager #+ Our Mission is to be a progressiue and livable community, a walkable village, which is safe and secure. Date: (60 -Day Rule Effective) knc C 7"", C6cL Fee: $130.00 City of St. Antkony Application for Conditional Use Permit Zi 1�T r.5-{ c:N ,�uY,Son *)ry-- «.t_ Applicant: :Y- NN0 tOt Id, Phone: LU L4 ` -,� 12 -Nm Address: Status of Applicant: (Owner, Buyer, Renter, Agent, etc.) � -0� G2- Street Address and/or Legal Description of Subject Property: Zoning Designation of Subject Property: ��nn+cE Ur`t+Ie 1oQn}''\\ Reason for Conditional Use Permit Request: pht e -i/l zAncC n. . `i e- "ViVw-f -i�.-�, \JUt d1'\S APPLICANTS, PLEASE NOTE: Minnesota Statutes and City Ordinances require that the following criteria must be satisfied before a Conditional Use may be authorized. Please respond in writing to these criteria, using additional sheets, if necessary. 1.) The requested Conditional Use is one of the Permitted Conditional Uses specifically listed for the Zoning District in which the Conditional Use is to be located. 2.) Explain how the requested Conditional Use will not be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or injurious to property values of improvements in the area. C,6" r r\ a g kc.� bee^ rv-c e) )n-) - V -P N r -a)- 40 \c;�t, �\c-zcr-dWs 4-6 4k. pub► c , 3.) Explain why the requested Conditional Use is necessary or desirable at the above location to provide a service or a facility which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare of the neighborhood or communi r T= abilc` s PJ: err�inte�5 cl,\Dse ilnls c7 �Ss lac4ii� to cve4- gy db'�e�tiu� -�u Svn� dl n} ►�e �o�l. l��o�i. C:\Doeuments and Settings\BSuciu\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Filcs\OLK3C\Con(litional Use Request 2005.doe 1 - pv-��rxrcz cmc re G25Scry �� c)&O-1�-A& covTrF19- -�3 N Su rruvr-d i A3 c ,%� AMY. :... t O • C � Cb n��y• 1 O �D AMY. :... t wmki to 01" cb CA ch 0 ell wa 0 wmki 01" � 354 ell wmki U) :C) lb , -tD • cb '73. ::3 (D Q ::3 - cp CD Z3 ro -4y CL b %) _0 U) 77 (D 11 smoll-U-71, iLsk � -i � S_rti Y CD `C GCD O o -°m CD G ® > j �CD _5 CDr-L C, •—�� Lig —y _t i � Cis 6 R Ig $ jR € 4g ng 1A�' 6R ja9gJjyx 1RGg 11111p g4 ljsg � ag6@ 1331616g€ 111 R9 € a 480,1 • r' '1REs ^2 a! k@g R $ §g4 1 $ gl R §l �LR .oda s s R g€ :g2 a4;@ al'i c a s $�@ fl@ F Agga& g6 A€HE^R&� BB RgB i �'a@ is EIF a u @$tlaA mil 71 p ¢ g6 3 RSS k Rq 'e zg $'Epela�tq pg§RR glFaAFa€&gl �g6gE d4 ggg REgq aE aR2!'e Aa Raeai spg€ i.jg 23�d € ee¢'a P�gg � 4 E eg aG fp $p4�R g� �i� � S $��Yg� � t F § €pp g$a e4ea� �� ogu R.$$$Af� la nO p5p$� �I$ �A{,�99>e 3a P5 � @ Al gE a A R A gE F ]`�^It R` G S E E E $ 9 y4iyg 4 €� & ygR este ; eA Rex @q!� g !€ �Cgpg �yr � C Y ��� tl^•�¢ F AbY� Y Ey R F, 6 9 Eb A � O E Q Yri KS �'"P�OE��a[ � m F g v 6 Ss��REP �.4pR � 'RE R5q�d�}qgqyPy gR�a3nA R Ro P yy`�P ag E a r GGG p g $ ¢g gg p5p q yy 9ggEP 4 FEB N 1§111 3, �q aagg €€¢¢gi�J � pp g�g �2$HS I; RSgR pi's � b gg gMot 4R�9Q9Q`EDE�g5���5 5E ¢9 i In E R . 6P� �x'r,q�g��ypQ@�pQPp@�5�5�y�gAqKqCF� 0�q7 ����pppp¢�pppppp��x¢�gq�EgyRC�� RR yM ® �RgRRg.��FI; MFl9Rg y$$��g'¢Y¢Y s pr . � gg ��49�£:K§s �gaggagga�g)5)5 �a�ag§ gig ,b �g3535§ �� §g�gg�gY g 9�E4E (//T�T� IlV$�gnd4C �9q a€a EPE,§ g �S? ^ae C% v F €5 ���EAD �Y' MEAD 7sv 'S SF@@s$ 4g Gk pR €Egp¢ (W L�Fgp3 €a v P6 ERx g4 SqA� �22y�$ .; TpppT _'^ SS�y��fi tA�Ra¢$E9 �i55�j5'S �S%:YKanYYg¢ ppp$4p$pp3@p�p"ppp_pp_pTpp ii�j aiS9iS9i53n p_pTpp ti ppppS Fr{� Rp pi�p�µgYq�T 5�j53y 5gS9ig3i� pT it555�[ pY ppR 5 RAFRAR tp5tp �j5�j �j3�j5 Ta5g5�j �j5g �5j �5j�[ S9 j F S R�E� 55@Y@EY$.^.£SII R'r3q'n B7�5g6CEiRC4E5RivE¢g��'4 P'¢'E R€RRa9�Fr.NY Fae� B d�p Yq�� �� frg §R4Raa'4i5�4�-z ff6E Fnp•g�'�E �� a 4 $ & g I'r. 4; s � � $5 9 > as"A'4 $�F a�•:y:g4zgagp4'+�' < � $ y '�+ v � * aR•P e qq ; 9R �€{ E�555y(}Ep'qax"^kA^p€ �� ,�i'�63RPgrv3J(�FeYO@..�� n p ea 91 Vs a VR €' �e F Baa 453 a rye € s ¢ r !O ff r EO IR 3 .M ';X ' I#p p47e d aa?y345Nnnn 66p t p 55 �t7 nn .» 6 55 555565 a aa6 �qgg Ezl�._ : Ca F € F.5§_R 4 °Ic E. G E 8p3 $$ �IE Re 05 �`% ?1 `t � [ aa •, ••AVFV✓� e a� } 4 R����`�qq��B�8�R�paB V $ Lqp y{ £q £3g SRF �p n < GY :yx N -_i qp �� O RQ{{pin(S(yy"iy `3�Ya}S pgVY CELS pStE 3 Gy Pd Pp ayya`biR3g •]tl']• P n ^.0 fi 2p jJ y I O Sm Llmz � r �SiRih��3 k fr :kg e� gE & z an y O y I I o p Pf R R B 5 iti s { i 9 H1 0 y 9 %99 g Xlel000 I ' 9 ik,�� 1 ff io li ! J � J.3IIH JNIISIX3 r „o -- �•;m?rmmmrrzn?n ;rir;nr; n; 01 0 43 CITY OF ST, ANTHONY VILLAGE RESOLUTION 09-064 RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THE REQUEST FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT (CUP) FOR A WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS ANTENNA AND FACILITIES (WTF) AT 2601 KENZIE TERRACE. WHEREAS, Representatives from T -Mobile submitted an application for a Conditional Use Permit under City Code §90.05; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony Planning Commission held a Concept Review on April 21, 2009 to review T -Mobile's CUP request to install WTF and related equipment on the roof of the Kenzington Condominiums at 2601 Kenzie Terrace; and WHEREAS, a 60 Day Extension Notice advising of the need to waive the 60 Day Rule and extend the timeline by, an additional 60 days was sent on May 26, 2009 to Mr. Joey Gay and to Mr. Jed Kruchten, both T -Mobile agents; and WHEREAS, a public hearing was rescheduled and the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on July 21, 2009 on the proposed CUP; and WHEREAS, all required public notices regarding the public hearing were posted and sent as required by State Statute; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has recommended approval of the proposed CUP to the City Council based upon testimony presented by the applicant, the affirmative vote of the majority of the condominium association in favor of installing the cell phone antennas; and no comments in opposition to the proposed conditional use permit for the cell phone antennas at the conclusion of the public hearing; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has recommended approval based on additional written and verbal testimony from the applicant and other interested persons; and WHEREAS, upon consideration of the application and supporting materials, Staff's report, and all other information constituting the record of this application, the City Council upon further deliberation, voted to approve the requested Conditional Use Permit and directed the preparation of the Findings of Fact and this resolution as a contemporaneous record of the Council's decision; and THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of St. Anthony does hereby adopt the following Findings of Fact related to the requested CUP: Findings: Criteria #1 The use is one of the Conditional Uses specifically listed for the district in which the property is located and is not in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan. Finding #1 This use is not in conflict with the current Comprehensive Plan. The Comprehensive Plan designates this site as PUD Residential and according to the City's Zoning Code, Chapter IX, WIRELESS TELECOMMUICATION TOWERS, §90.06, Permitted Conditional Use Permits, states a tower or WTF shall be permitted only if a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) has been applied for, the applicant has complied with the requirements of this Subsection and those of Subsection 152.243, Conditional Use Permits; and approved by the City Council. Criteria #2 The use will not be detrimental to the health, safety, or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or to the values of property in the vicinity. Finding #2 The applicant stated that T -Mobile is in compliance with all FCC requirements. Testimony from the Kenzington Condominium Association Board and residents affirmed that they had participated in the negotiations to bring the rooftop cell phone antennas to the Kenzington and held a vote among the residents that approved the negotiated contract. Criteria #3 The use will provide a service or a facility, which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare. Finding #3 The proposed siting and installation of the wireless telecommunications antenna and related equipment cabinets will provide the coverage needed and which is in the best interest of the public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare. Criteria #4 The City Council has specified all conditions, which the Council deems necessary to make the use compatible with other uses in the area. • Landscaping amendments at the discretion of the Association to screen equipment cabinets from the view of the residents and neighboring property. • Establish and maintain a six (6) foot clearance between the telecommunications equipment cabinet and the property line, where possible, to allow for the passage of T - Mobile repair/maintenance personnel, Kenzington maintenance personnel, and City Public Safety personnel. • T -Mobile will be required to notifij the City should any significant upgrades in technology be required or preferred to improve coverage. Significant upgrades will require an amendment to the CUP. Minor adjustinents to improve reception or service will not require an amendment to the CUP. