|
Table 2
<br />listimated Taxpayer Costs & Crime - Reduction Benefits of Sixteen Programs (in 1997 Dollars)
<br />Name of
<br />Intervention
<br />and Quality of
<br />Research Design
<br />(H =high;
<br />PM preln'Irrwnamry)
<br />Taxpayer Costs and
<br />Program Effectiveness for Reducing Taxpayer Criminal Justice System Benefits,
<br />Felonies in Washington Per Program Participant
<br />pima
<br />Victim
<br />Avoided
<br />Net Gain
<br />(Loss),
<br />Taxpayer
<br />AND
<br />victim
<br />Costs
<br />Avoided
<br />Type of
<br />Offenses
<br />Measured
<br />Without the
<br />Program, the
<br />Number of
<br />Offenses
<br />per Person
<br />Wth the i Net Present Value
<br />Rogram,
<br />Number
<br />of Years
<br />Before
<br />Cost Is
<br />Paid Back
<br />Percent
<br />Reduction
<br />n
<br />Felonies
<br />Needed to
<br />Break
<br />Even
<br />the Number
<br />of
<br />Offenses
<br />per
<br />Participant
<br />Percent
<br />Cost of
<br />Change Program
<br />Crimnal
<br />Justice
<br />Costs
<br />Avoided
<br />Net Gain
<br />(Loss)
<br />�\,2.YSEnii:5
<br />$.3
<br />,. (',..
<br />erry Pre - School
<br />(Michigan)
<br />iyracuse Family
<br />levelopment
<br />'>revn
<br />L ti`2' f
<br />...,
<br />. 5
<br />H
<br />M
<br />u :'Yl: �>Xf
<br />S:: {��:, )'
<br />felony
<br />arreataby
<br />age27
<br />felony
<br />eonvietlon•
<br />by age 25
<br />�♦ . , n» %.
<br />) i .✓
<br />Y..:" '•
<br />fuy' yy�'
<br />OS
<br />1.75
<br />0.18
<br />\''
<br />i \•`%i>
<br />0.90
<br />0.01
<br />PW' A9n
<br />`:t4:.
<br />y
<br />•T.
<br />pj a
<br />SSsav?l,:
<br />-48%
<br />_ ...»...w
<br />,
<br />93 h
<br />k,.' }}pp
<br />i3. Yis . C :
<br />�{
<br />$13,938
<br />»__ ...._.._.
<br />$18,037
<br />».wv
<br />y tt�y�
<br />Y��i2,nYvi.,
<br />Y53a .L. , . �
<br />( K.
<br />t ) $ •�
<br />\\
<br />Doesn't
<br />$13,442 (5496)
<br />Pay Back
<br />».. »..._.._. ». w
<br />Doesn't
<br />$3,953 (314,084) Back
<br />•1 R='`H. 2
<br />��. .K... \ >E
<br />�.ti. > , {) }�Y i''NON33u.c^
<br />.F�ff{i�.��a•
<br />-50%
<br />Cant
<br />Break
<br />Even
<br />.: \ ♦
<br />Q{
<br />`:l tA'AF.,
<br />;2:iiAIS�M';
<br />..,.
<br />$16,717 316,221
<br />$3,842 (310,241)
<br />C'R
<br />Nw ...
<br />,>av ,.
<br />ieattle Socia
<br />Development H
<br />Pro'ect
<br />felony
<br />arrests by 1.01 0.80 -21% $2,991 $3,068 378 14 -20%
<br />age25
<br />33,191 33,268
<br />i >2 ixz:2eLrix •\ •.
<br />a•* �i.
<br />\3<,,.
<br />i::irdicaa��i.:.>�:'° .. •..