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the City Council that the application to issue a Conditional Use Permit to T -Mobile to install and locate roof top cell phone antennas and related equipment at 2061 Kenzie Terrace is hereby approved and subject to the above -referenced conditions. Adopted this 28�h day of July 2009. ATTEST: City Clerk Reviewed for Administration: Mayor City Manager 45 STAFF REPORT 6 To: Mayor and Council City Manager From: Kim Moote-Sykes, Assistant City Manager Date: July 28, 2009 Subject: Fence Height Variance — 2912 Silver Lake Court Requested-Action- Date e uestedAction: Date Application Received: Property Address: Zoning District: 60 -Day Expires: Waiver Letter Required: Public Hearing May 26, 2009 2912 Silver Lake Court R1 -A July 24, 2009 Yes X Date Sent: June 29, 2009 No Future Action: Council Action on the Fence Height Variance Request for 2912 Silver Lake Court Background: The owner of 2912 Silver Lake Court, Mr. Ronald Severson, contacted Staff about the process for obtaining a two (2) -foot variance to the City's fence ordinance at Subsection 150.072, (C) Fence Size. The City's ordinance restricts the height of fences at the building setback or behind to six (6) feet. Mr. Severson reported that he is requesting to be able to replace his 6 -foot back fence with an 8 -foot back fence. He explained that his property is adjacent to 2916 Silver Labe Court, the owners of which were granted a 2 -foot variance in 2008 to install an 8 -foot back fence to block out traffic noise and street lights from Silver Lake Road. Mr. Severson indicated that he too, has to deal with the same traffic noise and street light -issues from Silver Lake Road. Application Review As part of the application process, the applicant is required to provide evidence that discloses facts that are unique to the subject property. Section 152.245 of the City Ordinance outlines the requirements that must be addressed to qualify for a variance and the process by which a variance is granted. Specifically Section 152.245 (C) states that no variance will be granted unless evidence presented supports the following facts: Strict enforcement would cause undue hardship because: Theproperty cannot be tut to a reasonable use without the variance. Mr. Severson proposes to replace kis back fence with a fence that will be two feet higher than the current fence to act as a barrier to vehicular noise and street lights, maintaining their property values and to continue the City's goal of keeping housing stock that is safe and livable. The circumstances causing the hardship were not created by the owner. The current house was built in 1968, at a time when there were less traffic on Silver Lake Road. Due to the slope of the backyard, the six-foot fence currently in existence is located on the lowest site of the property and is not sufficient to buffer traffic noise or 07212009 2912 Silver Lake Court Council Fence Variarice.doc street lights. Mr. Severson is proposing to replace the current fence with an eight -foot fence if a variance is 47 granted: The variance if granted will not alter the essential characteristics of the locality. Rebuilding the fence to eight feet high will not be a detriment to the neighborhood and will more in keeping with the essential characteristics of the area. Mr. Severson stated that their neighbor to the northeast has an eight (8) foot fence, for which the City granted a variance. Economic considerations alone 'are not the basis of the hardship. While the variance if approved, would maintain the value of this property, it is not the only consideration for the property owners. They have expressed a need to have a privacy fence that would reduce the amount of noise and light impacting the enjoyment of their property. The circumstances causinZ the hardship are unique to the individual lot. The lot is an interior, residential lot built adjacent to Silver Lake Road in 1965. The Severson propose to replace the fence because it is in need of repair and they would like to replace it with a higher fence, similar to the fences of their neighbor, who are also adjacent to Silver Lake Road. While the situation does also affect several neighbors, it is unique to those residential properties along Silver Lake Road. The Rranting of the variance is in kee in with the sl2irit and intent of the Zonin Code. The Zoning Code was adopted to protect the health, safety and general welfare of the City and its people. By granting this variance, the Seversons will be able to install an eight foot fence that will provide some level of protection from the noise from the traffic on Silver Lake Road and light shed from the street lights. Action: Pass a recommend to Council to approve or deny the two -foot variance request to the City's Fence Height Ordinance based on the findings of fact as derived from information presented by the applicants and Staff. Communications: Staff received no calls of concerns about the installation of the higher fence. Attachments: • Application and supporting documents • Site Map • Photograph of Site 07212009 2912 Silver Lake Court Council Fence Variane.doc M r�48 May 22, 2009 Kim Moore -Sykes Assistant City Manager St. Anthony Village 3301 Silver Lake Road St. Anthony, MN 55418-1699 Dear Ms Moore -Sykes: I have enclosed the Variance application and property line inspection permit for the fence replacement at 2912 Silver Lake Court. If you have any questions or need additional information, please contact me. Sincerely, Ronald J S verson 2912 Silver Lake Court St. Anthony, MN 55421 612-360-1466 3301 Silver Lake Road • St. Anthony, MN 55418 • (p) 612.782.3301 • (f) 612.782.3302 www.ci.saint-`anthony. mn.us VARIANCE APPLICATION SUPPLEMENTAL DATA A. GENERAL DATA Ronald S Severson APPLICANT, S NAME: The above-named individual, firm, or corporation hereby respectfully submits the following supplemental data insupport of the preliminary information provided on the accompanying zoning application summary form dated 5/22/09 for the purpose of securing a variance from existing land use zoning controls. Severson Ronald 612-360-1466 Contact Person Last Name First Day Phone B. PROJECT INFORMATION 150.072 (C) 1. Specify the section of the Ordinance from which a variance is sought: 2. Explain how you wish to vary from the applicable provisions of the Ordinance: Replace excisting 6 foot fence on back property line with 8 foot fence 3. Explain why the strict enforcement of the Ordinance would cause an undue hardship or deny reasonable use of the property. State Statute defines hardship as the following: Undue hardship as used in connection with the granting of a variance means the property in questions cannot be put to a reasonable use if used under conditions allowed by the official controls, the plight of the landowner is due to circumstances unique to the property not created by the landowner, and the variance if granted, will not alter the essential the character of the locality. STATEMENT ATTACHED 4. Check all additional supporting documents and date which are being submitted to help explain this project proposal: 51 Site Plan ❑ Topographic Map k] Other (specify) Picture I IdEREBY CERTIFY wi'rii MY SIGNATURE 'I A'1' ALL DATA ON MY APPLICATION FORMS, PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS ARE TRUE AND CORRECT'PO TI- :ST' OF MY E 5/22/09 Si atme of pplicant Date ORDER GRANTING OR DENYING A VARIANCE In accordance with the fundings stated on the reverse side of this document, the City of St. Anthony hereby (] approves, (] denies the foregoing application for variance. If approved, said approval is subject to the general and special conditions following the findings section on page 2. BY: -- --- — -- - --- - - -- — -- -- ----- - Authoiized Signahne Title Date 1-1:APlanning\1'onns\Variance Application 200`i.doc 50 S ILvs2 LA%4e C ovvtt gnb�tE SS z9 i2 S Ewen L+e� (��e�e VARIANCE APPLICATION STATEMENT 51 Address 2912 Silver Lake Court St, Anthony, MN 55421-3453 Legal description Sect -31 Twp -030 Range -023 Harstad Second Addition Lot 3 Block 3 PIN 31.30.23.24.0005 Owner name, address 2912 Silver Lake Court and phone number St. Anthony, MN 55421-3453 612-789-8750 Zoning District R-1 Unique circumstances The back of the lot is lower than the house so the fence is in the lowest spot. The property is located close to Silver Lake Road and road noise and lights impact adversely, at times, with use and enjoyment of the back yard. Due to low location of the fence and the fact that the neighbor on the east side has an 8 foot fence, the replacement fence should not alter the character of the locality Drawing Attached Statement of request Replace excisting 6 foot fence on back property line with an 8 foot fence. 52 4A qJI ` � � �%' al., � � �'.�! +' l\+lam! '1� 1�' •4..a-= � � � �. T�} i '`v -ell - 4,;m&piorer v4 Page I of I tike Ramsey County Online Maps & Data Map Layers Lege6d Navigation Current Selection neo KIJ Parcel Polygons on: feature round ftan y 0-n S-wrh by Pm el cmumo I ID Saamh ramal ID 313D23240005 WaMt Humba, 2912 0 U.It sw*at SILVER lA1x: cr CKY SLANTIONY ZNP SWI -3453 AI Ower Nam: 1 IDI SEVERSON 40 o...Nam 2 WAY *NE SEVERSON 8-4 own. Strwt,; .7912 SILVER mdr LAKE CT ownw ST ANMONY Chy/Stabs/210 MN 5"21-1453 Hamoat.o. Name I RONALD I SEVERSON Reference Map: Find a Location Query/Select Maps/Reports Other Tools 53 5/14/2009 54 CITY OF ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE RESOLUTION 09-065 A RESOLUTION FOR A VARIANCE FOR FENCE HEIGHT OF TWO (2) FEET FOR 2912 SILVER LAKE COURT WHEREAS, The property owner of 2912 Silver Lake Court, Ronald Severson, submitted an application for a two -foot variance to the City's fence ordinance, Title XV, Chapter 150, Subsection §150.072 (C) Fence Size. WHEREAS, Mr. Severson is proposing to replace his six-foot back fence that is adjacent to Silver Lake Road with an eight -foot back fence to reduce the traffic noise and street lights from Silver Lake Road. WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony Planning Commission held a Concept Review on May 19 , 2009 to review Mr. Severson s request for two -foot variance to the fence height ordinance; and WHEREAS, Mr. Severson submitted an application for a variance on May 26,2009; and WHEREAS, as the 60 -Day Rule expired on July 24, 2009, Mr. Severson was given written notice of the City's need for an extension; and WHEREAS, a public hearing was scheduled with the Planning Commission and was held on July 21, 2009 for the proposed two -foot variance; and WHEREAS, all required public notices regarding the public hearing were posted and sent as required by State Statute; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has recommended approval of the proposed two -foot variance to the City Council based upon the information presented by the Staff, the applicants presentation and that no one from the public appeared in opposition to the proposed variance request for the additional two (2) feet of fence; and WHEREAS, upon consideration of the application and supporting materials, Staff's report, and all other information constituting the record of this application, the City Council upon further deliberation, voted to approve the requested variance to the City's fence height variance and directed the preparation of the Findings of Fact and this resolution as a contemporaneous record of the Council's decision; and THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of St. Anthony does hereby adopt the following Findings of Fact related to the requested variance: Findings: 1. The variance, if granted, will not alter the essential characteristics of the locality. Rebuilding the fence to eight (8) feet will not be a detriment to the neighborhood and will be more in keeping with the essential characteristics of the area. The Seversons have reported that their neighbors to the northeast each have an eight (8) foot fence. 2. The Seversons propose to replace the back fence with a fence that will act as a barrier to vehicular noise and lights from the commercial properties on the east side of Silver Lake Road, which are outside the corporate boundaries of the City of St. Anthony, and are therefore not subject to the City's ordinances. Allowing the variance to the back fence height will maintain their property values and continue the City's goal of keeping housing stock that is safe and livable. The circumstances causing the hardship were not created by the owner. The current house was built in 1968, at a time when there were less traffic on Silver Lake Road. Additionally, due to the slope of the backyard, the six-foot fence currently in existence is located on the lowest elevation of the property and is not sufficient to buffer traffic noise or street lights. Mr. Severson is proposing to replace the current fence with an eight - foot fence if a variance is granted. 4. Economic considerations alone are not the basis of the hardship. While the variance if approved would maintain the value of this property, it is not the only consideration for the property owners. They have expressed a need to have a privacy fence that would reduce the amount of noise and lighting impacting the enjoyment of their property. 5. The circumstances causing the hardship are unique to the individual lot. The lot is an interior, residential lot built adjacent to Silver Lake Road in 1968. The Severson propose to replace the fence because it is in need of repair and they would like to replace it with an eight -foot fence, similar to their neighbors' fences. The granting of the variance is in keeping with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code. The Zoning Code was adopted to protect the health, safety and general welfare of the City and its residents. By granting this variance, the Seversons will be able to install an eight (8) foot back fence that will provide some level of protection from the noise created by the traffic on Silver Lake Road and from light shed by the commercial properties on the 55 east side of Silver Lake Road. By granting this variance, the Seversons feel they will have an improved enjoyment of their property. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the City Council that the application to grant the two -foot variance request to owners of 2912 Silver Lake Court to locate and install an eight -foot back fence is hereby approved. Adopted this 28th day of July 2009. ATTEST: Mayor City Clerk Reviewed for Administration: City Manager 56 STAFF REPORT To: Mayor and Council City Manager From: Kim Moore -Sykes, Assistant City Manager Date: duly 28, 2009 Subject: CUP Request for Electronic Sign at 3303 -- 33,d Avenue NE Requested Action: Date Application Received: Prol2eriy Address: Zoning District: 60 -Day Expires: Waiver Letter Required: Future Action: Public Hearing ISD 282 Application for CUP for an Electronic Sign June 10, 2009 3303 - 33rd Avenue NE Recreational/Open Space August 9, 2009 Yes Date Sent: No X City Council action on Planning Commission Recommendation re: Electronic Sign CUP — ISD 282 Background: Linn Bjornrud, Wold Architects and Engineers, contacted Staff to ask about the process For obtaining a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow for the placement of an electronic sign on the St. Anthony Middle School and High School property. Staff advised Mr. Bjornrud of the process and the City's sign ordinance at 155.29 DISTRICT SCHEDULES, (D), states that while electronic signs are permitted with an approved CUP in a Recreational/ Open Space Zoning District; flashing and animation are not permitted (2)(a); and hours of operation are restricted (2)(b). Application Review and Analysis: As part of the application, Mr. Bjornrud indicated that the proposed electronic sign will replace the two (2) signs that existed previously; one identified the St. Anthony Middles School and one identified the St. Anthony High School. One double -sided electronic sign will be used by both schools to communicate events to the community. 