<br />(Sig Brothers/Big
<br />Sisters P
<br />dentorinq
<br />..qiE, i $`.o •%pZ •• .2, ce::� �2 •� \wig.• \•,:,e��z ,.�.e s�;.: ,.> "x"" 3.° jai; a� ' n t:�• ... 't ':
<br />»
<br />•�;. m. .t�^,. 2, • \ \ :.\• >i,s, >,:< \ ' C ):..,.,io.0 �s�\i_ ",x
<br />i 2 : �,�'12',:`A�,>�(ent iil��Y;uv,�i� •��f�ft�0.�dar� >i€ <:Cam�:.:.�
<br />felony
<br />convictions 0.27 0.21 -20% $1,000 $1,978 3978 3 -10%
<br />by age 25
<br />e •:3>;? :aarw
<br />> y..`' T G�i•,,Y3�'•.. >�,�iiii
<br />$2,505 33,483
<br />juantum M
<br />Opportunities
<br />\. ,•QHV•.
<br />;\�`LR ;�i�
<br />felony DOesn't Leant
<br />arrests by 0.35 0.10 -71 °h $12,528 $4,216 (38,312) Break
<br />age 25 Pay Back _
<br />�.' , ,,:e � ». CQV` p. Q„ '\ Z•`\
<br />:,1p�iir .< a; a;; �: ia�>:•; 2a; ��; i��i,,: ���€., ,.;�<;tt��,,:�Y�;�;.;:»�a,:35. �;`. �5;?i;;r ;ixia>e:;�» ,•\, '•,x'�..,•�ii::
<br />$4,247 (34,066)
<br />'C Y,\\i,�\\\•
<br />>."va„»zii:�s;i.
<br />$7,299 312,326
<br />Adolescent
<br />Diversion Project H
<br />felony
<br />convictions 0.45 0.29 -34%
<br />by age 25
<br />$1,028 $6,055 35,027 1 -6%
<br />,Michigan)
<br />'unctional ram ify
<br />Thera M
<br />!Therapy
<br />felony re• -27%
<br />convictions 0.68 0.49 27/0
<br />by age 25
<br />°
<br />$1,900 $7,168 35,268 1 -7,5
<br />$8,640 313,908
<br />Intensive
<br />Supervision M
<br />(Ohio)
<br />felony re-
<br />convictions 0.68 0.59 -13%
<br />by age 25
<br />Doesn't
<br />$5,959 $4,004 (31,955) Pay Back -19%
<br />$4,159 32,204
<br />Intensive
<br />Supervision P
<br />(Orange Co., CA)
<br />felony re-
<br />convictions 0.68 0.53 -22%
<br />by age 25
<br />$4,556 $6,164 31,609 4 -16%
<br />$6,961 38,569
<br />ImerAgency M
<br />Coordination
<br />felony re-
<br />convictions 0.27 0.19 -29%
<br />by age 25
<br />$1,000 $2,900 31,900 2 -10%
<br />$3,672 S5,572.,
<br />Juvenile Boot
<br />Camp Summary H
<br />Multi-Systemic
<br />Multi - Systemic
<br />Thera H
<br />Py
<br />felony
<br />convictions 0.68 0.78 16%
<br />felony re-
<br />»...« -44%
<br />convictions 0.68 0.38 -4416
<br />by age 25
<br />Doesn't
<br />($1,515) ($4,426) (32,912) 5%
<br />r _ _ Back .._.
<br />0
<br />34,500 $12,381 37,881 2 -16/0
<br />($4,998) (37,910)
<br />$13,982 321,863
<br />Paint Creek
<br />Youth Center H
<br />(Ohio)
<br />felony re-
<br />conviction. 0.68 0.56 -16%
<br />by age 25
<br />$4,705 $5,056 3351 6 -15%
<br />$5,250 35,601
<br />Teamchild (King
<br />P
<br />County, WA)
<br />.Ionyfe' ,
<br />conviction• 0.27 0.21 -20%
<br />by age 25
<br />o
<br />$625 $2,074 31,449 2 -6°k
<br />$2,500 33,950
<br />Thurston County
<br />FastTrack P
<br />Diversion
<br />felony re-
<br />convictions 0.27 0.19 -29%
<br />by age 25
<br />3136 $2,900 32,764 1 -1%
<br />$3,672 36,436
<br />Treatment
<br />(Foster Care P
<br />fOreoonl
<br />I eiony re-
<br />convictions 0.68 0.43 -37%
<br />by age 25
<br />$3,941 39,757 35,815 2 -15%
<br />$11,760 317,575
<br />Page 33
<br />
|