1. The requested conditional use is one of the Permitted Conditional Uses specifically listed for the zoning district in which the conditional use is located. City Code at 155.29 DISTRICT SCHEDULES, (D) Recreational Open Space, states that electronic signs are permitted with an approved CUP in the Recreational/ Open Space zoning district. 2. That the requested conditional use permit will not be detrimental to health, safety or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or injurious to property values of improvements in the area. The School District plans to replace the two (2) existing ground signs at the St. Anthony Middle School and the St. Anthony High School with one electronic sign. Mx. Bjornrud has indicated that the School District will adhere to City requirements regarding hours of operation of the sign. The City Code states that in no event shall the sign be permitted to be operated between the hours of 10:00 p.m, and 6:00 a.m., 155.29(D)(2)(b). 07212009 Council CUP 3303 33rd Ave electronic sign.doc Mr. Bjom=d stated that the School District will not include flashing or animation as part of the software program to be used for the proposed electronic sign so as to be in conformance with the City Code, 155.29(D)(2)(a). 3. The requested Conditional Use Permit is considered necessary or desirable at the subject location to provide a service or a facility which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare of the neighborhood or community. The School District states that it is the intent of this proposed electronic to communicate school district information and events that will be of interest to the community (155.29(D)(2)(0). Communications: Staff received no phone calls regarding the proposed electronic sign for this school location. One resident who attended the concept review and lives across the street from the Middle School/High School did voice concerns about the possible flashing, animation or brightness issues that might be associated with the proposed electronic sign. Staff also received a call from a resident who voiced objections about the public notification process for the electronic signs for both locations, Wilshire Park Elementary and the Middle School/High School. While the resident is not within the notification area either school, he was concerned that the community would find the information confusing and difficult to find. Attachments: • Application • Design. Drawing of the Proposed Sign • Proposed Sign Placement Aerial Photo of Property 07212009 Council CUP 3303 33rd Ave electronic sign.doc ri St. Anthony IkA New Brighton INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 282 June 16, 2009 Mr. Mike Morrison, City Manager City of St. Anthony Village 3301 Silver Lake Road St. Anthony, MN 55418 Dear Mike, On behalf of St. Anthony -New Brighton Schools District #282, I would like to thank you for the cooperative efforts displayed thus far regarding our current referendum projects. As part of the construction scope, we are requesting a Conditional Use Permit to replace the existing exterior monument signs at the Middle School, High School, and Wilshire Park Elementary School. We believe that these new monument signs will not only serve the purpose of building identification, but will also provide valuable service to the community through the proposed electronic message portion of the designs. This messaging capability will allow on -demand communication of school district and community events and information. While providing this service is important to us, respect for our neighbors is also paramount to the success of this design. The allowed hours of operation will ensure that these new installations do not disturb residents late in the evening or early in the morning. We feel confident that the design proposed complies with City Ordinances, and we welcome any comments or suggestions that the Planning Commission or City Council may have. Thank you for your consideration throughout this exciting process. Sincerely, Dr. Rod K. Thompson Superintendent of Schools RKT/sb €ri. f;m�? 1h�uot€�tsaie, Supennlenden� RrtE�o�sElasnry@sta¢i¢Phuralr.kl2.mn,ay 3303 33rd Aveirue 61E K St. Anthony, MM 55418 612.106.1150 L 612.106.1020 o,unvstmiihany.kl2.mn.us 59 Wo Date: 5.20.0% Fee: $1311. (60 -Day Rule Effective) Y� IJ_ ..-ol �/0 /Dq City of St. Anthony l Application for Conditional Use Permit Applicant: Mb%% VADIQ R° Se. 4"L OI LT? —T 11`24% Phone: 612.10(o. %00o Address: 33®16 SSM AM"14% Nr Status of Applicant: (Owner, Buyer, Renter, Agent, etc.) OW A e R Street Address and/or Legal Description of Subject Property: Wit &%k Zoning Designation of Subject Property: VWCA*A t'*14A6 0SMCW b%STJL%LT Reason for Conditional Use Permit Request: �ZQe%t-ST c Past C, Ve? S $AG* W%t4 &V4 SM APPLICANTS, PLEASE NOTE: Minnesota Statutes and City Ordinances require that the following criteria must be satisfied before a Conditional Use may be authorized. Please respond in writing to these criteria, using additional sheets, if necessary. 1.) The requested Conditional Use is one of the Permitted Conditional Uses specifically listed for the Zoning District in which the Conditional Use is to be located. 2.) Explain how the requested Conditional Use will not be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of persons -residing or working in the vicinity or injurious to property values o,` iinprovements in the area. 3.) l .plain why the requested Conditional Use is necessary or desirable at the above is catvon �> provide service c_~ a facility which is in the interest of public coavc nienc< and wili - olirI-J.1-dW the gc nclrai rvelfare of the nelgliborhood or conirnunrty. C ADocun cnu; and SC.J npSMkSuciaALocal ScChI I C[I)p Imy Inicmet I ucsVOI.IU( \Condit onai Us(: R, quest ?005-doc 61 Additionally, applicants must submit ALL of the following information to City Hall by the Tuesday that is thirty (30) days prior to the regularly scheduled meeting of the Planning Commission or City Council meeting at which the request will be heard at a Public Hearing. 1.) Completed application for the specific request and payment of the fee. 2.) Complete survey and site plans of the subject property (including dimensions and elevations) showing the building, driveways, curb cuts, ingress, egress, etc., on the property and in relation to adjacent properties. 3.) Explanation of materials to be used and plans for screening, landscaping, fencing and dumpster enclosures. 4.) Drawings of completed buildings, if appropriate to the project, and materials used. 5.) Storm water retention and drainage. The appropriate watershed district or water management organization are required to be notified of the project. 6.) A letter explaining the reason for the Conditional Use Permit. In the letter, please describe that the circumstances to warrant the need for the request. An incomplete application will not be scheduled before the Planning Commission or City Council. Signature of the Applicant: C:AOocum ents and Set tingsVBSueiuALocal SettingsV'TeIll porary Intetnct F l esV01,K3CVCond it on a Use Request 9005.doc I&NN"OTA lflO ILUNOIS Lu MICH6GAN ul :1 11 COLOLAVO k za it: V_V jg X-C r T T + rl ELECTRONIC Mf55A6F_ 516N M St. Anl6ny M New edoldon ("BMWOMT 50(00t DISTRICT 212 62 305 $T. PETER STREET WoLD Awcarmcrs AND ENGINEERS ST. PAUL, MN 55102 a I PRECAST 5HAPE 01 BRICK 1, TYPICAL SURFAGE MOUNTED LOGO WITH "HALO" BACK LIC?HTIN6 PfZECAST SHAPE #2 MONUMENT SIC -N F.A5T/^F.!5T ELMVATION 114" = 1'-0" )TE; PROPOSED 516N SURFAGE 1PY AREA 5HOINN HATIGHED. )TAL = 37A 5F PER SIDE )TAL = 15.8 5F GRAND TOTAL )TAL = ( ALLOWED 80 5-F, fillpr AIFF 8? PROJECT: s c-Hool-I 2001, 1 -10 -MUNT" DATE: 2/1b1061 COMMISSION NO: M2150 REVISION" REV. DAT E: A"It ProjeCt Filgs\:A -,.laonq mut, Bri(,htm W4/200q M5H5fjbjorffudl rA S�4—& FT CMAM �Ayt •4+u�1 Cry lAR • W HiT@ e 7 c-Imm- U! FEME ANDERSON -JOHNSON ASSOCIATES, INC, LANDSCAPEARCFIITECTURE SITE PLANNING • CI17L ENGINEERJNG 7373 GOLDEN YALLURalb 3UAE 76tl AllymFUPOLMUNSM7 F:ax(7631314-331 PNI76313N•ft]Y 305 ST. PETERS EET ST. PAL14 HN 55102 FAX 651.223.5646 M, 651.227.7773 IN X BROCKWAY, 5l M 220 PALATINE, R. 60067 FAX 847.241.6105 TEL: 547.241.6105 251.6 Iry 14vi-7 ;5.e � e T e 0 25 50 SUBJECT: i'` ONUS ENI T 516N LOCATION ION DATE.: 02/15/200v -i COMMISSION NO: 052130 R6 REVISIONS REV. DATE 06,110/0q �- _ Bing Maps SA Middle School/High School — Electronic Sign Placement it FREEI Use Five Searrh 411 to find movies, businesses & more: 900 -CALL -411. . -.v �� 1. .rage 10I I F 9 1 1 31 Arlthotq. -A IW7 M '41 I 5�44-,Kt, -4Z t4, 14E 33rd Ave NE 33rd Ava NE A -q Bird's eye view reaps can"i be printed, so another map view has been substituted. 65 http://wvtlw.bing.cotn/r.,za,,)s/p7-ii,it.aspx?,,iLict=en-us&z=2c?,.u=b&cp=rh,li6-wlel-76y-%Ivdq,?,,,pt=-pb 6/11/2009 M. CITY OF ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE RESOLUTION 09-066 RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THE REQUEST FROM THE INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 282 FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT (CUP) FOR AN ELECTRONIC SIGN AT 3303 - 33RD AVENUE. WHEREAS, Linn Bjornrud, Wold Architects and Engineers, submitted an application on behalf of ISD 282 for a Conditional Use Permit for an electronic ground sign as required by the City Code, Title XV, Chapter 155 SIGNS, §155.29 District Schedules, (D) Recreational/Open Space Zoning Disrtict; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony Planning Commission held a Concept Review on April 21, 2009 to review ISD 282 CUP request to install an electronic sign at the St. Anthony Middle School and the St. Anthony High School, located at 3303 - 33rd Avenue NE; and WHEREAS, the School District submitted the CUP application for an electronic ground sign on June 10, 2009; and WHEREAS, the proposed electronic sign will replace the two existing signs individually identified the St. Anthony Middle School and the St. Anthony High School; and WHEREAS, a public hearing was scheduled and the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on July 21, 2009 on the proposed CUP; and WHEREAS, all required public notices regarding the public hearing were posted and sent as required by State Statute; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has recommended approval of the proposed CUP to the City Council based upon the information presented by the Staff, the applicant's presentation and that no one from the public appeared in opposition to the proposed Conditional Use Permit for the electronic sign; and WHEREAS, upon consideration of the application and supporting materials, Staff's report, and all other information constituting the record of this application, the City Council upon further deliberation, voted to approve the requested Conditional Use Permit and directed the preparation of the Findings of Fact and this resolution as a contemporaneous record of the Council's decision; and THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of St. Anthony does hereby adopt the following Findings of Fact related to the requested Conditional Use Permit: Findines: 67 Criteria #1 The use is one of the Conditional Uses specifically listed for the district in which the property is located and is not in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan. Finding 41 This use is not in conflict with the current Comprehensive Plan. The Comprehensive Plan designates this site Recreational/Open Space and according to the City's Zoning Code, Title XV, LAND USE, Chapter 155 SIGNS, §155.29, District Schedules (D) states that electronic signs are permitted with an approved Conditional Use Permit (CUP); the applicant has also complied with the requirements of Subsection 152.243, Conditional Use Permits; and approved by the City Council. Criteria #2 The use will not be detrimental to the health, safety, or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or to the values of property in the vicinity. Finding #2 The School District plans to replace the two existing ground signs at the St. Anthony Middle School and the St. Anthony High School, located at 3303 - 33rd Avenue NE with one double -sided electronic ground sign. Mr. Bjornrud testified that the School District will adhere to the City Ordinance at §155.29(D)(2)(a)(b), which states that an electronic sign is permitted with an approved CUP in the Recreational/Open Space Zoning District; that the School District will not have animation or flashing as part of the electronic sign's software and that the School District will not operate the sign between the hours of 10:00 PM and 6:00 AM. Criteria #3 The use will provide a service or a facility, which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare. Finding #3 The School District stated that the intent of the proposed electronic ground sign is to communicate school and district information and events that are of interest to the community, according to the City Ordinance, 155.29 (D)(2)(D. Criteria #4 The City Council has specified all conditions, which the Council deems necessary to make the use compatible with other uses in the area. • Landscaping is required for ground signs and may consist of shrubs, plants, rocks, or other decorative material located around the ground sign. • Hours of operation will be restricted between the hours of 10:00 PM and 6:00 AM. • Confirm that the proposed electronic ground sign is not situated in a right-of-way or an utility easement. • The message changeability shall be limited to the minimum amount of changes required to accomplish the purpose of the sign. • 'The sign shall not be pernritled to flash or contain animation. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the City Council that the application to issue a Conditional Use Permit to Independent School District 282 to locate and install an electronic ground sign at 3303 - 33=d Avenue NE is hereby approved and subject to the above -referenced conditions. Adopted this 28th day of July 2009. ATTEST: City Clerk Reviewed for Administration: Mayor City Manager STAFF REPORT 6 Mayor af:d Council City Manager From; Kim Moore -Sykes, Assistant City Manager Date; July 28, 2009 Subject: CUPS Request for ateatonic Sign at 3600 Mghcrest Road Requested A.ctian: Date Anbfrcation Received: Property Address: Zoning Disttict: 60 -Day Expires: Waiver Letter Required: Future Action: Public Hearing TSD 282 Application for CUP for an Electronic Sign June 10, 2009 3600 Highcrest Road Recreational/Open Space August 9, 2009 Yes Date Sent: No X City Council action on Planning Commission Recommendation re Electronic Sign CUP — ISD 282, Ea�kground: Linn Bjornrud, Wold Architects and Engineers, contacted Staff to ask about the process for obtaining a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow for the placement of an electronic sign on the Wilshire Park Elementary School property. Staff advised Mr. Bjornrud of the process and the City's sign ordinance at 155.29 DISTRICT SCHEDULES, (D), states that while electronic signs are permitted with an approved CUP in a Recreational/ Open Space Zoning District; flashing and animation are not permitted(2)(a); and hours of operation are restricted (2)(b). As part of the application, Mr. Bjornrud indicated that the proposed electronic sign would replace the existing ground sign at Wilshire Park Elementary. One double - sided electronic sign will be used to communicate events to the community. At the public hearing before the Planning Commission, discussion of the sign location revealed concerns that the sign might be too close to the semaphore. Mr. Bjornrud stated that the proposed sign location is outside of the right-of-way for 37th Avenue but was not able to get definitive information from the County about the required distance that the sign needs to be from the semaphore. He reported that he would try to obtain that information before the Council meeting on Tuesday evening. He also indicated that he would talk with the School District about the possibility of moving the proposed electronic sign to the location of the existing sign. Application Analysis: L The requested conditional use is one of the Permitted Conditional Uses specifically listed for the zoning district in which the conditional use is located. City Code at 155.29 DISTRICT SCHEDULES, (D) Recr•eationai Open Space, states that electronic signs are permitted with an approved CUP in the Recreational/Open Space zoning district. 07212009 Council CUP 3600 Highcrest Rd electronic sign.doc 2, That the tegiaested conditional use perailt.will not be Actrimental to .health, safety or genetal 70 wnlfaTe of petgons residing or worldng in the vielnhy Of injuriom to ptoperty values of iraptovements ift the area, The Sdiool District plana to replace the e4stuag ground sign at the Wilshire Park Elementay School with one elect tobic sign. Mt BJo,=4d has indicated that the School Nstdct will adhere to City teeluitemcuts togarding hoots of upontion, of the sign. no City Code states that in no event shall the sign be permitted to be operated between the hours of 10:00 p.in, and 6x00 a.xnt,,155.29(D)(2)(b). Mr. $j oxarud stated that the School District will not include Bashing or animation as part of the software program to be used fear the proposed electronic sign so as to be in conformance with the City Code, 155.29(D)(2)(a). Staff advised Mr. $jornrud that the proposed site of the electronic sign is within the County's road right-of-way and he would need to contact the County for their process for placing structures in the right-of-way. Staff also received an email from a resident with traffic concerns about installing the electronic sign at the corder of 37'` Avenue and Highetest Road, 3. The requested Conditional Use Permit is considered necessary or desirable at the subject location to provide a service or a facility which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare of the neighborhood or community. The School District states that it is the intent of this proposed electronic to communicate school district information and events that will be of interest to the community (155.29(D)(2)(f)). Communications: Staff has received no phone calls regarding the proposed electronic sign for this location. Staff did receive an email from a resident who voiced a concern that the electronic sign may be too close to 37`x' Avenue, perhaps causing some difficulty with sightlines for drivers in the intersection of 37`h Avenue and Highcrest Road. Staff also received a tail from a resident who voiced objections about the public notification process for the electronic signs for both locations, Wilshire Park Elementary and the Middle School/High School. While the resident is not within the notification area either school, he was concerned that the community would find the information confusing and difficult to find. Attachments: • Application Design Drawing of the Proposed Sign and Proposed Sign Placement • Aerial Photo of Property • Resident Email 07212009 Council CUP 3600 Highcrest Rd electronic sign.doc DETAIL OF • 71 MINNESOTA 3055 ST. PETER STREET O L� rLL4N015 �,.I1 . 1 (f 4aV u/Y�• WOSD ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS MICHIGAN t/ t ST. PAUL, MN 55 t� COLORADO i PRECAST SHAPE #1 ELECTRONIC MESSAGE SIGN pr St. Anthony 4 New Brighton INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT ]BR BRICK 1. TYPICAL SURFACE MOUNTED L060 KITH "HALO" BACK LIGHTING PRECAST SHAPE #2 MONUMENT SIGN EAST/WEST ELEVATION 1/4" = 1'-0" SIGN !BURFACE COPY AREA 1/4" = 1'.-0" )TE: PROPOSED 5I6N 5URFAGE )PY AREA SHOWN HATCHED. )TAL = 31A 5F PER 5IDE )TAL = 15.8 SF GRAND TOTAL )TAL = < ALLOWED 80 S.F. RROJrCr: "SAINT ANTHONY 5EC"C)NPARY° SGHOOL 2009 IMPROVEMENTS DATE: 2/16/09 RFVISIONS: li\R^_eilprol�LC Piles\R N0.F.onq Nem 9: u�Flgn COMMISSION NO: 062150 REV. DATE. bPo/00011105]:or, /H �, 72 ANDERSON-JONNSO.N D ASSOCIATES, INC D I,Ah7A5CAPFARCAITF.CTl9?P • .SITF. PLAh'h7NG • CIV17,Fh(77NFF.R1Ff, (• )JiJ fOlAfiti l'A(.LF.Y FORD ,R:RF.ThI IITTAPOII(. wisV7 PH171;3IH1-7I29 37th Ave NE 73 rrranaa�mozc�csunr�:ITrur. 3D5 ST, PUERSTREET ST. PAU1, NU 55103 FAX: 651.223.5046 TEL 651.227.7773 110 N. BROCKWAY, SUITE 220 PAUkTRIE, IL 60067 FAX: 042241.6105 TEL: 847.241.6105 SUR.773CT.- MONUMENT 516N LOGATION DATE: 02/18/2009 CO.MMISSION.NO: 082129 REVISIONS zj� RED. DATE 01/23/09 ONE 0 25 50 ONE J i� y 1 v a¢ JiI ' 1 F < 5 tl 1: ti i 1 SIA i e l �� Y PI t� 4n t. 1j, 7 : 1 C i § co s[` I ;e —a D r y fi E v a¢ JiI ' tl 1: ti FLA J il+d¢� ygyg op v JiI ' tl 1: ti i i e J il+d¢� ygyg op v JiI ' 75 Left intentionally Blank r I lilt - Iviaps Bing Maps Wilshire Park Elementary School — Electronic Sign Placement j, FREE! Use Gve Search 411 to find I movies, businesses & more i *084ALL-411. Page I of 1 76 _!337thAve NE oat* Ail I�A Page I of 1 76 Coa n ly Ro . A .... � 0 009 2, Bird's eye view maps Cal"i be Printed, so another rnap view has been substituted. Coa n ly Ro . A .... � 0 009 77 Kim Moore -Sykes From: ALLEN & ANNETTE OTTE (a.a.otte@msn.com] Sent: Saturday, July 18, 2009 8:30 PM To: Kim Moore -Sykes Subject: Electronic Signage at Wilshire Kim: I was just watching a rerun of the Planning Commission (I think) on signage for the schools. The drawing for Wilshire shows the sign set back only 15 feet from 37th Ave. Last year I complained to the police when someone, advertising a play or something at school, placed a big sign at a position that blocked view of the traffic on East bound 37th, when setting at the stoplight on Highcrest ready to turn right on to East bound 37th. Please make sure the sign is far enough back from 37th to allow a clear view of East bound traffic when setting at the stop light on Highcrest. Thanks Allen Otte St. Anthony WIN MNew Brighton INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 282 June 16, 2009 Mr. Mike Morrison, City Manager City of St. Anthony Village 3301 Silver Lake Road St. Anthony, MN 55418 Dear Mike, On behalf of St. Anthony -New Brighton Schools District #282, I would like to thank you for the cooperative efforts displayed thus far regarding our current referendum projects. As partof the construction scope, we are requesting a Conditional Use Permit to replace the existing exterior monument signs at the Middle School, High School, and Wilshire Park Elementary School. We believe that these new monument signs will not only serve the purpose of building identification, but will also provide valuable service to the community through the proposed electronic message portion of the designs. This messaging capability will allow on -demand communication of school district and community events and information. While providing this service is important to us, respect for our neighbors is also paramount 5o the success of this design. The allowed hours of operation will ensure that these new installations do not disturb residents late in the evening or early in the morning. We feel confident that the design proposed complies with City Ordinances, and we welcome any comments or suggestions that the Planning Commission or City Council may have. Thank you for your consideration throughout this exciting process. Sincerely, V Dr. Rod K. Thompson Superintendent of Schools RKT/sb 11i. Rcd Tlmtysurr, Suodmiendmd F rPfrarnlesus OO sfaeYl€ taT.ki'2.eorra.n: 3303 33rd Rvonue Af Q St. Rndrong hllN 55418 o I. 612.706.1150 1 612.706.1020 www.stonPhonµl;l2.nutus W. 79 Date: g. U' O0i (60 -Day Rule Effective) Fee: $130 City ofst. Anthony Application for Conditional Use Permit Applicant: INDOCAD ENT U*ogL plsTVAf' *2 -SL Phone: 61%.706•loop Address: 3303 3320 AVV-14ME NE Status of Applicant: (Owner, Buyer, Renter, Agent, etc.) O W N Vt Street Address and/or Legal Description of Subject Property: WJL&I %%IC- EA!JL* %. S. -t 3600 HtG%%CALe$T RAD Zoning Designation of Subject Property: ILI2LR2A-Poff AI. ol?VM S Qk(-Cc btS- %CT Reason for Conditional Use Permit Request: MOVA1E'ST 1-0 t04STLMM" V1.1'5ML0N10 V%ESSAGC% SIGN ON SITCr APPLICANTS, PLEASE NOTE: Minnesota Statutes and City Ordinances require that the following criteria must be satisfied before a Conditional Use may be authorized. Please respond in writing to these criteria, using additional sheets, if necessary. 1.) The requested Conditional Use is one of the Permitted Conditional Uses specifically listed for the Zoning District in which the Conditional Use is to be located. ori clkm OVLOf14'Awev tsv.21 10 nvv'� 7,0 2.) Explain how the requested Conditional Use will not be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or injurious to property values of improvements in the area. Rx", Uxx-c rv"Vo r; M 4 vv&) k`o&' niv, wlip I 1 (5�1. 4:x%1, , 3.) Explain why the requested Conditional Use is necessary or desirable at the above location to provide a service or a facility which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to pthe general welfareof the neighborhood or community. i CADOGLIn]Cn LB and Settings\l3Suciu\Local Sellings\Temporary Internet Piles\01'K3C\C01Idi1i0nal Use Request 2005.doc Additionally, applicants must submit ALL of the following information to City Hall by the Tuesday that is thirty (30) days prior to the regularly scheduled meeting of the Planning Commission. or City Council meeting at which the request will be heard at a Public Hearing. 1.) Completed application for the specific request and payment of the fee. 2.) Complete survey and site plans of the subject property (including dimensions and elevations) showing the building, driveways, curb cuts, ingress, egress, etc., on the property and in relation to adjacent properties. 3.) Explanation of materials to be used and plans for screening, landscaping, fencing and dumpster enclosures. 4.) Drawings of completed buildings, if appropriate to the project, and materials used. 5.) Storm water retention and drainage. The appropriate watershed district or water management organization are required to be notified of the project. 6.) A letter explaining the reason for the Conditional Use Permit. In the letter, please describe that the circumstances to warrant the need for the request. An incomplete application will not be scheduled before the Planning Commission or City Council. Signature of the Applicant: -.. Z L'4x C:ADocuments and SettingsVi3SuciuALncd SettingsCfcmpomy Internet bilesVOIXRAConditional Use Request2005.doc CITY OF ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE RESOLUTION 09-067 RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THE REQUEST FROM THE INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT 282 FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT (CUP) FOR AN ELECTRONIC SIGN AT 3600 HIGHCREST ROAD. WHEREAS, Linn Bjornrud, Wold Architects and Engineers, submitted an application on behalf of ISD 282 for a Conditional Use Permit for an electronic ground sign as required by the City Code, Title XV, Chapter 155 SIGNS, §155.29 District Schedules, (D) Recreational/Open Space Zoning District; and WHEREAS, the City of St. Anthony Planning Commission held a Concept Review on April 21, 2009 to review ISD 282 CUP request to install an electronic sign at the Wilshire Park Elementary School, located at 3600 Highcrest Road; and WHEREAS, the School District submitted the CUP application for an electronic ground sign on June 10, 2009; and WHEREAS, the proposed electronic sign will replace the existing ground sign that identifies the elementary school; and WHEREAS, a public hearing was scheduled and the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on July 21, 2009 on the proposed CUP; and WHEREAS, all required public notices regarding the public hearing were posted and sent as required by State Statute; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has recommended approval of the proposed CUP to the City Council based upon the information presented by the Staff, the applicant's presentation, and that no one from the public appeared in opposition to the proposed Conditional Use Permit for the electronic sign; and WHEREAS, upon consideration of the application and supporting materials, Staff's report, and all other information constituting the record of this application, the City Council upon further deliberation, voted to approve the requested Conditional Use Permit and directed the preparation of the Findings of Fact and this resolution as a contemporaneous record of the Council's decision; and THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of St. Anthony does hereby adopt the following Findings of Fact related to the requested Conditional Use Permit: Findings: Criteria #1 The use is one of the Conditional Uses specifically listed for the district in which the property is located and is not in conflict with the Comprehensive Plan. Finding #1 The proposed electronic ground sign is not in conflict with the current Comprehensive Plan. The Comprehensive Plan designates this site Recreational/Open Space and according to the City's Zoning Code, Title XV, LAND USE, Chapter 155 SIGNS, §155.29, District Schedules (D) states that electronic signs are permitted with an approved Conditional Use Permit (CUP); the applicant has also complied with the requirements of Subsection 152.243, Conditional Use Permits and approved by the City Council. Criteria #2 The use will not be detrimental to the health, safety, or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or to the values of property in the vicinity. Finding #2 The School District plans to replace the existing ground sign at Wilshire Park Elementary School with one double -sided electronic ground sign. Mr. Bjornrud testified that the School District will adhere to the City Ordinance at §155.29(D)(2)(a)(b), which states that an electronic sign is permitted with an approved CUP in the Recreational/Open Space Zoning District; that the School District will not have animation or flashing as part of the electronic sign's software and that the School District will not operate the sign between the hours of 10:00 PM and 6:00 AM. Criteria #3 The use will provide a service or a facility, which is in the interest of public convenience and will contribute to the general welfare. Finding #3 The School District stated that the intent of the proposed electronic ground sign is to communicate school and district information and events that are of interest to the community, according to the City Ordinance, 155.29 (D)(2)(f). Criteria #4 The City Council has specified all conditions, which the Council deems necessary to make the use compatible with other uses in the area. • Landscaping is required for ground signs and may consist of shrubs, plants, rocks, or other decorative material located around the ground sign. • Hours of operation will be restricted between the hours of 10:00 PM and 6:00 AM. • Confirm that the proposed electronic ground sign is not situated in a right-of-way or an utility easement. Confirm that the sign copy surface is in compliance with the City Code. • The message changeability shall be limited to the minimum amount of changes required to accomplish the purpose of the sign. • The sign shall not be permitted to flash or contain animation. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the City Council that the application to issue a Conditional Use Permit to Independent School District 282 to locate and install an electronic ground sign at 3600 Highcrest Road is hereby approved and subject to the above - referenced conditions. Adopted this 281h day of July 2009. ATTEST: City Reviewed for Administration: Mayor City Manager MEMORANDUM DATE: June 9, 2009 TO Mayor, Councilmexuber FROM; Mire Mornson, City Matiager Jay Hartman, Public Woxks Director RE: Staff Report on Snow Plowing Parking Restrictions During the calendar year 2008, the City Council decided to amend the current Snow Plowing Ordinance for the City of St. Anthony. The change was made and had a sunset date of July 1; 2009. The primary goal of this change was to give residents more flexibility on when they could park on the roadway during the plowing season. To date for the 200812009 Snow Plowing season, 28 citations were issued by the Police Department. Throughout the 200812009 plowing season, the Public Works Department responded to a total of 11 full plowing events. The average number of vehicles in the street to plow around was 15 per plowing event. In the event that the Public Works Department has to "Return Plow" in the areas where vehicles were parked, the cost breakdown is as follows: Straight Time: 1 truck and operator $80/hour Overtime Rate: 1 truck and operator $120/hour The "Return Plow" Average 1 hour per snow plowing event During the 2008/2009 plowing season., Public Works incurred 6 addition hours of plowing at overtime rate. The remaining 5 hours were completed during regular hours. The 2 options for consideration are as follows: 1. Go back to the original ordinance regarding Snow Plowing & Parking Restriction on November 1 through April 1. 2. Proceed with the current ordinance. O'i.TY OF ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE ORDINANCE 05-005 CHAP'T'ER 9. nuxr' IC AND VEHICLE REGULATIONS Section 900 - GENERAL REGULATIONS 920.07 Parking Dgnr nir sDQ)j,RefgOvftl. Subd, 1. No person shall park a vehicle on any city street for period of 48 hours, commencing inunediately after two (2) inches or more of continuous snowfall, or until -snow removal has been completed curb to curb. This ordinance will sunset on July 1, 2009. This ordinance change shall be in full force and effect upon passage by the City Council and Publication of the Ordinance or a Summary thereof in the City's official newspaper. First Reading; April 22, 2008 Second Reading: May 13, 2008 Adopted: May 27, 2008 ayor AT"FEST: &U k4_ City Clerk i Publish: June 4, 2008 W. MEMO DATE: April 1, 2009 TO; Mike Mornmon, City M.auager Jay Hartman, PZio Works Director FROAJC John Ohl; Chief of Police SUBJECT: Snow Em(, gGtlGy Park ng The police department issues snow emergency citations to faGiliYaYe the orderly removal of snow from city streets. From January 1, 2008 to March 21, 2008, the police department wrote 86 citations to vehicles in violation of our 3:00 a.m. to 7:00 Un- ordinance. From January 1, 2009 to March 21, 2009, the police department wrote 28 citations to vehicles in violation of our 2 inch snow fall ordinance. JOivj CITY Or ST, ANTHONY VILLAGE ORDINANGP 2009-005 PARKING DURING SNOW REMOVAL § 72,36 PARKING DURING SNOW REMOVAL. (A) No person shall park a vehicle on any city street for a period of 48 hours, commencing immediately after 2 inches or more of continuous snowfall or until snow removal has been completed curb to curb. (13) Whenever it is necessary to the proper direction control, regulation of traffic, plowing and/or the removal of snow, ice, or waste, or maintenance or improvement of any highway or street to remove any vehicle standing on a highway or street in the city, then any police officer is authorized to provide for the removal of the vehicle and have the same removed to the nearest convenient garage or other place of safety. The cost of removal and storage of the vehicle will be charged to the owner of the vehicle, and to the person causing the violation. These ordinance changes shall be in full force and effect upon passage by the City Council and publication of the Ordinance or a Sununary thereof in the City's official newspaper. First Reading: June 9, 2009 Second Reading: June 23, 2009 Adopted: ATTEST: City Clerk Mayor FUTURE COUNCIL AGENDA ITEMS 7/2812009 Meeting Date Meeting Type Staff' Items/Issues August 11 Regular City Engineer Accept Feasiblity Report and Order Plans and Specifications for the 2010 Street Project City Manager Quarterly Goals Update Consent Agenda Contract with Northwest Youth and Family Services August 25 Regular August 31 Worksession 6 pm Review 2010 Levy Limits and Tax Levy Silver Lake Village Update September s Special 5:00 p.m. Ribbon Cutting Ceremony for Water Re -Use Project City Manager Finance Director Setting the City's Proposed 2010 Tax Levy & Budget in Compliance with the T -N -T Act Consent Agenda Kiwanis Peanut Day Proclamation -September 22 He(n lar Planning Commission items from September 15 Consent Agenda Approval of Election Judges for General Municipal Election September 29 Special Worksession Joint Meeting with School Board followed by worksession October 13 City Engineer Approve Plans & Specifications, and order Advertisement for Bids October 27 Planning Commission items from October 20 City Engineer Plans and Specifications and Ordering Advertisement for Bids for 2010 Street Project City Manager Quarterly Goals November 2 Worksession 6 pm November 10 City Manager Ordinance - Sign Text Amendment (second reading) City Clerk Canvass results from the November 5 election November 24 Planning Commission items from November 17 December 8 Consent Agenda Appoint Planning and Park Commissioners City Engineer Receive Bids, & Compute Assessments for 2010 Street Project December 22 Planning Commission items from December 15 August 2009 Monthly Planner WednesdaySunday Monday Tuesday .. Jul 2009 Sep 2009 S M T W T F S S M T W T F S Villagefest 1 2 T4 1 2 3 4 5 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 26 27 28 29 30 31 27 28 29 30 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Worksession 6pm MN Night to Unite 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 City Council Meeting 7pm 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 Planning Commission Meeting 7 pm 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 City Council Meeting 7 pm Filing for candidacy begins 30 31 Worksession 6 pm Printed by Calendar Creator for Windows on 7/22/2009 HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AGENDA CITY OF ST. ANTHONY VILLAGE July 28, 2009 Call to Order. Roll Call. I. Approval of July 28, 2009, H.R.A. Agenda. II. Consent Agenda. These items are considered routine and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Councilmember or citizen so requests, in which event the item will be removed from the Consent Agenda and placed elsewhere on the agenda. A. Approve June 23, 2009, H.R.A. Minutes. (pp. 1 — 2) B. Claims. (p. 3) III. Public Hearings. IV. General Policy of Business of the H.R.A. V. Staff Reports. VI. H.R.A. Commissioner Comments. VII. Information and Announcements. VIII. Adjournment. Z.ACouncil Meetings120091072820091HRA agenda.doc 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 CITY OF ST. ANTHONY HRA REGULAR MEETING MINUTES JUNE 23, 2009 CALL TO ORDER. Chair Faust called the meeting to order at 7:37 p.m. ROLL CALL. Commissioners present: Chair Faust; Commissioners Gray, Roth, Stille, and Thuesen Commissioners absent: None Also Present: Executive Director Michael Morrison. I. APPROVAL OF JUNE 23, 2009 HRA MEETING AGENDA Motion by Commissioner Stille, seconded by Commissioner Roth, to approve the June 23, 2009 Housing and Redevelopment Authority Agenda as presented. Motion carried unanimously. II. CONSENT AGENDA. Motion by Commissioner Thuesen, seconded by Commissioner Roth, to approve the Consent Agenda, which consisted of: A. H.R.A. Meeting Minutes of ME 12, 2009; B. Claims; and C. Resolution 09-008; Authorizing an Increase in the Principal Amount of Interfund Loans for Tax Increment Financing District No 3-5. III. PUBLIC HEARINGS. None. IV. GENERAL POLICY OF BUSINESS OF THE H.R.A. None. V. STAFF REPORTS None. VI. H.R.A. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS None. VII. INFORMATION AND ANNOUNCEMENTS Motion carried unanimously. 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Housing and Redevelopment Authority Meeting Minutes June 23, 2009 Page 2 None. VIII. ADJOURNMENT Chair Faust adjourned the meeting at 7:38 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Carol Hamer TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. ATTEST: City Clerk Chair 2 3 00000000000 twig 00000000000 I-�h7 C ww�owio io vi wio In io G' \H 41 NwNWUI IrINO�J iP �P N N7y� wy JJ O wo w " TWaIPww1p0 O � �n � CCzzci Hyl y C x WCt+H m3 Oro t' Woz rirtln WN7JO00 R�VWW LH. O H. 0bro z]�yy t�JH q/to nOOH N H H 1 P3 W M (n 'HEW .4gobmtr W n rINWH U n 0 n 0 ;zw!e4w Hy n 00 z x n" m LA m m " x rowwwwwwwwww n F-�o�Ow JQ�Ut �PWNV S 00000000000 J J J J J J J J J J J 0000\\\\\\\ N N N N N N N N N N N io �o io io iow io���o io H 0000\\\\\\\ p7 00000000000 W owm WH I y O J NN O 001mm l0 Ut N CPN NSP � N oww:PF' WMAw N oil- lfl N lf�tt�0 0 V1 0� Jrx �9 V tOJOW0001J NQ�lO J 000 Ut 0O` d w o t4 �.S 00 0 0 V J0000omm y WH P Ll µ W 3